The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
31 October 2023 07:12:56
Well, from the BBC R4 forecast at 0655 you'd never guess that a storm was coming up - not a mention of anything beyond 24 hours. Maybe the event has been cancelled?
I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

White Meadows
31 October 2023 07:15:11

Well, from the BBC R4 forecast at 0655 you'd never guess that a storm was coming up - not a mention of anything beyond 24 hours. Maybe the event has been cancelled?

Originally Posted by: DEW 

A case of too much emphasis placed on the Mickey Mouse models perhaps. The same ones that always overcook snowfall, extreme temperatures..?

 

doctormog
31 October 2023 07:21:06

Well, from the BBC R4 forecast at 0655 you'd never guess that a storm was coming up - not a mention of anything beyond 24 hours. Maybe the event has been cancelled?

Originally Posted by: DEW 

If I had to guess it is because of the uncertainty of the track and therefore strength and location of the worst of the winds. If the forecasters put out specifics or warnings too early then the track changes to lessen, increase or change the impact the inevitable criticism and confusion will ensue. If the track is a bit more certain later today or tomorrow I would expect a much more high profile approach even if there are a few caveats that things can still change.


NMA
  • NMA
  • Advanced Member
31 October 2023 07:25:18

Final details of the track of this storm will not be ironed out until Wednesday afternoon. A small change of 150 miles north or south will have a huge impact one way or the other. 

As it stands the channel is going to get the worst of the winds so shipping could be affected. Luckily the tide will be running with the wind in the morning.

We have recently moved to a house which is powered by just electric. The cables are carried by those old telegraph poles…. There is nothing between the house and the Atlantic except for a few fields and low twisted elm trees.

Originally Posted by: roadrunnerajn 

To watch storm force winds against tide off the Bill is something you'll never forget. The waves are incredible to see. If you can actually stand up that is.

I won't be heading in that direction though this time. Too dangerous.


Vale of the Great Dairies

South Dorset

Elevation 60m 197ft

Ally Pally Snowman
31 October 2023 07:25:28

Well, from the BBC R4 forecast at 0655 you'd never guess that a storm was coming up - not a mention of anything beyond 24 hours. Maybe the event has been cancelled?

Originally Posted by: DEW 

It does look like the worst will be over the Channel this morning.  Amber warning for the South Coast perhaps. Surprised they didn't mention it though.

 


Bishop's Stortford 85m ASL.
Retron
31 October 2023 07:37:42

03Z UKV holds the corridor of severe winds through the Channel. Still uncertainty, although the blend and ENS have increased the chances of an historic event for the south coastal regions.

More to resolve today.

 

Originally Posted by: nsrobins 

The UKV is the first model I've seen to take the centre over Kent. More of that, please, in fact another 50 miles SE would be ideal!

(As you say, though, the Channel coasts will be in for a battering no matter what, and the Westcountry too, especially Cornwall).


Leysdown, north Kent
idj20
31 October 2023 07:39:03
Still not looking great for my location with several hours of 45+ mph sustained and 65 to 75 mph gusts. It doesn’t sound THAT extreme and not to the same level as the Oct ‘87 storm, but this one is all straight in from the south where my coastal house won’t be sheltered from the worst of the gusts by the built up hilly bit to my south west. Oh well, just hope my recent roof repairs does hold up as I try to ride this one out, we are overdue a big blow anyway - as long as we don’t end up with another Winter 2013/14.
Home location: Folkestone Harbour.
nsrobins
31 October 2023 07:40:57

West Sussex coast Met office forecast only briefly topping 59mph maximum gust at 3am before subsiding? If that’s anything to go by hardly historic. 

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

Is this an app, and if so what single-source data does it use?

There are two clues above which suggest this sort of ‘forecast’ should not be taken in isolation.


Neil

Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)

Stormchaser, Member TORRO

Retron
31 October 2023 07:48:23

Is this an app, and if so what single-source data does it use?

There are two clues above which suggest this sort of ‘forecast’ should not be taken in isolation.

Originally Posted by: nsrobins 

He's just on about the website. It uses UKV and, as fas as I can tell, something from MOGREPS for more than a couple of days out.

Down here the Met Office site tends to have the lowest forecast, ECM in the middle and GFS at the top end - it's been that way for several years.

