The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

Brian Gaze
07 December 2022 07:50:03
MOGREPS-G 00z update on 07/12 offers a lot of support for the Global model operational run. A big snow event in the southern half of the UK looks like a possibility at least.

https://www.theweatheroutlook.com/twodata/mogreps-stamps.aspx?hour=168&fvar=mslp500 

UserPostedImage


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Ally Pally Snowman
07 December 2022 07:57:46
Yes the ECM ensembles are much better this morning but they do tend to swing with the Op. The drama has a few days to run yet.

 


Bishop's Stortford 85m ASL.
Brian Gaze
07 December 2022 08:24:09
ECM is actually a pretty dry run. Certainly not a big snow event in the south next week if it is correct.
Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
07 December 2022 08:30:27
The old joke about 2 economists getting you 3 opinions applies to the models at the moment; only it's a case of N models giving you 2N opinions, as they all change come the next run. But for the moment ...

WX temps show cold air well spread across W Europe including Britain in week 1, withdrawing to E France in week 2 but intensifying, Britain still on the cold side, though; a bigger mass of extra-cold air developing over Siberia; a little milder over Spain but colder in the Balkans. Mainly dry over Britain in week 1 with pptn all around; in week 2 the pattern shifts to one patch on the N Atlantic also affecting britain, and intense rainfall separately around Greece.

GFS Op - Britain under N/NE lies resulting from LP over Scandinavia which slowly fills leaving cold air over Britain to mon 12th. This morning's treatment of the Atlantic LP leaves it W of Ireland and Britain under a weak N-S ridge of \HP (1015mb) Wed 14th. High pressure continues to be present and intensifies as part of a Scandinavian HP 1035mb Sun 18th N Sea and strong S-lies for W coasts. The Atlantic LP then diversifies into a trough moving E-wards across Britain and the final chart, Fri 23rd, shows something 'normal' for midwinter with W-lies between HP to the SW and LP over Iceland.

ECM - the coldies' favourite; from Mon 12th the Atlantic LP projects a trough into the Channel Wed 14th 995mb N France with enough cold air advected from the E to suggest the possibility of snow in S England. The LP then grows into a three-centre feature Fri 16th, 995mb Germany, 1000mb Finland and 995 mb Norwegian Sea, all with quite cold air advected over Britain. A startling difference from GFS.

GEFS - remaining v cold and mainly dry to Tue 13th after which chaos ensues; the mean is back to norm but this means very little with e.g.  selected runs in the S, Sun 18th one 10C above norm and one 10C below. Most ens members have some pptn from that Tue with snow row figures highest as the potential breakdown starts 

Other models are available, as they say.


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

Gandalf The White
07 December 2022 08:48:23

ECM is actually a pretty dry run. Certainly not a big snow event in the south next week if it is correct.

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

Yes, the precipitation only skirts the far south on the 00z op.  But given the band of rain/snow is only, what,  50-100 miles wide, any slight adjustments in the modelling will have huge consequences for any specific location.

As others have said, this will only slowly become clearer into the weekend, and in terms of precise detail not even by then. But potential, certainly.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



nsrobins
07 December 2022 09:20:21
Someone on the other side made a good point this morning - if we could re-analyse the charts and (if they existed) ensemble data for Dec 1963, Feb 1978 and Jan 1987 for instance, we'd probably see just the same amount of uncertainty and spread leading up to those event, if not more. And actually the 2010 episode has many a wobble and variation even 5 days out. I completely accept that the scripting of NWP and the associated processing power is exponentially better than it was just 20 yrs ago, but subtle changes to starting data are introduced for a reason - because the starting data itself has error bars and is often sparse in areas where it's needed.

The skill in medium term forecasting is not in the interpreation of one chart from one model, but in looking at all available data and deriving a blended solution that (at the time) is most likely, with the caveat that it will change from hour to hour. I find the intense scrutiny of every chart entertaining, but in scientific and practical terms it is not the best approach.

 


Neil

Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)

Stormchaser, Member TORRO

Brian Gaze
07 December 2022 09:30:16
Indeed. 🙄

Other basic pointers are: 1) Be sure you know what chart you are looking at and make sure it isn't a cached version 2) Check the forecast variables such as precipitation before making assumptions about what it is showing 😁


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Downpour
07 December 2022 09:34:24

Indeed. 🙄

Other basic pointers are: 1) Be sure you know what chart you are looking at and make sure it isn't a cached version 2) Check the forecast variables such as precipitation before making assumptions about what it is showing 😁

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

Dry, if not very dry, for the reliable timeframe.

Midweek next week might offer some interest, on the nearer shores of Fantasy Island.


