The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

Global Warming
31 October 2021 19:42:34

This thread is for all comments, discussion, and analysis of temperatures in the UK during November, with particular emphasis on the Central England Temperature (CET), for the simple reason that it is the longest-running temperature series in the world with over 360 years of data. But you can comment on any interesting temperature statistics or data from across the UK, including your own backyard.  

For those taking part in the competition, all CET predictions for November should be sent directly to me via the forum private message system. Please do not post them directly into the thread.     

Historic CET summary for November

1981-2010 (30 years) 7.14C

1991-2020 (30 years) 7.41C 

2001-2020 (last 20 years) 7.52C  

Last November was warm at 8.5C as was 2018. 2019 was cooler with 6.2C. 

Here is a chart of the November CET for all years since 1961    

UserPostedImage

Direct link to a larger version of the chart

Current model output     

GEFS - 850's look very close to average throughout, albeit with a lot of scatte. T2m temperatures are warmer in week 2 before turning cooler in the second half of the month. 

https://www.wetterzentrale.de/de/show_diagrams.php?geoid=49069&model=gfs&var=2&run=99&lid=ENS&bw= 

https://www.wetterzentrale.de/de/show_diagrams.php?geoid=49069&model=gfs&var=5&run=99&lid=ENS&bw=

ECM (de Bilt) shows surface temperatures fairly steady across the first half of the month.

http://www.knmi.nl/exp/pluim/Data/PLUIM_06260_NWT.png 

Met Office contingency planners outlook  

https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/binaries/content/assets/metofficegovuk/pdf/business/public-sector/civil-contingency/3moutlook-ndj-v1secure.pdf

Very clear signal for above average probability of mild conditions in November with a very low chance of a cold month.

Surrey John
31 October 2021 21:06:43
Thanks for new monthly competition

I will PM my prediction before midnight


Bradford on Avon, Wiltshire

35m ASL

Saint Snow
01 November 2021 10:21:38

Wah!! 

Could go either side of average and the MO over the past few days has bounced around a bit (in terms of the weather for the UK)


Martin

Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)

A TWO addict since 14/12/01

"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."

Aneurin Bevan

springsunshine
02 November 2021 08:34:11

Given how late this thread was started i hope there will be no penalties for entries posted in in the first 2 or 3 days of November.

lanky
02 November 2021 08:46:41

Given how late this thread was started i hope there will be no penalties for entries posted in in the first 2 or 3 days of November.

Originally Posted by: springsunshine 

I posted mine (by email as requested) on 30th October before the thread was opened

Waiting till 3rd of the month gives a definite unfair advantage to those late posters IMO


Martin

Richmond, Surrey

ARTzeman
02 November 2021 11:28:55

Met Office Hadley         9.8c      Anomaly       0.7c provisional to 1st

Metcheck                      7.23c    Anomaly       0.30c

Netweather                   8.85c    Anomaly       1.96c

Peasedown St John     7.56c     Anomaly     0.15c.       




Some people walk in the rain.

Others just get wet.

I Just Blow my horn or trumpet

Stormchaser
02 November 2021 11:57:19

The lack of a stonewall end-of-preceding-month deadline is causing a bit of a problem IMO, given how much model output sometimes changes its tune in the space of a day or two. We saw it big-time in Sep, then to a lesser extent in Oct. I know that my estimate would have been a little higher had I submitted it on 2nd Oct (probably only by a few tenths at most, mind - so still not very close to the actual).

Trouble is, we can't say with any confidence that what applies to one person is also the case for the majority.

For this month, my estimate would be a little lower now than the one I sent on 31st, but is this true for most people?


If you have any problems or queries relating to TWO you can Email [email protected]

https://twitter.com/peacockreports 

2025's Homeland Extremes:

T-Max: 32.0°C 12th Aug | T-Min: -5.4°C 4th Jan | Wettest Day: 31.8 mm 18th Dec | Ice Days: None

Keep Calm and Forecast On

Saint Snow
02 November 2021 12:11:58

The lack of a stonewall end-of-preceding-month deadline is causing a bit of a problem IMO, given how much model output sometimes changes its tune in the space of a day or two. We saw it big-time in Sep, then to a lesser extent in Oct. I know that my estimate would have been a little higher had I submitted it on 2nd Oct (probably only by a few tenths at most, mind - so still not very close to the actual).

Trouble is, we can't say with any confidence that what applies to one person is also the case for the majority.

For this month, my estimate would be a little lower now than the one I sent on 31st, but is this true for most people?

Originally Posted by: Stormchaser 

 

 

Yeah, I'd go lower if I were sending my guess today.

I think GW needs to reintroduce the deadline for entries (and appropriate penalties for late PMs)

 


Martin

Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)

A TWO addict since 14/12/01

"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."

