The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

Gandalf The White
15 December 2022 00:27:29

Drunk logic incoming😋

I get the sentiment but.....

It's sort of like asking a mathmetician to do some sums:-

 2 x 2 x 3 = 12

Or

1.5/7*21+4(4x4)/7 = who knows  what the **** that comes to

People program the models, people who are much, much more intelligent than me but at the end of the day there are some situations that are easy to model and some that aren't.  I might get the 1st sum right, but might be off by a bit on the 2nd one. So a flat zonal flow I get right, a meridonal flow with a greenie HP I get nearly right. 

Originally Posted by: Hippydave 

I think there are two basic issues with the model output: firstly, the data that is plugged into the models as the starting point is not 100% accurate and therefore it doesn't matter how accurate the mathematical equations might be, those opening errors, however tiny, will multiply and eventually render the predictions wrong.   That is, of course, why they run ensemble suites, to test how tiny changes in the opening position will alter the evolution; as we have all seen, sometimes the effects are really quite significant within just a few days - whilst on other occasions there is reasonable stability for perhaps 5-6 days out (as we have seen recently).  There is also the fact that measuring 'stability' by looking at the effect at a single geographical point isn't especially reliable: if that point is at the margins of an air mass boundary it will look different to somewhere that is more stable.

The second issue is that the mathematical equations are, and can only be, an approximation to how the atmosphere behaves; that approximation has clearly got better over time, and the more grid points within the model then the better the results should be - as evidenced by the very high resolution short-term ones.  Even then, as we saw last weekend with the development of that small LP that brought snow to the south-east and Home Counties, some of even the high res ones simply didn't pick it up.  If they had the same opening data then that suggests errors in the model.

 


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



Arbroath 1320
15 December 2022 00:36:02

I think there are two basic issues with the model output: firstly, the data that is plugged into the models as the starting point is not 100% accurate and therefore it doesn't matter how accurate the mathematical equations might be, those opening errors, however tiny, will multiply and eventually render the predictions wrong.   That is, of course, why they run ensemble suites, to test how tiny changes in the opening position will alter the evolution; as we have all seen, sometimes the effects are really quite significant within just a few days - whilst on other occasions there is reasonable stability for perhaps 5-6 days out (as we have seen recently).  There is also the fact that measuring 'stability' by looking at the effect at a single geographical point isn't especially reliable: if that point is at the margins of an air mass boundary it will look different to somewhere that is more stable.

The second issue is that the mathematical equations are, and can only be, an approximation to how the atmosphere behaves; that approximation has clearly got better over time, and the more grid points within the model then the better the results should be - as evidenced by the very high resolution short-term ones.  Even then, as we saw last weekend with the development of that small LP that brought snow to the south-east and Home Counties, some of even the high res ones simply didn't pick it up.  If they had the same opening data then that suggests errors in the model.

 

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

Excellent post. And so accurate. 


Kenmore, Highland Perthshire, GGTTH
BJBlake
15 December 2022 00:41:19

incredible stuff. But the ease at which the models are flipping I wouldn’t rule out Pete tong returning for breakfast 

Originally Posted by: The Beast from the East 

ROFL - I hate Pete Tong - he too often gate crashes breakfast parties. In my experience. Santa - this way: Pete Tong - any other way! LOL
Brecklands, South Norfolk 28m ASL
BJBlake
15 December 2022 00:59:16

Excellent post. And so accurate. 

Originally Posted by: Arbroath 1320 

Agreed. Slam Dunk. Thats why its so fascinating to watch, as each evolution starts with a reset of the ‘now’ actual data, and we see the trends verify or evolve - and occasionally - to our liking or more often otherwise.  Our preferences may leave us hopeful or disappointed.

It’s a bit like watching Ipswich: On paper they should win, sometimes it plays out, but it just takes one bad tackle, a sending off,  or a fluke goal from the lowly opposition (as happed two weeks ago)...and most games you are on the edge of your seat, unable to relax, even if they are winning, because there are so many variables and possibilities. Keeps me watching them. . If the won every time, eventually, I’d get bored with it. With the models, those rare but amazing verifications of a trend emerging towards what is in the UK an unusual and transformational weather type - such as snowy Synoptics, in the context of normal for the UK - keeps me watching. 


