The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

CField
16 November 2023 10:38:42
Wonder except for the occasional meander the forthcoming three months will see the high  keep its shape and locate somewhere in the region eastern central Atlantic south west of UK.Scandinavia will be in the freezer and occasional incursions of cold air to the north east UK. The rest of us it will be another " What if winter of nothingness ".
Favourite snowstorm

Famous channel low

Dec 31st 1978

Hastings East Sussex

Foot of level snow severe drifting

Next day max temp -4 degrees Celsius

Gandalf The White
16 November 2023 11:01:13

Quite a common theme each year - decent cold charts show up for beginning of Dec seemingly forgetting about the key driver of the weather at this time of year the PV! Fun looking at some of the output while it’s there though - rapidly disappearing now

Originally Posted by: ballamar 

Looking at the charts it seems to me that the problem is as much about the proximity of the high pressure belt to our south. That has been the main reason that colder air fails to flow sufficiently south. Sadly, for those hoping for seasonal winter weather, the climatological trend is for higher pressure to our south due to climate change; Brian posted the evidence last year. It doesn’t stop cold spells but it makes them less likely.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



nsrobins
16 November 2023 14:31:21

Looking at the charts it seems to me that the problem is as much about the proximity of the high pressure belt to our south. That has been the main reason that colder air fails to flow sufficiently south. Sadly, for those hoping for seasonal winter weather, the climatological trend is for higher pressure to our south due to climate change; Brian posted the evidence last year. It doesn’t stop cold spells but it makes them less likely.

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

Fair point. The science suggests the frequency of cold winters in the UK will drop at a similar rate as the frequency of severe rain or wind events increases, and the preponderance of high 500hPa anomalies to our south is evidence if you need it.

That said the weather is weather and never say never and all that. 


Neil

Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)

Stormchaser, Member TORRO

Ally Pally Snowman
16 November 2023 15:46:12
Snow at Christmas is just magical.  We had 5 inches last year about two weeks before. I told my boys 6 and 8 at the time to drink it in as its so rare. Driving home in the dark that week with people's houses decorated with thick snow everywhere was just bliss. 

Who knows when that will happen again here could easily be 20 years.  

 


Bishop's Stortford 85m ASL.
ballamar
16 November 2023 16:07:56

Snow at Christmas is just magical.  We had 5 inches last year about two weeks before. I told my boys 6 and 8 at the time to drink it in as its so rare. Driving home in the dark that week with people's houses decorated with thick snow everywhere was just bliss. 

Who knows when that will happen again here could easily be 20 years.  

 

Originally Posted by: Ally Pally Snowman 

Possibly the most annoying snowfall ever - 5 miles on the wrong side of the isotherm! Rain and sleet for me very frustrating 

Retron
16 November 2023 16:12:07

Snow at Christmas is just magical.

 

Originally Posted by: Ally Pally Snowman 

1970 was the last time there was a Christmas card scene down here, i.e. snow falling and settling on Christmas Day. That was several years before I was born, and I'm now in my mid 40s!

Since I became sentient I've seen a couple of flakes (literally a couple) fall on Christmas Day one year, one year where there was some snow still in the garden (which made my day!) and another where I drove two miles to the hills nearby to see some snow on the ground, it having failed to settle IMBY. I would love to see a proper Christmas scene - at home.

As it'll be 53 years this year since it last happened, I don't fancy the chances. I suspect I'll be dead before it happens again, but hey... one of these years Kent might just get lucky.

Back to the here and now, I note the storm which the models had been showing for today ended up passing to the south (there were orange wind warnings in France as a result, they named the storm "FREDERICO"). This is good news, as it's been a long time since the last low went south of the UK - meaning the novelty of easterlies and NE'lies for a time today, together with that orangey glow in the sky as the sun set and the rain poured down. An omen for winter, perhaps? Certainly if it'd been 8 weeks later those of us in the south would have been on lamppost watch this evening!

As for the models further out, they're still coming to terms with the next big pattern change. It remains to be seen where the long-wave pattern ends up, but an Atlantic ridge of some magnitude seems to be the most favoured outcome IMO - whether it ridges far enough north to bring noteworthy cold remains to be seen (some of the GEFS over the past couple of days have brought the -10 850 line south over England), but as we all know - unlike damaging winds, or dangerous heat, those cold outliers seldom seem to come off!

If nothing else, though, at least we should see less in the way of rainfall for most - and I'm sure that'll be a most welcome change right now!