The other thing the Met Office automated forecasts tend to do is creep up nearer the time, as has already happened here (Thursday started off with low 40s, it's now low 50s and - if the modelling stays the same - will doubtless be higher on the day).

The text forecast is always worth looking at, as it's written by humans under direction from the Chief Forecaster. Today's offering for the SE says,

Storm Ciaran will bring severe gales and heavy rain to the region on Thursday.

They wouldn't say "severe gales" unless they meant it, force 9 winds aren't to be taken lightly.


Leysdown, north Kent
DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
31 October 2023 08:04:13

Well, from the BBC R4 forecast at 0655 you'd never guess that a storm was coming up - not a mention of anything beyond 24 hours. Maybe the event has been cancelled?

Originally Posted by: DEW 

Perhaps more an idiosyncrasy of the individual forecaster - or just that he'd been told to fit everything into 30 seconds, which always annoys me, as someone with an interest in weather. 

Anyway the 0755 forecast led with it but cautioned to keep listening for warnings as these were likely to be amended as the storm approached.


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

NMA
  • NMA
  • Advanced Member
31 October 2023 08:23:05

Is this an app, and if so what single-source data does it use?

There are two clues above which suggest this sort of ‘forecast’ should not be taken in isolation.

Originally Posted by: nsrobins 

The problem is though that too many people do rely on these apps as gospel and even plan their lives by what the phone shows.

I was talking to my brother yesterday about them and he said the same. Don't use in isolation.

I've known people who plan a summer do two weeks in advance using these kind of apps and they're the ones who then vociferously say the forecasts are never right when it rains on the day.

Reading about damaging winds and severe gales is how we should be planning ahead if we can. Not an app that says only 59mph winds for a short time. In other words don't leave garden trampolines and so on out in garden. Plenty of warning this time and if it doesn't come off so be it. 

But to me it looks noteworthy.

 


Vale of the Great Dairies

South Dorset

Elevation 60m 197ft

Tim A
31 October 2023 08:31:03
Apps such as the Met Office app show blended solutions (from MOGREPS) more than a couple of days out, the result of this seems to be that they generally don't show anything exciting or extreme at that range , so hard to know how extreme an event will be from the App.

This applies to high, low temperatures, wind speeds, snow and rain events etc. 


Tim

NW Leeds

187m asl

 My PWS 

nsrobins
31 October 2023 08:31:47
As much as I advocate the integrity of modern NWP, there is always room for deviations that might not be possible to model until short term. If and when RACY occurs, the process tends to induce a left tilt on track so as a rule of thumb the deeper and more rapidly deepening the low, the more the tilt to the left of track.

When our friend gets into the SW approaches tomorrow evening, we might see late changes to track that could be bad news for a wider area.

 


Neil

Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)

Stormchaser, Member TORRO

AJ*
  • AJ*
  • Advanced Member
31 October 2023 08:44:22

Perhaps more an idiosyncrasy of the individual forecaster - or just that he'd been told to fit everything into 30 seconds, which always annoys me, as someone with an interest in weather. 

Anyway the 0755 forecast led with it but cautioned to keep listening for warnings as these were likely to be amended as the storm approached.

Originally Posted by: DEW 

I've given up listening to the R4 forecasts because they are so rushed and sketchy thanks to the limited time given to present them.

Carol Kirkwood on this morning's video forecast on the BBC website mentioned gusts as much as 90mph with exposure in some parts of southern England in her introduction, and then later, specifically about Thursday, after mentioning some uncertainty about the track of the centre of the low, 50-60mph gusts inland with 90mph gusts, possibly more, in exposed places through the English Channel. 


Angus; one of the Kent crew on TWO.

Tonbridge, 40m (131ft) asl

White Meadows
31 October 2023 08:55:32

Is this an app, and if so what single-source data does it use?

There are two clues above which suggest this sort of ‘forecast’ should not be taken in isolation.

Originally Posted by: nsrobins 

An app? Go and wash your mouth out young man!

 

Chunky Pea
31 October 2023 09:09:53

Apps such as the Met Office app show blended solutions (from MOGREPS) more than a couple of days out, the result of this seems to be that they generally don't show anything exciting or extreme at that range , so hard to know how extreme an event will be from the App.

This applies to high, low temperatures, wind speeds, snow and rain events etc. 