Aneurin Bevan

ARTzeman
03 November 2021 11:23:45

Met Office Hadley        8.8c.       Anomaly       -0.2c provisional to 2nd 

Metcheck                     6.54c      Anomaly       -0.38c

Netweather                  7.8c        Anomaly      0.59c  

Peasedown St John    7.45c      Anomaly      0.05c. 




Some people walk in the rain.

Others just get wet.

I Just Blow my horn or trumpet

Hippydave
03 November 2021 16:49:24

 

 

 

Yeah, I'd go lower if I were sending my guess today.

I think GW needs to reintroduce the deadline for entries (and appropriate penalties for late PMs)

 

Originally Posted by: Saint Snow 

My gut feel and looking at the mid range output is that this month is going to be milder than average again. Not seen anything that's changed my mind on that either from when I chucked my guess in a few days ago. Chilly start, a couple of very mild CET returns to mitigate that and then back to a bit above average for the middle of the month with milder nights keeping the CET up.

Of course despite all that I went chilly No reason other than I assumed a fair few people would take the mid range output and the fact it seems very easy to get some notably mild weather these days, add in the last 2 months warmth and go strongly above average. On that basis if there's a bit of a flip in the mid range (or the minority colder options come off) and/or a colder last third I'll climb the table somewhat. 

Be interesting to see what the guesses were to see if my hunch about other peoples' guesses was correct or if that is as iffy as my CET guess

 


Home: Tunbridge Wells

Work: Tonbridge

Whether Idle
03 November 2021 18:51:52

GW decides the rules, we accept his decisions.  Its his competition we participate in.


Dover, 5m asl. Half a mile from the south coast.
ARTzeman
04 November 2021 11:17:32

Met Office Hadley        8.2c       Anomaly       -0.5c provisional to 3rd

Metcheck                     6.67c     Anomaly       -0.25c

Netweather                  7.12c     Anomaly        0.23c

Peasedown St John     7.3c      Anomaly       -0.1c.   




Some people walk in the rain.

Others just get wet.

I Just Blow my horn or trumpet

ARTzeman
05 November 2021 11:32:40

Met Office Hadley       7.8c      Anomaly      -0.6c provisional to 4th

Metcheck                    6.08c    Anomaly      -0.84c

Netweather                 6.89c    Anomaly      -0.02c

Peasedown St John    6.9c     Anomaly      -0.5c.




Some people walk in the rain.

Others just get wet.

I Just Blow my horn or trumpet

Col
  • Col
  • Advanced Member
05 November 2021 15:30:21

GW decides the rules, we accept his decisions.  Its his competition we participate in.

Originally Posted by: Whether Idle 

Personally I would make the deadline midnight at the very end of the month unless otherwise specifically stated. Impose the penalties for anyone who misses that whatever the circumstances. That may seem draconian but it keeps it simple. This is what in fact I had previously imagined was already happening until I realised that the penalties for late entrants weren't always being applied, and tended to be when a model flip in the first couple of days of the month could be seen as giving those late entrants a distinct advantagre.


Col

Bolton, Lancashire

160m asl

Snow videos:

http://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3QvmL4UWBmHFMKWiwYm_gg

Stormchaser
05 November 2021 15:53:44

I concur with Col's suggestion regarding deadlines. I think it's fair enough to make suggestions - it's then up to GW whether to implement them or not.

"I assumed a fair few people would take the mid range output and the fact it seems very easy to get some notably mild weather these days..."

Originally Posted by: Hippydave 

Interesting to read this, as trying to second-guess the spread of predictions has caught me out a few times this year. In both Jan & Feb, I assumed that cold short to mid-term model output would skew predictions considerably toward the cold side. In Jan, this proved only half true, while in Feb, I was staggered by the number of average to mild predictions, given the very cold 2nd week being consistently modelled plus the SSW impacts raising likelihood of persistence through the week after.

It's one of the quirks of this competition now that all predictions are kept hidden until after the deadline (and understandably so). It can result in you having put much more on the line than you thought, so to speak, if you consider the relative error, compared to others in the competition. For me, in Feb, it was gargantuan.

I wonder how many of us have sometimes (or even often) arrived at / conjured up a bold prediction, then dialed it down a bit, assuming that the spread of predictions will be focused around a certain range?

My estimates are often suppressed in this way, especially later in the year when there's more to lose, unless I'm way down in the table of course! For this month, I've gone closer to average than I would have, assuming that a lack of clear signals will result in a wide spread of predictions focused at slightly above average (in light of climate warming).

I await the predictions table with some trepidation .


