The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

moomin75
28 January 2019 17:23:20

 

AFAIK, no-one here works for the MetO and thus no-one here gets access to the full range of information that they have at their disposal.

Last February, there was a time when both the GFS & ECM op runs over a few days seemed to be somewhat at odds with the MetO's prediction of a major cold blast at the end of the month and we had some people here saying "Surely the MetO will have to change their forecast now", or words along those lines. We all know who was proved right in the end, which I why I for one think it would be wise to think the MetO will be wrong with their current thoughts no matter how poor GFS FI may look in some runs.

Originally Posted by: David M Porter 

It's not just the GFS though David. Have you seen the ECM 0z. That ain't showing anything from the east or Northeast!!


Witney, Oxfordshire

100m ASL

backtobasics
28 January 2019 17:26:51

Well one way or another we are going to see a backtrack. Either fron the Met Office or from the models. I know which one I HOPE to see backtrack.

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

true enough, easterlies can develop at relatively short notice, still time yet. FWIW I’m indifferent once I have seen a bit fall, I’ll then happily take mild useable weather through till spring.

David M Porter
28 January 2019 17:35:12

It's not just the GFS though David. Have you seen the ECM 0z. That ain't showing anything from the east or Northeast!!

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

I take your point Kieren. What I would add is that neither model covers the period from now until late February which the entirety of the MetO's forecasts go out to and GFS only goes as far ahead as the next fortnight. That only takes us to 11/12th February or around then. As everyone who follows the models regularly must know, anything for more than a week ahead is very much open to change even under normal circumstances and far-off GFS FI can certainly never be relied upon.

Look at the three GFSop runs today as an example of how much they can and do change from one run to the next. For all GFS 12z is poor for cold, deep FI in the previous two runs today looked a bit more prosmising although neither delivered a deep freeze.

In short, all I am saying is don't discount the MetO yet. They were right about a change to colder weather in the middle of this month and they were likewise proved correct about the Beast at the end of last February at a time when some of us were beginning to have doubts.


Lenzie, Glasgow

"A body of men holding themselves accountable to nobody ought not to be trusted by anybody." – Thomas Paine

JACKO4EVER
28 January 2019 17:40:20
Some trends starting to appear? Ok it’s FI but lots of output now shows nothing to which the MetO refer to. There has to be some backdown soon surely?
moomin75
28 January 2019 17:40:33

 

I take your point Kieren. What I would add is that neither model covers the period from now until late February which the entirety of the MetO's forecasts go out to and GFS only goes as far ahead as the next fortnight. That only takes us to 11/12th February or around then. As everyone who follows the models regularly must know, anything for more than a week ahead is very much open to change even under normal circumstances and far-off GFS FI can certainly never be relied upon.

Look at the three GFSop runs today as an example of how much they can and do change from one run to the next. For all GFS 12z is poor for cold, deep FI in the previous two runs today looked a bit more prosmising although neither delivered a deep freeze.

In short, all I am saying is don't discount the MetO yet. They were right about a change to colder weather in the middle of this month and they were likewise proved correct about the Beast at the end of last February at a time when some of us were beginning to have doubts.

Originally Posted by: David M Porter 

You are my alter-ego David. Mr Positive all the time.....we are yin and yang πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚


Witney, Oxfordshire

100m ASL

Retron
28 January 2019 17:41:28

Wow, that's one hell of a swing mild from the 12z GEFS. It'll be interesting to see whether EPS shows a similar flip later today...


Leysdown, north Kent
Gooner
28 January 2019 17:41:34

 

It's a trend that is growing as I said yesterday. I really don't want to annoy people but if I'm commenting on the models, the writing is on the wall ***IF*** these verify. But the trend is becoming clearer. I'm not saying it will happen, but it's not looking like the Met Office 15-30 dayer which is painting a very wintry February with a higher than average chance of East or Northeast winds. I just do not see what they are seeing.

