The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

Col
  • Col
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
25 March 2023 08:14:06
There has been a lot of talk on here regarding our weather in recent years having become more 'boring'. Now of course 'boring' is subjective, be it lack of extremes, longer periods of the same type of weather or simply lack of a weather type you find interesting.

What I am interested to know is there any statistical evidence to back up these claims, for example are runs of wet/dry/cold/warm conditions getting longer than they used to be?

Discuss 🙂


Col

Bolton, Lancashire

160m asl

Snow videos:

http://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3QvmL4UWBmHFMKWiwYm_gg

lanky
25 March 2023 09:02:30

There has been a lot of talk on here regarding our weather in recent years having become more 'boring'. Now of course 'boring' is subjective, be it lack of extremes, longer periods of the same type of weather or simply lack of a weather type you find interesting.

What I am interested to know is there any statistical evidence to back up these claims, for example are runs of wet/dry/cold/warm conditions getting longer than they used to be?

Discuss

Originally Posted by: Col 

One way of measuring ot would be to look at the scatter of daily temperature means over a period. Arguably the bigger the scatter the more variability there is in daily means an the less "boring" the weather

Of course a winter with continuous sub zero temperatures for 3 months would be described as anything but boring but would appear right at the top of the list as the most boring since there is little scatter on the daily readings. Something like Kevin's winter index would be a better measure

Anyways in terms of scatter it is quite easy to loosk at this every days since 1772 for the Daily CET Mean ad the charts below show this for Winter and the whole year

In both cases the trend is to "more boring"

I guess this must be related to the Stickiness of the jet stream in one particular shape or location.

UserPostedImage

UserPostedImage


Martin

Richmond, Surrey

Bolty
25 March 2023 11:11:24
I suppose it depends what you mean by "boring" as what one person considers boring weather, another might consider interesting/enjoyable etc. For instance, I personally find long spells of warm and dry weather in spring and summer enjoyable and interesting, but I recognise others might consider it to be tedious, especially after a while. On the flip side however, interesting weather doesn't necessarily mean enjoyable. In this case, I think this March has been quite meteorologically interesting, but I haven't particularly enjoyed it.

That said, I do think we are seeing longer spells of anticyclonic dominance, and highs tend not to bring much in the way of mobile weather. It ties in with some of the theories that as the world warms, we are seeing the subtropical belts gradually shift poleward, which for the UK means more influence from the Azores High. Taking that, then you probably could say that our climate is becoming more boring.


Scott

Blackrod, Lancashire (4 miles south of Chorley) at 156m asl.

My weather station 

Brian Gaze
25 March 2023 11:44:52
I can't present any evidence so will offer a subjective view. Winters have become more boring. Summers have become more interesting. Spring and autumn are interesting seasons, although on the forums they tend to be neglected. 
Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Tim A
25 March 2023 12:49:28
Similar from a subjective view Summers are more exciting because of the intense heat possible. Perhaps only a matter of time before some severe thunderstorms too. 

Not sure winters have got any more boring. The 90's were boring on the whole and most of the 00's but a lot more interesting 08-13 and then some more interesting events in the last few years too (Easterlies, big snow events and Spring snowfalls).  


Tim

NW Leeds

187m asl

 My PWS 

Spring Sun Winter Dread
25 March 2023 15:26:24
I thought 2022 was under rated.

scorching hot summer with record temps in July and one of the warmest Augusts ever

exceptionally mild autumn with one of the warmest October/November's ever and that amazing Sunday in mid November when 20C was achieved in places 

Extremely dry period March to August (especially July)

And then to cap it all off , the most noteworthy winter cold snap (albeit brief ) for many years in December with an almost overnight flip from mild autumn weather to a full on two week freeze up.

Which came too late to stop it being the warmest ever year

If you can't find anything interesting in all that then I dare say weather watching may not be the interest for you to be honest 

 

scillydave
25 March 2023 15:55:07
For me it's the extremes of weather that I find the most interesting (therefore least boring). In this respect the weather has become more interesting in so much as we've regularly broken high temperature records throughout the year.

