The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

johncs2016
12 August 2023 18:50:40

Thing about summer is that it is never cold, so why bother wanting a record breaking temp? Ive yet to meet anyone who enjoys extreme heat. On paper, they say they do, but in the actual, they'll suffer as much as the rest of us. đŸ„”

 

Originally Posted by: Chunky Pea 

I'm fully in agreement with that.

Last year, I had to endure temperatures of around 35°C as far north as the Scottish Borders, and that just wasn't pleasant at all, so I would hate to imagine what it must have been like further south in those locations where the temperature reached 40°C at that same time (thankfully, there are no signs of that happening again on the latest model output, even on the hottest runs).

Having said that though, the summer is the time when I want to be seeing the highest temperatures of the year for the exact same reasons why I would want the coldest temperatures to occur during the winter.

When you add those two factors together, I would be looking for the hottest day to occur in the actual summer and be quite hot, but without getting anywhere near to the extent where this is likely to break all sorts of records.

This means that I will be more than happy to see a summer when the temperature here in Edinburgh gets to around 27/28°C at some point in time as long as those are the highest temperatures of that particular year.

Once the temperature up here gets to 30°C or higher though, that's when I start to get a bit uncomfortable and that would equally the case during the winter if there was ever such a time when the temperature here in Edinburgh got to around -20°C or lower in any given winter.

 


The north of Edinburgh, usually always missing out on snow events which occur not just within the rest of Scotland or the UK, but also within the rest of Edinburgh.

Chunky Pea
12 August 2023 19:18:48

Once the temperature up here gets to 30°C or higher though, that's when I start to get a bit uncomfortable and that would equally the case during the winter if there was ever such a time when the temperature here in Edinburgh got to around -20°C or lower in any given winter.

 

Originally Posted by: johncs2016 

Oddly, I find temps below about -3.0c to be more comfortable than the usual penetrating +6c to +9c winter mediocrity these parts are known for. 

During extreme heat, even those who profess to love it will find ways to cool down. Give me a 16c to 19c blue sky day anyway with a light, cooling breeze over a stagnant 25c plus with dp's in the high teens to low 20s, which sadly has become the norm with summers lately. 

 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
13 August 2023 07:19:02
WX temps; warm across all of Europe, indeed very warm in central regions and E Mediterranean, excepting N Scandinavia. Something of a pu-back from the N in week 2 with much cooler air from the NE affecting Russia, all of Scandinavia, maybe Scotland. SE England hanging on to some warmth, but the very warm weather is by then down to S France across to S Poland, but with some local hot spots in the Balkans. Rain patchy and well distributed in week 1 away from the Med which is dry; in week 2 organising into a band N Spain - France - the Baltic - Russia.

GFS Op; current LP over Scotland slowly clearing, just hanging back a little over the Midlands tomorrow, then pressure rises over Scandinavia and falls to the SW (by Fri 18th 1030mb Bothnia and 990mb Fastnet respectively) briefly generating a blast of warm air from the south*. The LP fills and moves NE-wards while the HP declines and by Wed 23rd Britain is under slack LP along with most of continental Europe. A separate LP 995mb S Russia is beginning to bring in the cooler weather mentioned above, but the remnants of this combined with an Atlantic ridge of HP turn the winds into the NE over Britain Sat 26th before the ridge moves S to cover Britain and the NE-lies affect the continent Mon 28th.

ECM; some differences in placing the LP (more to the W of Ireland than the SW) but broadly the same as GFS.

GEFS; near norm now but warming up around Fri 18th reaching about 5C above norm in the S, 3C in the N, much less than predicted a few days ago, but the temp steadily declines thereafter in most ens members with the mean back to norm Fri 25th (op & control indeed rather cool for a few days after that). Not much rain in the SE, greatest chances around Mon 21st. Pulse of rain crossing from Plymouth to Newcastle tomorrow, otherwise limited amounts for the rest of England and NE Scotland, more persistent in the NW.

* - edit - the BBC were showing a jet stream last night over Scotland and suggesting that the warm air might not get further north.

 


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

Rob K
13 August 2023 10:22:49

Quite possibly. I think statistically, the hottest day of the year happens 5-10% of the time in September. In 2011 it happened in October!

Originally Posted by: Bolty 

For some parts of the country that might possibly have been true but the hottest day of 2011 across the UK as a whole was June 27. 

Looking at this morning’s models I fear the idea of a warm and settled second half of August may have been a mirage. 


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

The Beast from the East
13 August 2023 11:02:58

For some parts of the country that might possibly have been true but the hottest day of 2011 across the UK as a whole was June 27. 

