The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

ARTzeman
  • ARTzeman
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
12 January 2022 15:58:01

Hello, Thank you for the email in connection with CET FIGURES 1961-2020

We have received the following response from the team that manages this.

 

At present, as the correspondent has spotted, the HadCET pages on the external HADobs website quote CET statistics w.r.t.the 1961-1990 averaging period.

These pages will be updated when we complete the transition to a new version of HadCet which will be referred to as HadCETvn2, which e hope will be achieved by the middle of this year. At this point, the web pages will be redesigned and will be able to quote statistics w.r.t. either1961-1990 or 1991-2010. At the same time, it is likely that a user interface will be introduced which will allow much more flexibility in what information can be displayed in response to real-time user requests. In the meantime, though, with these future plans in mind, our existing offering is unlikely to be enhanced as these web pages will soon be  "end of life".

I hope this helps and thank you for getting in touch

Weather Desk Met office Exeter Devon




Some people walk in the rain.

Others just get wet.

I Just Blow my horn or trumpet

jhall
12 January 2022 18:11:12

I'm surprised that they quote 1991-2010 as an option, as I thought that the WMO-approved standard period for climate averages was thirty years, a shorter period presumably being thought to run the risk of being overinfluenced by one or two exceptional years. But perhaps 1991 was just their typo for 1981.


Cranleigh, Surrey
Whether Idle
12 January 2022 18:44:54

I'm surprised that they quote 1991-2010 as an option, as I thought that the WMO-approved standard period for climate averages was thirty years, a shorter period presumably being thought to run the risk of being overinfluenced by one or two exceptional years. But perhaps 1991 was just their typo for 1981.

Originally Posted by: jhall 

I think its a school-boy error.  30 yrs is the standard.


Dover, 5m asl. Half a mile from the south coast.
ARTzeman
  • ARTzeman
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
12 January 2022 23:40:10

Maybe we should move on and accept new modern figures.




Some people walk in the rain.

Others just get wet.

I Just Blow my horn or trumpet

Gandalf The White
13 January 2022 01:19:55

Maybe we should move on and accept new modern figures.

Originally Posted by: ARTzeman 

It’s an interesting point. I’ve always accepted that the average is a baseline against which to describe the current weather, ie the conditions relative to what might normally be expected.  Unless the reference period is updated periodically (every decade) then increasingly the baseline becomes a less accurate/relevant reference point.

But in terms of describing the effects of climate change we also need to be showing how temperatures of the 30-year reference periods have increased.  1961-1990 v 1991-2020 is likely to be an eye-opener for some, and a grim confirmation for others, of how fast our climate is shifting (‘fast’ in geological terms).


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



Brian Gaze
13 January 2022 08:46:46

One of the problems flagged up elsewhere is that we now report "above average" for the majority of the months because temperatures in the UK are rising so quickly. Therefore, switching to a 20 year measure may have help; however, I personally would stick with the 30 year period because there is a lot of value in seeing how things are changing.


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Brian Gaze
13 January 2022 08:47:43

 

It’s an interesting point. I’ve always accepted that the average is a baseline against which to describe the current weather, ie the conditions relative to what might normally be expected.  Unless the reference period is updated periodically (every decade) then increasingly the baseline becomes a less accurate/relevant reference point.

But in terms of describing the effects of climate change we also need to be showing how temperatures of the 30-year reference periods have increased.  1961-1990 v 1991-2020 is likely to be an eye-opener for some, and a grim confirmation for others, of how fast our climate is shifting (‘fast’ in geological terms).

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

Read your post after making mine. This is exactly the point. 


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

westv
13 January 2022 08:54:33

I vaguely remember it took forever for the Met Office to switch from the 61 - 91 average to the 71 - 01 average.

Chunky Pea
13 January 2022 21:34:29

 

It’s an interesting point. I’ve always accepted that the average is a baseline against which to describe the current weather, ie the conditions relative to what might normally be expected.  Unless the reference period is updated periodically (every decade) then increasingly the baseline becomes a less accurate/relevant reference point.