If you have any problems or queries relating to TWO you can Email [email protected]

https://twitter.com/peacockreports 

2025's Homeland Extremes:

T-Max: 32.0°C 12th Aug | T-Min: -5.4°C 4th Jan | Wettest Day: 31.8 mm 18th Dec | Ice Days: None

Keep Calm and Forecast On

Saint Snow
05 November 2021 16:40:16

 

Personally I would make the deadline midnight at the very end of the month unless otherwise specifically stated. Impose the penalties for anyone who misses that whatever the circumstances. That may seem draconian but it keeps it simple. This is what in fact I had previously imagined was already happening until I realised that the penalties for late entrants weren't always being applied, and tended to be when a model flip in the first couple of days of the month could be seen as giving those late entrants a distinct advantagre.

Originally Posted by: Col 

 

 

Agreed - but we need to know in advance that that's the rule, and have the thread going a couple of days beforehand.

GW has been brilliant running this, but I know these days he's often snowed under with trivial stuff like work and family life (). If he's happy to carry on, then fantastic, but if he's struggling, then he shouldn't be afraid to say so.


Martin

Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)

A TWO addict since 14/12/01

"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."

Aneurin Bevan

Saint Snow
05 November 2021 16:41:57

I wonder how many of us have sometimes (or even often) arrived at / conjured up a bold prediction, then dialed it down a bit, assuming that the spread of predictions will be focused around a certain range?

Originally Posted by: Stormchaser 

 

Me.

Did it last month (was originally going in at 11.92) and lost out, but there's been a couple of months I've benefited.

 

 


Martin

Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)

A TWO addict since 14/12/01

"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."

Aneurin Bevan

ARTzeman
06 November 2021 11:23:45

Met Office Hadley       7.6c      Anomaly      -0.6c provisional to 5th

Metcheck                    6.3c      Anomaly      -0.29c

Netweather                 6.75c    Anomaly      -0.16c

Peasedown St John    7.1c      Anomaly      -0.3c.  




Some people walk in the rain.

Others just get wet.

I Just Blow my horn or trumpet

ARTzeman
07 November 2021 11:16:36

Met Office Hadley       7.8c        Anomaly       -0.2c

Metcheck                   7.26c       Anomaly       0.34c

Netweather                7.47c       Anomaly       0.58c

Peasedown St John    6.9c       Anomaly       -0.1c.  




Some people walk in the rain.

Others just get wet.

I Just Blow my horn or trumpet

Global Warming
07 November 2021 20:58:28

Here is the November CET tracker. After a cold start it turns much milder for the middle part of the month. Maybe turning a bit cooler as we finish week three but no sign of anything especially cold at this stage.

UserPostedImage

Chart 1

UserPostedImage

Chart 2

Global Warming
07 November 2021 21:13:20

Here are the predictions for November

UserPostedImage

Table 1

Global Warming
07 November 2021 21:18:37

Further to the comments in this thread, we can certainly go back to applying the long standing rule for this competition that all predictions must be in by 23:59 of the last day of the previous month in order to avoid a penalty. Predictions will be accepted until the 2nd of the month with a 0.2C penalty for submitting on the first and a 0.4C penalty for submitting on the second. We can start applying that more strictly again from the December predictions onwards. 

I still have people commenting on the thread being opened only just before the end of the month. Since we don't post predictions in the thread any more and haven't done for some time, it is completely irrelevant when the thread is opened. Predictions can be sent in by PM at any time. I will open the thread when I have time, which may often not be until late on the final day of the month.

GezM
  • GezM
  • Advanced Member
08 November 2021 09:34:07

Here are the predictions for November

UserPostedImage

Table 1

Originally Posted by: Global Warming 

I'm surprised to see myself so far down the list of predictions. Given a fair number of forecasts for a cool, settled month, I thought I was being quite 'brave' going for 7.65C! 2nd half of November still appears to be quite uncertain with the GFS Ops runs showing a few cold blasts while the ENS is looking milder. 


Living in St Albans, Herts (116m asl)

Working at Luton Airport, Beds (160m asl)

Frank H
08 November 2021 10:20:14

Here are the predictions for November

UserPostedImage

Table 1

Originally Posted by: Global Warming 

Oh.....

Tried to be different to what I thought the 2 leaders would predict.

Looks like i've overdone it.

Or have I ??


Wrightington, Wigan
Saint Snow
08 November 2021 10:31:28

I still have people commenting on the thread being opened only just before the end of the month. Since we don't post predictions in the thread any more and haven't done for some time, it is completely irrelevant when the thread is opened. Predictions can be sent in by PM at any time. I will open the thread when I have time, which may often not be until late on the final day of the month.

Originally Posted by: Global Warming 

 

  That'd be me, then.

 

I find both the averages (1981-2010/1991-2020/2001-2020) and the graphs invaluable in helping guide my estimate. 

If you're not going to be posting them in advance, can you advise where you get this info from so I can check it myself (and do they do the graph?!?!) 

 

 


Martin

Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)

A TWO addict since 14/12/01

"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."

Aneurin Bevan

Remove ads from site