Looking at this morning’s models I fear the idea of a warm and settled second half of August may have been a mirage. 

Originally Posted by: Rob K 

06z offering some hope for the heat seekers, trough holds back for longer and backed up by the control, but an east west divide


Purley, Surrey, 70m ASL

"We have some alternative facts for you"

Kelly-Ann Conway - former special adviser to the President

Joe Bloggs
13 August 2023 11:04:13

For some parts of the country that might possibly have been true but the hottest day of 2011 across the UK as a whole was June 27. 

Looking at this morning’s models I fear the idea of a warm and settled second half of August may have been a mirage. 

Originally Posted by: Rob K 

I’m always wary when the MetO model doesn’t play ball. It was a stinker yesterday. 

Still looking warm though. 

The Beast from the East
13 August 2023 11:17:49
Pert 3 is a TimS special

https://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/gefs_cartes.php?code=3&ech=204&mode=1&carte=0&ext=0 


Purley, Surrey, 70m ASL

"We have some alternative facts for you"

Kelly-Ann Conway - former special adviser to the President

GezM
  • GezM
  • Advanced Member
13 August 2023 13:12:35

Pert 3 is a TimS special

https://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/gefs_cartes.php?code=3&ech=204&mode=1&carte=0&ext=0 

Originally Posted by: The Beast from the East 

Still a few hotter runs on the 6z and the Ops run is good but overall there are more cool perts on this run bringing the average 850 temp down. The trend this summer is for warmer perts to be wrong as we approach the day so my gut feeling is for nothing significant to happen for the foreseeable. 


Living in St Albans, Herts (116m asl)

Working at Luton Airport, Beds (160m asl)

Jiries
13 August 2023 13:23:35

Still a few hotter runs on the 6z and the Ops run is good but overall there are more cool perts on this run bringing the average 850 temp down. The trend this summer is for warmer perts to be wrong as we approach the day so my gut feeling is for nothing significant to happen for the foreseeable. 

Originally Posted by: GezM 

What happened to the hot weather that supposed to come next week?  Can 't find a reliable source to know what the weather be like as all current models, forecasts and apps had been severely wrong every single time.  Never seen a wrong occurring non-stop in the past newspapers, older TV forecasts and Ceefax/teletexts before?  Because of the wrongness all the time I only now rely from looking outside from the windows instead.

doctormog
13 August 2023 14:09:18

I remember looking at the models online in the 90s and the difference in the level inter-day changes and reliability compared with recent years is remarkable. The suggestion that 5 day forecast now are less accurate than in the Ceefax era is risible.


Jiries
13 August 2023 14:49:35

I remember looking at the models online in the 90s and the difference in the level inter-day changes and reliability compared with recent years is remarkable. The suggestion that 5 day forecast now are less accurate than in the Ceefax era is risible.

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

I remember the models was more better and accurate most times in the early days unheard of back tracking or downgrading in the reliable to mid range,.  Those country file forecasts and ceefax was more reliable very often with some wrongness but very rare unlike now very wrongness constantly.  If a model kept downgrading a heatwave or snowy event every time then it mean very unreliable and should had not need to show this in the first place for early to mid range.  Plus the apps are nasty one, extremely wrong even on the days itself.

doctormog
13 August 2023 14:53:04
I won’t waste my time with the numerous studies that show the improvement of NWP accuracy in recent decades as I think it would be dismissed out of hand.
Jiries
13 August 2023 14:55:04

Models itself in the early days, no back tracking, downgrading constantly in the early to mid range.  I used to view the charts a lot and always see it coming off from 7 days to 0 hours.   Models and apps are no use to me at all, window watching is the way to go and open the door to check if cold, stay in doors all day.   This Friday onward we supposed to be in a heatwave of low 30's in some places, now I see is just a tad above average are low 20's, so that big margin of error by nearly 10C within in a reliable range.  

Retron
13 August 2023 15:44:28

I won’t waste my time with the numerous studies that show the improvement of NWP accuracy in recent decades as I think it would be dismissed out of hand.

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

I think there is an element of trying to be too accurate.

In the old days, we would have had a "sunshine and showers" symbol on the BBC weather map, plonked over a large area, and for just a morning or afternoon time slot.

These days you'll have an exact copy of the UKV output for a given hour, complete with convective shower predictions. This feeds the apps, of course.

Sadly far too many people take those apps as gospel, and get quite annoyed if it rains when the app was showing sunshine! (This happens a lot, as the models still struggle with convective rainfall). It's much less of an issue for frontal rainfall, as that's generally easier to predict.

