The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

westv
04 January 2024 12:51:46

Indeed Darren. A classic case of cold for the far north where only a small proportion of the UK population live. Mild for the vast majority. Let’s hope it doesn’t command much support. 

Originally Posted by: Downpour 

For those that want it I suppose a part of the UK is better than it all going to Greece!

Retron
04 January 2024 12:55:35

I'd suggest the bit in bold is the key point as from reading comments about teleconnections the impression given is they influence our weather and not the other way round. As it is something I have little knowledge of, I don't know the answer, but I have wondered whether, like NAO, it is  product of the model output and therefore subject to the same influences as them. Also, are there weather forums in the Pacific region discussing how "teleconnections" in our part of the world influence their weather?! 

Originally Posted by: overland 

Essentially the teleconnections are just ways of looking at the model charts in different ways - that much is fine, and uncontroversial.

As you've highlighted, NAO is essentially the anomaly between the climatological Azores High and the Iceland Low, and the others are similar. The MJO is essentially a way of looking at rainfall over the Indian and Pacific oceans, QBO measures which way the winds are blowing in the stratosphere in the tropics, GLAAM is essentially measuring how strong and how zonal the jetstream is - and so on.

You can use these indices to have an idea of the overall pattern, making it easier - but by no means certain - to figure out where the upper ridges and troughs will be, and how amplified they will be (or the Rossby waves, to give them their proper name), but remember: it's just another way of looking at the plain old charts we're all used to.

The controversial bit comes when people look at a GFS or ECM chart and extrapolate that into the MJO, then infer how that's going to affect us. All they're doing really is looking at rainfall charts through a different lens, and they're just as much subject to change from run to run as the traditional charts we're all used to seeing! I do feel there's far too much faith put into these things, and in my view looking at a chart showing the MJO going into phase 7, 8 or 1 and inferring it's going to get cold is no different to looking at the GEFS and seeing that half the runs are showing cold - it might happen, it might not, and the MJO charts are generated from the same ensembles anyway!

The other part of this is you can have all the background signals in the world, but we've seen time and time again how a "spoiler low", "shortwave" - call it what you want - pops up and derails a cold spell. That's the price we have to pay for being a tiny island at the edge of a great ocean, tiny changes - impossible to predict far in advance with global models - can make a massive difference here.

As for weather forums, there are those in the States of course - and from what I've seen, they discuss the same indices, NAO, MJO etc as we do, just in a much drier tone - sucking much of the fun out of it IMO!


Leysdown, north Kent
Chunky Pea
04 January 2024 13:03:22

Looking at the closest time period in the GEFS set (18z on that Sunday), nothing else comes close to the warmth - the op is a humungous outlier, showing as it does 11C down here at that time. The closest I can see is a single 8, and the majority are in the 0 to 4 range. The mean is around 3.

Phew. However, because it's such a massive outlier it also means that the rest of the run (i.e. the jam tomorrow portion) is even less reliable than normal.

Here's hoping the op isn't a trendsetter, and that the status quo resumes for the 12z set!

Originally Posted by: Retron 

Highlights my increasing view that ops beyond about day 5 are a waste of energy. Is there really any use for such high res detail beyond that? For instance, such fine tuned detail (regarding any parameter) on a day 10 chart that will rarely, if ever, verify. 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Chunky Pea
04 January 2024 13:17:37
QBO, Nino, etc are provably uncorrelated to winter weather patterns over this tiny region of the Atlantic. 
Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Brian Gaze
04 January 2024 13:20:03

Essentially the teleconnections are just ways of looking at the model charts in different ways - that much is fine, and uncontroversial.

As you've highlighted, NAO is essentially the anomaly between the climatological Azores High and the Iceland Low, and the others are similar. The MJO is essentially a way of looking at rainfall over the Indian and Pacific oceans, QBO measures which way the winds are blowing in the stratosphere in the tropics, GLAAM is essentially measuring how strong and how zonal the jetstream is - and so on.

You can use these indices to have an idea of the overall pattern, making it easier - but by no means certain - to figure out where the upper ridges and troughs will be, and how amplified they will be (or the Rossby waves, to give them their proper name), but remember: it's just another way of looking at the plain old charts we're all used to.

