The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

johncs2016
11 February 2021 11:43:50

 

 

That's exactly what happens - at this time of year the minimum is often at or near 0900 and the value is counted twice. Not a perfect solution but historically readings were only done once per day at 0900 GMT and the thermometers reset at that time, so the practice has to continue now so the records are compatible.

The 09-09 max and min temperatures are not recorded on the synop messages.

Rob - by the way check your inbox.

Originally Posted by: Viking3 

As you might well have known from other threads, I have been learning quite a lot recently about decoding raw SYNOP codes (which cover all of the observations for some of  those stations with an 03xxx WMO number (there are other stations such as Edinburgh Airport which issue METAR codes rather than SYNOP codes, but which still have a 03xxx WMO number) and some of the observations for those stations with a 99xxx WMO code).

What I have noticed is that for Edinburgh Gogarbank and the botanic gardens in Edinburgh, the SYNOP code at 6z will record the minimum temperature for the 24 hour period leading up to that and yet, the temperature (especially at this time of the year) will still carry on dropping after that so that by 9z, we will often already have a temperature which is lower than that 6z minimum, and which would be regarded as the actual minimum if we went by the traditional 9z to 9z system which I would like to able to go by (as I was doing with the rainfall data from SEPA until the recent cyber attack there put paid to that for now).

I would therefore imagine that this situation would have happened at quite a number of stations with it ending up being colder as a result, that what has been shown on the official SYNOP reports.


The north of Edinburgh, usually always missing out on snow events which occur not just within the rest of Scotland or the UK, but also within the rest of Edinburgh.

Ally Pally Snowman
11 February 2021 11:48:31

Looks like Braemar did get to -23c. Stunning. 

https://mobile.twitter.com/metoffice

 


Bishop's Stortford 85m ASL.
Rob K
11 February 2021 11:52:03

 

 

That's exactly what happens - at this time of year the minimum is often at or near 0900 and the value is counted twice. Not a perfect solution but historically readings were only done once per day at 0900 GMT and the thermometers reset at that time, so the practice has to continue now so the records are compatible.

The 09-09 max and min temperatures are not recorded on the synop messages.

Rob - by the way check your inbox.

Originally Posted by: Viking3 

 

If this is the case, do low temperatures that occur after 6am get "lost from the system" on the automated stations or is there a system for reporting them? I assume they must get reported somehow as the Met Office official minima are often lower than the 6am synop minima.


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

Dave B
11 February 2021 11:55:00

I work for Vaisala here in the UK and can see information from the 1100 or so roadside weather stations dotted around the UK and Ireland. The lowest temperature I've seen reported by the road weather station network this morning was from Tillyfourie on the A944 in Aberdeenshire where -22.8C was reported at 0630.

johncs2016
11 February 2021 12:18:32

 

 

If this is the case, do low temperatures that occur after 6am get "lost from the system" on the automated stations or is there a system for reporting them? I assume they must get reported somehow as the Met Office official minima are often lower than the 6am synop minima.

Originally Posted by: Rob K 

I'm not an expert in this matter but by looking at a site such as Metemanz which I can get raw synop data from, they have a way of calculating the actual minimum and maximum temperatures which also takes into consideration, what happens after the 6z and 18z SYNOP reports are issued and I have noticed that minimum temperatures which are found to be lower than the one given in the 6z data are often shown in italics in order to indicate that.

I would therefore imagine that the Met Office would have a similar system and for me, it would be great to be able to find out more about that as I report minimum and maximum temperatures quite a lot on this forum, and that would help me me to be able to report that in as accurate a way as possible.

 


The north of Edinburgh, usually always missing out on snow events which occur not just within the rest of Scotland or the UK, but also within the rest of Edinburgh.

Viking3
  • Viking3
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
11 February 2021 13:55:50

 

 

If this is the case, do low temperatures that occur after 6am get "lost from the system" on the automated stations or is there a system for reporting them? I assume they must get reported somehow as the Met Office official minima are often lower than the 6am synop minima.

Originally Posted by: Rob K 

The automated stations send back a whole load more data than is put out in the hourly synops, so the 09-09 data is recorded automatically and relayed back to the Met Office pretty much in real time.

There are lots of other manual climate stations and sometimes the results from these only get sent back at the end of the month or whenever the observer read the instruments.

Records from these stations are available through the Centre for Environmental Analysis (CEDA) - someone posted links for this data before in another thread. The data for the preceding year is generally uploaded by the middle of the following year so 2019 data for all of the stations was made available mid 2020. We'll have to wait a long time (summer 2022!) to see all the data from these other stations this February.

