Rather than me go on hearsay and befuddled recollection on my part (age does that to you, Let me point to the development of martin as an example.
8am 29 Oct.. the NHC discussion concludes..."Further development unlikely"
8pm 29 Oct.. ............................................."chances decreasing"
2pm 30 Oct................................................" development no longer anticipated"
5.45 am 31 Oct The area of disturbed weather no longer appears on NHC outlook charts or discussions.
2pm 31 Oct The area reappperas and the discusiion mentions ..." a small window of opportunity for development"
5.05am 1 Nov Nhc discussion concludes " 70% chance of development"
11am 1 Nov Now becomes Tropical Storm Martin
11am 2 Nov Upgraded to Hurricane Martin
Now this is just one example. I mentined before the dismissal that Lisa would cross into the Bay of Campeche, yet here with the remnants of Lisa in exactly that location. Doesnt look likely there will be regeneration, but based on the above with Martin...can we have confidence in NHC forecasting.
Ther are several other examples this season of similar outputs, but I have not the time nor inclination to look at them all. However if anyone is interested these archived discussions (back to 2014 in this set) can be found at the NHC archives https://www.nhc.noaa.gov/archive/xgtwo/gtwo_archive_list.php?basin=atl
Originally Posted by: Bow Echo