The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

DPower
31 December 2021 15:20:03

 

Look at the strength of zonal winds?! No signs of it weakening or any SSW's then!? - How strange given we are in an easterly QBO!?

No description available.

Originally Posted by: tallyho_83 

How many times have we seen a east or negative QBO in winter with a strong polar vortex.

I think there are so many indices and  teleconnections that are not understood properly, understood at all, or have limited impact for our neck of the woods to have any real effect. Same old names on other forum winter after winter all vying  for attention with unending posts of AAM, MJO, ENSO, QBO etc, etc, etc and how this is going to increase or dampen our winter expectations. Then rather than admit whoops got that completely wrong you will hear the familiar woes of poorly forecasted MJO or la Nina tending to act more le Nino etc etc etc. 

The weightings of all of these teleconnections acting together or against each other ( lets not even go there with mountain torques, friction torques ) are to chaotic, complex, and variable  to be understood with any real degree of accuracy after all look at the NWP with all their super computer power and yet we see how poorly they struggle beyond 3 to 5 days. 

p

Words: 125

 

Options:
RobN
  • RobN
  • Advanced Member
31 December 2021 15:22:22

Saying that, for several days, the majority of the MO was showing high pressure over Greenland ridging southwards over Iceland. 

I'm still none the wiser how such a strong signal evaporated into the total opposite within the space of a handful of runs, from just 3/4 days out.

Originally Posted by: Saint Snow 

Sod looked down from above, didn't like what he saw, and invoked his law.


Rob

In the flatlands of South Cambridgeshire 15m ASL.

Gooner
31 December 2021 15:25:55

 

 

How many times have we seen a east or negative QBO in winter with a strong polar vortex.

I think there are so many indices and  teleconnections that are not understood properly, understood at all, or have limited impact for our neck of the woods to have any real effect. Same old names on other forum winter after winter all vying  for attention with unending posts of AAM, MJO, ENSO, QBO etc, etc, etc and how this is going to increase or dampen our winter expectations. Then rather than admit whoops got that completely wrong you will hear the familiar woes of poorly forecasted MJO or la Nina tending to act more le Nino etc etc etc. 

The weightings of all of these teleconnections acting together or against each other ( lets not even go there with mountain torques, friction torques ) are to chaotic, complex, and variable  to be understood with any real degree of accuracy after all look at the NWP with all their super computer power and yet we see how poorly they struggle beyond 3 to 5 days. 

p

Words: 125

 

Options:

Originally Posted by: DPower 

Good post and totally agree - I'm not sure we fully understand how it all works , we can all look back at history to see what gave us XYZ one year but in reality it means nothing in this ever changing warming world.   

Pot luck as to what we get IMO 


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus

Banbury

North Oxfordshire

378 feet A S L



David M Porter
31 December 2021 15:52:46

 

Good post and totally agree - I'm not sure we fully understand how it all works , we can all look back at history to see what gave us XYZ one year but in reality it means nothing in this ever changing warming world.   

Pot luck as to what we get IMO 

Originally Posted by: Gooner 

As everyone well knows, it's not the first time there has been a major U-turn from the models when they have seemingly been in generally good agereement for a time about the likelihood of a cold spell, only to then drop it and go for the exact opposite. Someone mentioned early December 2012 in the last thread as another good instance of this from the relatively recent past.

Going back even further, I am reminded of mid-February 2009 as well. That month started with a cold easterly spell (I think some areas in the south saw their first notable snowfalls since 1991 during this spell), and for a time the models were in pretty good agreement that that spell would probably last for much of the rest of the month. One night however, the models seemed to flip almost all at once and brought an early end to the cold spell, and the rest of that month was IIRC generally much milder.


Lenzie, Glasgow

"A body of men holding themselves accountable to nobody ought not to be trusted by anybody." – Thomas Paine

squish
31 December 2021 17:08:20
UKMO and GEM both have an interesting SE diving slant if the jet at +144 which results in a scandi high trying to build on the GEM

Small straws ….


D.E.W on Dartmoor. 300m asl
doctormog
31 December 2021 17:11:35

UKMO and GEM both have an interesting SE diving slant if the jet at +144 which results in a scandi high trying to build on the GEM

Small straws ….

Originally Posted by: squish 

Yes I thought the GEM run was particularly interesting:

 


DPower
31 December 2021 17:20:12

 

Hugo always struggled with those anomaly charts, I remember arguing with him on here about it in the past.

The first of his posts shows zonality displaced southwards, nothing especially cold for us. The second picture shows the zonal flow corrected further north, and enhanced in strength - which is what we're going to see.

