The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

StrathspeyWeather
08 August 2019 16:15:33

For a long time I have been questioning the accuracy of the Davis Vantage Pro2 when it comes to measuring rainfall. For the last 10 years I have been using a standard 5 inch rain-gauge alongside the VP2 set-up. Since then I have found that the VP2 regularly under-reads the rain-gauge in the region of 10-20%. I suspect that during periods of severe/heavy rain however this inaccuracy rises even higher. One particular wet spell earlier this week tends to support this: The 24 hour period ending 10 am Wednesday 7th the VP2 showed 50.0 mm of rainfall, whilst the rain-gauge showed 68.8 - a difference of around 37%. The rainfall during that period was particularly heavy, and was sustained. I suspect that the tipping bucket system is losing rain during its operation by being overwhelmed in effect by the severity of the rain. Has anybody else using the VP2 had cause to question the system's accuracy?


Live Weather from Cromdale, in the Cairngorms National Park of Highland Scotland.

http://strathspeyweather.co.uk  (Met Office Climate Station)

four
  • four
  • Advanced Member
08 August 2019 16:30:32

I thought the same and played with the adjustment screws but the change was minimal - so I added an offset of about 15%.
There's an upgraded rain collector which does away with the tipping bucket just come out.
This is it I think, not outrageous money
https://www.weatherspares.co.uk/davis-aerocone-rain-collector-for-pro2-pro-and-wizard--6461-513-p.asp

Or is that just the bucket .. anyway there is a new option which just plugs in..


Chunky Pea
08 August 2019 16:47:02

Have noticed this myself. Davis V2 is not the most accurate regarding rainfall and mine does under record by about 10% thereabouts. 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Chunky Pea
08 August 2019 16:49:44

I thought the same and played with the adjustment screws but the change was minimal - so I added an offset of about 15%.
There's an upgraded rain collector which does away with the tipping bucket just come out.
This is it I think, not outrageous money
https://www.weatherspares.co.uk/davis-aerocone-rain-collector-for-pro2-pro-and-wizard--6461-513-p.asp

Originally Posted by: four 

Got one of these last year Four, hasn't really made much of a difference to be honest. 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Devonian
08 August 2019 18:13:36

For a long time I have been questioning the accuracy of the Davis Vantage Pro2 when it comes to measuring rainfall. For the last 10 years I have been using a standard 5 inch rain-gauge alongside the VP2 set-up. Since then I have found that the VP2 regularly under-reads the rain-gauge in the region of 10-20%. I suspect that during periods of severe/heavy rain however this inaccuracy rises even higher. One particular wet spell earlier this week tends to support this: The 24 hour period ending 10 am Wednesday 7th the VP2 showed 50.0 mm of rainfall, whilst the rain-gauge showed 68.8 - a difference of around 37%. The rainfall during that period was particularly heavy, and was sustained. I suspect that the tipping bucket system is losing rain during its operation by being overwhelmed in effect by the severity of the rain. Has anybody else using the VP2 had cause to question the system's accuracy?

Originally Posted by: StrathspeyWeather 

Agreed, and pretty much my experience. Having recorded weather for many year I sort of know what a inch of rain is like. I don't claim to be able to know that to 10% but last year the gauge was so inaccurate (but still factory settings) it simply was obvious it was wrong.

I did the test where you 'pie'r*2 it (aka drip ~23cc (something like that...)  through the funnel and you should get five reed switch clicks, which equals 1mm). I did that and it clicked the right number of times (indeed, I poured more through and it was still counting right), but it still under records by a large amount, 20% or so - which of course is a whopping one click in five.

I'm still unsure why it counts clicks right but under records by 20% or so . And i don't think it's to do with rain rate, it has to rain very heavily for the gauge to be swamped. Nor am i convinced by the argument about wind or exposure, for the money Davis really ought to provide kit that gets closer to single figure inaccuracy imo - if it's 20% out you might as well just eyeball a bucket each morning.

Anyway, I fiddled around with the adjusters and I get readings closer to the check gauge than I did.

StrathspeyWeather
08 August 2019 18:27:45
Thanks guys for each of your replies, and it's interesting to hear that others too experience the same problem. It appears that Davis are at least aware of the problem, which given the age of the VP2 one would expect. The single bucket tipper looks better, along with the updated cone but begs the question as to whether they can consistently provide acceptable levels of accuracy.
Live Weather from Cromdale, in the Cairngorms National Park of Highland Scotland.

http://strathspeyweather.co.uk  (Met Office Climate Station)

Chunky Pea
08 August 2019 18:33:47

 

Agreed, and pretty much my experience. Having recorded weather for many year I sort of know what a inch of rain is like. I don't claim to be able to know that to 10% but last year the gauge was so inaccurate (but still factory settings) it simply was obvious it was wrong.

