The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

tierradelfuego
23 July 2023 17:51:48

Strangely, I've now seen that the rain values shown on the VP 2 console do not equal those which appear in WeatherLink. For example, WeatherLink (after fully downloading the data successfully) is showing a total of 9.2mm for 22/07/23, but the console is reporting 11.4mm for the same period,

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

That does sound very strange Brian, no idea why, sorry. I have only ever used Cumulus from a software perspective.

Out of interest, as not sure if asked/confirmed previously... are you using the old style two-way tipping bucket or the newer spoon version?

I bought one of the ClimeMET manual gauges just out of interest from this thread, and my newer style spoon version is pretty much bang on the money.

Edit - the only reason I can think of for the discrepancy is a difference between midnight or 9am recording... perhaps.

 


Bucklebury

West Berkshire Downs AONB

135m ASL

VP2 with daytime FARS

Rainfall collector separated at ground level

Anemometer separated above roof level

WeatherLink Live (Byles Green Crew )

Brian Gaze
23 July 2023 17:53:58

That does sound very strange Brian, no idea why, sorry. I have only ever used Cumulus from a software perspective.

Out of interest, as not sure if asked/confirmed previously... are you using the old style two-way tipping bucket or the newer spoon version?

I bought one of the ClimeMET manual gauges just out of interest from this thread, and my newer style spoon version is pretty much bang on the money.

 

Originally Posted by: tierradelfuego 

It looks like this

https://www.davisinstruments.com/products/tipping-bucket-aluminum-plated 

So, I think that's the two-way tipping bucket.


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

tierradelfuego
23 July 2023 17:57:35

It looks like this

https://www.davisinstruments.com/products/tipping-bucket-aluminum-plated 

So, I think that's the two-way tipping bucket.

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

That is the old style that they changed a year or two ago. Not saying either is perfect but I do think the newer one records better...

Not sure if you would have seen my edit on the software discrepancy - the only reason I can think of for the discrepancy is a difference between midnight or 9am recording... perhaps.


Bucklebury

West Berkshire Downs AONB

135m ASL

VP2 with daytime FARS

Rainfall collector separated at ground level

Anemometer separated above roof level

WeatherLink Live (Byles Green Crew )

Brian Gaze
24 July 2023 07:29:21

That is the old style that they changed a year or two ago. Not saying either is perfect but I do think the newer one records better...

Not sure if you would have seen my edit on the software discrepancy - the only reason I can think of for the discrepancy is a difference between midnight or 9am recording... perhaps.

Originally Posted by: tierradelfuego 

Good suggestion, but it isn't the issue in my case. 


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

warrenb
24 July 2023 08:36:12
Thanks for pointing out rain tipper upgrade, just purchased from Weather Spares, on offer at the moment at £79
Brian Gaze
24 July 2023 11:31:51

Thanks for pointing out rain tipper upgrade, just purchased from Weather Spares, on offer at the moment at £79

Originally Posted by: warrenb 

I may also go down this route. Can you give an update on how it is easy to replace the existing bucket once you've done it?


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

warrenb
24 July 2023 15:19:07
I shall indeed. But looking at the video on the site it appears to be just unclipping the original and clipping in the new one.
tierradelfuego
24 July 2023 15:21:13

I may also go down this route. Can you give an update on how it is easy to replace the existing bucket once you've done it?

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

Took me about 2 minutes with a flat head screwdriver, simply pried at one end and the old one comes out...


Bucklebury

West Berkshire Downs AONB

135m ASL

VP2 with daytime FARS

Rainfall collector separated at ground level

Anemometer separated above roof level

WeatherLink Live (Byles Green Crew )

Chunky Pea
25 July 2023 16:19:20
Have been experimenting with another thermometer since January. The 'Govee Wi-Fi Thermo-Hygrometer', which, while advertised as an indoor thermo, works just as well outside. I placed this thermo inside of the Davis V2 stevenson screen to see how well it works against the actual Davis thermo and I am very well pleased with the results. 

A sample of recent readings from this Govee thermo, as taken inside of the V2 screen, and as viewed from my phone:

Temp and humidity:

UserPostedImage

and lower down in the screen, Dewpoint and VPD (great for measuring the 'drying' potential of the air).

