The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

Quantum
  • Quantum
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
30 January 2020 19:00:29

Popped into this thread a few times, and I'm not sure whether "unusually cold" is referring to air aloft or temperatures at the surface?

 

Above is the daily mean temperature and climate north of the 80th northern parallel estimated from the average of the 00z and 12z ECM analysis for all model grid points inside that area. 

Originally Posted by: Arcus 

Yes this is a little confusing. A few points to clear it up

a) DMI is only the region around the North pole not the arctic ocean as a whole. The north pole has been slightly less cold than, for example, the beaufort or barents.

b) Even above average can mean 'unusually cold'. The arctic is warming so rapidaly that every single year sees winter temperatures 10+C above the line on DMI. Compare it to some previous years and you will see what I mean! If you did, say, a linear fit of the arctic temperature over the last 40 or so years you'd get a steep positive line. 2020 would be well below that line though even if it is well above an average from the 80s, 90s or even 00s.

c) And even if there are positive anomolies over the arctic there are even higher positive anomolies on the NHem continents. Most recent winters you see insanely high positive anomolies in the arctic and neutral or negative anomolies on the continents. This year it has flipped.

 


25/26 (850hpa temp) 11 days snow/sleet falling

18/11 (-4) 19/11 (-6) 20/11 (-6) 01/01 (-7) 04/01 (-10) 10/01 (-7) 11/01 (-3) 30/01 (-1) 13/02 (-6) 15/02 (-4) 18/02 (-6)

24/25 10d

18/11 (-6) 19/11 (-6) 23/11 (-2) 22/12 (-5) 04/01 (-5) 05/01 (0)14/02 (0) 15/02 (0)12/03 (-6) 13/03 (-6)

23/24 8d

29/11 (-6) 30/11 (-6) 02/12 (-5) 03/12 (-5) 04/12 (-3) 16/01 (-3) 18/01 (-8)08/02 (-5)

22/23 7d

18/12 (-1)06/03 (-6) 08/03 (-8) 09/03 (-6) 10/03 (-8) 11/03 (-5) 14/03 (-6)

21/22 12d

Arcus
30 January 2020 19:03:06

 

Genuine answer. No idea  (but it’s a fair question and my point was just to suggest that what you are asking is at least in theory a possibility, but I have not checked).

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

Thanks , I'm hoping for an anomaly chart posting from someone who's got a better bookmark collection than me.


Ben,

Nr. Easingwold, North Yorkshire

30m asl

Arcus
30 January 2020 19:04:28

 

Yes this is a little confusing. A few points to clear it up

a) DMI is only the region around the North pole not the arctic ocean as a whole. The north pole has been slightly less cold than, for example, the beaufort or barents.

b) Even above average can mean 'unusually cold'. The arctic is warming so rapidaly that every single year sees winter temperatures 10+C above the line on DMI. Compare it to some previous years and you will see what I mean! If you did, say, a linear fit of the arctic temperature over the last 40 or so years you'd get a steep positive line. 2020 would be well below that line though even if it is well above an average from the 80s, 90s or even 00s.

c) And even if there are positive anomolies over the arctic there are even higher positive anomolies on the NHem continents. Most recent winters you see insanely high positive anomolies in the arctic and neutral or negative anomolies on the continents. This year it has flipped.

 

Originally Posted by: Quantum 

Thanks Q 


Ben,

Nr. Easingwold, North Yorkshire

30m asl

Quantum
  • Quantum
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
30 January 2020 19:49:55

Oh one final point.

2m temps are strongly related, also, to the thickness and quality of the sea ice. This is largelly the reason why Global warming affects the arctic ocean more strongly than any other reason.

So even below average 850hpa temps (compared to say the 80s) may well give above average 2m temps because the sea ice is only 1m thick compared to 3m thick.