I did the test where you 'pie'r*2 it (aka drip ~23cc (something like that...)  through the funnel and you should get five reed switch clicks, which equals 1mm). I did that and it clicked the right number of times (indeed, I poured more through and it was still counting right), but it still under records by a large amount, 20% or so - which of course is a whopping one click in five.

I'm still unsure why it counts clicks right but under records by 20% or so . And i don't think it's to do with rain rate, it has to rain very heavily for the gauge to be swamped. Nor am i convinced by the argument about wind or exposure, for the money Davis really ought to provide kit that gets closer to single figure inaccuracy imo - if it's 20% out you might as well just eyeball a bucket each morning.

Anyway, I fiddled around with the adjusters and I get readings closer to the check gauge than I did.

Originally Posted by: Devonian 

There is an option on the Davis to record in 0.1mm steps. I tried this a few years back and it was a disaster. Under recorded by about 50%. 

But even on factory settings, it isn't great. A couple of weeks ago it recorded a daily total of 39mm, yet my trusty mug rain gauge (equal in circumference top to bottom, measured nearly 45mm. That is a huge and unacceptable difference to be honest. 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

08 August 2019 18:49:12

I have had the same experience. The Davis VP2 under records and my traditional gauge over records.

I didn’t have the time or wherewithal to do the official calibration check. So instead I played around with the adjustment screws until I was getting readings more consistent on a regular basis with the closest Met Office official station (Odiham) and high graded local stations in the COL network (including A graded Stratfield Mortimer).

I am now much more confident my readings are reasonably accurate. By no means perfect but a lot more accurate than they were. The readings tend to be least accurate in high winds because the VP2 gauge is relatively high off the ground in the default setup and hence subject to swirling and eddying winds.

Devonian
08 August 2019 19:20:36

Thanks guys for each of your replies, and it's interesting to hear that others too experience the same problem. It appears that Davis are at least aware of the problem, which given the age of the VP2 one would expect. The single bucket tipper looks better, along with the updated cone but begs the question as to whether they can consistently provide acceptable levels of accuracy.

Originally Posted by: StrathspeyWeather 

I dunno, it ought not to be beyond the wit of man (Davis) to make a rain gauge for a several hundred pound weather station and make it acceptably (+-10%?) accurate. The VP2 is a great bit of kit (mine has otherwise been faultlessly and accurately running since 12/16) but its rain gauge clearly isn't. How it is that the VP2 gauge looks just like the VP1 one but (to my mind) isn't as accurate is odd - which brings me back to how it counts clicks...

richardabdn
09 August 2019 17:10:07

I have a VP2 tipping rain bucket and think it is dreadful for the money. Very inaccurate and I'm constantly having to manually adjust rain totals.

Today it says we have had 11mm which seems low to me. Compare that with Westhill to the west which had 22mm and Nigg to the east which has recorded 10mm http://apps.sepa.org.uk/rainfall

I am about equidistant between the two so would expect to have rainfall of perhaps nearer 15mm. Obviously this will not always work e.g. in the July 2018 thunderstorms I watched all the heavy rain go to my east then later it went to my west so in that instance the total was indeed much lower. However that is not the case today with more persistent rain which will be heavier with increasing altitude and distance from the sea hence the difference between Nigg and Westhill.

A cheap garden centre rain gauge which I keep for a check, and cost about £5, has recorded 16mm. I am not saying this is accurate but it seems nearer the mark to me. Dyce has logged 18mm but it always seems wetter there for some reason.

One other thing is that it also seems to get blocked up with debris very easily. This occurred the other night when it logged 2.6mm when the real total should have been about 8mm.

 


Aberdeen: The only place that misses out on everything

2023 - The Year that's Constantly Worse than a Bad November

2024 - 2023 without the Good Bits

2025 - The Weekend Curse hell intensifies

Brian Gaze
08 April 2023 13:16:51
I'm checking mine out right now. During March it appeared to underreport by a huge margin. 
Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

tierradelfuego
08 April 2023 16:44:27

I'm checking mine out right now. During March it appeared to underreport by a huge margin. 

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

I certainly have found mine way better since decoupling it from the ISS and having it at ground level, I bought the separate rain gauge for this and have it a few metres away.


