The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

llamedos
  • llamedos
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
17 April 2020 05:06:11

Day 26.......


"Life with the Lions"

TWO Moderator

Brian Gaze
17 April 2020 05:25:48

Last post in the last thread summarises the current situation.

Some back of fag packet calculations from someone who actually has some expertise in it: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/apr/16/number-coronavirus-pandemic

TL;DR - 600,000 deaths required in the UK to get herd immunity if the virus transmission rate is at the lower end of current estimates. Not exactly optimistic reading. He does seem to be suggesting that testing and tracing is the only way out before a vaccine.

Presumably these are the sort of horrific calculations that caused a change in UK policy. Without testing and tracking it's hard to see how they can justify a lockdown release in the forseeable future unless something has changed.

Would be nice to see a journalist try and get them to refute this article in the briefing tomorrow...

Originally Posted by: pfw 


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Brian Gaze
17 April 2020 05:47:59

Ouch...a boss breaks cover. Hope he isn't hounded out of his job for spilling the beans. Not surprised to learn that the UK government doesn't understand what is possible in the UK. 

The director of a large NHS trust has contacted the BBC asking for the phone numbers of Burberry and Barbour because he does not have enough gowns for his staff working on coronavirus wards.

...

UK garment factories approached by the BBC have said the government doesn't fully understand what is possible in the UK, and which firms could produce what. This lack of understanding has caused production delays.

 

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-52319576

 


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

llamedos
  • llamedos
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
17 April 2020 05:54:19

Ouch...a boss breaks cover. Hope he isn't hounded out of his job for spilling the beans. Not surprised to learn that the UK government doesn't understand what is possible in the UK. 

The director of a large NHS trust has contacted the BBC asking for the phone numbers of Burberry and Barbour because he does not have enough gowns for his staff working on coronavirus wards.

...

UK garment factories approached by the BBC have said the government doesn't fully understand what is possible in the UK, and which firms could produce what. This lack of understanding has caused production delays.

 

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-52319576

 

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

and the irony pointed out in that article relating to supply problems - "Almost all of the UK's supply of gowns used by the NHS is made in China and the Far East"


"Life with the Lions"

TWO Moderator

DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
17 April 2020 06:00:27

Continued from the last thread:

Rail companies working the system. Some people who have an annual season, have found that the companies regard it as a 9-month ticket with a 3-month bonus added so if you ask for a refund with the last few months outstanding, very little is payable under the existing rules  - and this despite Government promises that the companies would have to refund pro rata in the present circumstances. [You and yours, Radio 4, lunchtime today]

DEW wrote:

That's bizarre and very likely illegal. If someone took a rail company to court I'm certain that the ruling would be that the payment is spread evenly across weeks of the year.

Gandalf wrote:

A more extensive account of the situation here.

https://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/experts/article-8125799/Can-season-ticket-refund-Covid-19-makes-work-home.html

The rail companies' argument is that if someone bought an annual season knowing they only wanted it for two months, they would get the annual discounted rate without any intention to enter into their half of the bargain, i.e. a commitment to travel for a year. Or, taken to extremes I suppose, could even get a week's travel at the cheap rate.  More earthily, their spokesman compared it to a BOGOF offer - you wouldn't get a refund on that second tin of beans if you took it back.

Some companies have accepted that in the present circumstances a pro rata refund is appropriate, but others (notably Greater Anglia)are dragging their heels.


War is God's way of teaching Americans geography - Ambrose Bierce

Chichester 12m asl

DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
17 April 2020 06:08:02

We hear a lot about 100,000 tests or whatever. Beyond those tests allowing key workers to get back to work, is there any point in mass testing until an efficient and comprehensive contact tracing process is in place? And that requires a large amount of labour even if the process doesn't start until the number of new daily cases has been brought down to, say, a hundred or so.


War is God's way of teaching Americans geography - Ambrose Bierce

Chichester 12m asl

Retron
17 April 2020 06:28:08

Yes I can relate to that and I know a lot of people who have said they’re used to it and quite like it now.  I’m one of the lucky ones too!  

Originally Posted by: Caz 

It's an interesting one how this affects people differently.