Now if they had been showing an actual cold spell, or an overwhelming consistent Scandinavian High instead, he'd have an argument perhaps...

Originally Posted by: Retron 

Still shows a large reversal to what it was showing and if they are so ambiguous then not worth showing at all.

 

 

 

 

 

Gandalf The White
31 December 2021 17:31:43

 

Yes I thought the GEM run was particularly interesting:

 

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

The ‘close up’ view as that intense LP tracks east along the south coast looks impressive here: almost a 10c temperature difference between the south coast and Bristo.l

North of the boundary it’s around 3c with heavy precipitation. That sort of set up could easily deliver some heavy snow for areas with any reasonable elevation (at 100m it should be nearer 2c)


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



Retron
31 December 2021 17:48:10

Still shows a large reversal to what it was showing and if they are so ambiguous then not worth showing at all.

Originally Posted by: DPower 

Only if you don't understand them. As I explained, they just show the jet moving northwards and gaining strength.

A reversal of the synoptic situation, rather than a nudge northwards, would look completely different.

It's a gentle reminder that some of the charts we have access to require a good deal of thought to interpret, they're not as straightforward as they may seem. They're valuable to those who understand them, albeit as with all long-range charts they're very much subject to change nearer the time!

 


Leysdown, north Kent
Retron
31 December 2021 17:54:45

The ‘close up’ view as that intense LP tracks east along the south coast looks impressive here: almost a 10c temperature difference between the south coast and Bristo.l

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

 

The MetO output also shows a secondary low, zipping along, deepening as the jet engages it and pulling down some colder air as it does so.

That's definitely one to keep an eye on, for as you say it could lead to some significant weather on the boundary of the airmasses. These things are seldom plotted accurately that far out, though, and even tiny changes in track, intensity and indeed phasing with the jet will have a big effect on the outcome.

Beyond that, it's interesting to see heights rising to the north by 168 on the MetO run...

https://www.theweatheroutlook.com/twodata/ukmet.aspx?run=12&charthour=168&chartname=500hpa_height&chartregion=na-region&charttag=500hPa%20GPDM

 

 

 


Leysdown, north Kent
Gandalf The White
31 December 2021 18:38:47

 

 

The MetO output also shows a secondary low, zipping along, deepening as the jet engages it and pulling down some colder air as it does so.

That's definitely one to keep an eye on, for as you say it could lead to some significant weather on the boundary of the airmasses. These things are seldom plotted accurately that far out, though, and even tiny changes in track, intensity and indeed phasing with the jet will have a big effect on the outcome.

Beyond that, it's interesting to see heights rising to the north by 168 on the MetO run...

https://www.theweatheroutlook.com/twodata/ukmet.aspx?run=12&charthour=168&chartname=500hpa_height&chartregion=na-region&charttag=500hPa%20GPDM

 

Originally Posted by: Retron 

Indeed, Darren. The 12z ICON and ECM both take the LP roughly across the Midlands with less intensification, so the precise track and associated track will be up in the air for several more days possibly.  We could have anything from a period of light rain across the south with a wintry mix north of the track, through to a howling easterly backing north-easterly across the south Midlands and Home Counties with copious amounts of rain and snow.

Given our usual poor fortune I’ll go with the system not really developing at all. 


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



marting
31 December 2021 19:04:30
ECM tonight is incredible to watch as pieces of the polar vortex whizz around the northern hemisphere at speeds I have not seen before! Happy new year to all 👍😀

Martin


Martin

Greasby, Wirral.

CField
31 December 2021 20:32:44

Alaskan high very persistent going into the New Year....squeezes that polar vortex west of Greenland creating more energy to keep the NAO positive......just can't see where any real cold is going to develop for the UK until mid January at the earliest. 


Favourite snowstorm

Famous channel low

Dec 31st 1978

Hastings East Sussex

Foot of level snow severe drifting

Next day max temp -4 degrees Celsius

western100
31 December 2021 22:39:28

GFS 18z looks a little chillier on the westerly flow than recent updates?

Won’t change a lot but Scottish Ski and elevated N and W areas may see some snow


Worcestershire / Warwickshire Border

100m ASL

X…..@Weather4u2

Gooner
31 December 2021 23:04:09

GFS 18z looks a little chillier on the westerly flow than recent updates?

