The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

ballamar
18 October 2021 02:18:35

Looking like there is going to be a further build up of Scandinavian snow cover over the next couple of weeks, which in theory should increase the chances of a cold Winter in the UK.

Originally Posted by: Taylor1740 

To be honest the snow cover is late and every year there is a build up of snow cover. Not a good theory many more factors

Whether Idle
18 October 2021 04:28:15
I see 🙄 the season of rumours and straw clutching is now upon us…
Dover, 5m asl. Half a mile from the south coast.
Taylor1740
18 October 2021 06:33:47

 

To be honest the snow cover is late and every year there is a build up of snow cover. Not a good theory many more factors

Originally Posted by: ballamar 

It isn't late, like I said if you did your research into these things you would see that it is actually a little ahead of schedule so far. But yes it's just one of many factors but 2009 and 2010 also had an early build up of Scandinavian snow cover.


NW Leeds - 150m amsl
Taylor1740
18 October 2021 06:48:50

I see 🙄 the season of rumours and straw clutching is now upon us…

Originally Posted by: Whether Idle 

No it isn't though, a few people just commenting on the model output and factors that could affect the Winter, hardly pulling up rumours and straw clutching.


NW Leeds - 150m amsl
Gandalf The White
18 October 2021 07:09:36

 

It isn't late, like I said if you did your research into these things you would see that it is actually a little ahead of schedule so far. But yes it's just one of many factors but 2009 and 2010 also had an early build up of Scandinavian snow cover.

Originally Posted by: Taylor1740 

There really isn’t any clear linkage between the arrival of Scandinavian snow cover and our winter weather. It’s at best one tiny part of a complex jigsaw puzzle, and more likely a red herring.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
18 October 2021 07:13:28

Briefly, under pressure this morning:

Summary charts show seasonal temps for Europe except colder than average in Scandi. Uk on the edge of milder Atlantic, colder stuff moving into Russia but nothing exceptional. Rain plentiful in NW Europe week 1 (snow for Norway?) retreating slowly back NW to Atlantic week 2

GFS - current large LP on Atlantic giving mild S-lies, then slowly moving E to cover UK Wed 20th/ Thu 21st and winds switching N-ly. Then LPs mostly running N of UK and zonal flow; a promising ridge of HP Sat 30th/Sun 31st before an LP dips S-wards 970mb N Sea Wed 3rd

GEFS - current mild wet spell (high totals in S) ends with cool and dry Fri 22nd/Sat 23rd - rain begins again a couple of days later, mean temps near norm with a suggestion of mild spell Vri 29th and cooler after

ECM - similar to GFS but somewhat less zonal around Thu 28th, more of a NW-ly than a W-ly


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

Taylor1740
18 October 2021 08:57:58

 

There really isn’t any clear linkage between the arrival of Scandinavian snow cover and our winter weather. It’s at best one tiny part of a complex jigsaw puzzle, and more likely a red herring.

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

That is likely correct, but it is one of the natural variables that people that do long range winter forecasts will look at along with ENSO, SSTs, QBO and solar activity. 

TBH I'm quite skeptical on the merits of any seasonal forecasts, but was just pointing out that if you did believe Scandinavian snow cover in October increased the chances of a cold winter in the UK, then the next few weeks look quite good for that.


NW Leeds - 150m amsl
DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
19 October 2021 07:09:00

Wx summary showing seasonal temps across most of Europe i.e. mild Atlantic, colder weather establishing over NE Europe though the small corner of Siberia shown is still V warm. Rain for all UK week 1 spreading on into Germany & Poland, drier in S of UK week 2, 

Jet - loop dipping S around UK to the weekend, a brief lull, resuming close to or over N of UK Tue 26th to Tue 2nd (previous charts have shown it further S) then quiet again for the final 2 days

GFS - current LP crossing Shetland to Scandi, bringing in N-lies briefly Thu 21st, then W-lies with HP coming to dominate the S 1025mb Thu 28th, declining and allowing a secondary spin-off from the LP (which has stayed stuck over Scandi) to approach from the NE to be 990mb Irish Sea Mon 1st soon displaced by larger LP sitting out in the Atlantic with S-lies

GEFS - rain esp in S for a couple of days and a dip in temp Thu soon recovering to norm with a dry spell until Tue 26th after which mean temp near norm but a lot of variation in both temp and whether there will be rain or not in the S (so the HP mentioned above is not nailed on, see ECM below, and indeed wasn't nearly as dominant in yesterday's chart). Fairly frequent rain in the N does however appear in most runs.

ECM - takes a view that pressure will be generally lower, first with broad trough extending S from Iceland Mon 25th, then the W-ly spell is sandwiched between deeper LP further S (over Fair Isle) and HP over France (not UK) and much stronger W-ly winds


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

Brian Gaze
19 October 2021 08:05:24

Look at the number of months above CET compared to below it. 


