The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

Quantum
22 December 2021 13:26:50

 

Come on Dean. Even though I know you've always been super positive, you are really clutching at straws here.

If it flips back before Friday, I will eat a pair of my own underpants and stream it live on YouTube. 🤣🤣🤣

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

This kinda feels like a cosmic appeal to reverse psychology.

 


25/26 (850hpa temp) 11 days snow/sleet falling

18/11 (-4) 19/11 (-6) 20/11 (-6) 01/01 (-7) 04/01 (-10) 10/01 (-7) 11/01 (-3) 30/01 (-1) 13/02 (-6) 15/02 (-4) 18/02 (-6)

24/25 10d

18/11 (-6) 19/11 (-6) 23/11 (-2) 22/12 (-5) 04/01 (-5) 05/01 (0)14/02 (0) 15/02 (0)12/03 (-6) 13/03 (-6)

23/24 8d

29/11 (-6) 30/11 (-6) 02/12 (-5) 03/12 (-5) 04/12 (-3) 16/01 (-3) 18/01 (-8)08/02 (-5)

22/23 7d

18/12 (-1)06/03 (-6) 08/03 (-8) 09/03 (-6) 10/03 (-8) 11/03 (-5) 14/03 (-6)

21/22 12d

Brian Gaze
22 December 2021 13:29:47

So what went wrong with the models to you think? Crap data collection or poor interpretation of the data’s by the models. As they say in business systems, put crap in. - you get crap out..

Originally Posted by: BJBlake 

They are global models so the question is how are they performing at the global level. When looked at like that the differences between the JMA run which Quantum posted and some of the others is actually tiny. In fact, the verification stats suggest they are doing quite well at the moment.

https://www.emc.ncep.noaa.gov/gmb/STATS_vsdb/allmodel/daily/cor/cor_day5_HGT_P500_G2NHX.png

Be interesting to see if these numbers change much in the next few days or not.


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

doctormog
22 December 2021 13:36:54

 

Come on Dean. Even though I know you've always been super positive, you are really clutching at straws here.

If it flips back before Friday, I will eat a pair of my own underpants and stream it live on YouTube. 🤣🤣🤣

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

To be fair what he says is correct. The GEM ensembles have been rock steady. It’s either really impressive or they are just really slow to pick up on the change the other models are showing. This is the 00z ensemble set for here:


tallyho_83
22 December 2021 13:38:09

Meanwhile in Moscow daytime temperatures some 16 - 17c below the seasonal average with a max of -22c today:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/weather/524901

 


Home Location - Vixen Tor Close, Okehampton, Devon (221m ASL)

---------------------------------------

Sean Moon

Magical Moon

www.magical-moon.com

doctormog
22 December 2021 13:55:15

 

LOL  what are you talking about. The 12z run did not have snow this far south. Do you work for the met by any chance. Have you looked at the charts recently. Dear oh dear. 

Originally Posted by: DPower 

”This far south”? I refer to Eastern England and yes 12z Met Office data did indicate there was a possibility of snow on Christmas Day in parts of eastern England on Christmas Day. It’s really not my problem if (a) you don’t post your location and (b) you don’t understand the model output. The Met Office know better than you do, whether you like it or not. Dear oh dear indeed.


Chichesterweatherfan2
22 December 2021 14:14:11

 

LOL  what are you talking about. The 12z run did not have snow this far south. Do you work for the met by any chance. Have you looked at the charts recently. Dear oh dear. 

Originally Posted by: DPower 

 

how can I put this delicately....there's another weather forum out there that might just suit you better

White Meadows
22 December 2021 14:15:54

 

”This far south”? I refer to Eastern England and yes 12z Met Office data did indicate there was a possibility of snow on Christmas Day in parts of eastern England on Christmas Day. It’s really not my problem if (a) you don’t post your location and (b) you don’t understand the model output. The Met Office know better than you do, whether you like it or not. Dear oh dear indeed.

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

Well said Doc 👍

fairweather
22 December 2021 14:25:43

 

Good grief. 

We’ve seen some letdowns in our time but this one really does take the mickey. 

I feel remarkably nonchalant about the whole thing, which makes for a very pleasant change. 😂😂😂

Originally Posted by: Joe Bloggs 

Yes, same here Joe. Like when I started drinking less. Finally realised I couldn't hack the hangovers any more.


S.Essex, 42m ASL
fairweather
22 December 2021 14:28:19

Well said Doc 👍

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

 Seconded. They have managed to forecast it pretty much as reality dictates. Said there was a possibility of a colder spell, didn't mention snow and said it was uncertain at that stage. No point in people shooting the messenger.


