The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

Retron
  • Retron
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
20 January 2024 16:45:18

Arpege has at least 70mph gusts for all of the UK from storm Isha. Very unusual.  Gfs a tad lower 60 to 65mph at least.

 

Originally Posted by: Ally Pally Snowman 

Well, it's 2-1 to Arpege so far... and this time around, it's been showing much higher values than the MetO raw. Hopefully that means it'll be 2-2 by Tuesday!

Arpege 12z on the left, MetO 6z on the right... the 12z isn't out just yet.

https://images.meteociel.fr/im/35/23056/arpegeuk_52_101_0xcn0.png 

https://images.meteociel.fr/im/34/679/ukmohd_uk1_52_66_0qid7.png 

UserPostedImageUserPostedImage


Leysdown, north Kent
Heavy Weather 2013
20 January 2024 17:11:41

Well, it's 2-1 to Arpege so far... and this time around, it's been showing much higher values than the MetO raw. Hopefully that means it'll be 2-2 by Tuesday!

Arpege 12z on the left, MetO 6z on the right... the 12z isn't out just yet.

https://images.meteociel.fr/im/35/23056/arpegeuk_52_101_0xcn0.png 

https://images.meteociel.fr/im/34/679/ukmohd_uk1_52_66_0qid7.png 

UserPostedImageUserPostedImage

Originally Posted by: Retron 

Is Aperge higher resolution?


Mark

Beckton, E London

Less than 500m from the end of London City Airport runway.

Retron
  • Retron
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
20 January 2024 17:37:47

Is Aperge higher resolution?

Originally Posted by: Heavy Weather 2013 

Yes, but it shouldn't make that much difference - compare the inland gridpoints, for example.

Arpege is 5km over France and higher elsewhere, increasing depending on distance from France (5 or 6 over the UK, I think). The MetO global is 17km, but the "HD" MetO as seen on Meteociel is 0.1 degrees, i.e. 7km at our latitude.

Incidentally the high-res MetO 12z is now available. Here's a comparison of the 12z Arpege (left) vs 12z MetO (right) in terms of gusts:

https://images.meteociel.fr/im/23/21088/arpegeuk_52_63_0ypv9.png 

https://images.meteociel.fr/im/86/17848/ukmohd_uk1_52_63_0kfu6.png 

UserPostedImageUserPostedImage 

 


Leysdown, north Kent
Heavy Weather 2013
20 January 2024 17:56:40

Yes, but it shouldn't make that much difference - compare the inland gridpoints, for example.

Arpege is 5km over France and higher elsewhere, increasing depending on distance from France (5 or 6 over the UK, I think). The MetO global is 17km, but the "HD" MetO as seen on Meteociel is 0.1 degrees, i.e. 7km at our latitude.

Incidentally the high-res MetO 12z is now available. Here's a comparison of the 12z Arpege (left) vs 12z MetO (right) in terms of gusts:

https://images.meteociel.fr/im/23/21088/arpegeuk_52_63_0ypv9.png 

https://images.meteociel.fr/im/86/17848/ukmohd_uk1_52_63_0kfu6.png 

UserPostedImageUserPostedImage 

 

Originally Posted by: Retron 

Thanks Darren. So Aperge clearly more extreme of the two, but even a blend is not good news. I’m struggling to understand why there is no orange warning, 


Mark

Beckton, E London

Less than 500m from the end of London City Airport runway.

Chunky Pea
20 January 2024 18:09:17
Models suggesting that strong ocean winds could reach up as far as me, 20 miles inland, as they stream up, undisturbed, from Galway Bay. Not expecting anything too severe but I'm charging up the camping lamps just in case. 

met Eireann have issued a Red warning for the Donegal coastline so worst of the winds expected up there.


