The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

Chunky Pea
22 November 2021 17:59:05

 

Probably associated with the recent change of the average synoptics. The loss of Arctic Ice over the last several decades is put down as the reason for the advection of warmer or less cold waters into the Arctic as suggested by this research' -

https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fmars.2020.00491/full%20%C2%A0

 

 

Originally Posted by: polarwind 

There is certainly some merit to this. 

I always keep an eye on the conditions in the N Norwegian Sea /southern Arctic ocean. This region has been very prone to warmer SW'ly' flows in recent years, keeping the SST's in that region warm. During the 'colder' decades of the 70s/80s etc, tropical SW'ly's were not as common n the region (going by reananalysis charts) whereas more potent northerly streams were and more akin to the synoptic set up there now:

It would take a few consistent months of this sort of synotpic to encourage even a slight cooling of the hugely high SST anomaly in that region, which in turn, would help in reducing the potency of Atlantic tropical flows into the Arctic itself. 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

polarwind
22 November 2021 19:23:43

 

There is certainly some merit to this. 

I always keep an eye on the conditions in the N Norwegian Sea /southern Arctic ocean. This region has been very prone to warmer SW'ly' flows in recent years, keeping the SST's in that region warm. During the 'colder' decades of the 70s/80s etc, tropical SW'ly's were not as common n the region (going by reananalysis charts) whereas more potent northerly streams were and more akin to the synoptic set up there now:

It would take a few consistent months of this sort of synotpic to encourage even a slight cooling of the hugely high SST anomaly in that region, which in turn, would help in reducing the potency of Atlantic tropical flows into the Arctic itself. 

Originally Posted by: Chunky Pea 

Any thoughts about what might be driving the changes in the synoptics? - which may of course be short or long term in duration.


"The professional standards of science must impose a framework of discipline and at the same time encourage rebellion against it". – Michael Polyani (1962)

"If climate science is sound and accurate, then it should be able to respond effectively to all the points raised…." - Grandad

"The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves, and wiser people so full of doubts". - Bertrand Russell

"Science is the belief in the ignorance of the experts" – Richard Feynman

"A consensus means that everyone agrees to say collectively what no one believes individually.”- Abba Eban, Israeli diplomat

Dave,Derby

Chunky Pea
22 November 2021 19:32:35

Any thoughts about what might be driving the changes in the synoptics? - which may of course be short or long term in duration.

Originally Posted by: polarwind 

That I would have no idea on. One theory I would put forward is that the pattern over the NE Atlantic (mostly straight west to east) this year allowed a relatively good opportunity for cold to build up undisturbed in that region of the Arctic. Duration probably will only be short term I would say, but all eyes on as they say. 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

polarwind
22 November 2021 21:08:15

 

That I would have no idea on. One theory I would put forward is that the pattern over the NE Atlantic (mostly straight west to east) this year allowed a relatively good opportunity for cold to build up undisturbed in that region of the Arctic. Duration probably will only be short term I would say, but all eyes on as they say. 

Originally Posted by: Chunky Pea 

   I agree and it's also interesting in that the low pressure systems in the NE Atlantic, have had the tendency for two or three years now, to head from west to east or NW to SE. Besides reducing the flow rate of the North Atlantic Drift, this would lead to lower water vapour content over the Arctic Basin especially along the Eurasian coastal areas, both inland  and sea. This in turn, would lead to higher radiative heat losses. Eventually, after a transition period where recently high SST's would slowly reduce over a year or two, Ice area would both expand and its life be prolonged and become more than marginal.

Anyone have a clue as to the recent history of water vapour values in the Arctic?

 

 

 


"The professional standards of science must impose a framework of discipline and at the same time encourage rebellion against it". – Michael Polyani (1962)

"If climate science is sound and accurate, then it should be able to respond effectively to all the points raised…." - Grandad

"The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves, and wiser people so full of doubts". - Bertrand Russell

"Science is the belief in the ignorance of the experts" – Richard Feynman

"A consensus means that everyone agrees to say collectively what no one believes individually.”- Abba Eban, Israeli diplomat

Dave,Derby

four
  • four
  • Advanced Member
22 November 2021 21:24:08
Gandalf The White
22 November 2021 21:30:30

Dozens of ships trapped by ice up to 1.5m thick, weeks earlier than normal
Originally Posted by: four 

">https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2021/11/22/dozens-ships-stuck-arctic-ice-freezes-early-reverse-recent-warming

It’s behind a Paywall but the opening sentence mentions an inaccurate weather forecast as the cause of the problem?