Chingford

London E4

147ft

Whiteout
07 December 2022 09:39:45

Someone on the other side made a good point this morning - if we could re-analyse the charts and (if they existed) ensemble data for Dec 1963, Feb 1978 and Jan 1987 for instance, we'd probably see just the same amount of uncertainty and spread leading up to those event, if not more. And actually the 2010 episode has many a wobble and variation even 5 days out. I completely accept that the scripting of NWP and the associated processing power is exponentially better than it was just 20 yrs ago, but subtle changes to starting data are introduced for a reason - because the starting data itself has error bars and is often sparse in areas where it's needed.

The skill in medium term forecasting is not in the interpreation of one chart from one model, but in looking at all available data and deriving a blended solution that (at the time) is most likely, with the caveat that it will change from hour to hour. I find the intense scrutiny of every chart entertaining, but in scientific and practical terms it is not the best approach.

 

Originally Posted by: nsrobins 

Surely Neil this is summed up by the fax charts, now they are in the reliable time frame these have to be the 'sense of truth', afterall they are made up are they not of all forecasts with human input 🙂


Home/Work - Dartmoor

240m/785 ft asl

The Beast from the East
07 December 2022 09:49:11
What is wrong with Meteociel? Cant seem to get GFS
Purley, Surrey, 70m ASL

"We have some alternative facts for you"

Kelly-Ann Conway - former special adviser to the President

MRayner
07 December 2022 09:50:56
This cold air arriving is certainly not that cold , raining here , temp goes up in showers to 1.9C , and temps in Orkney still 1.5C with rain showers 🤔, is the sea temps diluting this cold air ?
Location Whisky 🥃 country, Cragganmore ,Moray, 440 AMSL

Lionel Hutz
07 December 2022 09:52:28

Surely Neil this is summed up by the fax charts, now they are in the reliable time frame these have to be the 'sense of truth', afterall they are made up are they not of all forecasts with human input 🙂

Originally Posted by: Whiteout 

👍

Perhaps others will disagree but for me, it's only when things appear in the FAX charts that they are in the reliable(and even then nothing is absolutely certain).


Lionel Hutz

Nr.Waterford , S E Ireland

68m ASL



Zubzero
07 December 2022 10:01:33
The lead up to 2010 cold spell on the charts was massively different to now. 

Heavy Weather mentioned why Retron hasn't commented  onthis cold spell so far. Normally he'd do a -10 850hpa or more ens watch,  apart from the odd ens that briefly touch -10  and so far there is very little sign of much snow away from the hills and costs in the North. Any charts are still at 6+ days away that show any decent snowfall and are random with little to any ens or X model support. It may change but so far it's just a cold and mostly dry spell of Weather, nothing much to write home about for now. 

nsrobins
07 December 2022 10:26:40

What is wrong with Meteociel? Cant seem to get GFS

Originally Posted by: The Beast from the East 

Meteociel has frozen half way into the 00Z run and Wetter is painfully slow. A lot of stress of their servers.


Neil

Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)

Stormchaser, Member TORRO

fairweather
07 December 2022 10:37:01
Fun to discuss snow potential but until the TV presenters get confident it is unlikely to be an accurate assumption but no problem in having a go. Nevertheless, sticking to the knowns, it is going to be a very cold week ahead with the risk of frosts even in the South. (None so far here). After a week or so there are a large number of models now suggesting something milder but of course with far less certainty. However we know how that usually turns out. 
S.Essex, 42m ASL
Gandalf The White
07 December 2022 10:37:46

The lead up to 2010 cold spell on the charts was massively different to now. 

Heavy Weather mentioned why Retron hasn't commented  onthis cold spell so far. Normally he'd do a -10 850hpa or more ens watch,  apart from the odd ens that briefly touch -10  and so far there is very little sign of much snow away from the hills and costs in the North. Any charts are still at 6+ days away that show any decent snowfall and are random with little to any ens or X model support. It may change but so far it's just a cold and mostly dry spell of Weather, nothing much to write home about for now. 

Originally Posted by: Zubzero 

So, pretty much what we should expect from an early December northerly - which has so far only arrived in the far north.  It was ever the case that a bone dry Arctic flow required disturbances in the flow or an incursion of less cold, moist air to get any wintry precipitation inland.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



fairweather
07 December 2022 10:40:33

The lead up to 2010 cold spell on the charts was massively different to now. 

Heavy Weather mentioned why Retron hasn't commented  onthis cold spell so far. Normally he'd do a -10 850hpa or more ens watch,  apart from the odd ens that briefly touch -10  and so far there is very little sign of much snow away from the hills and costs in the North. Any charts are still at 6+ days away that show any decent snowfall and are random with little to any ens or X model support. It may change but so far it's just a cold and mostly dry spell of Weather, nothing much to write home about for now. 