 


25/26 (850hpa temp) 11 days snow/sleet falling

18/11 (-4) 19/11 (-6) 20/11 (-6) 01/01 (-7) 04/01 (-10) 10/01 (-7) 11/01 (-3) 30/01 (-1) 13/02 (-6) 15/02 (-4) 18/02 (-6)

24/25 10d

18/11 (-6) 19/11 (-6) 23/11 (-2) 22/12 (-5) 04/01 (-5) 05/01 (0)14/02 (0) 15/02 (0)12/03 (-6) 13/03 (-6)

23/24 8d

29/11 (-6) 30/11 (-6) 02/12 (-5) 03/12 (-5) 04/12 (-3) 16/01 (-3) 18/01 (-8)08/02 (-5)

22/23 7d

18/12 (-1)06/03 (-6) 08/03 (-8) 09/03 (-6) 10/03 (-8) 11/03 (-5) 14/03 (-6)

21/22 12d

Chunky Pea
31 January 2020 12:37:28

If this were to verify for next weekend (and a high chance that it won't) it would make it the lowest temp anom over the greater Arctic region (60 N)  for this time of year since 1989!

 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Quantum
  • Quantum
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
31 January 2020 12:51:04

Arctic sea ice is responding.

 


25/26 (850hpa temp) 11 days snow/sleet falling

18/11 (-4) 19/11 (-6) 20/11 (-6) 01/01 (-7) 04/01 (-10) 10/01 (-7) 11/01 (-3) 30/01 (-1) 13/02 (-6) 15/02 (-4) 18/02 (-6)

24/25 10d

18/11 (-6) 19/11 (-6) 23/11 (-2) 22/12 (-5) 04/01 (-5) 05/01 (0)14/02 (0) 15/02 (0)12/03 (-6) 13/03 (-6)

23/24 8d

29/11 (-6) 30/11 (-6) 02/12 (-5) 03/12 (-5) 04/12 (-3) 16/01 (-3) 18/01 (-8)08/02 (-5)

22/23 7d

18/12 (-1)06/03 (-6) 08/03 (-8) 09/03 (-6) 10/03 (-8) 11/03 (-5) 14/03 (-6)

21/22 12d

Chunky Pea
31 January 2020 13:02:37

Just reading T. A Harley's assessment of early 1989 and it was one of the mildest on record apparently. I wonder is there is a connection between an unusually cold Arctic and warmer temps over N Europe during the winter months? 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Quantum
  • Quantum
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
31 January 2020 13:14:13

Just reading T. A Harley's assessment of early 1989 and it was one of the mildest on record apparently. I wonder is there is a connection between an unusually cold Arctic and warmer temps over N Europe during the winter months? 

Originally Posted by: Chunky Pea 

I'm sure there must be.

I can't really think of a pattern that would easily make both cold or both mild.

Well if it's just N europe then possibly, but if it's low latitudes in general.

 

 


25/26 (850hpa temp) 11 days snow/sleet falling

18/11 (-4) 19/11 (-6) 20/11 (-6) 01/01 (-7) 04/01 (-10) 10/01 (-7) 11/01 (-3) 30/01 (-1) 13/02 (-6) 15/02 (-4) 18/02 (-6)

24/25 10d

18/11 (-6) 19/11 (-6) 23/11 (-2) 22/12 (-5) 04/01 (-5) 05/01 (0)14/02 (0) 15/02 (0)12/03 (-6) 13/03 (-6)

23/24 8d

29/11 (-6) 30/11 (-6) 02/12 (-5) 03/12 (-5) 04/12 (-3) 16/01 (-3) 18/01 (-8)08/02 (-5)

22/23 7d

18/12 (-1)06/03 (-6) 08/03 (-8) 09/03 (-6) 10/03 (-8) 11/03 (-5) 14/03 (-6)

21/22 12d

Chunky Pea
31 January 2020 13:16:00

 

I'm sure there must be.

I can't really think of a pattern that would easily make both cold or both mild.

Well if it's just N europe then possibly, but if it's low latitudes in general.

Originally Posted by: Quantum 

December 2010 might be one example. 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Quantum
  • Quantum
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
31 January 2020 13:19:56

 

December 2010 might be one example. 

Originally Posted by: Chunky Pea 

Dec 2010 was classic 'warm arctic, cold continents' though.
Very cold over the whole of the Erasian continent. But the arctic was very warm indeed.