UserPostedImage

What I have observed with using this particular wifi thermo:

1. it is much more 'sensitive' to tiny changes in air temp / hum than the V2 thermo. 

2. it is much quicker to react to sudden changes also. The V2 temp/hydro I have observed for years now, takes ages to react to a sudden drop/rise in temp.  

3. Far better at reading actual humidity, with full 100% readings when the air is truly saturated. Of all the different V2 thermos/hydros I've owned, not one of them ever read the actual humidity of the air right. My current one never goes beyond 92%, even if there is dense fog/drizzle out. The one before that never broke 95%, and the one before, 94%!! This new Govee one also more sensitive to lower humidity readings also, which once again, the V2 edition struggles with.

For a while now, I've been becoming increasingly annoyed with my Davis V2, as it has become a cumbersome, and at times, expensive machine to maintain. I think once this next V2 thermo/hydro goes bust (as they always do after a year or two), I'll be sticking solely with this new Govee gadget. This connects readily with your wifi so you can always get the latest reading on the dedicated app no matter where you are. Plus, you can view hourly, daily and monthly trends in a flash via line graphs etc, plus to option to export data into a CSV file. No fuss at all which is exactly what I want. 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Brian Gaze
25 July 2023 17:16:10

I shall indeed. But looking at the video on the site it appears to be just unclipping the original and clipping in the new one.

Originally Posted by: warrenb 

Thanks. 👍


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Brian Gaze
25 July 2023 17:17:33

For a while now, I've been becoming increasingly annoyed with my Davis V2, as it has become a cumbersome, and at times, expensive machine to maintain. I think once this next V2 thermo/hydro goes bust (as they always do after a year or two), I'll be sticking solely with this new Govee gadget. This connects readily with your wifi so you can always get the latest reading on the dedicated app no matter where you are. Plus, you can view hourly, daily and monthly trends in a flash via line graphs etc, plus to option to export data into a CSV file. No fuss at all which is exactly what I want. 

Originally Posted by: Chunky Pea 

I've been having the same thoughts with my VP2 and may start to consider alternatives.


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Brian Gaze
27 July 2023 06:47:34
Last night's rain was a good test. 

VP 2: 10.2mm

Analogue rain gauge: 15mm

That's conclusive for me. Last throw of the dice with my VP2 is to upgrade the rain tipping bucket / switch. If that doesn't produce more consistent results I'll start looking at alternative weather stations.


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

warrenb
28 July 2023 14:36:44
OK so got the new tipping bucket for VP2. Very simple to take out the old one and fit the new, just a flat head screwdriver to pop out the old, and a good firm push to insert the new one.

Most difficult part is of course getting the cable into the tiny hole for the connection. It hasn't rained yet, so haven't tested it.

I think one issue with the VP and rain is the leaf catcher in the bucket, there is also a new version of this, but the original which I have looks very deep before any rain can actually get into the bucket. I may be talking rubbish, but am now praying for rain to test it out.


Brian Gaze
29 July 2023 12:55:05
I've also just installed the new style VP 2 rain tipping spoon. Agree, installation is easy, although the cable is finicky. Waiting for rain too. 
Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Chunky Pea
02 August 2023 15:46:35

Then on days when nothing was recorded there was irritating drizzle or light showers that weren't enough to cause a tip 🤮

 

Originally Posted by: richardabdn 

One of Richard's posts borrowed from another thread, but it highlights another issue I have with the DV2 perfectly: the tipping frequency. All too often I have noticed even short lived heavy showers not being picked up on by the Davis due to its low resolution tipping measurement. Showers that can drench in seconds not being 'logged' until the next shower comes along or not at all until the next rain event that could be days onto the future. I really don't understand why the tip measurement was set at 0.3mm per tip and not 0.1mm or less which would prove to be far more accurate and useful. 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Brian Gaze
02 August 2023 17:11:19
I've now been using the new tipping spoon for several days. Unfortunately, the first test period turned into a fiasco when a number of flying ants drowned in my analogue gauge rendering an accurate reading impossible on Sunday. However, the rain total since midday yesterday is virtually identical on both devices. Therefore, I'm satisfied the VP2 is now measuring rainfall relatively accurately and the cause of the problem was a faulty sensor / reed switch.
Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Chunky Pea
05 October 2023 17:15:44
It's been raining, albeit only lightly, continuously for over 24hs now, and while my nearest official met station, located less than two miles away, recorded about 23mn over the period, my Davis has recorded the grand sum of 3.3mm for the same 