Originally Posted by: Tim A 

Despite not living in the UK, I use that app as I find it to be more accurate than most, and no less for windspeed and gusts. I have noted more than once that 'taf' forecasts for airports over here are usually very close to what the UKmet forecasts. I do think that the one parameter which the ukmo excels on is depression tracks and wind speed potential. 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Retron
31 October 2023 10:01:14
An encouraging move on the 6z GFS op, which moves things much further south again - meaning just the Isles of Scilly and Kent get a walloping.

ICON has moved similarly southwards, so a good morning so far!


Leysdown, north Kent
idj20
31 October 2023 10:18:58

An encouraging move on the 6z GFS op, which moves things much further south again - meaning just the Isles of Scilly and Kent get a walloping.

ICON has moved similarly southwards, so a good morning so far!

Originally Posted by: Retron 

Still looking grim for my back yard, if anything showing even higher wind speeds at around 9 am. Going to need a last minute surprise miracle in terms of hoping for the best outcome. 


Home location: Folkestone Harbour.
nsrobins
31 October 2023 10:21:33

An encouraging move on the 6z GFS op, which moves things much further south again - meaning just the Isles of Scilly and Kent get a walloping.

ICON has moved similarly southwards, so a good morning so far!

Originally Posted by: Retron 

It has - by about 75miles - now entering Dorset and moving NE. Given the corridor of strongest winds are consistently between about 100-200miles south of the centre, the majority of the south escapes the worst - on this run.

There is a significant part of me that hopes for further adjustments south as a) I’m happy to be wrong and make changes to my forecast and b) I don’t want repairs to do at home.

Of course there’s a lesser part of me that is looking for a severe end event just for the experience, but as I get older this part diminishes.


Neil

Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)

Stormchaser, Member TORRO

Retron
31 October 2023 10:28:14

It has - by about 75miles - now entering Dorset and moving NE. Given the corridor of strongest winds are consistently between about 100-200miles south of the centre, the majority of the south escapes the worst - on this run.

Originally Posted by: nsrobins 

Even Arpege has the low dragged further southeast, but it's not enough to stop devastation across the Westcountry and Kent. Hopefully it'll continue to move SE'wards over the coming runs.

There is a significant part of me that hopes for further adjustments south as a) I’m happy to be wrong and make changes to my forecast and b) I don’t want repairs to do at home.

Of course there’s a lesser part of me that is looking for a severe end event just for the experience, but as I get older this part diminishes.

Even as a kid, I hated wind - 1987 and being more scared than ever before, or since, is a part of that. Severe snowdrifts and ice? My favourite severe weather type. Fog? Okay as long as you don't need to go out. Rain? Not my favourite, but I'm on a slight hill and thus avoid the worst. Wind is the only one you can't avoid, and it's the one which can cause expensive repairs - a damaged roof, for example, then leads to damp; a blown-over fence may damage my posh shed, flying debris can scrape the car. And there's always the risk of a tree coming down.

 


Leysdown, north Kent
White Meadows
31 October 2023 10:28:44
Upgrade to Amber is out. A slither of 75-80mph for the most part across the south coast. Hopefully we escape the worst. 
Retron
31 October 2023 10:34:20

Still looking grim for my back yard, if anything showing even higher wind speeds at around 9 am. Going to need a last minute surprise miracle in terms of hoping for the best outcome. 

Originally Posted by: idj20 

You're in pretty much the worst place in the UK for this (the possible exception being the Isles of Scilly). Fingers crossed for you though... this is one event I hope we all miss!


Leysdown, north Kent
Gusty
31 October 2023 10:35:36
oh dear, this ain't good.

All we can now do is wait and prepare.


Steve - Folkestone, Kent

Current conditions from my Davis Vantage Vue

https://www.wunderground.com/dashboard/pws/IFOLKE11 

Join Kent Weather on Facebook.

https://www.facebook.com/stevewall69/ 



nsrobins
31 October 2023 10:38:10
To emphasise the uncertainties, GFS and ECM have both undersampled (00Z input) the jet strength above the nascent low that will become Ciaran. They both have it at about 165kn when in reality from a sounding (Maine) it was over 180kn. 

There is every possibility the low will track left of model on approach - I can’t emphasize the risks enough should this happen.


Neil

Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)

Stormchaser, Member TORRO

SnowyHythe(Kent)
31 October 2023 10:40:50
I was going to suggest an East Kent meet up. Like old times…Perhaps not..🙈

Remove ads from site