The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

overland
30 November 2023 16:42:59
It is weird how the 0z runs have been more progressive recently, but ones later in the day go the other way. It's been mentioned a few times, but I've not paid any attention as it's not logical with the way the models work.  However it keeps happening and it's getting to the stage where it might be more than a statistical anomaly.
Mumbles, Swansea. 80m asl
doctormog
30 November 2023 16:47:14

It is weird how the 0z runs have been more progressive recently, but ones later in the day go the other way. It's been mentioned a few times, but I've not paid any attention as it's not logical with the way the models work.  However it keeps happening and it's getting to the stage where it might be more than a statistical anomaly.

Originally Posted by: overland 

I have noticed that for a number of years and I wonder if it is to do with the range of input data sources at the initiation times of the various different runs. Perhaps it’s my mind playing tricks on me.


Retron
30 November 2023 16:58:40

I have noticed that for a number of years and I wonder if it is to do with the range of input data sources at the initiation times of the various different runs. Perhaps it’s my mind playing tricks on me.

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

It used to be that the 0z and 12z runs had a fuller set of data. They used to verify more highly than the 6z and 18z runs too.

It also used to be the case that a lack of aeroplane data over Christmas led to all sorts of wacky blocking popping up, only to vanish as flights got back to data a couple of days later - this happened pretty much every year, the exception being when the outlook was already looking blocked (in our region).

These days there's much more data being fed in, including vast amounts of satellite data which simply wasn't available even 10 years ago. It's enough to have reduced the impact of lack of data over the past couple of Christmases.

I still wouldn't be surprised, mind you, to see the 0z and 12z runs continuing to verify more highly than the others!

EDIT: I also wonder if the ever-increasing resolution of the GFS in particular is causing problems. The "dartboard phenomenon" seems to have become worse in the past few years, and I wonder if it's because the model is now able to resolve very small-scale phantom features which end up throwing things awry - whereas with fewer grid points, they wouldn't have appeared at all, thus wouldn't have gone on to cause issues.

It should also be mentioned that ECM has also increased its resolution massively over the years, but doesn't suffer as much from the "dartboards". They've always had better results overall than GFS, though, so presumably their algorithms are better able to get rid of those phantom features...

 


Leysdown, north Kent
Rob K
30 November 2023 16:59:48

Which makes me wonder....are the models programmed with climate change assumptions these days....so that instead of running with scenarios purely based on historical data, they are delivering outcomes with a big dollop of a "climate change will make our weather more extreme" assumption added in, with a greater emphasis for the runs excess of 8 days ?

Originally Posted by: Timmytour 

As far as I understand the models, they are not programmed with either climate change assumptions OR historical data.

All they do is model the atmosphere as a fluid - you take measurements of the temperature, pressure, wind speed etc etc at various points, and the model just calculates what happens to the fluid flow. They are not programmed with "if the pressure rises here then there will be a Scandinavian high over here, because that's what happened in 19xx".


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

overland
30 November 2023 17:10:02

I have noticed that for a number of years and I wonder if it is to do with the range of input data sources at the initiation times of the various different runs. Perhaps it’s my mind playing tricks on me.

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

It's an interesting one as we (I!) only really pay attention when there is cold on offer so haven't noticed it at other times.


Mumbles, Swansea. 80m asl
Retron
30 November 2023 17:11:54

They are not programmed with "if the pressure rises here then there will be a Scandinavian high over here, because that's what happened in 19xx".

Originally Posted by: Rob K 

True enough, although it's worth mentioning that's how Graphcast works, the new ECM/Google ML model.

The holy grail would be merging the two codebases, but that'd be a hell of a job. In other words, "the physics over our grid points would say x will happen, but checking with ML shows that 9 out of 10 times something pops up and messes it up, so we'll go with that instead".

You could call it the "No white Christmases ever again for Kent" model! 😂

(There were also "bias corrected" versions of some models available in the past, but the difference between those and the normal models was minimal at best in terms of overall accuracy. It could well be that there are certain tweaks applied to the traditional models to reduce known errors...)

And doing more digging, how's this for interesting? It's from the GFS changelog back in 2019.

https://www.emc.ncep.noaa.gov/emc/docs/FV3GFS_OD_Briefs_10-01-18_4-1-2019.pdf 

Initial discovery of odd convection in FV3GFS (Mark Klein, WPC)

Fixed an issue with climatological tendencies applied to the model (4x/day!)

Fit-to-radiosondes

GFS and FV3GFS winds too weak, but FV3GFS is closer to obs.

FV3GFS winds better in troposphere but worse in stratosphere

Fit-to-analyses FV3GFS reduced GFS cold bias in middle to upper stratosphere.

FV3GFS wind RMS worse in stratosphere but comparable to EC

 


Leysdown, north Kent
Heavy Weather 2013
30 November 2023 17:22:40
This isn’t a dig at anyone, but you know winter is here when start talking about input data and verification. Winter is here. Yay.
Mark

Beckton, E London

Less than 500m from the end of London City Airport runway.