I'm a really sick to death of that machine at this stage. The hundreds upon hundreds of euros I have invested in it over the years, and it still never fails to let me down during sizable rain events. Same thing happened back in August too. The wettest day of the month and hardly a drop of rain was recorded. 🤬


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Brian Gaze
05 October 2023 17:21:19

It's been raining, albeit only lightly, continuously for over 24hs now, and while my nearest official met station, located less than two miles away, recorded about 23mn over the period, my Davis has recorded the grand sum of 3.3mm for the same 

I'm a really sick to death of that machine at this stage. The hundreds upon hundreds of euros I have invested in it over the years, and it still never fails to let me down during sizable rain events. Same thing happened back in August too. The wettest day of the month and hardly a drop of rain was recorded. 🤬

Originally Posted by: Chunky Pea 

Has yours got the new style tipping spoon? I've found it a lot more accurate, although I am convinced there was a fault on my old one because the readings were so far off the mark.

https://www.davisinstruments.com/products/vantage-pro2-tipping-spoon-replacement-kit 

 


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Chunky Pea
30 December 2023 12:44:25
It seems my that my Davis anemometer died a death sometime during the night. Still reporting direction, but no windspeed at this point. In fairness, the anemometer has worked well for the last 15 odd years or so, so it has had a good run. Normally, I'd be scrambling all the pennies I can muster to have replaced with a new one, but those days are gone. If it isn't one thing with the Davis V2, it's another, and it has cost me a bomb to maintain. Just the other day, the hydrometer started playing up by not reporting, or misreporting, humidity values. This is a tried and true sign that the whole thermo sensor is about to die.... yet again. It is just over a year old (was purchased and installed in Summer 2022).

When that inevitably goes completely, that too will not be replaced. It is obvious to me now that Davis sensors cannot tolerate a humid climate for very long. As I said in an earlier post, I am experimenting with another wifi temp sensor in the Davis radiation shield itself and am more than satisfied with the results of it. I just refuse to spend another 80 odd quid for yet another Davis temp/hydro sensor that rarely, if ever, lasts for more than 2 years. 

 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Retron
30 December 2023 13:09:14

It seems my that my Davis anemometer died a death sometime during the night. Still reporting direction, but no windspeed at this point. In fairness, the anemometer has worked well for the last 15 odd years or so, so it has had a good run. Normally, I'd be scrambling all the pennies I can muster to have replaced with a new one, but those days are gone. If it isn't one thing with the Davis V2, it's another, and it has cost me a bomb to maintain.

 

Originally Posted by: Chunky Pea 

You've really had rotten luck with yours! I installed my VP2 in 2020 and haven't had to touch it since then - aside from cleaning out some gunk from the rain gauge funnel a few times.

With the anemometers, I remember reading ages ago that the reed goes in them.  For the sake of £3, it might be worth a punt:

https://weatherspares.co.uk/products/davis-reed-switch-for-anemometer-wind-speed-module 

Edit: says you need some soldering skills, so that'd rule me out! 😆


Leysdown, north Kent
Chunky Pea
31 December 2023 09:30:44

You've really had rotten luck with yours! I installed my VP2 in 2020 and haven't had to touch it since then - aside from cleaning out some gunk from the rain gauge funnel a few times.

With the anemometers, I remember reading ages ago that the reed goes in them.  For the sake of £3, it might be worth a punt:

https://weatherspares.co.uk/products/davis-reed-switch-for-anemometer-wind-speed-module 

Edit: says you need some soldering skills, so that'd rule me out! 😆

Originally Posted by: Retron 

Thanks for that link, Retron. I'm going to give that a go actually. 

My anemometer is roof mounted, so I'll have to get a monkey brother of mine (he never needs a ladder to climb great heights!) to go up there when he has the time sometime in April or May. No way am I going to send him up there at this time of year when the steep roof is slimy with damp and drizzle greese. 

I see from looking data from last night that the anemometer randomly reported  windspeeds again just after 5am, only to stop again about 5 minutes later. Something definitely not connecting right alright. 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

warrenb
31 December 2023 09:34:43

Remove ads from site