Similarly in the timespan Jiries is referring too, forecasts were by necessity brief. You would have had something like "scattered showers in the south and east, longer spells of rain over Scotland" - whereas these days you will have a weather app showing an 80% chance of rain at 10AM, a 0% chance at 11AM, and a 30% chance at noon... way too specific for most people's needs!

That said, with time we tend to remember the good (or completely wrong!) forecasts, rather than the mediocre "rain lighter than forecast", "high winds didn't show up" and so forth. There were plenty of times in the 80s and 90s, at least, where snow was mentioned but something cropped up and it didn't come off as planned. And other times, the opposite, of course: "Maybe enough snow for a snowball", said the TVS weather forecaster, then we had a foot and a week-long freeze!

Again, now we have all the ensemble output, model runs four or more times a day, we get to see all those aborted weather things that don't come off. Pre-Web, they simply wouldn't have been mentioned in most cases!

(The "chief forecaster's briefings" were used by the BBC back in the day too, I suspect they no longer have access to these now they've ditched the Met Office and access the data via a third party. A shame, as those briefings were fascinating!

From "Will", who worked at the Met Office in the 90s - this was posted in usw in 1999:

OK time to put a few misunderstandings to rest once and for all.

The TV forecasts, indeed all of the forecast output from UKMO is based on the

Chief forecaster's appraisal of the situation. With input from other forecasters

as well including those at the BBC on conference.

The forecasters at NMC Bracknell have access to every single model output from

all countries as well as a whole range of *proper* ensemble products as well as

mesoscale model outputs and frequent satellite data, radar data and all other

types of observations, the wealth of data is staggering. All of this is assessed

for consistency and runs which stand out will be noted but often not followed

even if it is the UKMO model. After coming to a consensus view the charts are

prepared using on-screen modification to ensure 4-D consistency.

The reasons behind the issue of the forecast charts and the weather that is

expected are then sent out to all UKMO forecast Offices as a briefing for all

forecasters including those on the media.

Sometimes alternative scenarios are drawn up with probability of occurrence.

These are for UKMO forecasters so that they can bear in mind when delivering

forecasts to customers.

That is a very general overview of the forecast process. Hope it clears up a few

misnomers.

There is no adherence to one model, all play their part, particularly the full

ensembles at longer range where they can provide more accurate guidance than any

one model. The superb handling of the recent anticyclonic spell with 1040 hPa

pressure is a case in point which was spot on in the ensemble mean which NMC

often used.

I rarely go into such detail in public, but as this is a scientific group I do

not wish mis-understandings to arise.

 


Leysdown, north Kent
Brian Gaze
13 August 2023 15:48:14

I think there is an element of trying to be too accurate.

In the old days, we would have had a "sunshine and showers" symbol on the BBC weather map, plonked over a large area, and for just a morning or afternoon time slot.

 

Originally Posted by: Retron 

👍 I've made this point before and think it is a big part of the problem.


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

doctormog
13 August 2023 15:55:24

I think there is an element of trying to be too accurate.

In the old days, we would have had a "sunshine and showers" symbol on the BBC weather map, plonked over a large area, and for just a morning or afternoon time slot.

These days you'll have an exact copy of the UKV output for a given hour, complete with convective shower predictions. This feeds the apps, of course.

Sadly far too many people take those apps as gospel, and get quite annoyed if it rains when the app was showing sunshine! (This happens a lot, as the models still struggle with convective rainfall). It's much less of an issue for frontal rainfall, as that's generally easier to predict.

Similarly in the timespan Jiries is referring too, forecasts were by necessity brief. You would have had something like "scattered showers in the south and east, longer spells of rain over Scotland" - whereas these days you will have a weather app showing an 80% chance of rain at 10AM, a 0% chance at 11AM, and a 30% chance at noon... way too specific for most people's needs!

 

Originally Posted by: Retron 

I agree, this is all true. However the insinuation that the models used to be reliable and are now less so is nonsense. Your explanation clearly shows where the issues arise both in terms of unnecessary/unreliable detail and over-reliance on or understanding of such detail (and probabilistic forecasts). 

There is an element of, what use is a forecast for an 80% chance of rain when you end up getting the 20% chance of no rain, but such is the nature of forecasting!


Spring Sun Winter Dread
13 August 2023 16:47:53
I remember some spectacular fails in forecasting 20+ years ago . Definitely wasn't the case that it was infallible or even that the broad pattern was always correctly forecast let alone the detail 

I once went to a festival expecting dry and sunny and temps in the late 20s C on the opening day and instead got a day of heavy rain to start, heavy showers the next day, with the hot and dry only arriving briefly a couple of days later. 

This was forecast from a day or 2 out as well .