You need to register on this site but it's free, and then you can browse some of the archives. The URL is http://data.ceda.ac.uk/badc/ukmo-midas-open

 


Keith

Aboyne, Aberdeenshire

135m asl

Viking3
  • Viking3
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
11 February 2021 14:06:34

I work for Vaisala here in the UK and can see information from the 1100 or so roadside weather stations dotted around the UK and Ireland. The lowest temperature I've seen reported by the road weather station network this morning was from Tillyfourie on the A944 in Aberdeenshire where -22.8C was reported at 0630.

Originally Posted by: Dave B 

 

Very interesting Dave and thanks for posting that information. That value matches very closely a couple of amateur stations in Alford, a couple of miles west of that sensor , with -22.9 and -23.1 respectively.


Keith

Aboyne, Aberdeenshire

135m asl

richardabdn
11 February 2021 17:17:06

Nothing exceptional here with a low of -8.7C. I recorded lower temperatures in February 2009, February 2010 and December 2010.

Despite there being only a slight breeze yesterday it refused to drop out after sunset, as used to happen, so can't get properly cold nights any more. Extremely irritating and infuriating 


Aberdeen: The only place that misses out on everything

2023 - The Year that's Constantly Worse than a Bad November

2024 - 2023 without the Good Bits

2025 - The Weekend Curse hell intensifies

johncs2016
11 February 2021 18:02:47

Nothing exceptional here with a low of -8.7C. I recorded lower temperatures in February 2009, February 2010 and December 2010.

Despite there being only a slight breeze yesterday it refused to drop out after sunset, as used to happen, so can't get properly cold nights any more. Extremely irritating and infuriating 

Originally Posted by: richardabdn 

That is roughly in line with what was recorded last night at the botanic Gardens in Edinburgh which was the only one of my three local stations where the temperature failed to drop down into minus double figures. In the case of here in Edinburgh, this could well be because the botanic Gardens is the only one of my three local stations which is situated close to or within the city centre which is usually a bit warmer under these conditions due to the urban heating effect. 

Because of that, I am guessing that your temperature readings might have been taken close to or within Aberdeen's city centre which would also be warmer than the outskirts for that very same reason. However, even that is still a lot colder than what we usually get on most winter nights these days and is therefore  something which I wouldn't exactly be complaining about.


The north of Edinburgh, usually always missing out on snow events which occur not just within the rest of Scotland or the UK, but also within the rest of Edinburgh.

Rob K
11 February 2021 18:15:33

Altnaharra had a max of -6.2C today and is already back down to -12.2C at 6pm.


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

doctormog
11 February 2021 18:15:41
I was quite lucky I think as the minimum I recorded last night was -10.1°C which is the coldest I have recorded for many years. I’m keeping my fingers crossed for an ice day but I have a feeling that the snow showers encroaching from the east may scupper that.
Crepuscular Ray
11 February 2021 19:42:10
It was -6 C at 6.30pm in Edinburgh!
Jerry

Edinburgh, in the frost hollow below Blackford Hill

Rob K
11 February 2021 20:14:01

A big difference between Altnaharra and Kinbrace now - Altnaharra has "rocketed" to -7.1C while Kinbrace only a little way to the east is -13.8C. Tain Range close to the east coast is also -13.


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

dagspot
11 February 2021 22:15:33
Edinburgh Airport at -11dc
Neilston 600ft ASL
noodle doodle
12 February 2021 00:14:17
Yeh I don't get how at 10pm Edinburgh airport can be -11 and Gogarbank, only about a mile away, is at -3? There's no mountain ranges in between that I've noticed 🙂
johncs2016
12 February 2021 06:27:20

Yeh I don't get how at 10pm Edinburgh airport can be -11 and Gogarbank, only about a mile away, is at -3? There's no mountain ranges in between that I've noticed :-)

Originally Posted by: noodle doodle 

I have noticed quite a lot during the winter months, especially in sub-zero conditions at night that the temperature at Edinburgh Airport is often a lot lower than what it is at  other nearby stations such as Edinburgh Gogarbank. I am wondering if increased radiation escaping from the tarmac on the airport's runway has anything to do with that in same way in which increased radiation onto the runways down at Heathrow Airport often causes the temperatures to be higher there during the day in the summer months, than at other nearby stations.

One thing to note though is both Edinburgh Airport and Edinburgh Gogarbank are classed as official WMO stations with a WMO index of 03xxx (that is 03160 for Edinburgh Airport and 01366 for Edinburgh Gogarbank). Unlike Edinburgh Gogarbank though, Edinburgh Airport is not classed as an official Met Office station (if you look for it on the Met Office's WOW site, you will be redirected towards Edinburgh Gogarbank as the nearest station to there).