The controversial bit comes when people look at a GFS or ECM chart and extrapolate that into the MJO, then infer how that's going to affect us. All they're doing really is looking at rainfall charts through a different lens, and they're just as much subject to change from run to run as the traditional charts we're all used to seeing! I do feel there's far too much faith put into these things, and in my view looking at a chart showing the MJO going into phase 7, 8 or 1 and inferring it's going to get cold is no different to looking at the GEFS and seeing that half the runs are showing cold - it might happen, it might not, and the MJO charts are generated from the same ensembles anyway!

The other part of this is you can have all the background signals in the world, but we've seen time and time again how a "spoiler low", "shortwave" - call it what you want - pops up and derails a cold spell. That's the price we have to pay for being a tiny island at the edge of a great ocean, tiny changes - impossible to predict far in advance with global models - can make a massive difference here.

As for weather forums, there are those in the States of course - and from what I've seen, they discuss the same indices, NAO, MJO etc as we do, just in a much drier tone - sucking much of the fun out of it IMO!

Originally Posted by: Retron 

Superb post. The only thing I'll add is there is a lot of demand for medium to long range weather forecasts. If anyone has figured things out they won't be posting on weather forums. Also, the UK Met, Meteo France, NCEP, DWD etc. wouldn't be investing so much money in supercomputers if they could just hire a few experts. 


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

ballamar
04 January 2024 13:22:42

Highlights my increasing view that ops beyond about day 5 are a waste of energy. Is there really any use for such high res detail beyond that? For instance, such fine tuned detail (regarding any parameter) on a day 10 chart that will rarely, if ever, verify. 

Originally Posted by: Chunky Pea 

People take them too seriously! But sometimes they are fun to look at and dream 

doctormog
04 January 2024 13:28:59
Looking at the ECM 00z ensemble data, this is quite a remarkable chart, it shows the 500hPa thickness anomalies at day 9.

UserPostedImage

https://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/ecmwf/runs/2024010400/EDM101-216.GIF 

IMO that is possibly one of the strongest signals you could get of a Greenland High at that range.

 


overland
04 January 2024 13:30:42

Essentially the teleconnections are just ways of looking at the model charts in different ways - that much is fine, and uncontroversial. snipped

Originally Posted by: Retron 

Many thanks for the detailed reply. I'm in no position to criticise their use, not having read up about them, but it does sound like they don't offer much more than the standard model output


Mumbles, Swansea. 80m asl
llamedos
04 January 2024 13:30:59
I've moved some posts to the "Off topic posts" thread in the Forum Arms - inevitably some posts which quote the original off topic post will get dragged there as well. 

Better to just stay on topic really, as already requested.


"Life with the Lions"

TWO Moderator

picturesareme
04 January 2024 13:32:49
This current low seems to be further west and more inland than was being forecasted even two days ago! What knock-on will this will have going forward I wonder 🧐
Taylor1740
04 January 2024 13:56:05

The model output ties in very well with the medium term Met Office outlook (I.e. beyond day 6) which states:

”By the middle of next week, the wind should ease and, with high pressure in charge, there should be a good deal of dry weather. Cloud amounts will continue to be quite variable, but all areas should see some sunshine at times. Much colder than recently, with frost probably becoming quite widespread and some freezing fog patches are possible in places. Beyond next week, conditions are likely to remain cold, with an increasing chance of some wintry showers, particularly in the north.

Updated: 14:00 (UTC) on Wed 3 Jan 2024”

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

yes, though in regards to the 18 Jan - 1 Feb outlook they say that currently the chance of a severe cold outbreak is low, which doesn't really tie in with the output in the GEFS which I would say a majority is showing quite a significant cold outbreak at the moment.


NW Leeds - 150m amsl
doctormog
04 January 2024 14:02:22

yes, though in regards to the 18 Jan - 1 Feb outlook they say that currently the chance of a severe cold outbreak is low, which doesn't really tie in with the output in the GEFS which I would say a majority is showing quite a significant cold outbreak at the moment.

Originally Posted by: Taylor1740 

I’m not sure the wording of that section gets updated more than around twice weekly (even the time stamp suggests otherwise). I suspect it reflects the output from a few days ago but I may be wrong.