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



Devonian
22 November 2021 21:41:56

Dozens of ships trapped by ice up to 1.5m thick, weeks earlier than normal
Originally Posted by: four 

">https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2021/11/22/dozens-ships-stuck-arctic-ice-freezes-early-reverse-recent-warming

Even teams facing relegation can, it seems, score the odd goal.

polarwind
23 November 2021 09:34:05

Even teams facing relegation can, it seems, score the odd goal.

Originally Posted by: Devonian 

Yes and Derby scored 3.


"The professional standards of science must impose a framework of discipline and at the same time encourage rebellion against it". – Michael Polyani (1962)

"If climate science is sound and accurate, then it should be able to respond effectively to all the points raised…." - Grandad

"The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves, and wiser people so full of doubts". - Bertrand Russell

"Science is the belief in the ignorance of the experts" – Richard Feynman

"A consensus means that everyone agrees to say collectively what no one believes individually.”- Abba Eban, Israeli diplomat

Dave,Derby

Quantum
23 November 2021 09:47:18

Its possible JAXA sea ice extent could jump out of the bottom 15 tommorow. Its been a long time since that has happened.

 


25/26 (850hpa temp) 11 days snow/sleet falling

18/11 (-4) 19/11 (-6) 20/11 (-6) 01/01 (-7) 04/01 (-10) 10/01 (-7) 11/01 (-3) 30/01 (-1) 13/02 (-6) 15/02 (-4) 18/02 (-6)

24/25 10d

18/11 (-6) 19/11 (-6) 23/11 (-2) 22/12 (-5) 04/01 (-5) 05/01 (0)14/02 (0) 15/02 (0)12/03 (-6) 13/03 (-6)

23/24 8d

29/11 (-6) 30/11 (-6) 02/12 (-5) 03/12 (-5) 04/12 (-3) 16/01 (-3) 18/01 (-8)08/02 (-5)

22/23 7d

18/12 (-1)06/03 (-6) 08/03 (-8) 09/03 (-6) 10/03 (-8) 11/03 (-5) 14/03 (-6)

21/22 12d

polarwind
23 November 2021 10:01:14

Its possible JAXA sea ice extent could jump out of the bottom 15 tommorow. Its been a long time since that has happened.

 

Originally Posted by: Quantum 

Have you seen this news -

Ships stuck in Arctic Ice ..... because of early freeze.

I wonder what position JAXA sea ice extent will move to in a months time?


"The professional standards of science must impose a framework of discipline and at the same time encourage rebellion against it". – Michael Polyani (1962)

"If climate science is sound and accurate, then it should be able to respond effectively to all the points raised…." - Grandad

"The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves, and wiser people so full of doubts". - Bertrand Russell

"Science is the belief in the ignorance of the experts" – Richard Feynman

"A consensus means that everyone agrees to say collectively what no one believes individually.”- Abba Eban, Israeli diplomat

Dave,Derby

Quantum
23 November 2021 11:20:16

Have you seen this news -

Ships stuck in Arctic Ice ..... because of early freeze.

I wonder what position JAXA sea ice extent will move to in a months time?

Originally Posted by: polarwind 

I'd be very surprised if it lasts, and fully expect us to return to the bottom 5. Will be delighted if I'm wrong ofc.

I think long term ice loss trends have been less pronounced in Spring/Autumn; by the time we get to January it would be genuinely unexpected if we hold this position.

 


25/26 (850hpa temp) 11 days snow/sleet falling

18/11 (-4) 19/11 (-6) 20/11 (-6) 01/01 (-7) 04/01 (-10) 10/01 (-7) 11/01 (-3) 30/01 (-1) 13/02 (-6) 15/02 (-4) 18/02 (-6)

24/25 10d

18/11 (-6) 19/11 (-6) 23/11 (-2) 22/12 (-5) 04/01 (-5) 05/01 (0)14/02 (0) 15/02 (0)12/03 (-6) 13/03 (-6)

23/24 8d

29/11 (-6) 30/11 (-6) 02/12 (-5) 03/12 (-5) 04/12 (-3) 16/01 (-3) 18/01 (-8)08/02 (-5)

22/23 7d

18/12 (-1)06/03 (-6) 08/03 (-8) 09/03 (-6) 10/03 (-8) 11/03 (-5) 14/03 (-6)

21/22 12d

Gandalf The White
23 November 2021 11:49:31

Have you seen this news -

Ships stuck in Arctic Ice ..... because of early freeze.

