The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

Sevendust
10 November 2021 07:41:55

GEFS now much flatter than recent sharp digressions between cold and mild in mid-term. Mean close to average

David M Porter
10 November 2021 07:46:35

 

Bren works for a private weather company not the meto

Originally Posted by: Sevendust 

Thanks Dave. Maybe I was thinking of James (Stormchaser)?


Lenzie, Glasgow

"A body of men holding themselves accountable to nobody ought not to be trusted by anybody." – Thomas Paine

DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
10 November 2021 08:07:26

Off again -on again -gone again; GFS must have more excuses for not fulfilling its promise of a cold spell than ... [fill in name of politician here]. And there's a late-season disturbance which is likely to develop into a tropical storm to add to the mix showing up on NHC and GFS charts becoming a fully-fledged N Atlantic LP by Fri. That'll confuse the models, too! 

FWIW here's what this morning shows;

wx summary - no cold patch over Europe as yesterday: the cold area over NE Europe has shrunk but intensified, and Europe as a whole looks about average for the next 2 weeks. Rain on W fringes of Europe ad W Med also around for next two weeks, v dry in C Europe.

Jet - running around or close to UK with tendency to loop to the north until Tue 23rd when it dips S to France and Spain

GFS op - basically zonal with W/SW lies, pressure quite high to S and low to N with interruptions when an LP intrudes e.g. 990mb Fri 12th Hebrides, Mon 15th 1010mb Corsica (brief E-ly input for the S) until Tue 23rd when trough develops S-ward from Iceland and brings down N-lies as it traverses E-wards to Scandi

GEFS - mean temp declining slowly from just above norm to just below with no more than the usual scatter of runs either side; some rain from Wed 17th onwards. Greater variation between runs in Scotland with the op positively warm around Sat 20th, and an isolated bump of rain Sat 13th

ECM - agrees with GFS this morning; perhaps a stronger pressure gradient around Fri 19th with gales


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

briggsy6
10 November 2021 09:54:08

So the tabloid story of an Arctic blast blanketing us with snow is unlikely to materialise then?


Location: Uxbridge
mulattokid
10 November 2021 09:58:17

 

Sorry, you're not getting away with that. I haven't answered my own question. I ask again: what additional modelling is available?

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

Does sound somewhat conspiratorial to be fair.


Located in West London

"Everything in life is our fault, but that's not our fault!"

Anonymous friend of Quentin Crisp

Hungry Tiger
10 November 2021 10:19:37

Their GFS goes out to t+408

Originally Posted by: Saint Snow 

That;s nearly a fortnight.


Gavin S. FRmetS.

TWO Moderator.

Contact the TWO team - [email protected]

South Cambridgeshire. 93 metres or 302.25 feet ASL.



Sevendust
10 November 2021 10:35:46

Thanks Dave. Maybe I was thinking of James (Stormchaser)?

Originally Posted by: David M Porter 

I know that James has studied applied meteorology at Uni.

Adrian (Adiwood) works for the meto

Laura (Brens ex) works at the meto I believe

DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
10 November 2021 10:40:53

 

Sorry, you're not getting away with that. I haven't answered my own question. I ask again: what additional modelling is available?

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

Isn't there a distinction between model outputs that the MetO makes available  and the methods by which they generate data? 

The chart in https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/research/approach/modelling-systems/unified-model/index shows that all the weather models available are fully represented on TWO (bar MOGREPS-15?). I exclude 20-year outputs as being climate, not weather. I should be surprised in the MetO aren't working on detailed 30-day outputs and unsurprised if these are not released as being as yet (or maybe ever) too unreliable.

As for methods, the outline parameters are published here https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/research/approach/modelling-systems/unified-model/weather-forecasting but parameters are a long way from detailed programming, and even the parameters are a good way from a website such as TWO which focuses on model output..


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

Saint Snow
10 November 2021 10:42:22

 

Bren works for a private weather company not the meto

Originally Posted by: Sevendust 

 

 

Didn't his [then] partner work for the Met Office?

 

 

edit: ignore this, I see you've subsequently made the same point  

 


Martin

Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)

A TWO addict since 14/12/01

"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."