Brian Gaze
04 January 2024 14:04:09

I’m not sure the wording of that section gets updated more than around twice weekly (even the time stamp suggests otherwise). I suspect it reflects the output from a few days ago but I may be wrong.

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

Indeed. The fact they don't update every day is perhaps the most important thing people should take on board.


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Saint Snow
04 January 2024 14:07:04

Essentially the teleconnections are just ways of looking at the model charts in different ways - that much is fine, and uncontroversial.

As you've highlighted, NAO is essentially the anomaly between the climatological Azores High and the Iceland Low, and the others are similar. The MJO is essentially a way of looking at rainfall over the Indian and Pacific oceans, QBO measures which way the winds are blowing in the stratosphere in the tropics, GLAAM is essentially measuring how strong and how zonal the jetstream is - and so on.

Originally Posted by: Retron 

I get the NAO and GLAAM point absolutely - they're just reflections of what certain aspects of the weather is actually doing at a given point.

Isn't QBO a little different, though? I know it measures winds in the stratosphere, but aren't stratospheric winds more an influencer of weather patterns?

Similarly with ENSO - I know that, simplistically, it's a measure of SST's in a particular area of the Pacific... but it does influence weather patterns (as opposed to being just a representation of the relative positions of weather systems)

 


Martin

Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)

A TWO addict since 14/12/01

"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."

Aneurin Bevan

picturesareme
04 January 2024 14:17:41

yes, though in regards to the 18 Jan - 1 Feb outlook they say that currently the chance of a severe cold outbreak is low, which doesn't really tie in with the output in the GEFS which I would say a majority is showing quite a significant cold outbreak at the moment.

Originally Posted by: Taylor1740 

Where exactly though is this severe cold for January in the charts except for perhaps a few ensembles. At the moment it's just looking to be cold perhaps locally very cold. 

White Meadows
04 January 2024 14:26:28
Still waiting for the long range text update, today, tomorrow, Saturday perhaps but in the meantime here’s some exciting news from the 14.00 update in the mid term:

“…Much colder than recently, with frost probably becoming quite widespread and some freezing fog patches are possible in places. Beyond next week, conditions are likely to remain cold, with an increasing chance of some snow showers, developing particularly in the north.”

 

nsrobins
04 January 2024 14:41:35

Superb post. The only thing I'll add is there is a lot of demand for medium to long range weather forecasts. If anyone has figured things out they won't be posting on weather forums. Also, the UK Met, Meteo France, NCEP, DWD etc. wouldn't be investing so much money in supercomputers if they could just hire a few experts. 

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

(Agree about Darren’s post).

There will always be a demand for medium/long range accuracy in the same way people crave clairvoyance or need to know if they’ll win the lottery next week. The unknown is always the most desired.

Having been denied data for two days (mid Atlantic) I’ve enjoyed dropping into model land today. The overriding message is HLB is on the cards from this weekend and that brings risks (of a wintry nature) we haven’t really seen for several years, and possibly several decades. It wouldn’t surprise me to see a few -20s at 850 thrown into the suite in the next few days.

 


Neil

Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)

Stormchaser, Member TORRO

Whiteout
04 January 2024 14:46:39

Still waiting for the long range text update, today, tomorrow, Saturday perhaps but in the meantime here’s some exciting news from the 14.00 update in the mid term:

“…Much colder than recently, with frost probably becoming quite widespread and some freezing fog patches are possible in places. Beyond next week, conditions are likely to remain cold, with an increasing chance of some snow showers, developing particularly in the north.”

 

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

Yep, solid update with the words 'wintry showers' being replaced with the word 'snow showers' - take that 😀


Home/Work - Dartmoor

240m/785 ft asl

Chunky Pea
04 January 2024 15:14:06

I get the NAO and GLAAM point absolutely - they're just reflections of what certain aspects of the weather is actually doing at a given point.

Isn't QBO a little different, though? I know it measures winds in the stratosphere, but aren't stratospheric winds more an influencer of weather patterns?