I live on my own, am an only child and am used to being by myself, my close family all having died. My plan, once the wolves die (the youngest at the moment being 9, so maybe another 5-7 years), is to leave my job at the school and, if I want to, work from home. I will get a dog for company and plan to take long walks with him along the footpaths, beaches and cliffs nearby. I'm not one of those who enjoys exercise, so the idea of going for a 4-mile walk alone doesn't appeal... it's fine with wolves though!

So far I'm really, really missing the wolves. It's 2½ months since I last saw them and although driving along a busy M25 to get to them isn't much fun, the change of scenery, the other volunteers and of course the wolves make it greatly worthwhile. I also miss meeting up with one of my friends and taking his dogs for a walk along the coast, or having my friends come round for a games morning (Mario Kart is much more fun when you've a few people in a room playing it).

I can kind of con myself into thinking it's just a weekend without the wolves, but of course I know it isn't. It's the same strategy I used when my dad died; I could imagine he'd just gone away for a week, then another week... I was and am used to being on my own, but it still felt odd. I guess, in a way, it's a kind of very mild bereavement - at least in this case, though, there'll be a semblance of normality eventually.

The other bits... the queues for Tesco, the lack of being able to pop out at 5:30AM on a Saturday to do the shopping when nobody's around, being able to get a haircut, the loss of just being able to take an Easter egg round to a friend as a surprise - it all feels like some sort of weird dream. It's not, of course, it's real life!

There are positives, of course. I'm not one for walks (at least on my own), but being in the garden and watching the wildlife of a lunchtime is relaxing. I'm lucky in that I have no worries about money and I'm also lucky in that I can do my job mostly from home, so I'm gaining over 10 hours a week of time saved from commuting and getting in early to beat traffic.


Leysdown, north Kent
Retron
17 April 2020 06:39:30

From the Tele - bad news from the Netherlands (where they've been doing antibody testing). It would suggest the stark choice is either trash the economy, or take large numbers of deaths in order to build immunity.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2020/04/16/uk-faces-eight-ten-waves-coronavirus-population-achieves-herd/

UK faces eight to ten waves of coronavirus before population achieves herd immunity

A study shows just three per cent of Dutch people had developed immunity by the end of the first week of April - the country's virus peak

Hopes that Britain can achieve widespread Covid-19 immunity by the end of the lockdown have been dealt a devastating blow after research suggested only a small proportion may have acquired resistance to the disease.

Drawing on the research, Professor Anthony Costello, a former British director of the World Health Organisation, warned that the UK faces eight to ten waves of coronavirus before the population achieves herd immunity.

In such a scenario, both the death toll and economic consequences would be catastrophic.

In the middle of March, before the lockdown was introduced, Sir Patrick Vallance, the country's chief scientific adviser, said about 40m people in the UK could need to catch the coronavirus to build up “herd immunity” and prevent the disease coming back in the future. 

Sir Patrick was defending Boris Johnson’s decision at the time not to follow other European countries by closing schools and banning mass gatherings. 

...

Prof Costello also said a Dutch study - if it proved accurate - raised serious concern for the UK because it suggested just three per cent of the Netherlands had acquired immunity by the end of the first week of April - when the pandemic was at its peak in that country.

The study, conducted by Dutch blood bank authorities, analysed tests for the Covid-19 antibody - an indicator of immunity - on 4,200 blood donors.

Just three per cent had acquired immunity, the scientists concluded. Prof Costello said if the findings were verified that would have alarming consequences for the UK’s ability to fight coronavirus.

He said: “We won’t get herd immunity if what the latest models show are correct. In the UK we would have to get through another eight to ten waves to get to herd immunity. This study in the Netherlands shows antibody levels are very low in the community and so the idea it is rapidly spreading and giving protection at the same time isn’t there.”


Leysdown, north Kent
Sevendust
17 April 2020 06:49:17

China upgraded it's death estimate for Wuhan. Adding another 1290 to the toll overnight

Justin W
17 April 2020 06:51:52

From the Tele - bad news from the Netherlands (where they've been doing antibody testing). It would suggest the stark choice is either trash the economy, or take large numbers of deaths in order to build immunity.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2020/04/16/uk-faces-eight-ten-waves-coronavirus-population-achieves-herd/

UK faces eight to ten waves of coronavirus before population achieves herd immunity

 

Originally Posted by: Retron 

We would 'need' to tolerate between 600,000 and 1million deaths to achieve herd immunity.