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Retron
  • Retron
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
20 January 2024 18:11:25

Thanks Darren. So Aperge clearly more extreme of the two, but even a blend is not good news. I’m struggling to understand why there is no orange warning, 

Originally Posted by: Heavy Weather 2013 

To complete the picture, here's the ICON 7km (left) and GFS (right) view, in the same scale. The GFS doesn't have a "max gust to hour" option, so I've taken a snapshot when winds are highest in London.

https://images.meteociel.fr/im/8/16636/iconeu_uk1_52_63_0mlb0.png 

https://images.meteociel.fr/im/97/21453/36_289UKlfr3.GIF 

UserPostedImageUserPostedImage


Leysdown, north Kent
scillydave
20 January 2024 18:16:09
If the Met Office 15z is correct then I wouldn't want to be on Mull tomorrow - there's a top gust of 106mph! A tad breezy even by their standards.

Worryingly if the strongest winds track just 20 of 30 miles south then Glasgow and Edinburgh would be right in the firing line.

I can't help thinking that this will be the most impactful storm that we've had country wide for some time. Thank goodness it's an overnight job.


Currently living at roughly 65m asl North of Cowbridge in the Vale of Glamorgan.

Formerly of, Birdlip, highest village in the Cotswolds and snow heaven in winter; Hawkinge in Kent - roof of the South downs and Isles of Scilly, paradise in the UK.

Gandalf The White
20 January 2024 21:12:21

If the Met Office 15z is correct then I wouldn't want to be on Mull tomorrow - there's a top gust of 106mph! A tad breezy even by their standards.

Worryingly if the strongest winds track just 20 of 30 miles south then Glasgow and Edinburgh would be right in the firing line.

I can't help thinking that this will be the most impactful storm that we've had country wide for some time. Thank goodness it's an overnight job.

Originally Posted by: scillydave 

The forecast a few minutes ago on BBC News 24 said this would be the most powerful storm of the winter so far, with widespread disruption likely.  He predicted a chance that the warning for Scotland might be upgraded to Red if the predicted conditions continued to worsen.  As things stand the predictions sit between Force 11 and Force 12 for a large part of Scotland: absolutely horrendous.

Plus of course there’s likely to be more flooding as the snow melts very fast.

I really hope everyone stays safe and damage is limited.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



johncs2016
20 January 2024 21:56:01

If the Met Office 15z is correct then I wouldn't want to be on Mull tomorrow - there's a top gust of 106mph! A tad breezy even by their standards.

Worryingly if the strongest winds track just 20 of 30 miles south then Glasgow and Edinburgh would be right in the firing line.

I can't help thinking that this will be the most impactful storm that we've had country wide for some time. Thank goodness it's an overnight job.

Originally Posted by: scillydave 

That's not going to do me any good when I'm trying to sleep though as I live in a high rise block of flats and it gets very noisy here when it gets really windy.

It's even a bit wild and noisy here tonight with that wind and that is before Storm Isha has even arrived, so I'm dreading tomorrow night big time.

 


The north of Edinburgh, usually always missing out on snow events which occur not just within the rest of Scotland or the UK, but also within the rest of Edinburgh.

Chunky Pea
20 January 2024 21:59:38
These sort of storms were two a penny before the start of this century,(spurred on by more frequent and intense airmasses over n America and the near arctic) and they were the real deal. Still, at least we are being assured that the Atlantic still can have a bit of oomph when it tries. 

Back edge of tomorrow's frontal feature looks potentially quite active. Some lightning to compliment the wild winds would go down a treat. 😀


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

The Beast from the East
21 January 2024 00:01:06
Surely has to be amber, not as strong as henk but lasting much longer so cumulative damage. I assume will upgrade tomorrow 
Purley, Surrey, 70m ASL

"We have some alternative facts for you"

Kelly-Ann Conway - former special adviser to the President

doctormog
21 January 2024 00:12:50
There are amber warnings out and have been since this morning (and indeed yesterday). The question is will there be red? I don’t like the wind but at least no one with any interest in meteorology could describe the output as dull!
Jiries
21 January 2024 05:44:13
Another borefest so called storm without snow and subzero temps. Storms in USA or Cyprus I take massive interest as it will brings snow, hail, and thunder actions while here just lame wet and windy. 
DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
21 January 2024 07:26:02

Another borefest so called storm without snow and subzero temps. Storms in USA or Cyprus I take massive interest as it will brings snow, hail, and thunder actions while here just lame wet and windy. 