Bucklebury

West Berkshire Downs AONB

135m ASL

VP2 with daytime FARS

Rainfall collector separated at ground level

Anemometer separated above roof level

WeatherLink Live (Byles Green Crew )

Brian Gaze
08 April 2023 17:33:12

I certainly have found mine way better since decoupling it from the ISS and having it at ground level, I bought the separate rain gauge for this and have it a few metres away.

Originally Posted by: tierradelfuego 

When you say "the separate rain gauge" do you mean it is a standalone piece of kit? If so can you post a link to it?


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

tierradelfuego
08 April 2023 17:48:45

When you say "the separate rain gauge" do you mean it is a standalone piece of kit? If so can you post a link to it?

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

Yes exactly Brian, I just unplugged the built in rain gauge (and left it there collecting spider's webs), and plugged this one in instead.

https://www.weathershop.co.uk/davis-6464m-aerocone-rain-collector 


Bucklebury

West Berkshire Downs AONB

135m ASL

VP2 with daytime FARS

Rainfall collector separated at ground level

Anemometer separated above roof level

WeatherLink Live (Byles Green Crew )

Brian Gaze
08 April 2023 18:07:02

Yes exactly Brian, I just unplugged the built in rain gauge (and left it there collecting spider's webs), and plugged this one in instead.

https://www.weathershop.co.uk/davis-6464m-aerocone-rain-collector 

Originally Posted by: tierradelfuego 

Thanks, I may go down that route. I wonder if animals are a potential problem? Fox roams our garden, we get regular visits from badgers and not so long ago a deer found its way in. 


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

tierradelfuego
08 April 2023 18:38:39

Thanks, I may go down that route. I wonder if animals are a potential problem? Fox roams our garden, we get regular visitors from badgers and not so long ago a deer found its way in. 

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

I would have thought the bird spikes would put pay to most of those, but who knows, they can all be persistent buggers. We are very rural but probably because of that hardly ever see a fox (there are one family in the woods), the badgers similarly are in the woods but do terrorise some gardens nearby. We did have a problem with muntjac, but every time they come in I just light the bbq and they soon fear the worst 😋

I was a bit more wary when one of the wolves escaped a few years back, the roads were closed and there were armed police and a chopper around, but other than that it's just rabbits mostly. 


Bucklebury

West Berkshire Downs AONB

135m ASL

VP2 with daytime FARS

Rainfall collector separated at ground level

Anemometer separated above roof level

WeatherLink Live (Byles Green Crew )

Retron
09 April 2023 03:30:10

I was a bit more wary when one of the wolves escaped a few years back, the roads were closed and there were armed police and a chopper around, but other than that it's just rabbits mostly. 

Originally Posted by: tierradelfuego 

That was Torak, who was let out by some animal rights activists one night.

You were right to be wary, he would have been a severe risk to your hotdog sausage supplies!

(In reality, he was a lovely old wolf, I hand-reared him back in 2006 and was one of his handlers right 'til the end of his life many years later. When he escaped, after running around for a bit, his owner caught up with him, called him over and put a collar and lead on him.)

Incidentally, with the topic in question, I have had doubts about my own VP2 rain guage, but whenever there's been an issue it's been down to gunk collecting inside, down the very small hole at the bottom of the cone.


Leysdown, north Kent
Brian Gaze
06 May 2023 07:41:28
Still looking into this and it seems my VP2 is consistently recording about 50% of total rain. I've tried tipping the rain collecting mechanism each way and it registers 0.2mm in each direction. 

Any ideas?


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

tierradelfuego
06 May 2023 09:39:53

Still looking into this and it seems my VP2 is consistently recording about 50% of total rain. I've tried tipping the rain collecting mechanism each way and it registers 0.2mm in each direction. 

Any ideas?

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

There's obviously a number of factors Brian, many of which are well-documented so apologies if any or all have been done or considered, I'm sure they will have been. Other than that it's pretty well documented it's not the greatest rain collector, but then what is in the amateur to semi-pro range, and how many gardens have the ideal locating site possible.

1. Have you done a pipette test or similar to see if it is actually recording the right amount of rain for a 0.2mm tip?

2. It would be interesting to know against what you are comparing it to, presumably a manual, but if it's another similar to the VP2 (let's call it mechanical) some are known to actually record more than they should, from the browsing I did ages ago.

3. Dirty tipping buckets are always a problem with dust and dirt build up meaning that it takes less than 0.2mm to tip. Obviously that is unlikely to be your issue as it would tip more..