No government would ever go for that. Restrictions (to a greater or lesser degree) are here to stay until/if there is an effective vaccine and there is considerable doubt about that.


Yo yo yo. 148-3 to the 3 to the 6 to the 9, representing the ABQ, what up, biatch?
DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
17 April 2020 07:06:43

There must be something wrong about special flights needed to bring Romanians to the UK to pick home-grown fruit and veg especially when the Romanians themselves are justifiably nervous about contracting Covid during the flight, despite all checks and masks worn


War is God's way of teaching Americans geography - Ambrose Bierce

Chichester 12m asl

Ulric
17 April 2020 07:14:55

 

We would 'need' to tolerate between 600,000 and 1million deaths to achieve herd immunity.

No government would ever go for that. Restrictions (to a greater or lesser degree) are here to stay until/if there is an effective vaccine and there is considerable doubt about that.

Originally Posted by: Justin W 

Unless they could plausibly pass the blame and responsibility to the stupid, lazy plebs. Don't get the idea that governments value life. They are predisposed to sacrifice millions in wars to protect real-estate and their own power. They won't hesitate once they find a way to evade responsibility.


Solar is only worth it if your roof has toenail fungus.
Gandalf The White
17 April 2020 07:22:33

There must be something wrong about special flights needed to bring Romanians to the UK to pick home-grown fruit and veg especially when the Romanians themselves are justifiably nervous about contracting Covid during the flight, despite all checks and masks worn

Originally Posted by: DEW 

Yes, I did wonder about the risk they were taking. But as one of them who was interviewed said, ‘there’s no work in Romania and I can earn more in four months here than I can earn in a year back home.’

Of course if more Brits had volunteered then we wouldn’t have had to fly people in.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



Brian Gaze
17 April 2020 07:25:33

From the Tele - bad news from the Netherlands (where they've been doing antibody testing). It would suggest the stark choice is either trash the economy, or take large numbers of deaths in order to build immunity.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2020/04/16/uk-faces-eight-ten-waves-coronavirus-population-achieves-herd/

UK faces eight to ten waves of coronavirus before population achieves herd immunity

A study shows just three per cent of Dutch people had developed immunity by the end of the first week of April - the country's virus peak

Hopes that Britain can achieve widespread Covid-19 immunity by the end of the lockdown have been dealt a devastating blow after research suggested only a small proportion may have acquired resistance to the disease.

Drawing on the research, Professor Anthony Costello, a former British director of the World Health Organisation, warned that the UK faces eight to ten waves of coronavirus before the population achieves herd immunity.

In such a scenario, both the death toll and economic consequences would be catastrophic.

 

Originally Posted by: Retron 

 Thanks for bringing this to our attention on the forum. Several of us have mentioned the Dutch study and I have been keenly awaiting to see what it shows. Frankly I'm not surprised at all. Not one iota. I have long suspected that many people "who had corona in Jan or Feb" are guilty of wishful thinking, although needless to say a few of them will be correct. 

Edit: I'm going to stick my neck out here and say the idea that 50% of people with the corona virus remain asymptomatic will turn out to be complete bull. Gut feel only. No evidence to back it.  


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

speckledjim
17 April 2020 07:26:34

 

Yes, I did wonder about the risk they were taking. But as one of them who was interviewed said, ‘there’s no work in Romania and I can earn more in four months here than I can earn in a year back home.’

Of course if more Brits had volunteered then we wouldn’t have had to fly people in.

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

Its not about the lack of volunteers, it’s down to skills. The Romanians come every year so are highly skilled, the British farmers don’t have time to train someone up from scratch.  


Thorner, West Yorkshire



Journalism is organised gossip

Brian Gaze
17 April 2020 07:27:12

There must be something wrong about special flights needed to bring Romanians to the UK to pick home-grown fruit and veg especially when the Romanians themselves are justifiably nervous about contracting Covid during the flight, despite all checks and masks worn

Originally Posted by: DEW 

I still don't know why we need these Romanian workers. I keep reading that 1 million people in the UK have volunteered to help. Surely some of them could do farming work? I honestly don't understand the stigma attached to it.