Brecklands, South Norfolk 28m ASL
Heavy Weather 2013
15 December 2022 05:09:21
A less good ICON and GFS this morning it has to be said. Likely one of the variety of options that was in the suite yesterday. 

ICON very messy.

GFS develops a low south of Greenland which doesn’t phase very well with the low, creating a weak

and messy and short lived northerly. It does finish with a huge scandy high though.

More runs needed.


Mark

Beckton, E London

Less than 500m from the end of London City Airport runway.

Tim A
15 December 2022 07:30:16
At least it looks likely that Midlands Northwards will see some transient snow on Sunday.  Will only be a couple of hours though for most.  Maybe 3-8cm.  I will plan to go out with the kids between 9am and 12pm whilst it falls and before it starts to melt. 

 


Tim

NW Leeds

187m asl

 My PWS 

Rob K
15 December 2022 07:32:38
0Z GEFS mean is quite a lot milder again. Long way to go yet until this is settled. 
Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

Heavy Weather 2013
15 December 2022 07:34:35
Overall output this morning is a complete dogs dinner. 

There seems to be this random low spawn south of Iceland and it doesn’t know what to do with itself. 

The whole thing looks a mess to me and the subsequent scatter in the ensembles suggests we may have to wait a few more days for this to resolve itself. It’s annoying as we seemed to make some progress yesterday - just for things to go a bit messy. Equally, that does leave room for optimism. Until there is a definitive shift to mild, we cannot rule out a mild snap followed by a cold spell. 

The NH view is what makes this so fascinating 

 


Mark

Beckton, E London

Less than 500m from the end of London City Airport runway.

doctormog
15 December 2022 07:39:40

Overall output this morning is a complete dogs dinner. 

There seems to be this random low spawn south of Iceland and it doesn’t know what to do with itself. 

The whole thing looks a mess to me and the subsequent scatter in the ensembles suggests we may have to wait a few more days for this to resolve itself. It’s annoying as we seemed to make some progress yesterday - just for things to go a bit messy. Equally, that does leave room for optimism. Until there is a definitive shift to mild, we cannot rule out a mild snap followed by a cold spell. 

The NH view is what makes this so fascinating 

 

Originally Posted by: Heavy Weather 2013 

I think that’s a nice summary of what is still a very messy picture.


Caz
  • Caz
  • Advanced Member
15 December 2022 07:49:23

At least it looks likely that Midlands Northwards will see some transient snow on Sunday.  Will only be a couple of hours though for most.  Maybe 3-8cm.  I will plan to go out with the kids between 9am and 12pm whilst it falls and before it starts to melt. 

 

Originally Posted by: Tim A 

We haven’t seen a flake of snow yet and now our roof’s on our annexe, I’d be happy to see a bit of snow. 
Market Warsop, North Nottinghamshire.

Join the fun and banter of the monthly CET competition.

moomin75
15 December 2022 07:56:47

0Z GEFS mean is quite a lot milder again. Long way to go yet until this is settled.

Originally Posted by: Rob K 

Yep, and the latest MOGREPS show a mild blip, followed by a cold blip, and then a more sustained warm up.​​  
Witney, Oxfordshire

100m ASL

Jiries
15 December 2022 07:57:51

We haven’t seen a flake of snow yet and now our roof’s on our annexe, I’d be happy to see a bit of snow. 

Originally Posted by: Caz 

Also not seen snow in Nuneaton area and this bone dry spell still rate 0 to 10 because of that reason despite wasted very cold night here without snow covered to record much lower temps.  If models are messy then bin them all as they are all still far useless than the old days non internet forecasts 

Joe Bloggs
15 December 2022 08:02:52

Yep, and the latest MOGREPS show a mild blip, followed by a cold blip, and then a more sustained warm up.​​  

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

I just don’t think that’s correct.