4. Spiders webs can always cause an issue with sticking

5. Other than that I would say location is the main issue. I have certainly seen an improvement compared to my manual reader by decoupling and moving the VP2 to ground level, but it's still not perfect. Height is always a killer for rainfall with any wind. Obviously rain shadow is another big influence. In reality the height has an easy fix (decoupling) but for most people that usually increases the impact of rain shadow, so it's swings and roundabouts. Mine is at ground level so good, but is actually at the end of and in between two veg cages, so not ideal. The incoming rain from the South or SW is fine but a NW direction would be impacted... but bar putting it in the middle of the lawn, there's not much other option.

I just took at a look at the WeatherLink site, as although comparisons from one location even a mile away are impossible, it shows a picture. Within 5 miles of me - Most of the sites in a town, with presumably less option to site well due to likely smaller gardens are averaging 3mm today, most in a rural location are averaging 5mm. Mine is at 6mm, with only one higher at 7.4mm. A pretty big variation considering the radar looks reasonably similar in the locale.


Bucklebury

West Berkshire Downs AONB

135m ASL

VP2 with daytime FARS

Rainfall collector separated at ground level

Anemometer separated above roof level

WeatherLink Live (Byles Green Crew )

Chunky Pea
06 May 2023 12:01:28

Still looking into this and it seems my VP2 is consistently recording about 50% of total rain. I've tried tipping the rain collecting mechanism each way and it registers 0.2mm in each direction. 

Any ideas?

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

My Davis tipping spoons record 0.5mm for every two tips. I forget how to set it up in weatherlink (though easily done) but when I had it set to the 0.2mm per tip as you have now, it severely under recorded rainfall amounts. My current tip setting seems a lot closer to the mark, though still comes in with very slightly lower totals than in my standard manual rain gauge at the end of each month.


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Brian Gaze
23 July 2023 09:51:50
Finally got round to buying an analogue rain gauge  to enable a comparison. So the first results are in:

22/07/23 00:00 to 23/07/23 10:40

Vantage Pro 2, 12.5mm

Analogue: 17mm

The two rain collectors are positioned near to each other. I will do more testing as and when the weather allows, but the early signs are my VP2 is badly under reporting as I suspected. I've done some basic tests on it, e.g. tipping the cups each way to see whether a 0.2mm increment is recorded, cleaned it more frequently, and checked the reed switch. 

 


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Jiries
23 July 2023 10:33:07

Finally got round to buying an analogue rain gauge  to enable a comparison. So the first results are in:

22/07/23 00:00 to 23/07/23 10:40

Vantage Pro 2, 12.5mm

Analogue: 17mm

The two rain collectors are positioned near to each other. I will do more testing as and when the weather allows, but the early signs are my VP2 is badly under reporting as I suspected. I've done some basic tests on it, e.g. tipping the cups each way to see whether a 0.2mm increment is recorded, cleaned it more frequently, and checked the reed switch. 

 

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

A weather station that record every second for wind, temps and sunshine recorder would be great to pick up potential hottest, coldest and windiest values?  I had a W52500 was useless because it record every 1 minute so any highest, coldest and highest wind speed missed out.   I had a ice warner cabled probe I brought in Nicosia car shop that record every second and used that in August 2003 heatwave which pick up at 38.6C for a second or 2 and in Nicosia highest was 43.3C for a second.

Does your station record every second?   My other one that used to record the shed temps was every 30 seconds on outdoor sensor but every second for the console.

Brian Gaze
23 July 2023 11:02:15

A weather station that record every second for wind, temps and sunshine recorder would be great to pick up potential hottest, coldest and windiest values?  I had a W52500 was useless because it record every 1 minute so any highest, coldest and highest wind speed missed out.   I had a ice warner cabled probe I brought in Nicosia car shop that record every second and used that in August 2003 heatwave which pick up at 38.6C for a second or 2 and in Nicosia highest was 43.3C for a second.

Does your station record every second?   My other one that used to record the shed temps was every 30 seconds on outdoor sensor but every second for the console.

Originally Posted by: Jiries 

No. The archive interval can be set to 1 min, 5min, 10min, 15min, 30 min, 1 hr or 2hr.


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Brian Gaze
23 July 2023 11:04:27
Strangely, I've now seen that the rain values shown on the VP 2 console do not equal those which appear in WeatherLink. For example, WeatherLink (after fully downloading the data successfully) is showing a total of 9.2mm for 22/07/23, but the console is reporting 11.4mm for the same period,
Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Remove ads from site