Similarly with ENSO - I know that, simplistically, it's a measure of SST's in a particular area of the Pacific... but it does influence weather patterns (as opposed to being just a representation of the relative positions of weather systems)

 

Originally Posted by: Saint Snow 

Strat warming is another overhyped 'signal' in my opinion. 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

DPower
04 January 2024 15:15:11

You may remember MVH, who I always thought was overrated but who's ended up working for a weather company. He's still going on about how good it's going to be, complete with loads of jargon about AAM, eQBO, GSDM and all the rest:

https://community.netweather.tv/topic/99706-model-output-discussion-into-2024/?do=findComment&comment=4994387 

Quote:

"For those who want some winter weather after the last few weeks of very wet conditions then 'this is your time'. We approach mid-winter with such solid footing for cold synoptics that it should be a pleasure to watch the more unusual patterns being modelled in NWP and, interestingly, this continues to link in well with the majority if not all of the seasonal models with regards to how Jan and Feb and perhaps even Mar should progress. Winter is about to start..."

I still have my doubts, though, having seen this west based negative NAO pop up so many times before - and the 6z GFS op is doing nothing to allay those doubts.

I also still have strong reservations about the whole teleconnections business, as the teleconnections they use are themselves affected by the weather we're seeing in our part of the world - and the whole lot seems quite capable of chopping and changing, which is really no surprise considering it's just another way of viewing the models! It's just a fancier-sounding way.

Originally Posted by: Retron 

The amount of times I've seen these teleconnections go tits up yet they keep plugging this waffle, Hell they even think they can forecast the weather months in advance let along weeks. Metcast on Netweather even recons he saw this coming back in June. Heaven help us. The forum is a joke. They always have an excuse when their predictions go titicus verticus. You only have to look back to the tail end of November and into early December when they were spouting on about how the westerly zonal train would continue then several days later we had northerly blocking and a continental air source which brought cold to all in the UK plus snow to a number of places.

Teleconnections are real but their are many other factors involved and if supercomputers struggles to work out how they all come into play and how one forcing reacts with another and then another and another etc then I am  extremely dubious when they keep posting their rhetoric.

Take the next couple of weeks for example, there is no way we would be seeing the type of synoptics unfolding unless the stratosphere has a big hand in it which of course it does. A medium strength phase 2 MJO, medium strength GLAAM and relatively high GWO on their own would not produce anything like the amplification we are seeing in the synoptic patterns going forward.

That is my take on it anyway.

Back to the models and the ecm 06z control run is now showing an area of -10c 850 temps over England come Monday with convective activity. The ens are solid in the direction forward and for all of us snow and cold weather fans the outlook looks excellent.

 

squish
04 January 2024 15:38:37
I like the structure of the high pre-retrogression better on the ICON 12z ( as compared to the 00z run)

https://modeles12.meteociel.fr/modeles/icon/archives/2024010400/iconnh-0-180.png?0 

How this actually plays out we will only know through living it over the next 2 weeks. But it is abundantly clear that the NH is primed for a major pattern shift. This increases the chances of a severe cold outbreak for the UK markedly over the norm.

I would say 55% rather than 10% ( if that is the norm for this point in winter and maybe 5% being in a modern January)).

But the fact that it might be 55% doesn't guarantee it will unfold. We just need a bit of luck too. ( and physics doesn't involve luck...I just mean  luck in that the model runs that show the deep cold are right compared to the fewer runs that mess it all up)

Fascinating

 


D.E.W on Dartmoor. 300m asl
squish
04 January 2024 15:39:52
Rob K
04 January 2024 15:48:58
Did I mention how I've always rated the JMA as an excellent model?

https://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/jma/runs/2024010400/J264-21.GIF?04-0 

😉


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

Rob K
04 January 2024 16:06:55
Met O 12Z seems to be nudging the high northwards just a tad. A good sign?
Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

Saint Snow
04 January 2024 16:16:42

Met O 12Z seems to be nudging the high northwards just a tad. A good sign?

Originally Posted by: Rob K 

Presumably you mean the initial positioning (over Scotland/North Sea)?

Problem with the Met run (and others) is how the high ridges its south-east flank south-eastwards deep into the continent. Prevents a clean flow of the very cold air.

 


Martin

Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)

A TWO addict since 14/12/01

"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."

Aneurin Bevan

Remove ads from site