 

David M Porter
13 August 2023 20:20:20

I think there is an element of trying to be too accurate.

In the old days, we would have had a "sunshine and showers" symbol on the BBC weather map, plonked over a large area, and for just a morning or afternoon time slot.

 

Originally Posted by: Retron 

Bring back the good old symbols!


Lenzie, Glasgow

"A body of men holding themselves accountable to nobody ought not to be trusted by anybody." – Thomas Paine

Chunky Pea
13 August 2023 22:30:02

I agree, this is all true. However the insinuation that the models used to be reliable and are now less so is nonsense. Your explanation clearly shows where the issues arise both in terms of unnecessary/unreliable detail and over-reliance on or understanding of such detail (and probabilistic forecasts). 

There is an element of, what use is a forecast for an 80% chance of rain when you end up getting the 20% chance of no rain, but such is the nature of forecasting!

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

I think longer range forecasts (5 to 7 days) forecasts in the olden days were more based on a broader trends rather than specifics, much like today. I also think, maybe wrongly, that forecasters today amore reliant on models than in the past, when their own intuition and personal knowledge would have been more relied upon. 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Caz
  • Caz
  • Advanced Member
14 August 2023 06:50:36
I don’t think forecasting is worse than it used to be and I agree they try to be too precise but I think our expectations are too high as well.   We expect accurate information to be available at our fingertips every minute of the day and the weather on this small island won’t play ball. 
Market Warsop, North Nottinghamshire.

Join the fun and banter of the monthly CET competition.

DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
14 August 2023 07:07:51
WX temp charts show very warm all across NW Europe in week 1, with a few hot spots in the Med, and Scandinavia though cooler than the rest si still above norm. In week 2, the weather cools down on  a broad front, with the very warm weather reduced to S France, the Danube Basin and points south of there. Still a little above norm for Britain. Rain in week 1 patchy from the Atlantic coast as far S as France and NE-wards from there; in week 2 heavier pptn from Scotland SE-wards to Ukraine, but a very dry area opening up in the Channel.

GFS Op; current LP moving away NE-wards to be replaced by the 'heat pump' of SE-lies between LP W of Ireland and HP over Norway. This only last to Sat 19th when the LP wins out and moves up to the Faeroes switching the winds to a fresher SW-ly through to Wed 23rd. The LP then drops down to Scotland before giving way to a N-S ridge of HP just about lasting out the BH weekend Sat 26th - Mon 28th. The final frames show HP to the S and LP to the N with a zonal W-ly stretching from Greenland to Russia. 

Jet stream shows a weak streak across Britain Mon 21st and something much stronger aimed directly at Britain Wed 30th.

ECM as GFS to Sun 20th when it reloads the heat pump to Tue 22nd before rejoining GFS with SW-lies

GEFS; a much diminished heat 'ripple' Thu/Fri 18th/19th then mean temp close to norm for the rest of the forecast, but with considerable variation in ens members; a minority want to bring back some warmth around Tue 22nd in the S. Rain fwidely on Sat 19th, otherwise only occasional dramatic totals in isolated runs in the S but smaller amounts more continuously further N. 


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

Brian Gaze
14 August 2023 07:07:52
Onwards and downwards. The Glorious Twelfth has been and gone so it's time to start thinking about autumn! 🍁

UserPostedImage


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

NMA
  • NMA
  • Advanced Member
14 August 2023 07:21:49

Onwards and downwards. The Glorious Twelfth has been and gone so it's time to start thinking about autumn! 🍁

UserPostedImage

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

That began in Luce Bay in early July for me. 🩈⛈Thank you Brian for mentioning it. Of course it begins in Scotland in earnest today I believe.

Apart from parts of Aberdeen where it's never left. 

Intuition is good when you don’t allow it to be clouded with personal bias i.e. hope casting. And that’s the hard part. Personal knowledge? Perhaps better but with today's computer models able to calculate all manner of possibilities that we were unable to do in the past, it’s still hard to spot trends in a chaotic system. Today's rain spot on I would say. Even the app is correct with light rain and moderate winds. But as Brian and Darren suggest, trying to be too exact is fraught with problems many times.

One thing I’ve noticed is that a model might for example pick up rain in six days time, drop the idea after three days and then a day or two before the original date bring it back again. And the original idea then comes up trumps with the rain.

 


Vale of the Great Dairies

South Dorset

Elevation 60m 197ft

Rob K
14 August 2023 09:44:00
Generally a rather uninspiring picture today. The only ray of hope is that the brief blip of warmer and more settled weather looks like it might just about coincide with my camping trip in a week's time. Although if GEM is right then even that isn't going to happen.
Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

Remove ads from site