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

That's because you don't work in Exeter , oddly enough I can 


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus

Banbury

North Oxfordshire

378 feet A S L



tallyho_83
28 January 2019 17:43:04

Indeed because again the GFS 12z is looking like milder for early-mid February. It's not a case of me looking at one operational but trends. There is nothing in the models that suggests anything particularly Easterly or severe in February. Quite the opposite in fact. I am only commenting on the models as they are showing, I am absolutely NOT trying to wind anybody up. 

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

 

I certainty am not wound up! Far from it but other members sometimes seem to have it in for me and/or not like me commenting on facts of each run because they are some 10 days out etc!? WHilst i know they will change each run or vary i don;t see what's the harm on commenting on them, comparing them to previous runs or posting charts from Op runs? Or what's wrong with comparing these runs to the Met outlook like what you are doing!? in the end this is the model output discussion and if some people don't wish to see my posts they can always hide them...! It's no biggie.

It is looking much milder and i agree 100%. 

Back to the more reliable time frame it seems like the heavier rain tomorrow will be between 3 and 6pm and by the time the temperature has fallen in time for snow the frontal system would have lost it's omph! So at the best we (east Devon will get light rain and sleet before it fizzles out().

Back to the ensembles they have trended much, much milder since the 06z run in both medium and long term and this isn't just the OP run: - Notice not one GFS ensemble member going down to -10 or below in FI stages? - You can seen by the ensemble mean from around 5th Feb!

12z run

06z run - Notice many ensembles go down between -5 and -10 @ 850hpa into FI and some go below -10 in FI stages of the 06z run:

Fingers crossed and see what the ECM has to offer? and what the 18z run will bring?

 


Home Location - Vixen Tor Close, Okehampton, Devon (221m ASL)


Sean Moon

Magical Moon

www.magical-moon.com

moomin75
28 January 2019 17:46:57

 

That's because you don't work in Exeter , oddly enough I can 

Originally Posted by: Gooner 

No Marcus but I do have access to the contingency planners forecasts and I still can't see what they're seeing. But hoping they are right.


Witney, Oxfordshire

100m ASL

Gooner
28 January 2019 17:47:14

It's not just the GFS though David. Have you seen the ECM 0z. That ain't showing anything from the east or Northeast!!

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

The EC clusters - over half of them have built a ridge to the NE  by 9th -10th Feb


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus

Banbury

North Oxfordshire

378 feet A S L



doctormog
28 January 2019 17:48:41
When did we sy FI was again? Seriously though, the immediate outlook is cold but the trend beyond the coming week, albeit with less agreement (as you would expect at that range) is not. For what it’s worth at 300hrs out the GFS op and GFSP at nothing alike syntically. That would suggest to me to look at the trends and over the last day or two that trend has been for high pressures to become somewhat more dominant which could lead to blocking in the β€œright place” or as shown my more of the output currently in the β€œwrong place” (for cold). I think a few more days will be need before we see a bit more clarity beyond the 3rd or 4th of February.
moomin75
28 January 2019 17:49:48

 

The EC clusters - over half of them have built a ridge to the NE  by 9th -10th Feb

Originally Posted by: Gooner 

As they have been for ages. Let's face it, this has been an unbelievably frustrating winter. I am going to make the most of whatever slush we get this week because I rather fancy that will be the lot for this winter. We will probably get a white Easter!


Witney, Oxfordshire

100m ASL

David M Porter
28 January 2019 17:50:33

Some trends starting to appear? Ok it’s FI but lots of output now shows nothing to which the MetO refer to. There has to be some backdown soon surely?

Originally Posted by: JACKO4EVER 

I don't see any clear trends yet, only continued uncertainty.

As I said to Kieren, the FI section of the GFS 00z and 06z op runs this morning both looked better for cold IMO than the 12z does.


Lenzie, Glasgow

"A body of men holding themselves accountable to nobody ought not to be trusted by anybody." – Thomas Paine

moomin75
28 January 2019 17:52:19

 

I don't see any clear trends yet, only continued uncertainty.