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

David M Porter
19 October 2021 08:13:21

IIRC throughout the noughties, we had way more months with above average CETs than those with below average CETs as well.

I recall that when I first joined this forum in 2006, I was wondering if we would ever see a sustained spell of severe winter cold again in this country. I didn't have to wait that long to find out the answer to that!


Lenzie, Glasgow

"A body of men holding themselves accountable to nobody ought not to be trusted by anybody." – Thomas Paine

Brian Gaze
19 October 2021 08:17:34

IIRC throughout the noughties, we had way more months with above average CETs than those with below average CETs as well.

I recall that when I first joined this forum in 2006, I was wondering if we would ever see a sustained spell of severe winter cold again in this country. I didn't have to wait that long to find out the answer to that!

Originally Posted by: David M Porter 

Agreed and of course blocked synoptics which bring fine summer weather can easily bring a cold snap in the winter. Nonetheless, IMHO recent climatology should not be ignored when assessing the long range prospects. 


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

springsunshine
19 October 2021 14:59:10

Looking like there is going to be a further build up of Scandinavian snow cover over the next couple of weeks, which in theory should increase the chances of a cold Winter in the UK.

Originally Posted by: Taylor1740 

How on earth does what is on the ground affect atmospheric pressure????

Taylor1740
19 October 2021 15:39:28

 

How on earth does what is on the ground affect atmospheric pressure????

Originally Posted by: springsunshine 

I'm not entirely sure on the exact mechanism it isn't my theory of course. If you check out GavsWeatherVids he covers Siberian/Scandinavian snow cover in his weekly winter forecast updates.

TBH I'm surprised people are completely unaware of it in what is meant to be a weather forum!!!!


NW Leeds - 150m amsl
Ally Pally Snowman
19 October 2021 19:40:14

 After a brief colder interlude,  it looks like another warm up to end October. 

 

 

 

 


Bishop's Stortford 85m ASL.
White Meadows
19 October 2021 21:01:22

 

I'm not entirely sure on the exact mechanism it isn't my theory of course. If you check out GavsWeatherVids he covers Siberian/Scandinavian snow cover in his weekly winter forecast updates.

TBH I'm surprised people are completely unaware of it in what is meant to be a weather forum!!!!

Originally Posted by: Taylor1740 

There is definitely a theory based on snow cover correlating with high pressure. Although my understanding of it is poor, I thought it was more prevalent in deep winter months when large anticyclones are more likely over NE/ Northern Europe, as opposed to more mobile systems typically associated with Autumn. 

From memory it has something to do with sunlight reflected back into space (rather than being absorbed as solar energy into earth).

Bit of a jigsaw puzzle but I’ve read numerous iterations in this very forum over the years.

JOHN NI
19 October 2021 21:46:06

There is definitely a theory based on snow cover correlating with high pressure. Although my understanding of it is poor, I thought it was more prevalent in deep winter months when large anticyclones are more likely over NE/ Northern Europe, as opposed to more mobile systems typically associated with Autumn. 

From memory it has something to do with sunlight reflected back into space (rather than being absorbed as solar energy into earth).

Bit of a jigsaw puzzle but I’ve read numerous iterations in this very forum over the years.

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

Isn't it basic physics? Landmasses which have a snowcover have dense cold air at/near the surface. Dense, cold air is heavy and exerts higher pressure at the surface. The Siberian high is an extreme example of this. 

It is fair to say that in years gone by Scandinavia used to see more extensive snowcover than nowadays - favouring the development of blocking highs across Finland and Sweden and increasing the chance of cold easterlies in the UK. However that’s a rarity nowadays. Even back in the day, there was many a winter when there was plenty of snow in Scandinavia and we didn’t have much cold. In short if the synoptics aren’t right, we wont drag in the cold air, even if its close by. 


John.

The orange County of Armagh.

Sevendust
19 October 2021 22:05:42

Isn't it basic physics? Landmasses which have a snowcover have dense cold air at/near the surface. Dense, cold air is heavy and exerts higher pressure at the surface. The Siberian high is an extreme example of this. 

It is fair to say that in years gone by Scandinavia used to see more extensive snowcover than nowadays - favouring the development of blocking highs across Finland and Sweden and increasing the chance of cold easterlies in the UK. However that’s a rarity nowadays. Even back in the day, there was many a winter when there was plenty of snow in Scandinavia and we didn’t have much cold. In short if the synoptics aren’t right, we wont drag in the cold air, even if its close by. 