Showing Birmingham as a fair example, I see a lot of scatter ranging from cool/cold (uppers around -5C) to mild. Wouldn’t describe it as a sustained warm up. 

UserPostedImage

 

Heavy Weather 2013
15 December 2022 08:05:34

Yep, and the latest MOGREPS show a mild blip, followed by a cold blip, and then a more sustained warm up.​​  

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

I’ve noted how you decided not to post any of the last three MOGREPS, and waited until today when they are ‘less’ good.

Besides, not really a sustained warm up. Still some scatter. It’s clear from all output this morning that things are up in the air. 


Mark

Beckton, E London

Less than 500m from the end of London City Airport runway.

Brian Gaze
15 December 2022 08:07:37
All change this morning. It's like the previous 3 updates have been erased.

UserPostedImage


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

moomin75
15 December 2022 08:10:12

I just don’t think that’s correct. Showing Birmingham as a fair example, I see a lot of scatter ranging from cool/cold (uppers around -5C) to mild. Wouldn’t describe it as a sustained warm up.   

Originally Posted by: Joe Bloggs 

Eh? That looks like a pretty pronounced warm up to my eyes. Yes there are a few cold stragglers, but the majority are trending mild now.​​​​​​​  
Witney, Oxfordshire

100m ASL

Joe Bloggs
15 December 2022 08:13:40

Eh? That looks like a pretty pronounced warm up to my eyes. Yes there are a few cold stragglers, but the majority are trending mild now.  

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

I don’t agree. I would not describe the latter stage of the MOGREPS ensemble set as a “sustained warm up”. 

Clearly Mark agrees too so I’m not going mad. 

DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
15 December 2022 08:14:20
MetO map https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/weather/maps-and-charts/temperature-map Â tracks the progress of the thaw on both the rainfall and temp layers. Rain for England moves in early on Sunday (it takes a bit longer to reach the north of Scotland) and for both the far S and far N sets in for 36-48 hours, somewhat drier in the middle by Monday. Temps rising into double figures in the S by midnight Sun/Mon (even overnight!), almost getting to that in the far N on Mon pm, before a general return to Dec norm.

WX charts give a wider picture with the 0C isotherm still as far W as Germany in week 1, plus a large area of the Atlantic near Iceland. Then in week 2, it has retreated to Belarus and it's only the land area of Iceland that is affected. There are still cold spots hanging on; the Highlands, Turkey and ultra-cold in Norway. Rain (mostly) for Atlantic coasts but including all of Britain in that for both weeks; in week 2 extending across S France to the W Med.

GFS Op - cold air staying around rather uncertainly to Sat 17th, then on Sun LP from Azores extends a trough N-wards so by Mon 19th the whole of W Europe is under strong S-lies between this trough, by then 985 mb W of Biscay to Hebrides, and HP 1040mb Belarus. The trough moves N and deepens (960mb off N Ireland Wed 21st) before finally moving away leaving a shallow secondary LP over England 1005mb Christmas Day with weak N-lies. Further deep Atlantic troughs appear in the week after Christmas but are blocked by HP (Norway 1050mb, Spain 1030mb Sat 31st) and will affect mainly W coasts, not that there may be S gales and occasional fronts for the rest of Britain.

ECM - similar to GFS at first, but shows the secondary on Christmas Day still out on the Atlantic with pressure high over Britain and light S-lies. A promising day for  a Christmas walk.

GEFS - abruptly very mild on Sun 18th with much rain and then dropping back 2-3 days later to December norm, even below for a while in the N, where it stays for the foreseeable with rain from time to tme. . Most ens members agree with this though control favours colder. 


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

moomin75
15 December 2022 08:18:15

I don’t agree. I would not describe the latter stage of the MOGREPS ensemble set as a “sustained warm up”. 

Clearly Mark agrees too so I’m not going mad. 

Originally Posted by: Joe Bloggs 

Maybe I'm going mad then.

The chart you posted shows a majority below -2 to a majority above +3.

My eyes aren't deceiving me surely.


