The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

moomin75
28 November 2023 17:27:01

There is so much uncertainty right now that I honestly think all bets are off wrt what happens from late next week onwards, Kieren.

I still clearly recall the state of total confusion the models were in for a while in mid-Feb 2018 when they first began to pick up on the development of the Beast, with some runs showing the Beast coming in while others wanted to bring in the atlantic. In the end the Beast won out, but it was on a knife-edge for while from what I recall.

Originally Posted by: David M Porter 

Virtually zero support from the GEFS for the 12z operational run David, so I would suggest it's a run for the bin!


Witney, Oxfordshire

100m ASL

doctormog
28 November 2023 17:31:16
The range of outcomes by day 10 on the 12z GEFS ensemble set is quite notable with very little consensus.
warrenb
28 November 2023 17:32:45

The range of outcomes by day 10 on the 12z GEFS ensemble set is quite notable with very little consensus.

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

Indeed we have a spread of +10 to -8 (bet you can't guess which one is -8).

Anyway, the spread is even between the runs as well, so as said, absolutely no consensus at all.


Retron
28 November 2023 17:33:50

Can you imagine what the charts would have looked like heading toward 1987 or 1991. As you say, one day 

Originally Posted by: warrenb 

I can tell you what they looked like in 1991 - the Today newspaper had a weather column by Philip Eden back then, and it showed a synoptic chart with a high to the NE of Scandinavia. The accompanying caption said "Cold high H will move southwestwards"... it was unusual, as they didn't usually say "cold high", just "high". The high did indeed move SW'wards, and a few days later we had our easterly.

They would have used the UKMO global model for that, so it picked it out a few days in advance at least.

I'm not sure about 1987, although I do know that snow was forecast as my mum freaked out... she hated snow so very much, as the previous year she'd had to help clear the road for the hearse that took her dad to the crematorium. I also know there was enough notice for her to get in a load of food and paraffin for the greenhouse heater, which was a good idea as we were cut off for over a week.


Leysdown, north Kent
CField
28 November 2023 17:42:20
As a few others have wisely pointed out...this isn't a straightforward transition to Southwesterlies yet....GFS picking up on something ..... been a long time since UK was under a Rex high... 
Favourite snowstorm

Famous channel low

Dec 31st 1978

Hastings East Sussex

Foot of level snow severe drifting

Next day max temp -4 degrees Celsius

Jiries
28 November 2023 17:43:27

Can you imagine what the charts would have looked like heading toward 1987 or 1991. As you say, one day 

Originally Posted by: warrenb 

That what I am after proper subzero temps, proper band of snow follow by showers and deep cold night temps.  Not much to ask for that UK can get those temps at our lattitude zone but the ruddy models that give those always take them away from us.  This Thursday they took the snow chances out and sent them further  south.  

Why the models always doing on purpose to send hte LP with snow chances down to EU and not us? But with rain they happy to throw at us.  I always blame the models for that entirely.   That why I miss the old days no models was exist so we get better winters cold spells.

ballamar
28 November 2023 17:43:42
Couple of members agreeing with the Op run! Has to start somewhere!
warrenb
28 November 2023 17:46:34
Anyone ever noticed that p19 goes cold at the slightest sniff. I always does, I call it the brown line of cold
moomin75
28 November 2023 17:47:45
As expected, the 12z GFS run is a HUGE outlier.

On we go!


Witney, Oxfordshire

100m ASL

DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
28 November 2023 18:09:25
WX temp charts unlike this morning when the freezing weather was due to retreat to Poland, now show a full-on blast in week 2 all the way to the Atlantic coasts. Britain is on the next coldest level, but not freezing except in the Highlands. 

http://www.wxmaps.org/pix/temp4  


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

Rob K
28 November 2023 18:25:35

I'm starting to think a human somewhere in GFS and ECM towers talk to each other and deliberately put out these runs manually just to toy with us all.

I am not falling for the 12z GFS one jot. A clear Outlier surely.

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

Looking at the postage stamps it's not totally without support. In the minority though. https://www.meteociel.fr/cartes_obs/gens_panel.php?modele=0&mode=1&ech=276&size= 


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

Taylor1740
28 November 2023 18:59:04

As expected, the 12z GFS run is a HUGE outlier.

On we go!

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

now that is what you call an outlier. A crushing set of ensembles for cold weather fans!


NW Leeds - 150m amsl
doctormog
28 November 2023 19:03:16

now that is what you call an outlier. A crushing set of ensembles for cold weather fans!