The Beast from the East
30 November 2023 17:24:07
Is ICON the new Nogaps? At least we might get a snowy breakdown out of this spell. Just hope its not the only one of the season, like last year
Purley, Surrey, 70m ASL

"We have some alternative facts for you"

Kelly-Ann Conway - former special adviser to the President

Ally Pally Snowman
30 November 2023 18:51:17
Decent snow event for central England on the ECM 12z for Saturday night. 

And another day 9 easterly


Bishop's Stortford 85m ASL.
Polar Low
30 November 2023 18:58:10
Tremendous fight from the block ecm very cold air digging in Eastern Europe.

very encouraging for cold weather fans

https://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/ecmwf.php?ech=240&mode=0&map=0&type=0&archive=0 

https://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/ecmwf.php?ech=240&mode=1&map=0&type=0&archive=0 

 

nsrobins
30 November 2023 19:05:03

Tremendous fight from the block ecm very cold air digging in Eastern Europe.

very encouraging for cold weather fans

https://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/ecmwf.php?ech=240&mode=0&map=0&type=0&archive=0 

https://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/ecmwf.php?ech=240&mode=1&map=0&type=0&archive=0 

 

Originally Posted by: Polar Low 

Agreed - ECM is a knats slider away from being a  Cobra run. Interesting.


Neil

Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)

Stormchaser, Member TORRO

Heavy Weather 2013
30 November 2023 19:15:36

Agreed - ECM is a knats slider away from being a  Cobra run. Interesting.

Originally Posted by: nsrobins 

Indeed.I said this morning that we shouldn’t be down. So much potential in the outlook. I was also happy with the 12z GFS in the medium term, it had potential. Let’s see how things go over next few days. If signal remain into tomorrows runs I’ll be getting excited.


Mark

Beckton, E London

Less than 500m from the end of London City Airport runway.

CField
30 November 2023 20:01:40
Great contest this Modern era  versus Old School ...
Favourite snowstorm

Famous channel low

Dec 31st 1978

Hastings East Sussex

Foot of level snow severe drifting

Next day max temp -4 degrees Celsius

Ally Pally Snowman
30 November 2023 20:04:45
ECM ensembles look very interesting the Op is one of the mildest with plenty going cold by the 6th.

https://www.wetterzentrale.de/en/show_diagrams.php?geoid=49069&model=ecm&var=2&run=12&lid=ENS&bw=1 


Bishop's Stortford 85m ASL.
Polar Low
30 November 2023 20:19:24
Control run was a corker severe cold heading west’ successful undercutting with monster beast.

https://www.weerplaza.nl/gdata/eps/eps_pluim_tt_06260.png 

 

ballamar
30 November 2023 20:28:28

Control run was a corker severe cold heading west’ successful undercutting with monster beast.

https://www.weerplaza.nl/gdata/eps/eps_pluim_tt_06260.png 

 

Originally Posted by: Polar Low 

outlier but not on its own 

Just to add thinks someone made a comparison to last year - completely different. Potential to tap into some real cold only low percentage but tantalisingly close. Could be some rascal ls in the ENS over next few days

Rob K
30 November 2023 20:38:01

Control run was a corker severe cold heading west’ successful undercutting with monster beast.

https://www.weerplaza.nl/gdata/eps/eps_pluim_tt_06260.png 

 

Originally Posted by: Polar Low 

One eyebrow raised 🤨


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

Polar Low
30 November 2023 20:45:40
Brian has noted

 

ECM 12Z also looks very favourable for a continuation of cold weather as we head towards the middle of December. In fact, a bitterly cold spell could quickly develop *if* the evolution it shows is correct

Polar Low
30 November 2023 20:56:01
Brian Gaze
30 November 2023 21:18:37
ECM ENS still supports average to mild weather in the south > 07/12. 

https://www.theweatheroutlook.com/premium/ecm-tables.aspx?run=12&fv=tmp2m&loc=london&lat=51.5&lon=0&p=&cty= 


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

squish
30 November 2023 21:31:43
18z ICON again consistent in lows trending towards undercutting 

https://modeles12.meteociel.fr/modeles/icon/archives/2023113018/iconnh-0-120.png?18 

at +120 even the low off Newfoundland is starting to undercut the cold airmass that extends across the North Atlantic 


D.E.W on Dartmoor. 300m asl
Russwirral
30 November 2023 21:51:24
Alot of cold building up towards siberia on all models today... possibly record breaking.

Something very cold brewing


doctormog
30 November 2023 21:56:13
If the GFS 18z run follows the earlier ensembles it will show much milder across all parts by the 7th. If it doesn’t it will be an interesting sign.
Gusty
30 November 2023 22:04:29
Its shaping up to be a fairly volatile spell of the weather next week. Sharp boundaries between cold air across the north of the UK and milder air across the south. 
Steve - Folkestone, Kent

Current conditions from my Davis Vantage Vue

https://www.wunderground.com/dashboard/pws/IFOLKE11 

Join Kent Weather on Facebook.

https://www.facebook.com/stevewall69/ 



White Meadows
30 November 2023 22:25:42
Lots of high lat blocking showing it’s hand around the globe, notibly so over northern Canada, polar vortex goes awol but still the Atlantic lows barrel up to Iceland relentlessly keeping the cold locked over mainland Europe. 

 

Remove ads from site