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Brian Gaze
17 April 2020 07:36:49


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

speckledjim
17 April 2020 07:40:39

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

its no wonder London is the worst hit place if this is how they social distance.


Thorner, West Yorkshire



Journalism is organised gossip

westv
17 April 2020 07:46:01
How can the Netherlands be doing antibody testing? The last I heard was that currently no country had a reliable method.
At least it will be mild!
Tim A
17 April 2020 07:46:06

 

 Thanks for bringing this to our attention on the forum. Several of us have mentioned the Dutch study and I have been keenly awaiting to see what it shows. Frankly I'm not surprised at all. Not one iota. I have long suspected that many people "who had corona in Jan or Feb" are guilty of wishful thinking, although needless to say a few of them will be correct. 

Edit: I'm going to stick my neck out here and say the idea that 50% of people with the corona virus remain asymptomatic will turn out to be complete bull. Gut feel only. No evidence to back it.  

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

Anecdotally I know, but I have heard of quite a few people testing positive with no symptoms particularly with the increased testing in recent days. Includes people in hospital for other reasons and people who have been care workers for or are family of an infected person.

But i agree it is wishful thinking to think more than 5% of population has had it.  


Tim

NW Leeds

187m asl

 My PWS 

roadrunnerajn
17 April 2020 07:46:09

 

I still don't know why we need these Romanian workers. I keep reading that 1 million people in the UK have volunteered to help. Surely some of them could do farming work? I honestly don't understand the stigma attached to it.

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

Again just a thought with no evidence to back it up.. could it be the farmers that are employing these Romanian workers are paying them less than we would except?


Germoe, part of the breakaway Celtic Republic. 80m asl
Retron
17 April 2020 07:51:32

Again just a thought with no evidence to back it up.. could it be the farmers that are employing these Romanian workers are paying them less than we would except?

Originally Posted by: roadrunnerajn 

Off the record, I hear the way it's done is they're offered a minimum wage, but then charged most of that for "accommodation" (i.e. 6 crammed into a manky old caravan).

The end result is they're working for peanuts.

How can the Netherlands be doing antibody testing? The last I heard was that currently no country had a reliable method.

Originally Posted by: westv 

They've been testing blood samples donated via blood banks, as I understand it. Lab-based testing works just fine, it's the home-use tests which are a bit flakey.

 


Leysdown, north Kent
Essan
17 April 2020 07:58:55

 

Off the record, I hear the way it's done is they're offered a minimum wage, but then charged most of that for "accommodation" (i.e. 6 crammed into a manky old caravan).

The end result is they're working for peanuts. 

Originally Posted by: Retron 



Which is still 3 times as much as they earn in Romania .... 

Added to which, it means we're not paying £5 a lb for potatoes in Tesco


Andy

Evesham, Worcs, Albion - 35m asl

Weather & Earth Science News 

Look in the doubt we've wallowed, look at the leaders we've followed, look at the lies we've swallowed, and I don't want to hear no more

Northern Sky
17 April 2020 08:01:31

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

Unbelievable. All the police joining in too! 

doctormog
17 April 2020 08:01:35

We hear and read a lot of preliminary studies and seem to take them as fact. There is a growing body of evidence, a bit like a jigsaw but the full picture is nowhere near complete.

We need to be very very careful about jumping on every report as conclusive evidence. People can dismiss these comments all they want but scientific consensus takes a long time and requires a large body of evidence. Each properly conducted study adds to that but in isolation is only one piece of the puzzle.

At the moment we need a time machine to get “useful results” but we do not have that. Until then caution and non-stop research needs to continue, but everything at this stage is almost in the “current best guess” category. I realise that is not quite true as some aspects of immunology and physiology are well known, but this this is a novel virus. Look back at SARS (version 1) and you will see it has taken years to get a decent understanding of it.

We don’t have years before we can act, so we will get things wrong and hindsight will no doubt show that. It’s not that those research groups who have carried out current studies have come to the wrong conclusions but often those limited conclusions have been extrapolated by people who want an answer, now. Often an answer is not possible just another series of relevant questions to address.

“Standing on the shoulders of giants”.


Remove ads from site