However too much of the same thing is also boring (even if it's an extreme) and as we've broken so many high temperature records in recent years they've started to lose their interest for me - unless they're off the scale like last year's 40c.

Heavy snowfall is increasingly rare as is breaking a low temperature record.

That leaves:

Drought - bit of a slow burner.

Rainfall - more difficult to see the impact of even in extreme events (unless you live in a flood prone area) and probably the most tedious of extreme weather.

Wind - a fair constant and so truly big extreme storms are few and far between.

Hail - wonderful as extreme weather but rare

Lightning - again brilliant extreme weather but rare.

So yes - I think the weather is more boring predominantly because we've lost the 'winter' aspect of our climate to a large degree across lowland Britain. It was always marginal but that's what made it interesting - you were more often on the cusp of something. You could also apply the same to summers of old - heatwaves then were something to really talk about and enjoy now they're commonplace. 

To sum up - we've lost some of the marginality we had.


Currently living at roughly 65m asl North of Cowbridge in the Vale of Glamorgan.

Formerly of, Birdlip, highest village in the Cotswolds and snow heaven in winter; Hawkinge in Kent - roof of the South downs and Isles of Scilly, paradise in the UK.

Taylor1740
25 March 2023 20:00:18
I feel like our weather has become more boring as there seems to be less variety now and especially in Winter there is no guarantee of seeing snow anymore which for me is the most exciting weather event we can have in the UK. 

There also seems to be less frequent and less intense winter storms, fewer thunderstorms in Summer, and even less fog in Autumn. 

I suppose it's good in some ways if our weather is becoming less impactful and just generally warmer however it is boring for weather enthusiasts. We should also not forget that we live in the UK so our climate is generally temperate and not extreme anyway, and that in the past there would have been long spells of boring weather people forget about or don't write about.

However just from my point of view the last couple of years compared to even 10-15 years ago it seems like the weather has been more boring recently at least on a day-to-day basis.


NW Leeds - 150m amsl
Jiries
25 March 2023 22:24:12
I ended the weather data in here since 2012 with the last working WS2500 Weather station had been switched off and took it to recycling centre for electrical recycling.  No regret but kept my Max and Min thermometer for heatwaves or very cold night temps.  Like everyone say very lacking of variety and most runs of summers had been poor since 2018 which was the longest good summer up to 2nd week of August.  I was able to record temps daily from May to 2nd week of August. I stopped when I knew it will not recovered again.  Weather data recording in Nicosia, Cyprus and Death Valley, USA continues as it never bored me at all.    UK is a temperate place but it becoming far more temperate with little change in temperatures day or night,
Saint Snow
25 March 2023 22:51:16
I'm going to buck the trend a little and say 'not really'. 

The point's been made by a couple of people that 'boring' (and 'interesting') are subjective. 

And I think it also depends on where in the UK you live. 

Here in low-lying NW England, I don't think the amount and frequency of snow in winter is that much different to the 70s, 80s & 90s. But I admit I might be being swayed by a glut of 10cm+ snowfalls in the 09-13 period (we've not had one here since 2013, although frequency of 1-3cm falls has been as high as ever) 

However, I can understand why people in SE England, especially close to the East Coast, are miffed. Darren/Retron often laments the lack of 'true midwinter easterlies', and this is obviously a big thing. 

In terms of summer, since we emerged from that horrible 07-12 period, we've had some good summer spells that rival pretty much anything from my preceeding 40 years. 

I'm not that bothered about thunder (it's nice, but not a deal breaker). But I do miss thick fogs that I do remember from the 80s & 90s (and had nothing to do with pollution by that time) 

So, overall, I don't think the weather in MBY is that different over the small sample size. 

​​​​​

 


Martin

Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)

A TWO addict since 14/12/01

"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."

Aneurin Bevan

Remove ads from site