But in terms of describing the effects of climate change we also need to be showing how temperatures of the 30-year reference periods have increased.  1961-1990 v 1991-2020 is likely to be an eye-opener for some, and a grim confirmation for others, of how fast our climate is shifting (‘fast’ in geological terms).

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

This table shows the running 30 year CET average (annual) since the 1961-1990 period. 

30 year base30 year avg
196119909.51
196219919.49
196319929.54
196419939.57
196519949.60
196619959.65
196719969.64
196819979.67
196919989.71
197019999.75
197120009.77
197220019.78
197320029.83
197420039.86
197520049.89
197620059.91
197720069.93
197820079.96
197920089.98
1980200910.02
1981201010.00
1982201110.05
1983201210.05
1984201310.03
1985201410.07
1986201510.12
1987201610.17
1988201710.22
1989201810.25
1990201910.24
1991202010.25
1992202110.27

From: https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/hadobs/hadcet/cetml1659on.dat

On average, there is about a 0.02/3c increase in each consecutive 30 year period with an upward trend that is pretty much consistently linear. 

 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Hungry Tiger
14 January 2022 15:19:41

One of the problems flagged up elsewhere is that we now report "above average" for the majority of the months because temperatures in the UK are rising so quickly. Therefore, switching to a 20 year measure may have help; however, I personally would stick with the 30 year period because there is a lot of value in seeing how things are changing.

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 


Gavin S. FRmetS.

TWO Moderator.

Contact the TWO team - [email protected]

South Cambridgeshire. 93 metres or 302.25 feet ASL.



Hungry Tiger
14 January 2022 15:21:07

Hello, Thank you for the email in connection with CET FIGURES 1961-2020

We have received the following response from the team that manages this.

 

At present, as the correspondent has spotted, the HadCET pages on the external HADobs website quote CET statistics w.r.t.the 1961-1990 averaging period.

These pages will be updated when we complete the transition to a new version of HadCet which will be referred to as HadCETvn2, which e hope will be achieved by the middle of this year. At this point, the web pages will be redesigned and will be able to quote statistics w.r.t. either1961-1990 or 1991-2010. At the same time, it is likely that a user interface will be introduced which will allow much more flexibility in what information can be displayed in response to real-time user requests. In the meantime, though, with these future plans in mind, our existing offering is unlikely to be enhanced as these web pages will soon be  "end of life".

I hope this helps and thank you for getting in touch

Weather Desk Met office Exeter Devon

Originally Posted by: ARTzeman 

A big thanks and well done for doing this.


Gavin S. FRmetS.

TWO Moderator.

Contact the TWO team - [email protected]

South Cambridgeshire. 93 metres or 302.25 feet ASL.



springsunshine
15 January 2022 11:12:23

 

This table shows the running 30 year CET average (annual) since the 1961-1990 period. 

30 year base30 year avg
196119909.51
196219919.49
196319929.54
196419939.57
196519949.60
196619959.65
196719969.64
196819979.67
196919989.71
197019999.75
197120009.77
197220019.78
197320029.83
197420039.86
197520049.89
197620059.91
197720069.93
197820079.96
197920089.98
1980200910.02
1981201010.00
1982201110.05
1983201210.05
1984201310.03
1985201410.07
1986201510.12
1987201610.17
1988201710.22
1989201810.25
1990201910.24
1991202010.25
1992202110.27

From: https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/hadobs/hadcet/cetml1659on.dat

On average, there is about a 0.02/3c increase in each consecutive 30 year period with an upward trend that is pretty much consistently linear. 

 

Originally Posted by: Chunky Pea 

Thanks very much for posting those stats

Just goes to show the cet is steadily and consistantly rising year on year.

And we wonder why we dont get cold winters anymore,along with the odd lengthening each year as well on getting one

Gandalf The White
15 January 2022 11:22:43

 

This table shows the running 30 year CET average (annual) since the 1961-1990 period. 