Witney, Oxfordshire

100m ASL

Joe Bloggs
15 December 2022 08:22:46

Maybe I'm going mad then.

The chart you posted shows a majority below -2 to a majority above +3.

My eyes aren't deceiving me surely.

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

I thought we all agreed you’re absolutely crackers, including you! 😂😂

I think we’re disagreeing over the semantics. I’m seeing some scatter/uncertainty and that’s how I’d describe the latter stages. Nothing bone-chilling by any stretch but some chilly ones amongst the noise. I personally wouldn’t describe them as a “sustained warm up”, there is too much uncertainty in the set to make that suggestion IMO.

Anyway the bigger picture isn’t great this morning compared to yesterday, although ECM is still fairly positive for coldies. We await future runs. Still very finely balanced with that low moving through.. will it/won’t it! 

Gandalf The White
15 December 2022 08:24:59

Eh? That looks like a pretty pronounced warm up to my eyes. Yes there are a few cold stragglers, but the majority are trending mild now.  

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

Maybe, given the clear volatility in the model output at the moment, you should say 'for now' rather than 'now', because we all know it will different through today - and beyond.

Agreement on the initial breakdown on Sunday has only reached consensus in the last 48 hours; the consensus now suggests a sharp return to average or just below within 48 hours.  Frankly what happens in a week from now is still guesswork because there are too many moving pieces in the jigsaw puzzle.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



moomin75
15 December 2022 08:29:42

I thought we all agreed you’re absolutely crackers, including you! 😂😂 I think we’re disagreeing over the semantics. I’m seeing some scatter/uncertainty and that’s how I’d describe the latter stages. Nothing bone-chilling by any stretch but some chilly ones amongst the noise. I personally wouldn’t describe them as a “sustained warm up”, there is too much uncertainty in the set to make that suggestion IMO. Anyway the bigger picture isn’t great this morning compared to yesterday, although ECM is still fairly positive for coldies. We await future runs. Still very finely balanced with that low moving through.. will it/won’t it!

Originally Posted by: Joe Bloggs 

OH yeh, we did. Yes I am pretty bonkers most of the time.

Let's just agree that there is huge volatility. They may well trend colder again on the next run....

Truth is, noone knows what's ahead.​​​​​​​  


Witney, Oxfordshire

100m ASL

Brian Gaze
15 December 2022 08:35:50
MOGREPS-G also looking milder in the mid term than some of the recent updates. The interest in the next 48 hours will be to see if we are still at the tipping point or if we have tipped.

UserPostedImage


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Downpour
15 December 2022 08:42:43
Kieron is just saying what he sees in front of him isn’t he? Nothing wrong with that.

No doubt that the ensemble suite is significantly milder this morning than it was last night.

It might flip back of course. 


Chingford

London E4

147ft

fairweather
15 December 2022 08:43:07

I think there are two basic issues with the model output: firstly, the data that is plugged into the models as the starting point is not 100% accurate and therefore it doesn't matter how accurate the mathematical equations might be, those opening errors, however tiny, will multiply and eventually render the predictions wrong.   That is, of course, why they run ensemble suites, to test how tiny changes in the opening position will alter the evolution; as we have all seen, sometimes the effects are really quite significant within just a few days - whilst on other occasions there is reasonable stability for perhaps 5-6 days out (as we have seen recently).  There is also the fact that measuring 'stability' by looking at the effect at a single geographical point isn't especially reliable: if that point is at the margins of an air mass boundary it will look different to somewhere that is more stable.

The second issue is that the mathematical equations are, and can only be, an approximation to how the atmosphere behaves; that approximation has clearly got better over time, and the more grid points within the model then the better the results should be - as evidenced by the very high resolution short-term ones.  Even then, as we saw last weekend with the development of that small LP that brought snow to the south-east and Home Counties, some of even the high res ones simply didn't pick it up.  If they had the same opening data then that suggests errors in the model.

Yes, this is the correct thought train on modelling. 👍

 

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 


S.Essex, 42m ASL

Remove ads from site