 


Leysdown, north Kent
Ally Pally Snowman
16 November 2023 16:34:50

Possibly the most annoying snowfall ever - 5 miles on the wrong side of the isotherm! Rain and sleet for me very frustrating 

Originally Posted by: ballamar 

Yes nothing more annoying when you just miss out. We were very lucky last December as it was a relatively small area that got it.

 


Bishop's Stortford 85m ASL.
Saint Snow
16 November 2023 16:54:49

Possibly the most annoying snowfall ever - 5 miles on the wrong side of the isotherm! Rain and sleet for me very frustrating 

Originally Posted by: ballamar 

More annoyingly, we were flying to Paris that morning for a long weekend. Snow moving in from the west. We had to wait for a de-icing and, as we were waiting, the light and not-lying snow became heavier and started to stick. The incompetent arseholes at Manc Airport closed the runway, supposedly for an hour to clear the runway. It maxed at 1cm deep. They kept it closed for 4 hours. Our flight got cancelled. Managed to get on another, but lost a whole day (out of 3)

 


Martin

Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)

A TWO addict since 14/12/01

"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."

Aneurin Bevan

Brian Gaze
16 November 2023 16:58:18

Yes nothing more annoying when you just miss out. We were very lucky last December as it was a relatively small area that got it.

 

Originally Posted by: Ally Pally Snowman 

Indeed. The impressive thing was how well the snow lasted through the following days. In some ways I thought it was better locally than the 2010 event.

Anyway, GFS is still not without interest this afternoon, but as usual it is heights to the south which ruin things. This really is the bane of the "modern era" as far as cold weather in west Europe is concerned. People can work themselves into all sorts of contortions to produce complicated explanations of why X, Y or Z in some far flung part of the world will lead to cold weather in the UK. However, ignore the basics at your peril - the high pressure belt to the south is steadily extending northwards.

UserPostedImage

 


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Saint Snow
16 November 2023 17:02:42

Indeed. The impressive thing was how well the snow lasted through the following days. In some ways I thought it was better locally than the 2010 event.

Anyway, GFS is still not without interest this afternoon, but as usual it is heights to the south which ruin things. This really is the bane of the "modern era" as far as cold weather in west Europe is concerned. People can work themselves into all sorts of contortions to produce complicated explanations of why X, Y or Z is some far flung part of the world will lead to cold weather in the UK. However, ignore the basics at your peril - the high pressure belt to the south is steadily extending northwards.

UserPostedImage

 

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

We need it to get a shift on and settle a further thousand miles north, then 😁


Martin

Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)

A TWO addict since 14/12/01

"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."

Aneurin Bevan

Retron
16 November 2023 17:37:43

People can work themselves into all sorts of contortions to produce complicated explanations of why X, Y or Z is some far flung part of the world will lead to cold weather in the UK. However, ignore the basics at your peril - the high pressure belt to the south is steadily extending northwards.

 

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

I'm not sure whether it was you, but I remember last winter someone posting a chart showing the rise in 500mb heights, I think it was, over the past few decades. It was stark and showed exactly what you're saying.

As for the wiffle about "teleconnections", I always take them with a pinch of salt - I sometimes think over on the other channel people throw around those technical terms (MJO etc) just to make themselves look good. And no, nobody's yet cracked it - for whatever they say, however good the moonsoon in India might be, or however high the anomalous heights over the Arctic rise, or how perfect the tripole anomaly might be in the Atlantic, it still seems to be harder than ever to get a proper wintry outbreak.

It can still happen, of course, but it reminds me of that game you used to see in shopping centres (roll dice to win a car). Instead of getting three sixes out of five dice, we now need four or even five out of five - purely to counter the inevitable rise in temperatures (and increased heights), plus the knock-on effects of these, which define our current climate.


Leysdown, north Kent
Gandalf The White
16 November 2023 18:44:09

I'm not sure whether it was you, but I remember last winter someone posting a chart showing the rise in 500mb heights, I think it was, over the past few decades. It was stark and showed exactly what you're saying.

As for the wiffle about "teleconnections", I always take them with a pinch of salt - I sometimes think over on the other channel people throw around those technical terms (MJO etc) just to make themselves look good. And no, nobody's yet cracked it - for whatever they say, however good the moonsoon in India might be, or however high the anomalous heights over the Arctic rise, or how perfect the tripole anomaly might be in the Atlantic, it still seems to be harder than ever to get a proper wintry outbreak.