Originally Posted by: JOHN NI 

Spot on 

DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
20 October 2021 07:14:58

Wx summary as yesterday in respect of temp: temps across most of Europe i.e. mild Atlantic, colder weather establishing over NE Europe though the small corner of Siberia shown is now cooling in week 2. Rain for all UK and Baltic week 1 moving to UK and France week 2

Jet - too complex to summarise but never far from UK and notably strong Thu 28th/Sat 30th. Perhaps on average a bit further S than yesterday

GFS - current blast from the N soon replaced by a mostly W/Sw flow with controlling Lp somewhere to the NW of Britain (HP not as evident in the S as yesterday) until Mon 1st when shallow trough moves S to cover UK, sticks around and deepens 970mb Hebrides Fri 5th

GEFS - after current heavy rain and following cold snap, dry and recovering to temp norm by Sun 24th. Probably warm around Fri 29th otherwise temps scattered either side of norm, rain never far away after Mon 25th, a few big totals in some runs for Scotland

ECM - like GFS but has swapped positions since yesterday and now favours higher pressure over S of UK to end October


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

Taylor1740
20 October 2021 07:52:29

 

Isn't it basic physics? Landmasses which have a snowcover have dense cold air at/near the surface. Dense, cold air is heavy and exerts higher pressure at the surface. The Siberian high is an extreme example of this. 

It is fair to say that in years gone by Scandinavia used to see more extensive snowcover than nowadays - favouring the development of blocking highs across Finland and Sweden and increasing the chance of cold easterlies in the UK. However that’s a rarity nowadays. Even back in the day, there was many a winter when there was plenty of snow in Scandinavia and we didn’t have much cold. In short if the synoptics aren’t right, we wont drag in the cold air, even if its close by. 

Originally Posted by: JOHN NI 

Yes that's the explanation, thanks!

And this year the Scandinavian snow cover is far more extensive than in recent years, and next few weeks are showing a further build in the northern half of Scandinavia.


NW Leeds - 150m amsl
Brian Gaze
20 October 2021 07:55:51

The next CPF update due very shortly will be interesting as it covers Nov/Dec/Jan. My guess is they'll be forecasting an increased probability of milder than average conditions aggregated through the 3 month period. 


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Saint Snow
20 October 2021 08:44:00

The next CPF update due very shortly will be interesting as it covers Nov/Dec/Jan. My guess is they'll be forecasting an increased probability of milder than average conditions aggregated through the 3 month period. 

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

 

Isn't that generally what LRFs do almost every winter?

I'd love LRFs to be able to nail the general synoptics of any given winter, but they're not exactly reliable.

What I wish there was more of is a post-winter reviewing of global synoptics in the months running up to significant winters for the UK, looking for specific signs and triggers. I imagine there's people at the Met Office (and with some commercial forecasters to a much lesser extent) to try to help themselves improve their LRF'ing, but I don't see this research/reviewing published (or at least not in layman's language) 


Martin

Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)

A TWO addict since 14/12/01

"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."

Aneurin Bevan

TomC
  • TomC
  • Advanced Member
20 October 2021 09:21:11

 

 

Isn't that generally what LRFs do almost every winter?

I'd love LRFs to be able to nail the general synoptics of any given winter, but they're not exactly reliable.

What I wish there was more of is a post-winter reviewing of global synoptics in the months running up to significant winters for the UK, looking for specific signs and triggers. I imagine there's people at the Met Office (and with some commercial forecasters to a much lesser extent) to try to help themselves improve their LRF'ing, but I don't see this research/reviewing published (or at least not in layman's language) 

Originally Posted by: Saint Snow 

I think it has always been true that most winters are mild. This kind of analysis is certainly available in the literature but tends to focus on he role of various forcings eg ENSO, OBO etc rather than individual seasons

Brian Gaze
20 October 2021 12:17:18

 

I think it has always been true that most winters are mild. This kind of analysis is certainly available in the literature but tends to focus on he role of various forcings eg ENSO, OBO etc rather than individual seasons

Originally Posted by: TomC 

Be interesting to know how much weighting is given to those factors vs seasonal models when the CPF is produced.


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

TomC
  • TomC
  • Advanced Member
20 October 2021 12:55:55

 

Be interesting to know how much weighting is given to those factors vs seasonal models when the CPF is produced.

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

 

They are discussed in the acompanying narrative and are a part of the models used. I don't know what role they play quantitatively in the forecast

TomC
  • TomC
  • Advanced Member
20 October 2021 12:59:44

 

Isn't it basic physics? Landmasses which have a snowcover have dense cold air at/near the surface. Dense, cold air is heavy and exerts higher pressure at the surface. The Siberian high is an extreme example of this. 

It is fair to say that in years gone by Scandinavia used to see more extensive snowcover than nowadays - favouring the development of blocking highs across Finland and Sweden and increasing the chance of cold easterlies in the UK. However that’s a rarity nowadays. Even back in the day, there was many a winter when there was plenty of snow in Scandinavia and we didn’t have much cold. In short if the synoptics aren’t right, we wont drag in the cold air, even if its close by. 

Originally Posted by: JOHN NI 

 

Blocking highs generally extend high into the atmosphere disrupting the jet stream hence they are warm highs, cold highs over snow cover are usually very shallow. I think the Scandinavian nountains interacting the Rossby waves are the source of Scandinavian blocking

Remove ads from site