I wonder what position JAXA sea ice extent will move to in a months time?

Originally Posted by: polarwind 

Yes, Four posted about it yesterday.  The article starts off by suggesting the weather forecast was wrong and that’s why they got stuck.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



Russwirral
23 November 2021 14:31:01

 

I'd be very surprised if it lasts, and fully expect us to return to the bottom 5. Will be delighted if I'm wrong ofc.

I think long term ice loss trends have been less pronounced in Spring/Autumn; by the time we get to January it would be genuinely unexpected if we hold this position.

 

Originally Posted by: Quantum 

http://www.climate4you.com/SnowCover.htm 

yeh there does seem to be a ceiling to ice extent.  although saying that we went from a position to be way ahead of the curve, to a massive catchup the other week, to looking like accelerating away again and advancing the ice coverage.

 

So it seems maybe there is a ceiling to get to, and maybe this year is just one route to that final picture.  Of course -with you - would love to be wrong and we see excessive ice this year.  


Russwirral
23 November 2021 14:33:43
Would also be interesting if this could somehow be linked to suppression of human movements and CO2 emissions during the last 18-22 months.

Just imagine there was such an impact that could be linked. Facinating.


Chunky Pea
23 November 2021 19:17:51

Would also be interesting if this could somehow be linked to suppression of human movements and CO2 emissions during the last 18-22 months.

Just imagine there was such an impact that could be linked. Facinating.

Originally Posted by: Russwirral 

Interesting theory. Also, the 'PDO' seems to be going into a cooler (or is that a 'negative') phase at the moment, which seems to be keeping Alaskan region very cold compared to the rest of the North American Continent. 10 day forecast for example:


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

polarwind
24 November 2021 20:43:03

Interesting reports from here about the trapped ships and recent ice build up.

the barents observer

Can't see much evidence to support wrong weather forecasts, other than the longer range forecasts being wrong, no doubt based on the very high temperature anomoly (2-4deg.C) experienced along the Russian coast in October and which would have been a big factor. The high speed of the icing seems relevant here.

 

 

 


"The professional standards of science must impose a framework of discipline and at the same time encourage rebellion against it". – Michael Polyani (1962)

"If climate science is sound and accurate, then it should be able to respond effectively to all the points raised…." - Grandad

"The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves, and wiser people so full of doubts". - Bertrand Russell

"Science is the belief in the ignorance of the experts" – Richard Feynman

"A consensus means that everyone agrees to say collectively what no one believes individually.”- Abba Eban, Israeli diplomat

Dave,Derby

White Meadows
25 November 2021 18:34:51

Interesting reports from here about the trapped ships and recent ice build up.

the barents observer

Can't see much evidence to support wrong weather forecasts, other than the longer range forecasts being wrong, no doubt based on the very high temperature anomoly (2-4deg.C) experienced along the Russian coast in October and which would have been a big factor. The high speed of the icing seems relevant here.

 

 

 

Originally Posted by: polarwind 

The ‘bad forecast’ theory seems rather daft. Dozens of ships from different regions all simultaneously going by exactly the same forecast. Unlikely. 

polarwind
25 November 2021 22:47:13

The ‘bad forecast’ theory seems rather daft. Dozens of ships from different regions all simultaneously going by exactly the same forecast. Unlikely. 

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

I agree.

There are many ships and as I understand it, not all stuck in the same place. 


"The professional standards of science must impose a framework of discipline and at the same time encourage rebellion against it". – Michael Polyani (1962)

"If climate science is sound and accurate, then it should be able to respond effectively to all the points raised…." - Grandad

"The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves, and wiser people so full of doubts". - Bertrand Russell

"Science is the belief in the ignorance of the experts" – Richard Feynman

"A consensus means that everyone agrees to say collectively what no one believes individually.”- Abba Eban, Israeli diplomat

Dave,Derby

Gandalf The White
25 November 2021 23:29:01

The ‘bad forecast’ theory seems rather daft. Dozens of ships from different regions all simultaneously going by exactly the same forecast. Unlikely. 

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 



The end of that article includes a telling comment which reveals the reality of which way the Arctic ice is heading:

“The complicated conditions with sea-ice is alarming for Russian authorities that are promoting the Northern Sea Route as a future alternative to the Suez Canal. Already by the winter of 2023-2024 there is to be year-round commercial shipping on the route and goods volumes are planned to rocket to 150 million tons already by year 2030.”