Originally Posted by: Taylor1740 

I’m not sure anyone had such high expectations in the day 10ish time range for those to be “crushed”. The uncertainty is high in that range and has been since this current cold spell came into the reliable time frame. 

I guess the GFS 12z op run may have been an outlier in some parts, here it is just one of the coldest option in “FI”.

UserPostedImage 

Beyond the cold or potentially wintriness in the next week or so it will be interesting to see how things evolve in early December. Very mild, average, cold? All options are on the table.


Rob K
28 November 2023 19:09:58

now that is what you call an outlier. A crushing set of ensembles for cold weather fans!

Originally Posted by: Taylor1740 

The ensembles are a lot better than the 6Z. At least there are two or three other runs taking the same route as the op. On the 6Z there was not a sausage.


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

ballamar
28 November 2023 19:21:24
I don’t think the ECM and GFS at 240 are massively different just the location of the cold
MBrothers
28 November 2023 19:25:35

now that is what you call an outlier. A crushing set of ensembles for cold weather fans!

Originally Posted by: Taylor1740 

a bit dramatic dear . 
Gandalf The White
28 November 2023 19:42:09

now that is what you call an outlier. A crushing set of ensembles for cold weather fans!

Originally Posted by: Taylor1740 

I have to assume that either you’re being unnecessarily dramatic or you’ve misunderstood the word ‘outlier’?

The Op is only a true outlier for a total of three days across the final seven days of the output, the rest of the time there is some support from the ensemble suite.  It hinges on whether the Op has the behaviour of the jet stream and the associated build of the Scandi high right.

Lack of support does not equal wrong, it just equals huge uncertainty.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



White Meadows
28 November 2023 20:02:33

I have to assume that either you’re being unnecessarily dramatic or you’ve misunderstood the word ‘outlier’?

The Op is only a true outlier for a total of three days across the final seven days of the output, the rest of the time there is some support from the ensemble suite.  It hinges on whether the Op has the behaviour of the jet stream and the associated build of the Scandi high right.

Lack of support does not equal wrong, it just equals huge uncertainty.

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

But yet again… it’s an outlier. 

 

Taylor1740
28 November 2023 20:45:23

I have to assume that either you’re being unnecessarily dramatic or you’ve misunderstood the word ‘outlier’?

The Op is only a true outlier for a total of three days across the final seven days of the output, the rest of the time there is some support from the ensemble suite.  It hinges on whether the Op has the behaviour of the jet stream and the associated build of the Scandi high right.

Lack of support does not equal wrong, it just equals huge uncertainty.

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

it's clearly an outlier on the basis that it doesn't have much support and is therefore very unlikely to evolve in that way or similar. It's way out of the range of the mean which for me is an outlier.


NW Leeds - 150m amsl
Gandalf The White
28 November 2023 20:55:44

it's clearly an outlier on the basis that it doesn't have much support and is therefore very unlikely to evolve in that way or similar. It's way out of the range of the mean which for me is an outlier.

Originally Posted by: Taylor1740 

As you say, it doesn’t have much support; which means it does have some limited support; which means it’s not really an outlier.

Anyway, semantics aside, the point is that it doesn’t make the evolution wrong, it just makes it risky or unlikely.  Since the Op runs at a higher resolution it ought to carry more weight, surely?


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



Polar Low
28 November 2023 21:02:15

We can’t really use the mean at that range it gets badly screwed with extreme members.

Some people like means other don’t I’m not a great fan.

Opp could be a trend setter it has made a sold decision at around the 8th which other members can’t see I think it unlikely but it has happened before but we would need to see some momentum.

Gfs always tends to be first when something is up and brewing other than its reluctance to undercut many moons ago hopefully its upgrades have sorted that out.

 

Gandalf The White
28 November 2023 21:23:27

But yet again… it’s an outlier. 

 

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

If you say so.  But it doesn’t render the Op wrong.  Unless you think otherwise?


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



squish
28 November 2023 21:48:40
18z has more of a snow threat fro the SW on Thursday...
D.E.W on Dartmoor. 300m asl
squish
28 November 2023 22:01:07
Its still all very up in the air for anything past 120 in my view.

The low near the Azores on this chart(18z +102) was originally supposed to be moving in from the SW this weekend...

https://modeles16.meteociel.fr/modeles/gfs/runs/2023112818/gfsnh-0-102.png?18 

 


D.E.W on Dartmoor. 300m asl
Downpour
28 November 2023 22:39:04
Some bright, crisp days and frosty mornings in the reliable. Snow likely to be in short supply. Seasonal, though. 
Chingford

London E4

147ft

Remove ads from site