 


25/26 (850hpa temp) 11 days snow/sleet falling

18/11 (-4) 19/11 (-6) 20/11 (-6) 01/01 (-7) 04/01 (-10) 10/01 (-7) 11/01 (-3) 30/01 (-1) 13/02 (-6) 15/02 (-4) 18/02 (-6)

24/25 10d

18/11 (-6) 19/11 (-6) 23/11 (-2) 22/12 (-5) 04/01 (-5) 05/01 (0)14/02 (0) 15/02 (0)12/03 (-6) 13/03 (-6)

23/24 8d

29/11 (-6) 30/11 (-6) 02/12 (-5) 03/12 (-5) 04/12 (-3) 16/01 (-3) 18/01 (-8)08/02 (-5)

22/23 7d

18/12 (-1)06/03 (-6) 08/03 (-8) 09/03 (-6) 10/03 (-8) 11/03 (-5) 14/03 (-6)

21/22 12d

kmoorman
31 January 2020 13:26:34

 

Dec 2010 was classic 'warm arctic, cold continents' though.
Very cold over the whole of the Erasian continent. But the arctic was very warm indeed.

 

Originally Posted by: Quantum 

 

My working assumption is that there's only so much cold to go around.  If it's all 'up north' we get nothing.


Home: Durrington, Worthing, West Sussex. (16 ASL)

Work: Canary Wharf, London

Follow me on Twitter @kmoorman1968

Chunky Pea
31 January 2020 13:27:02

Yes, looking at the maps, you are right Q, though the Arctic was particularly cold prior to that secondary outbreak over these parts. 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Winters Tale
31 January 2020 21:19:04

I noticed that temps near the pole have reached -40C today. Not sure I've seen temperatures that cold there in quite a long time. The arctic anomaly is also just below average at -0.1C today. 

It will be really interesting to see if this cold arctic trend remains through February and into the spring and if it will have a less dramatic effect on the melt season. 

 

Grant

David M Porter
01 February 2020 10:19:07

I have to say that I do find it somewhat strange that the record cold temperatures seen in the arctic over the past month or so have had virtually no mention at all in any section of the mainstream press, at least from what I have seen.

I am grateful to Quantum for opening this thread, as I and I imagine a great many other people would otherwise probably not have been aware of what has been happening in the arctic recently.


Lenzie, Glasgow

"A body of men holding themselves accountable to nobody ought not to be trusted by anybody." – Thomas Paine

doctormog
01 February 2020 11:34:11

I have to say that I do find it somewhat strange that the record cold temperatures seen in the arctic over the past month or so have had virtually no mention at all in any section of the mainstream press, at least from what I have seen.

I am grateful to Quantum for opening this thread, as I and I imagine a great many other people would otherwise probably not have been aware of what has been happening in the arctic recently.

Originally Posted by: David M Porter 

Have there actually been any record cold temperatures in the Arctic?


Quantum
  • Quantum
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
01 February 2020 13:02:00

 

Have there actually been any record cold temperatures in the Arctic?

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

I haven't done an exhaustative analysis on this. But I believe so yes.

Around new year's day the tropospheric polar vortex was particularly strong and yielded records across Alaska, Nunuvat and most notably greenland. In fact, although I'm not sure it has been verified, we may have seen the coldest northern hemisphere temp outside of siberia ever.


25/26 (850hpa temp) 11 days snow/sleet falling

18/11 (-4) 19/11 (-6) 20/11 (-6) 01/01 (-7) 04/01 (-10) 10/01 (-7) 11/01 (-3) 30/01 (-1) 13/02 (-6) 15/02 (-4) 18/02 (-6)

24/25 10d

18/11 (-6) 19/11 (-6) 23/11 (-2) 22/12 (-5) 04/01 (-5) 05/01 (0)14/02 (0) 15/02 (0)12/03 (-6) 13/03 (-6)

23/24 8d

29/11 (-6) 30/11 (-6) 02/12 (-5) 03/12 (-5) 04/12 (-3) 16/01 (-3) 18/01 (-8)08/02 (-5)

22/23 7d

18/12 (-1)06/03 (-6) 08/03 (-8) 09/03 (-6) 10/03 (-8) 11/03 (-5) 14/03 (-6)

21/22 12d

Quantum
  • Quantum
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
01 February 2020 13:03:35

 

If this keeps going we will end up outside of the bottom 15, I can't remember the last time that happened. Possibly the 90s.