S.Essex, 42m ASL
fairweather
22 December 2021 14:36:22

My only complaint about some of the modelling is that it doesn't seem to be able to attenuate very cold scenarios at early stages of development. I would guess over the last few years the ratio of severe cold spells forecast at 7-10 days out coming to fruition or being colder and longer compared to not happening/becoming milder is about 10:1 against. I can understand the model being inaccurate that far out but would expect it to be inaccurate 50:50 in each direction if the modelling was good? If I was head of the department working on the algorithms for the modelling I would be wanting an investigation into seeing why that was. 


S.Essex, 42m ASL
JOHN NI
22 December 2021 14:53:45
I think in short the global weather system is so chaotic that the small scale perturbations in the behaviour of the polar front jet say over the Pacific Ocean or the United States just cant be modelled in enough detail at days 7 to 10. The small scale changes in strength/direction/shear only become apparent as we get closer to T-0.

While the broadscale patterns can be picked out - (and you would have to say the current broadscale pattern has been picked out a good week ago) the position of the various synoptic features are just a few hundred miles misplaced from where models expected them last weekend. On a 'global' scale pretty darn good. On a UK scale - pretty terrible if you wanted a 'proper' cold spell.

Its not been the first time and it wont be the last.....


John.

The orange County of Armagh.

Hungry Tiger
22 December 2021 15:09:08

From temperature forecasts I've seen seems like any forthcoming cold spell has been well and truly kicked into the long grass.

Just before New Year  temperatures back up into double figures. This in some ways reminds me of some years ago whereby an intense cold spell was well and truly locked in - or at least appeared to be and then 48 hours before the models did a volte face and it was back to the mild gunk.

This now almost reminds me of that.


Gavin S. FRmetS.

TWO Moderator.

Contact the TWO team - [email protected]

South Cambridgeshire. 93 metres or 302.25 feet ASL.



tallyho_83
22 December 2021 15:09:57

The problem is Q, when it flips cold to mild, in my experience, there is rarely, if every a way back.

Not to say it can't happen, but very, very unlikely in the next week or so.

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

l do wonder why the models flipped so much? Why has this turned from what was forecast to be a prolonged cold and blocked spell and a dry Christmas to a cooler spell to a colder snap after Christmas and what now appears to be an exceptionally mild one with temperatures of +13c for Xmas eve in the SW with no cold weather returning into the NEW YEAR? What ever went so wrong!?

WHY was the EC 30 Day, JMA, UKM, ECM, CFS long range etc including the Met Office so wrong in their forecast? What do you put this down to!? 

Why are the models struggling so much? Lack of data?

Why were the models (as always) so accurate with the cold air in Eastern Europe and Scandinavia and there was no flip flopping there?

So many unanswered questions here.  


Home Location - Vixen Tor Close, Okehampton, Devon (221m ASL)

---------------------------------------

Sean Moon

Magical Moon

www.magical-moon.com

Rob K
22 December 2021 15:28:13

 

I remember a week or so ago I posted two inevitable rules of snow watching.

1) The model that doesn't predict cold and snow will be right (in this case the ICON)

2) Things are always further SW than predicted with slider type situations

 

Was wondering what happened when the unstoppable force met the immovable object. Now we know!

 

Originally Posted by: Quantum 

Simple - the slider turns out not to be a slider after all!


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

idot
  • idot
  • Advanced Member
22 December 2021 15:30:53

 

Lack of data?

 

Originally Posted by: tallyho_83 

often a lack of data. Or too much! 


Rob K
22 December 2021 15:31:04

My only complaint about some of the modelling is that it doesn't seem to be able to attenuate very cold scenarios at early stages of development. I would guess over the last few years the ratio of severe cold spells forecast at 7-10 days out coming to fruition or being colder and longer compared to not happening/becoming milder is about 10:1 against. I can understand the model being inaccurate that far out but would expect it to be inaccurate 50:50 in each direction if the modelling was good? If I was head of the department working on the algorithms for the modelling I would be wanting an investigation into seeing why that was. 

Originally Posted by: fairweather 

But the models aren't predicting "cold spells", they are just predicting the movement of the air. I seriously doubt the person in charge of modelling will be asking why the position of a couple of fronts was out by a few hundred miles in an insignificant part of the northern hemisphere. We only notice because it makes a difference to our weather.


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

nsrobins
22 December 2021 15:42:05
The remarkable thing about this whole business is the rapid collapse of heights to our NW. The EC anomaly charts (wk1, wk2 etc) have for a week or so been predicting strong positive anomalies over Greenland and negative ones just to our south. Instead we’re looking at the opposite. I wonder what happened to cause such a reversal?