It can still happen, of course, but it reminds me of that game you used to see in shopping centres (roll dice to win a car). Instead of getting three sixes out of five dice, we now need four or even five out of five - purely to counter the inevitable rise in temperatures (and increased heights), plus the knock-on effects of these, which define our current climate.

Originally Posted by: Retron 

Yes, it was Brian, as I mentioned this morning in my post above.

As you say, the odds are steadily worsening.  It doesn’t mean it can’t happen but makes it more difficult.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



ballamar
16 November 2023 18:50:24

Yes, it was Brian, as I mentioned this morning in my post above.

As you say, the odds are steadily worsening.  It doesn’t mean it can’t happen but makes it more difficult.

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

assuming the pattern change is the result of climate change - could flip as well

David M Porter
16 November 2023 19:14:51

assuming the pattern change is the result of climate change - could flip as well

Originally Posted by: ballamar 

I can remember during the first two winters that I was a member of this forum, 06/07 and 07/08 (both of which were poor for coldies), there were numerous discussions along these lines in this forum. IIRC, quite a few back then questioned whether a sustained spell of notable winter cold was even possible any more in the UK in view of the warming there had been up to that time. One member whom I will not name seemed convinced that such spells were consigned to the history books as winter pressure patterns would no longer allow for it. Little could anyone have envisaged at that point the events of two consecutive winters as we ended the first decade of the 21st century and moved into the second. The events of Dec 2009/Jan 2010 and then December 2010 were certainly a big surprise to me when they occured and not something I would have bet any money on happening a few years beforehand.

As someone said further up this page, the old saying of 'never say never' still holds true when it comes to the British weather these days just as it has done at any point in times past.


Lenzie, Glasgow

"A body of men holding themselves accountable to nobody ought not to be trusted by anybody." – Thomas Paine

Taylor1740
16 November 2023 19:50:33

Indeed. The impressive thing was how well the snow lasted through the following days. In some ways I thought it was better locally than the 2010 event.

Anyway, GFS is still not without interest this afternoon, but as usual it is heights to the south which ruin things. This really is the bane of the "modern era" as far as cold weather in west Europe is concerned. People can work themselves into all sorts of contortions to produce complicated explanations of why X, Y or Z in some far flung part of the world will lead to cold weather in the UK. However, ignore the basics at your peril - the high pressure belt to the south is steadily extending northwards.

UserPostedImage

 

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

that may end up being true that high pressure builds more to the South as we get to the Winter, however is it not true that the Jetstream has been tracking much further south than normal recently since around mid-October, which would therefore suggest that high pressure to the South of us has been weaker and or further south than normal recently, which also explains all these storms that have often affected places further south than normal?


NW Leeds - 150m amsl
Gandalf The White
16 November 2023 21:12:31

that may end up being true that high pressure builds more to the South as we get to the Winter, however is it not true that the Jetstream has been tracking much further south than normal recently since around mid-October, which would therefore suggest that high pressure to the South of us has been weaker and or further south than normal recently, which also explains all these storms that have often affected places further south than normal?

Originally Posted by: Taylor1740 

Yes, the jet stream has been further south, but that doesn’t alter the evidence of a slow but steady increase in heights to our south over recent decades. It’s like the difference between weather and climate.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



Rob K
16 November 2023 22:17:04

Indeed. The impressive thing was how well the snow lasted through the following days. In some ways I thought it was better locally than the 2010 event.

Anyway, GFS is still not without interest this afternoon, but as usual it is heights to the south which ruin things. This really is the bane of the "modern era" as far as cold weather in west Europe is concerned. People can work themselves into all sorts of contortions to produce complicated explanations of why X, Y or Z in some far flung part of the world will lead to cold weather in the UK. However, ignore the basics at your peril - the high pressure belt to the south is steadily extending northwards.

UserPostedImage

 

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

if it was simply a case of high pressure to the south then Eastern Europe would be similarly affected. But they still get plenty of snow. 


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

Taylor1740
16 November 2023 22:34:04

Yes, the jet stream has been further south, but that doesn’t alter the evidence of a slow but steady increase in heights to our south over recent decades. It’s like the difference between weather and climate.

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

perhaps so but in regards to weather forecasting surely you would look more at recent trends and the fact that the Jetstream has been further south than usual recently. I also haven't yet seen that much evidence in the modelling of that dreaded high pressure to the South pattern becoming established apart from the odd model run showing this that Brian has posted.