Originally Posted by: Zubzero 

👍


S.Essex, 42m ASL
moomin75
07 December 2022 10:47:14
Literally laughing out loud at the 6z FI this time around. Bringing in almost "winter heatwave" conditions now with temperatures up to around 15c. ​​​​​​​Christmas BBQ on the cards? 😂😂😂  ​​​​​​​Just a 17c difference at 2m when compared with yesterday's 6z. 
Witney, Oxfordshire

100m ASL

The Beast from the East
07 December 2022 10:53:16

Literally laughing out loud at the 6z FI this time around. Bringing in almost "winter heatwave" conditions now with temperatures up to around 15c. Christmas BBQ on the cards? 😂😂😂  ​​​​​​​Just a 17c difference at 2m when compared with yesterday's 6z. 

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

I cant get it on Meteciel

Can someone post link


Purley, Surrey, 70m ASL

"We have some alternative facts for you"

Kelly-Ann Conway - former special adviser to the President

Justin W
07 December 2022 11:05:38
I've been posting on this site since Brian fired it up in 2000 and experience tells me that if the GFS op shows a cold spell going t1ts up in two consecutive runs, then it will go t1ts up. I realise that there will be several days of cold before the t1ts up moment before Michael points this out!
Yo yo yo. 148-3 to the 3 to the 6 to the 9, representing the ABQ, what up, biatch?
Gusty
07 December 2022 11:15:32
To be honest nothing has really changed since a few days ago. All quite simple really. 

The cold air is arriving today as forecast. We can now expect several days of dry and cold weather with wintry showers on windward coastal areas where moisture can be tapped into and if any disturbances can get involved eleswehere (only usuallly visible at 48 hours). Notably cold nights as well ! 

The middle of next week has always looked like the period for an atlantic push from the SW. If it's a strong push we eventually turn milder from the south. If it stays away to the south we stay very cold. A narrow battleground snow event on offer for some if the front does get close enough.

I think all of this is great. I'd love to see the first atlantic push repelled by the cold block keeping us potentially wintry for another week or so as we edge closer to Xmas. Some snow would also be the icing on the cake.

 

 


Steve - Folkestone, Kent

Current conditions from my Davis Vantage Vue

https://www.wunderground.com/dashboard/pws/IFOLKE11 

Join Kent Weather on Facebook.

https://www.facebook.com/stevewall69/ 



Saint Snow
07 December 2022 11:17:40

To be honest nothing has really changed since a few days ago. All quite simple really. 

The cold air is arriving today as forecast. We can now expect several days of dry and cold weather with wintry showers on windward coastal areas where moisture can be tapped into and if any disturbances can get involved eleswehere (only usuallly visible at 48 hours). Notably cold nights as well ! 

The middle of next week has always looked like the period for an atlantic push from the SW. If it's a strong push we eventually turn milder from the south. If it stays away to the south we stay very cold. A narrow battleground snow event on offer for some if the front does get close enough.

I think all of this is great. I'd love to see the first atlantic push repelled by the cold block keeping us potentially wintry for another week or so as we edge closer to Xmas. Some snow would also be the icing on the cake.

 

Originally Posted by: Gusty 

Ideal scenario is that frontal snow pushes pretty far up the country to cover as much as possible, before stalling and being pushed back southwards (I know it would be snow-rain-snow for those further south)


Martin

Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)

A TWO addict since 14/12/01

"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."

Aneurin Bevan

doctormog
07 December 2022 11:50:04

I've been posting on this site since Brian fired it up in 2000 and experience tells me that if the GFS op shows a cold spell going t1ts up in two consecutive runs, then it will go t1ts up. I realise that there will be several days of cold before the t1ts up moment before Michael points this out!

Originally Posted by: Justin W 

I think many people could point that out before jumping straight to the area with lower confidence and making a guess based on limited evidence from 2 operational runs of one model.

Unsurprisingly the 06z GFS op run is a mild outlier in the medium to long term, with the t850hPa being over ten degress above the mean by the 29th (in London).


nsrobins
07 December 2022 11:54:58

I think many people could point that out before jumping straight to the area with lower confidence and making a guess based on limited evidence from 2 operational runs of one model.

Unsurprisingly the 06z GFS op run is a mild outlier in the medium to long term, with the t850hPa being over ten degress above the mean by the 29th (in London).

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

I mentioned the mean just now but I think I got away with it :)

Justin has a point - when GFS OP goes off on a different tack it should be noted but I'm not so sure if it's a given it will have got this right for the reasons previously stated ad nauseum.

The period in question has yet to get to 120hrs.


Neil

Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)

Stormchaser, Member TORRO

Remove ads from site