As I said to Kieren, the FI section of the GFS 00z and 06z op runs this morning both looked better for cold IMO than the 12z does.

Originally Posted by: David M Porter 

Something has to back down but the trend is clear in my eyes.


Witney, Oxfordshire

100m ASL

Gooner
28 January 2019 17:53:15

As they have been for ages. Let's face it, this has been an unbelievably frustrating winter. I am going to make the most of whatever slush we get this week because I rather fancy that will be the lot for this winter. We will probably get a white Easter!

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

Actually they haven't they have fluctuated , sometimes there have been 4 or 5  clusters but the fact that the latest has just 2 clusters and over 50% go with a strong HP to the NE really cant be dismissed .


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus

Banbury

North Oxfordshire

378 feet A S L



moomin75
28 January 2019 17:56:40

 

Actually they haven't they have fluctuated , sometimes there have been 4 or 5  clusters but the fact that the latest has just 2 clusters and over 50% go with a strong HP to the NE really cant be dismissed .

Originally Posted by: Gooner 

They've been showing this for ages with only very minor fluctuation. Doesn't change the fact that this winter has delivered zilch.


Witney, Oxfordshire

100m ASL

Arbroath 1320
28 January 2019 17:57:48

Wow, that's one hell of a swing mild from the 12z GEFS. It'll be interesting to see whether EPS shows a similar flip later today...

Originally Posted by: Retron 

Yes, a big switch to mild in the mean GEFS. Not a good sign.


Kenmore, Highland Perthshire, GGTTH
David M Porter
28 January 2019 17:59:23

Something has to back down but the trend is clear in my eyes.

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

We have already had others predicting at times earlier this winter that the MetO would drop their colder outlook for later in the winter, and they haven't done so. We had a change to generally colder weather than previously about a fortnight ago and quite a few areas have seen their first notable snow of the winter.

Had the MetO's forecast of a colder second half of January not come to pass and the pattern of December and early January continued up to now, I would have more reason to be doubtful of their thoughts for February. Until there is cross-model agreement, run-to-run consistency on a milder outlook and until such times at the MetO radically alter their forecast for February, I am keeping the faith even if no-one else does.


Lenzie, Glasgow

"A body of men holding themselves accountable to nobody ought not to be trusted by anybody." – Thomas Paine

Brian Gaze
28 January 2019 17:59:56

GEFS12z certainly have flipped milder tonight as Darren said. 

https://www.theweatheroutlook.com/twodata/gefs.aspx?run=na&lg=850&lglocation=london&charthour=06&chartname=ps_500hpa&chartregion=na-region&p=1&charttag=PS%20500hPa%20(GPDM)

Let's hope they go cold again! I reckon if we can keep the virtual winter on the road for a couple more weeks it will be the best ever. A virtual counterpart to 1963.


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

moomin75
28 January 2019 18:02:38

GEFS12z certainly have flipped milder tonight as Darren said. 

https://www.theweatheroutlook.com/twodata/gefs.aspx?run=na&lg=850&lglocation=london&charthour=06&chartname=ps_500hpa&chartregion=na-region&p=1&charttag=PS%20500hPa%20(GPDM)

Let's hope they go cold again! I reckon if we can keep the virtual winter on the road for a couple more weeks it will be the best ever. A virtual counterpart to 1963.

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

Oh yes Brian. In FI this has been the mother of all winters with copious snowfalls. 😁😊


Witney, Oxfordshire

100m ASL

Phil24
28 January 2019 18:04:36

Some absolutely ridiculous comments surrounding charts etc out in FI.  Its as if some don't actually get it.  The trend is cold with milder blips with the chance of the potential for a very cold period.  This is very likely to verify, why, because its winter and not yet February, law of averages, just like calling August a warmer month with the potential for it to be hot at times with the likelyhood of some rain.