Aneurin Bevan

Zubzero
10 November 2021 10:44:47
The information is on the met office website

https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/research/approach/modelling-systems/unified-model/weather-forecasting 

There is a lot more data publicly available now, then there used to be. The ECM data now being available and even MORGREPS and UKV,( Thanks Brian)

tallyho_83
10 November 2021 10:50:49

Look how warm it's forecast to be this Friday for the whole of Europe with many countries seeing double figure temperatures on 06z run? Wow wow wow!

 

 


Home Location - Vixen Tor Close, Okehampton, Devon (221m ASL)

---------------------------------------

Sean Moon

Magical Moon

www.magical-moon.com

The Beast from the East
10 November 2021 10:55:42

Look how warm it's forecast to be this Friday for the whole of Europe with many countries seeing double figure temperatures on 06z run? Wow wow wow!

 

 

Originally Posted by: tallyho_83 

Climate change is well and truly here. My wasp nest in the loft is still active. the Buggers are still alive!


Purley, Surrey, 70m ASL

"We have some alternative facts for you"

Kelly-Ann Conway - former special adviser to the President

Saint Snow
10 November 2021 10:56:32

 

That;s nearly a fortnight.

Originally Posted by: Hungry Tiger 

 

 

 


Martin

Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)

A TWO addict since 14/12/01

"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."

Aneurin Bevan

Brian Gaze
10 November 2021 10:59:39

 

Isn't there a distinction between model outputs that the MetO makes available  and the methods by which they generate data? 

The chart in https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/research/approach/modelling-systems/unified-model/index shows that all the weather models available are fully represented on TWO (bar MOGREPS-15?). I exclude 20-year outputs as being climate, not weather. I should be surprised in the MetO aren't working on detailed 30-day outputs and unsurprised if these are not released as being as yet (or maybe ever) too unreliable.

As for methods, the outline parameters are published here https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/research/approach/modelling-systems/unified-model/weather-forecasting but parameters are a long way from detailed programming, and even the parameters are a good way from a website such as TWO which focuses on model output..

Originally Posted by: DEW 

The national forecasting centres (e.g. NCEP in the USA, Meteo France, UK Met, DWD) generally make their model data available in what is called grib or grib2 format. For more info see:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GRIB

This comes straight off the supercomputers (NCEP's is known as WCOSSS) and is basically dumped onto file servers. It is then up to the end user (whether that be one of the big agencies or people like me) to take that and do something with it.

In some cases further processing is done by the national forecasting centre, for example cluster analysis on the ensemble output. This may or may not be made available to other users in grib2 format. NCEP pushes everything out freely as far as I am aware. In the UK the Met Office have a product called Decider which I don't currently have access to but which is available to the "public" to licence. (See https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/services/business-industry/energy/decider).

Therefore, I think the idea that organisation X, Y or Z has a "secret stash of data" is very misleading. If they can leverage advantage it will mostly be through having the best meteorologists to produce the forecasts and the best analysts to process the data sets and produce tools to make it easier to identify trends and the most probable scenarios.

    


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

pdiddy
10 November 2021 11:01:32

I think the MetO point boils down to analysis rather than access to data.  Looking at trends and analogues (which I think the extended or monthly outlook commented upon) as a professional must be more accurate in the long run than a bunch of amateurs.  Also, given the grief they face for getting it wrong, one must assume they have a degree of confidence in their longer range forecast?

Chunky Pea
10 November 2021 13:04:10

 

Sorry, you're not getting away with that. I haven't answered my own question. I ask again: what additional modelling is available?

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

None. Those that work in met offices are just more trained to interpret models better than most, that is all. 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

tallyho_83
10 November 2021 13:07:11

 

None. Those that work in met offices are just more trained to interpret models better than most, that is all. 

Originally Posted by: Chunky Pea 

The Met office stated in their Outlook from 14th November "A rather cold start to the period!"

Temperatures this Sunday could reach 13 or 14c and remain in double figures, so how is this a rather cold start?