 


25/26 (850hpa temp) 11 days snow/sleet falling

18/11 (-4) 19/11 (-6) 20/11 (-6) 01/01 (-7) 04/01 (-10) 10/01 (-7) 11/01 (-3) 30/01 (-1) 13/02 (-6) 15/02 (-4) 18/02 (-6)

24/25 10d

18/11 (-6) 19/11 (-6) 23/11 (-2) 22/12 (-5) 04/01 (-5) 05/01 (0)14/02 (0) 15/02 (0)12/03 (-6) 13/03 (-6)

23/24 8d

29/11 (-6) 30/11 (-6) 02/12 (-5) 03/12 (-5) 04/12 (-3) 16/01 (-3) 18/01 (-8)08/02 (-5)

22/23 7d

18/12 (-1)06/03 (-6) 08/03 (-8) 09/03 (-6) 10/03 (-8) 11/03 (-5) 14/03 (-6)

21/22 12d

Quantum
  • Quantum
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
01 February 2020 13:05:00

One curious thing about all this is the sheer strength of the climate change signal across the arctic, it's so disproportinate. No one can really 'feel' climate change at lower latitudes, but watch the arctic for a few years and you really can.

If it wasn't for climate change I suspect this would be the coldest year for more than 3 decades.


25/26 (850hpa temp) 11 days snow/sleet falling

18/11 (-4) 19/11 (-6) 20/11 (-6) 01/01 (-7) 04/01 (-10) 10/01 (-7) 11/01 (-3) 30/01 (-1) 13/02 (-6) 15/02 (-4) 18/02 (-6)

24/25 10d

18/11 (-6) 19/11 (-6) 23/11 (-2) 22/12 (-5) 04/01 (-5) 05/01 (0)14/02 (0) 15/02 (0)12/03 (-6) 13/03 (-6)

23/24 8d

29/11 (-6) 30/11 (-6) 02/12 (-5) 03/12 (-5) 04/12 (-3) 16/01 (-3) 18/01 (-8)08/02 (-5)

22/23 7d

18/12 (-1)06/03 (-6) 08/03 (-8) 09/03 (-6) 10/03 (-8) 11/03 (-5) 14/03 (-6)

21/22 12d

doctormog
01 February 2020 13:05:32

 

I haven't done an exhaustative analysis on this. But I believe so yes.

Around new year's day the tropospheric polar vortex was particularly strong and yielded records across Alaska, Nunuvat and most notably greenland. In fact, although I'm not sure it has been verified, we may have seen the coldest northern hemisphere temp outside of siberia ever.

Originally Posted by: Quantum 

I have kept an eye on this and except for specific location daily records I am not sure any records have been set. There has been some anomalous cold at times in a few places but not record breaking as far as I know.


Quantum
  • Quantum
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
01 February 2020 13:10:34

 

I have kept an eye on this and except for specific location daily records I am not sure any records have been set. There has been some anomalous cold at times in a few places but not record breaking as far as I know.

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

The greenland figure was -66C I believe.