I'm sure of course that by 1 December it will have flipped to that doomed pattern of high pressure to the South and you will say "I told you so."


NW Leeds - 150m amsl
Brian Gaze
16 November 2023 22:37:23

Yes, it was Brian, as I mentioned this morning in my post above.

As you say, the odds are steadily worsening.  It doesn’t mean it can’t happen but makes it more difficult.

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

This is the chart I posted last autumn.

UserPostedImage


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Gandalf The White
16 November 2023 23:42:30

perhaps so but in regards to weather forecasting surely you would look more at recent trends and the fact that the Jetstream has been further south than usual recently. I also haven't yet seen that much evidence in the modelling of that dreaded high pressure to the South pattern becoming established apart from the odd model run showing this that Brian has posted.

I'm sure of course that by 1 December it will have flipped to that doomed pattern of high pressure to the South and you will say "I told you so."

Originally Posted by: Taylor1740 

Well, I think the long-term trend is clear. Brian has reposted the chart and it shows an increase of about 3mb over my lifetime in the far south.  Of course there will be some oscillations during that time but the long term trend is pretty clear.

As I said, the long term trend doesn’t mean we can’t get periods of southerly tracking jets and potential cold weather, it just makes the odds longer.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



ballamar
17 November 2023 07:51:10

if it was simply a case of high pressure to the south then Eastern Europe would be similarly affected. But they still get plenty of snow. 

Originally Posted by: Rob K 

Hate saying this but that chart would infer more warm southerly flows over Greece taken at face value! Lots of opportunity for cold still but the trend is there to see. 

doctormog
17 November 2023 07:57:55
There seems to be quite a strong signal for colder conditions from the north for the last week of the month on the GFS 00z ensemble set this morning (excluding the op run!): 

UserPostedImage 


DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
17 November 2023 08:24:03
WX charts revive the idea of a major cooling for Europe over the next two weeks. For week 1 most of Europe (now incl Spain) is near norm though rather colder to the NE. In week 2 the freezing area currently over Russia extends SW-ward to the Balkans, Switzerland and even a touch in S France. The near continent is also noticeably colder but Britain has little change. Rain in week 1 stretches in a band from Britain to the Black Sea, heavy at the E end of this; in week 2 it is concentrated over the Aegean while in a change from yesterday the far west from Britain down to Spain becomes dry.

GFS OP - over the weekend an Atlantic LP circulates around the northern perimeter of Britain (FAX shows fronts across most of the country on Sat) ending up Tue 21st 1005mb Italy. For the next week to Tue 28th HP is parked W of Ireland with winds from the N running down the N Sea, particularly strong on Fri 24th as LP in the Baltic deepens. The HP then moves to the east and is centred 1035mb Wales Fri 1st while the Baltic LP declines (moving S to affect Greece) and air from the Atlantic moves across Britain.

ECM - the weekend LP above takes in E Britain as it moves away, rather than staying in the N Sea. The HP begins to grow from Tue 28th but stays further SW so on Fri 24th/Sat 25th all Britain has NW-ly gales. The HP does not re-establish and by Fri 1st LP from Greenland is 975mb Rockall and threatening a spell of Polar Maritime  air.

GEFS - Rain and milder for the weekend then dry into December with the possibility of a little rain then. Ens members agree on another mild spell near Fri 24th (note difference from ECM) after which most go cold,  mean slowly recovering to near norm but with decreasing agreement. Somewhat milder and later wetter in the far SW; for many places in Britain you can cherry pick at least one ens member with temps at -10C from Fri 24th onwards! Inverness snow row figures 25/33 around the 24th.


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

Brian Gaze
17 November 2023 09:12:16
Two points to make:

1) The chart shows the trend through the meteorological winter period as a whole

2) It is often passed off as fact that "Greece is taking the UK's cold weather", but does the evidence support that? Have average winter temperatures in Greece decreased in the last 50 years? (I genuinely don't know) 


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Rob K
17 November 2023 10:20:56

Hate saying this but that chart would infer more warm southerly flows over Greece taken at face value! Lots of opportunity for cold still but the trend is there to see. 

Originally Posted by: ballamar 

That's exactly what I mean. Yet from what I can see the Balkans seem to have got snowier in recent years. I suppose it could be that increased moisture from the south is leading to more precipitation, and the increased warmth not (yet) tipping the temperature high enough to prevent snow?


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

Remove ads from site