Won’t change a lot but Scottish Ski and elevated N and W areas may see some snow

Originally Posted by: western100 

Better than what we have now for sure 


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus

Banbury

North Oxfordshire

378 feet A S L



western100
31 December 2021 23:06:19

 

Better than what we have now for sure 

Originally Posted by: Gooner 

A little more interesting 

I love a good spring walk in the sun like today but I’m quite happy to wait until April for that 😂


Worcestershire / Warwickshire Border

100m ASL

X…..@Weather4u2

Gooner
31 December 2021 23:10:25

Deep into FI but much better and seasonal 


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus

Banbury

North Oxfordshire

378 feet A S L



Gooner
31 December 2021 23:17:04

At least we will see snow in the forecast .......................all change by tomorrow of course 


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus

Banbury

North Oxfordshire

378 feet A S L



ballamar
01 January 2022 02:11:01
Just checking has anyone mentioned 1947 yet? Looks like winter if it gets cold is going to be a late starter
Retron
01 January 2022 05:34:51

Just checking has anyone mentioned 1947 yet? Looks like winter if it gets cold is going to be a late starter

Originally Posted by: ballamar 

That usually doesn't appear until the desperation sets in - mid January or thereabouts!

Mind you, this morning's GFS output is a winter wonderland, albeit briefly, for the Midlands... here's a screengrab, click for full size. GEM backs it up too...

Of course, it's going to change some more as we get closer. It does show what a dumping of snow followed by a weak ridge can do though!

EDIT: The main cluster in the GEFS, remarkably, backs the op - with a very snowy picture for the Midlands. Notably many of the members have an area of really heavy precipitation, be it rain or snow, in the 20 or even 30mm per 6 hours category. That also tends to come with strong winds, all thanks to that little secondary low engaging the jet.

I can just imagine the headlines were that to happen!


Leysdown, north Kent
DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
01 January 2022 07:55:11

Tue 4th is the day to watch - see Darren's snow forecast above for the Midlands. Yesterday's incredibly violent storm on GEM has now turned into a more general but scarcely less violent N-ly. Other models range from GFS op with a well developed channel low (NE-lies for the Midlands) to ECM with a much weaker feature to FAX where it's little more than a trailing front and E-lies for the Channel coast to Meto which shows 5C and sunny periods, the heavy rain appearing on Thu.

But more generally 

WX summary temps slightly above norm for W Europe, the cold pool staying well  to the NE. Pptn for Atlantic coasts week 1 moving to N Atlantic week 2, some bits and pieces over the Continent both weeks

GFS - current HP with SW-ly collapsing as secondary LP 990mb Brittany(see above) with main low over Norway providing a cold feed Tue 4th; then a re-set as zonal W-lies start up only to be interrupted again Sun 9th with NWly from LP E Scotland 980mb.; back to W-ly again until HP Fri 14th which may then move W-wards (looks a bit uncertain) and let N-lies in Mon 17th

GEFS - temps down sharply to well below norm Wed 5th with pptn in S preceding it (snow row for S Coast ca 8, for B'ham ca 20 and again on 7th) - rising slowly to norm Sun 9th with more pptn in the meantime after which mean is norm and less pptn with much variation from ens members (op v cold at end). Scotland and N England similar temp profile but markedly less pptn excepting NW Scotland

ECM - similar to GFS (but see above re Tue)

hinking of comparison with yesterday, the models are still having problems producing reliable short-term forecasts


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

Russwirral
01 January 2022 08:26:09
GEM and GFS suddenly considering widespread snow on tuesday
Gandalf The White
01 January 2022 08:41:12

GEM and GFS suddenly considering widespread snow on tuesday

Originally Posted by: Russwirral 

It’s what GEM was showing yesterday. Obviously the intensification of that small LP system and its exact track are key. When the conditions are marginal then precipitation intensity is key to getting the freezing level down to the surface.

Other models are still handling developments differently, but potentially worthy of a dedicated thread if there’s more cross-model support.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



western100
01 January 2022 08:44:26
GFS throwing up a very snowy day for the Midlands on Tuesday. At T84 it shouldn’t be discounted but unlikely to verify quite like this. IME these pressure systems end up being pushed further South
Worcestershire / Warwickshire Border

100m ASL

X…..@Weather4u2

Ally Pally Snowman
01 January 2022 08:51:20

GFS throwing up a very snowy day for the Midlands on Tuesday. At T84 it shouldn’t be discounted but unlikely to verify quite like this. IME these pressure systems end up being pushed further South

Originally Posted by: western100 

 

We live in hope !

https://www.wetterzentrale.de/en/topkarten.php?map=20&model=gfs&var=25&run=0&time=90&lid=OP&h=0&mv=0&tr=3#mapref

 


Bishop's Stortford 85m ASL.

Remove ads from site