Home Location - Vixen Tor Close, Okehampton, Devon (221m ASL)

---------------------------------------

Sean Moon

Magical Moon

www.magical-moon.com

picturesareme
10 November 2021 13:21:31

Look how warm it's forecast to be this Friday for the whole of Europe with many countries seeing double figure temperatures on 06z run? Wow wow wow!

 

 

Originally Posted by: tallyho_83 

Nothing out of the ordinary there for early November. Bulk of central Europe 6-11C range with France, Spain, Portugal and parts of southern England in the 12-14C range.  The November average IMBY is 12C but this is for the entire month not just the first third.

Weathermac
10 November 2021 13:32:49

 

Climate change is well and truly here. My wasp nest in the loft is still active. the Buggers are still alive!

Originally Posted by: The Beast from the East 

Still got Wasps in my garden and this is after a few Frosts last week.

White Meadows
10 November 2021 13:56:38

I think the MetO point boils down to analysis rather than access to data.  Looking at trends and analogues (which I think the extended or monthly outlook commented upon) as a professional must be more accurate in the long run than a bunch of amateurs.  Also, given the grief they face for getting it wrong, one must assume they have a degree of confidence in their longer range forecast?

Originally Posted by: pdiddy 

Indeed. Surely Met office generated data, by definition is ‘modelling’ every likely outcome used towards their forecasts. How and who interprets that data is another matter. I don’t think they’d be shaking hands with Microsoft in a multi £bn deal on the assumption they go off the same everyday model output available to amateurs. 

Brian Gaze
10 November 2021 14:18:47

Indeed. Surely Met office generated data, by definition is ‘modelling’ every likely outcome used towards their forecasts. How and who interprets that data is another matter. I don’t think they’d be shaking hands with Microsoft in a multi £bn deal on the assumption they go off the same everyday model output available to amateurs. 

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

Can you answer my original point about what additional modelling is available to them?

I discussed some pointers here:

https://www.theweatheroutlook.com/twocommunity/default.aspx?g=posts&m=1389424#post1389424

 


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
10 November 2021 15:35:52

 

The national forecasting centres (e.g. NCEP in the USA, Meteo France, UK Met, DWD) generally make their model data available in what is called grib or grib2 format. For more info see:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GRIB

This comes straight off the supercomputers (NCEP's is known as WCOSSS) and is basically dumped onto file servers. It is then up to the end user (whether that be one of the big agencies or people like me) to take that and do something with it.

In some cases further processing is done by the national forecasting centre, for example cluster analysis on the ensemble output. This may or may not be made available to other users in grib2 format. NCEP pushes everything out freely as far as I am aware. In the UK the Met Office have a product called Decider which I don't currently have access to but which is available to the "public" to licence. (See https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/services/business-industry/energy/decider).

Therefore, I think the idea that organisation X, Y or Z has a "secret stash of data" is very misleading. If they can leverage advantage it will mostly be through having the best meteorologists to produce the forecasts and the best analysts to process the data sets and produce tools to make it easier to identify trends and the most probable scenarios.

    

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

Thanks for clarification, Brian


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

White Meadows
10 November 2021 18:33:13

 

Can you answer my original point about what additional modelling is available to them?

I discussed some pointers here:

https://www.theweatheroutlook.com/twocommunity/default.aspx?g=posts&m=1389424#post1389424

 

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

I think it must be kept mostly under hats, but most likely a much, much higher res variant of their own model. 
It’d be great to have an ex/ current employee’s views on this.

Brian Gaze
10 November 2021 18:43:53

I think it must be kept mostly under hats, but most likely a much, much higher res variant of their own model. 
It’d be great to have an ex/ current employee’s views on this.

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

So do you think ECM, Meteo France, NCEP, DWD, CMC etc. are all hiding higher res versions of their models under hats?


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

White Meadows
10 November 2021 18:48:14

 

So do you think ECM, Meteo France, NCEP, DWD, CMC etc. are all hiding higher res versions of their models under hats?

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

potentially some of them, or extended versions? 

Back to Met office… This certainly suggests they have eyes on tools we do not:

https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/services/government/defence-and-security/models

 

 

Remove ads from site