Originally Posted by: Jiries 

OK, so you want a SNOWstorm. But I haven't managed to find anywhere in Britain which is not forecast to have gusts of less than 50mph, and that means damage and disruption widely - my definition of a storm - and unlikely to be boring.

And on the topic of wind, the MetO warnings appear inconsistent. Many of the Amber areas seem to have wind gusts less than 60mph (the lowest on a random trawl were Eyemouth on the E coast of Scotland, and Balmoral, just nudging 50mph) while a substantial stretch of the S Coast of England has been left out of the Amber area despite forecast gusts greater than 60 mph (not just the notorious exposed spot at the Needles on the IoW at 74mph but 'ordinary' areas in Dorset such as Poole 61mph and Dorchester 60mph). 


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

Heavy Weather 2013
21 January 2024 08:36:03
From a strictly London perspective I’ve done a review of the models and I think it’s a safe bet that winds could reach up to 60mph. This is shown widely across many of the models. There are some that go higher so we should assume gusts in the region of 60-65mph. 

We’ve had one of Darren’s ‘ninja’ updates to the raw output on the MET app. This morning earlier it was showing 51mph as the max gust at LCY. But this is already up 3mph 54mph.

MOGREPS also showing support for winds to 60mph.

The next few two hi res outputs will be very important. But I would not be surprised to see an Amber warning issued for most of England and wales later this morning. 

People often day it’s a Sunday night and I agree London is a lot quieter, but even so it’s never quiet quiet.


Mark

Beckton, E London

Less than 500m from the end of London City Airport runway.

sunny coast
21 January 2024 08:57:13

Another borefest so called storm without snow and subzero temps. Storms in USA or Cyprus I take massive interest as it will brings snow, hail, and thunder actions while here just lame wet and windy. 

Originally Posted by: Jiries 

Because that's down to our geographical location in afraid we will never have N American style winters we are an island surrounded by warming seas with the gulf stream   . Continental winter high pressure becoming rarer in the warming climate 

Heavy Weather 2013
21 January 2024 10:12:44
MetOffice Amber warnings have been extended to cover a larger portion of England. IMHO I am surprised they have left London out of the Amber warning zone. A blend of output is suggesting 60-65mph
Mark

Beckton, E London

Less than 500m from the end of London City Airport runway.

Ally Pally Snowman
21 January 2024 10:20:57

MetOffice Amber warnings have been extended to cover a larger portion of England. IMHO I am surprised they have left London out of the Amber warning zone. A blend of output is suggesting 60-65mph

Originally Posted by: Heavy Weather 2013 

You do wonder why not just put the whole of UK under Amber as difference is marginal. 

 


Bishop's Stortford 85m ASL.
doctormog
21 January 2024 10:23:52
As is repeated ad naseum in the model output thread it will be because the lower wind speeds are modelled to impact parts of the country with the highest population…or something like that. More generally it looks very windy indeed in some NWern parts and maybe a few unpleasant surprises elsewhere depending on hiw things develop.
Heavy Weather 2013
21 January 2024 10:26:58

As is repeated ad naseum in the model output thread it will be because the lower wind speeds are modelled to impact parts of the country with the highest population…or something like that. More generally it looks very windy indeed in some NWern parts and maybe a few unpleasant surprises elsewhere depending on hiw things develop.

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

But looking across the models London looks like experiencing gust similar to that of other parts of the England. The differences are marginal. 

London on a Sunday while by far quieter than many other nights of the week is often still pretty busy on a Sunday night.