So, just three years from now they’re expecting to be able to navigate the Arctic route 365 days per year.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



doctormog
26 November 2021 06:56:42
Indeed. The new Líder nuclear-powered icebreaker that can travel at over 10 knots through 2 metre thick ice will certainly facilitate that.
polarwind
26 November 2021 09:12:29



The end of that article includes a telling comment which reveals the reality of which way the Arctic ice is heading:

“The complicated conditions with sea-ice is alarming for Russian authorities that are promoting the Northern Sea Route as a future alternative to the Suez Canal. Already by the winter of 2023-2024 there is to be year-round commercial shipping on the route and goods volumes are planned to rocket to 150 million tons already by year 2030.”

So, just three years from now they’re expecting to be able to navigate the Arctic route 365 days per year.

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

Yes, the reality you mention is based on what might reasonably be expected or forecast from the Arctic warming trend which has led to much reduced ice cover there.

However, the speed of increased Arctic ice cover the last few weeks is totally unexpected and goes against the scientists' forecast trend in a big way. The ongoing record breaking snowfalls and/or low temperatures in Siberia, China and Japan should not be ignored either.

In the early late seventies?, climatologists noticed the changes to Arctic synoptics and told those listening, that 'somethings up'.

The same might be said about the rapid increased ice cover and record snow and low temperatures.

Lets see what happens.


"The professional standards of science must impose a framework of discipline and at the same time encourage rebellion against it". – Michael Polyani (1962)

"If climate science is sound and accurate, then it should be able to respond effectively to all the points raised…." - Grandad

"The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves, and wiser people so full of doubts". - Bertrand Russell

"Science is the belief in the ignorance of the experts" – Richard Feynman

"A consensus means that everyone agrees to say collectively what no one believes individually.”- Abba Eban, Israeli diplomat

Dave,Derby

Surrey John
29 November 2021 15:58:50
Latest Baltic Sea temperatures

Some ice now formed near coasts

https://www.smhi.se/oceanografi/istjanst/produkter/sstcolor.pdf 


Bradford on Avon, Wiltshire

35m ASL

Quantum
30 November 2021 10:23:48

Almost no hudson bay ice gives scope for some truly massive gains over the next few days and weeks. I think its likely we will drop out of the bottom 15 JAXA.

 


25/26 (850hpa temp) 11 days snow/sleet falling

18/11 (-4) 19/11 (-6) 20/11 (-6) 01/01 (-7) 04/01 (-10) 10/01 (-7) 11/01 (-3) 30/01 (-1) 13/02 (-6) 15/02 (-4) 18/02 (-6)

24/25 10d

18/11 (-6) 19/11 (-6) 23/11 (-2) 22/12 (-5) 04/01 (-5) 05/01 (0)14/02 (0) 15/02 (0)12/03 (-6) 13/03 (-6)

23/24 8d

29/11 (-6) 30/11 (-6) 02/12 (-5) 03/12 (-5) 04/12 (-3) 16/01 (-3) 18/01 (-8)08/02 (-5)

22/23 7d

18/12 (-1)06/03 (-6) 08/03 (-8) 09/03 (-6) 10/03 (-8) 11/03 (-5) 14/03 (-6)

21/22 12d

polarwind
30 November 2021 12:48:23

Almost no hudson bay ice gives scope for some truly massive gains over the next few days and weeks. I think its likely we will drop out of the bottom 15 JAXA.

 

Originally Posted by: Quantum 

Yes Q -I wonder what this chart might look like in a few days time?

see - http://nsidc.org/data/seaice_index/images/daily_images/N_stddev_timeseries.png 


"The professional standards of science must impose a framework of discipline and at the same time encourage rebellion against it". – Michael Polyani (1962)

"If climate science is sound and accurate, then it should be able to respond effectively to all the points raised…." - Grandad

"The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves, and wiser people so full of doubts". - Bertrand Russell

"Science is the belief in the ignorance of the experts" – Richard Feynman

"A consensus means that everyone agrees to say collectively what no one believes individually.”- Abba Eban, Israeli diplomat

Dave,Derby

Russwirral
30 November 2021 13:09:33

Almost no hudson bay ice gives scope for some truly massive gains over the next few days and weeks. I think its likely we will drop out of the bottom 15 JAXA.

 

Originally Posted by: Quantum 

 

The Core arctic circle is now pretty much ice.  Will be some interesting research papers behind this in a few years.

 


Remove ads from site