30 year base30 year avg
196119909.51
196219919.49
196319929.54
196419939.57
196519949.60
196619959.65
196719969.64
196819979.67
196919989.71
197019999.75
197120009.77
197220019.78
197320029.83
197420039.86
197520049.89
197620059.91
197720069.93
197820079.96
197920089.98
1980200910.02
1981201010.00
1982201110.05
1983201210.05
1984201310.03
1985201410.07
1986201510.12
1987201610.17
1988201710.22
1989201810.25
1990201910.24
1991202010.25
1992202110.27

From: https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/hadobs/hadcet/cetml1659on.dat

On average, there is about a 0.02/3c increase in each consecutive 30 year period with an upward trend that is pretty much consistently linear. 

 

Originally Posted by: Chunky Pea 

Thanks for researching that CP.  As you say, about 0.25c per decade, which puts us on track to see the 30-year average above 11c by mid-century.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



jhall
15 January 2022 20:13:42

 

Thanks very much for posting those stats

Just goes to show the cet is steadily and consistantly rising year on year.

And we wonder why we dont get cold winters anymore,along with the odd lengthening each year as well on getting one

Originally Posted by: springsunshine 

Thanks from me too.

Rather splitting hairs, but it doesn't quite show that the CET is steadily rising year on year. What it does show is that each new year that is added at the end of the 30-year period is consistently warmer than the year 31 years earlier that has dropped out. That's still pretty alarming, as it shows that a relatively chilly year by current standards is warmer than a relatively mild year by the standards of 30 years earlier.


Cranleigh, Surrey
johncs2016
19 January 2022 08:53:05

I'm surprised that they quote 1991-2010 as an option, as I thought that the WMO-approved standard period for climate averages was thirty years, a shorter period presumably being thought to run the risk of being overinfluenced by one or two exceptional years. But perhaps 1991 was just their typo for 1981.

Originally Posted by: jhall 

It wouldn't be the same though without one of Arty's typos (I know that Caz will agree with me on that one).


The north of Edinburgh, usually always missing out on snow events which occur not just within the rest of Scotland or the UK, but also within the rest of Edinburgh.

Gandalf The White
19 January 2022 09:07:53

 

Thanks from me too.

Rather splitting hairs, but it doesn't quite show that the CET is steadily rising year on year. What it does show is that each new year that is added at the end of the 30-year period is consistently warmer than the year 31 years earlier that has dropped out. That's still pretty alarming, as it shows that a relatively chilly year by current standards is warmer than a relatively mild year by the standards of 30 years earlier.

Originally Posted by: jhall 

Perhaps ‘decade on decade’ would be more accurate, but there’s no disputing the relentless signal.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



Chunky Pea
20 January 2022 08:05:00

 

Perhaps ‘decade on decade’ would be more accurate, but there’s no disputing the relentless signal.

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

Agree. Year on year comparisons are useful in their own right but as you say, it is better to look at longer term trends as this will smooth out the loud noise that short term comparisons often produce. For example, if this year was to finished below average (which is highly unlikely) or cooler than 2021, it still wouldn't have a noticeable impact on the longer term rising trend.


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Rob K
20 January 2022 10:28:39
I'm still confused, is the new baseline period going to be 1991-2010 (20 years, unlikely), 1981-2010 or 1991-2020? I would have thought 1991-2020 as that is the decade we have just completed.
Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

jhall
20 January 2022 19:21:16

I'm still confused, is the new baseline period going to be 1991-2010 (20 years, unlikely), 1981-2010 or 1991-2020? I would have thought 1991-2020 as that is the decade we have just completed.

Originally Posted by: Rob K 

In the past, updating the 30-year reference period seems to have lagged by quite a bit (eg when going from 1961-1990 to 1971-2000). So based on that, I'd have thought that 1981-2010 was more likely.


Cranleigh, Surrey

Remove ads from site