Mark

Beckton, E London

Less than 500m from the end of London City Airport runway.

doctormog
21 January 2024 10:34:20
It does look as if much of the non-coastal parts of the SE will escape the worst of the winds, although it will still be windy. Here are some of the models’ max gusts:

ICON (06z): https://modeles12.meteociel.fr/modeles/icon/iconeu_uk1-52-36-0.png?21-10 

ARPEGE: https://modeles7.meteociel.fr/modeles/arpege/arpegeuk-52-36-0.png?21-04  

UKMO: https://modeles14.meteociel.fr/modeles/ukmo/run/ukmohd_uk1-52-36-0.png?21-04  


Retron
  • Retron
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
21 January 2024 10:49:50

It does look as if much of the non-coastal parts of the SE will escape the worst of the winds, although it will still be windy. Here are some of the models’ max gusts:

ICON (06z): https://modeles12.meteociel.fr/modeles/icon/iconeu_uk1-52-36-0.png?21-10 

ARPEGE: https://modeles7.meteociel.fr/modeles/arpege/arpegeuk-52-36-0.png?21-04  

UKMO: https://modeles14.meteociel.fr/modeles/ukmo/run/ukmohd_uk1-52-36-0.png?21-04  

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

I'm struck by the continuing difference between Arpege and the Met Office's modelling... the former is still keen to have gusts around 70mph widely across the south, including here, while the others show speeds in the 50s at most.

I've been keeping tabs on events with large discrepancies through the winter, and so far Arpege has called it right twice, compared to once for the Met Office. I suspect this will be two-all after this event, but given that GFS persists in showing gusts into the high 60s... all I can say is that I hope the Met Office and ICON are closer to the mark!


Leysdown, north Kent
johncs2016
21 January 2024 10:51:07

MetOffice Amber warnings have been extended to cover a larger portion of England. IMHO I am surprised they have left London out of the Amber warning zone. A blend of output is suggesting 60-65mph

Originally Posted by: Heavy Weather 2013 

I see that the whole of Scotland except for the Shetland Isles is now under that amber warning, and given how extensive that area now is, I wouldn't be surprised even at this very late stage if that wasn't upgraded to a red warning somewhere before these warnings officially come into effect.

EDIT:

Just as I have written that, I can now confirm that Storm Isha has now officially arrived here in Edinburgh as it has now started raining here. The winds haven't picked up yet and have actually died down since last night, but those really strong winds will no doubt come later on and I would imagine that this will happen once the main frontal system which is associated with this storm has moved through.

 


The north of Edinburgh, usually always missing out on snow events which occur not just within the rest of Scotland or the UK, but also within the rest of Edinburgh.

scillydave
21 January 2024 11:06:07

I see that the whole of Scotland except for the Shetland Isles is now under that amber warning, and given how extensive that area now is, I wouldn't be surprised even at this very late stage if that wasn't upgraded to a red warning somewhere before these warnings officially come into effect.

EDIT:

Just as I have written that, I can now confirm that Storm Isha has now officially arrived here in Edinburgh as it has now started raining here. The winds haven't picked up yet and have actually died down since last night, but those really strong winds will no doubt come later on and I would imagine that this will happen once the main frontal system which is associated with this storm has moved through.

 

Originally Posted by: johncs2016 

There's certainly an allowance in the risk matrix for that John. At the moment the uncertainty means that its still Amber. It meets the 'Impact' criteria for a Red just not the certainty level. If the details firm up and the really damaging winds (90mph+) in that swathe across Central Scotland are still there then it'll go Red later.


Currently living at roughly 65m asl North of Cowbridge in the Vale of Glamorgan.

Formerly of, Birdlip, highest village in the Cotswolds and snow heaven in winter; Hawkinge in Kent - roof of the South downs and Isles of Scilly, paradise in the UK.

Retron
  • Retron
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
21 January 2024 11:11:15

There's certainly an allowance in the risk matrix for that John. At the moment the uncertainty means that its still Amber. It meets the 'Impact' criteria for a Red just not the certainty level. If the details firm up and the really damaging winds (90mph+) in that swathe across Central Scotland are still there then it'll go Red later.

Originally Posted by: scillydave 

I wonder whether that potential swathe of "much higher than elsewhere" winds is indicative of a sting jet?


Leysdown, north Kent

Remove ads from site