PS: ICON, the master model, sticks with the balmy SW flow going towards New Year.


Neil

Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)

Stormchaser, Member TORRO

nsrobins
22 December 2021 15:44:38

 

But the models aren't predicting "cold spells", they are just predicting the movement of the air. I seriously doubt the person in charge of modelling will be asking why the position of a couple of fronts was out by a few hundred miles in an insignificant part of the northern hemisphere. We only notice because it makes a difference to our weather.

Originally Posted by: Rob K 

Its not just a few fronts though Rob as I’ve said above. It’s macroscale positions and strengths of surface and upper highs and lows. Most of the NWP has had a very bad week at the office in my opinion.


Neil

Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)

Stormchaser, Member TORRO

Lionel Hutz
22 December 2021 15:52:02

The remarkable thing about this whole business is the rapid collapse of heights to our NW. The EC anomaly charts (wk1, wk2 etc) have for a week or so been predicting strong positive anomalies over Greenland and negative ones just to our south. Instead we’re looking at the opposite. I wonder what happened to cause such a reversal?
PS: ICON, the master model, sticks with the balmy SW flow going towards New Year.

Originally Posted by: nsrobins 

To my eyes, that seems to be what went wrong here. High Pressure to the South is often the problem but that doesn't seem to be a difficulty currently. It's simply that pressure didn't rise to the North, in particular over Greenland/Iceland region. Is this harder to predict than pressure changes elsewhere?


Lionel Hutz

Nr.Waterford , S E Ireland

68m ASL



Quantum
22 December 2021 16:03:14

Its further south on the 12Z GFS.

 


25/26 (850hpa temp) 11 days snow/sleet falling

18/11 (-4) 19/11 (-6) 20/11 (-6) 01/01 (-7) 04/01 (-10) 10/01 (-7) 11/01 (-3) 30/01 (-1) 13/02 (-6) 15/02 (-4) 18/02 (-6)

24/25 10d

18/11 (-6) 19/11 (-6) 23/11 (-2) 22/12 (-5) 04/01 (-5) 05/01 (0)14/02 (0) 15/02 (0)12/03 (-6) 13/03 (-6)

23/24 8d

29/11 (-6) 30/11 (-6) 02/12 (-5) 03/12 (-5) 04/12 (-3) 16/01 (-3) 18/01 (-8)08/02 (-5)

22/23 7d

18/12 (-1)06/03 (-6) 08/03 (-8) 09/03 (-6) 10/03 (-8) 11/03 (-5) 14/03 (-6)

21/22 12d

Quantum
22 December 2021 16:05:56

UKMO 12Z looks alot better than the 0Z

Modele UKMO - Carte prévisions


25/26 (850hpa temp) 11 days snow/sleet falling

18/11 (-4) 19/11 (-6) 20/11 (-6) 01/01 (-7) 04/01 (-10) 10/01 (-7) 11/01 (-3) 30/01 (-1) 13/02 (-6) 15/02 (-4) 18/02 (-6)

24/25 10d

18/11 (-6) 19/11 (-6) 23/11 (-2) 22/12 (-5) 04/01 (-5) 05/01 (0)14/02 (0) 15/02 (0)12/03 (-6) 13/03 (-6)

23/24 8d

29/11 (-6) 30/11 (-6) 02/12 (-5) 03/12 (-5) 04/12 (-3) 16/01 (-3) 18/01 (-8)08/02 (-5)

22/23 7d

18/12 (-1)06/03 (-6) 08/03 (-8) 09/03 (-6) 10/03 (-8) 11/03 (-5) 14/03 (-6)

21/22 12d

Russwirral
22 December 2021 16:06:21
yeh already different, with less energy going north, more moving east

This is important as the block fights back

small changes


Russwirral
22 December 2021 16:09:15

Seems the LP is now factoring in some sort of resistance...

 

where as yesterdays run, the atlantic sweeped in with very little effort... with a couple of runs this could swing back

 


Lionel Hutz
22 December 2021 16:09:59

yeh already different, with less energy going north, more moving east

This is important as the block fights back

small changes

Originally Posted by: Russwirral 

Ah Jaysus. Here we go again.


Lionel Hutz

Nr.Waterford , S E Ireland

68m ASL



nsrobins
22 December 2021 16:10:28

Its further south on the 12Z GFS.

 

Originally Posted by: Quantum 

You need to speak up, Q. Most of us are still in the back bar drowning our sorrows 😂😂


Neil

Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)

Stormchaser, Member TORRO

Remove ads from site