I think part of the problem is that it's quite difficult to get hold of the exhausative data. Most of the time it's only every hour or so and to the nearest degree. It's also difficult to find some stations (for example greenland summit)

 


25/26 (850hpa temp) 11 days snow/sleet falling

18/11 (-4) 19/11 (-6) 20/11 (-6) 01/01 (-7) 04/01 (-10) 10/01 (-7) 11/01 (-3) 30/01 (-1) 13/02 (-6) 15/02 (-4) 18/02 (-6)

24/25 10d

18/11 (-6) 19/11 (-6) 23/11 (-2) 22/12 (-5) 04/01 (-5) 05/01 (0)14/02 (0) 15/02 (0)12/03 (-6) 13/03 (-6)

23/24 8d

29/11 (-6) 30/11 (-6) 02/12 (-5) 03/12 (-5) 04/12 (-3) 16/01 (-3) 18/01 (-8)08/02 (-5)

22/23 7d

18/12 (-1)06/03 (-6) 08/03 (-8) 09/03 (-6) 10/03 (-8) 11/03 (-5) 14/03 (-6)

21/22 12d

doctormog
01 February 2020 13:19:48

 

The greenland figure was -66C I believe.

I think part of the problem is that it's quite difficult to get hold of the exhausative data. Most of the time it's only every hour or so and to the nearest degree. It's also difficult to find some stations (for example greenland summit)

 

Originally Posted by: Quantum 

I looked at the official data for Summit Camp on the date in question at the time and there is absolutely no evidence that -66°C was reached. I think the value was around or just above -60°C (-59.2°C rings a bell). Yes that is very cold but not record breaking as far as I know.


Quantum
  • Quantum
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
01 February 2020 13:25:04

 

I looked at the official data for Summit Camp on the date in question at the time and there is absolutely no evidence that -66°C was reached. I think the value was around or just above -60°C (-59.2°C rings a bell). Yes that is very cold but not record breaking as far as I know.

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

-86.8F


25/26 (850hpa temp) 11 days snow/sleet falling

18/11 (-4) 19/11 (-6) 20/11 (-6) 01/01 (-7) 04/01 (-10) 10/01 (-7) 11/01 (-3) 30/01 (-1) 13/02 (-6) 15/02 (-4) 18/02 (-6)

24/25 10d

18/11 (-6) 19/11 (-6) 23/11 (-2) 22/12 (-5) 04/01 (-5) 05/01 (0)14/02 (0) 15/02 (0)12/03 (-6) 13/03 (-6)

23/24 8d

29/11 (-6) 30/11 (-6) 02/12 (-5) 03/12 (-5) 04/12 (-3) 16/01 (-3) 18/01 (-8)08/02 (-5)

22/23 7d

18/12 (-1)06/03 (-6) 08/03 (-8) 09/03 (-6) 10/03 (-8) 11/03 (-5) 14/03 (-6)

21/22 12d

Chunky Pea
01 February 2020 13:26:18

 

If this keeps going we will end up outside of the bottom 15, I can't remember the last time that happened. Possibly the 90s.

 

Originally Posted by: Quantum 

I thought sea ice extent was more dependant on SSTs than air temperature alone? Though having said that, one is bound to influence the other anyway. 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Quantum
  • Quantum
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
01 February 2020 13:30:54


25/26 (850hpa temp) 11 days snow/sleet falling

18/11 (-4) 19/11 (-6) 20/11 (-6) 01/01 (-7) 04/01 (-10) 10/01 (-7) 11/01 (-3) 30/01 (-1) 13/02 (-6) 15/02 (-4) 18/02 (-6)

24/25 10d

18/11 (-6) 19/11 (-6) 23/11 (-2) 22/12 (-5) 04/01 (-5) 05/01 (0)14/02 (0) 15/02 (0)12/03 (-6) 13/03 (-6)

23/24 8d

29/11 (-6) 30/11 (-6) 02/12 (-5) 03/12 (-5) 04/12 (-3) 16/01 (-3) 18/01 (-8)08/02 (-5)

22/23 7d

18/12 (-1)06/03 (-6) 08/03 (-8) 09/03 (-6) 10/03 (-8) 11/03 (-5) 14/03 (-6)

21/22 12d

doctormog
01 February 2020 13:34:37

Originally Posted by: Quantum 

Yes i have seen that as a provisional claim. I have not seen a source or verification for that graph and the official SYNOPS data and minimum for that date contradict the claim. https://www.ogimet.com/cgi-bin/gsynres?ind=04416&lang=en&decoded=yes&ndays=2&ano=2020&mes=01&day=04&hora=13 


Remove ads from site