Also, Edinburgh Airport doesn't transmit raw SYNOP data as Edinburgh Gogarbank does and instead, transmits METAR data which is a completely different format (the METAR code for Edinburgh Airport is EGPH). It is the manner in which this METAR data works which results in temperatures there only being reported to the nearest 1°C instead of the nearest 0.1°C and this means that the data for Edinburgh Gogarbank is always likely to be more accurate in the longer term, than the data for Edinburgh Airport which doesn't even include important data items such as rainfall totals.

 


The north of Edinburgh, usually always missing out on snow events which occur not just within the rest of Scotland or the UK, but also within the rest of Edinburgh.

Bolty
12 February 2021 14:31:51
Yesterday morning actually creeped down to just above -7°C here, after I went to bed. That makes it the coldest morning since February 2012:


Scott

Blackrod, Lancashire (4 miles south of Chorley) at 156m asl.

My weather station 

Bertwhistle
12 February 2021 18:37:37

 

I have noticed quite a lot during the winter months, especially in sub-zero conditions at night that the temperature at Edinburgh Airport is often a lot lower than what it is at  other nearby stations such as Edinburgh Gogarbank. I am wondering if increased radiation escaping from the tarmac on the airport's runway has anything to do with that in same way in which increased radiation onto the runways down at Heathrow Airport often causes the temperatures to be higher there during the day in the summer months, than at other nearby stations.

One thing to note though is both Edinburgh Airport and Edinburgh Gogarbank are classed as official WMO stations with a WMO index of 03xxx (that is 03160 for Edinburgh Airport and 01366 for Edinburgh Gogarbank). Unlike Edinburgh Gogarbank though, Edinburgh Airport is not classed as an official Met Office station (if you look for it on the Met Office's WOW site, you will be redirected towards Edinburgh Gogarbank as the nearest station to there).

Also, Edinburgh Airport doesn't transmit raw SYNOP data as Edinburgh Gogarbank does and instead, transmits METAR data which is a completely different format (the METAR code for Edinburgh Airport is EGPH). It is the manner in which this METAR data works which results in temperatures there only being reported to the nearest 1°C instead of the nearest 0.1°C and this means that the data for Edinburgh Gogarbank is always likely to be more accurate in the longer term, than the data for Edinburgh Airport which doesn't even include important data items such as rainfall totals.

 

Originally Posted by: johncs2016 

More efficient radiation should lead to a higher surface temperature- it's when that escaping heat is confined (as in sandy soil locations) that temperatures get lower.


Bertie, Itchen Valley.

Retire while you can still press the 'retire now' button.

Rob K
12 February 2021 18:49:49
I suspect we might beat the low from Wednesday night here, it's already -2. The wind is a bit stronger but the dewpoint is a lot lower. Met forecast is for a low of -4C while the Beeb go for -6C.
Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

Sevendust
12 February 2021 18:52:26

I suspect we might beat the low from Wednesday night here, it's already -2. The wind is a bit stronger but the dewpoint is a lot lower. Met forecast is for a low of -4C while the Beeb go for -6C.

Originally Posted by: Rob K 

Now -3.0'c here. That was the minimum last night. Bitter

marco 79
12 February 2021 21:44:02
Tonight might be the ultimate night for cold...not in the sense for extreme low temps but for more of a severe penetrating frost..here its -4.4c...with a wind gusting to 25mph..some windchill...
Home : Mid Leicestershire ...135m ASL
snow 2004
12 February 2021 22:34:51
Minus 4c with a strong gusty wind at times. Really is biting! Conditions must be brutal on the Snake Pass summit. Apparently it’s -7c up there!
Glossop Derbyshire, 200m asl
Sevendust
12 February 2021 23:20:05

Minus 4c with a strong gusty wind at times. Really is biting! Conditions must be brutal on the Snake Pass summit. Apparently it’s -7c up there!

Originally Posted by: snow 2004 

Yes the wind has been brutal all day - Temp now -4.6'c here

Rob K
13 February 2021 07:28:42

 

Yes the wind has been brutal all day - Temp now -4.6'c here

Originally Posted by: Sevendust 

What was your overnight low? -4.6C which is also the current temp. 


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

Ally Pally Snowman
13 February 2021 07:38:13

Coldest night of the winter here -4.5c

its quite windy as well which is making it very much brass monkeys out there.

 


Bishop's Stortford 85m ASL.

Remove ads from site