The MetO have been just about spot on, but read their forecast and when you do, you will notice that they are always full with caveats, it may or it may not, but the likelihood is, but it could change etc.  One thing is true about their forecasters, they are professionals and they do have access to information the likes of you and i can probably only dream of.

If you feel a need to post charts from two weeks from now showing snowmeggedon or BBQ time, at least have the intelect to justify your remarks with a reasoning based on facts that support your theory, rather than some churlish remark based on the fact that it looks good and fits your agenda. 

I live in the Midlands and we still dont really know what our weather potential regards snaow is going to be tomorrow, let alone a BBQ 2 weeks away.

 

doctormog
28 January 2019 18:07:01

 

Yes, a big switch to mild in the mean GEFS. Not a good sign.

Originally Posted by: Arbroath 1320 

In one set surely it is a sign of uncertainty? In two or more sets it is potentially a trend. Let’s see the 18z. If it is a big switch in the other direction is that a good sign, or a blip or highlighting the uncertainty? I would say the latter. 

Having said that it is not the direction cold weather fans will want to see I’m sure but if it continues I hope it switches to very mild anticyclonic early spring loveliness. The chances of that I fear are slim (as it is still midwinter!).

 

All this aside why have we switched from dismissing FI to seemingly only talking about it when there is so much of interest in the coming week? 


Arbroath 1320
28 January 2019 18:08:42

GEFS12z certainly have flipped milder tonight as Darren said. 

https://www.theweatheroutlook.com/twodata/gefs.aspx?run=na&lg=850&lglocation=london&charthour=06&chartname=ps_500hpa&chartregion=na-region&p=1&charttag=PS%20500hPa%20(GPDM)

Let's hope they go cold again! I reckon if we can keep the virtual winter on the road for a couple more weeks it will be the best ever. A virtual counterpart to 1963.

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

A quick look through the 12z GEFS suite is actually quite interesting. The high 850s are mostly due to high pressure sitting over or close to us, but not many from zonality.

Maybe all is not lost and pressure will build more NE on subsequent runs?


Kenmore, Highland Perthshire, GGTTH
moomin75
28 January 2019 18:09:21

Some absolutely ridiculous comments surrounding charts etc out in FI.  Its as if some don't actually get it.  The trend is cold with milder blips with the chance of the potential for a very cold period.  This is very likely to verify, why, because its winter and not yet February, law of averages, just like calling August a warmer month with the potential for it to be hot at times with the likelyhood of some rain.

The MetO have been just about spot on, but read their forecast and when you do, you will notice that they are always full with caveats, it may or it may not, but the likelihood is, but it could change etc.  One thing is true about their forecasters, they are professionals and they do have access to information the likes of you and i can probably only dream of.

If you feel a need to post charts from two weeks from now showing snowmeggedon or BBQ time, at least have the intelect to justify your remarks with a reasoning based on facts that support your theory, rather than some churlish remark based on the fact that it looks good and fits your agenda. 

I live in the Midlands and we still dont really know what our weather potential regards snaow is going to be tomorrow, let alone a BBQ 2 weeks away.

 

Originally Posted by: Phil24 

With all due respect Phil, we are simply commenting on the models in the model thread. That's what this thread is for. I don't think the comments are ridiculous. There is a trend, but who knows whether this trend will pick up pace or be dropped. That's why we comment in here. 😊 And the models are fascinating either way.


Witney, Oxfordshire

100m ASL

beanoir
28 January 2019 18:10:08

Oh yes Brian. In FI this has been the mother of all winters with copious snowfalls. 😁😊

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

GFS-p certainly seems to go with a total whiteout 

 

https://www.weatheronline.co.uk/cgi-bin/expertcharts?LANG=en&MENU=0000000000&CONT=ukuk&MODELL=gfs-para&MODELLTYP=1&BASE=-&VAR=weas&HH=84&ARCHIV=0&ZOOM=0&PERIOD=&WMO=

 

 

 

 


Langford, Bedfordshire

Remove ads from site