The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

Snow Hoper
31 January 2021 14:15:43

 

In times gone by I would use the BBC forecasts as a really useful tool to gain an insight into the likely outcome in the medium range - the 2001 John Kettley saga springs to mind. Or at least, it was a useful gauge to find out what the pros were thinking. 

Now, I see posts saying “but the BBC said this” and I find myself thinking “and?”. 

Originally Posted by: Joe Bloggs 

 

I've been this way with ITV, Sky, Channel 5 et al for sometime.

I find myself more and more arguing with the BBC forecasts nowadays, especially the local ones.


Going to war over religion is like killing each other to see who has the better imaginary friend.

Home : Mid Suffolk.

48m Asl

hobensotwo
31 January 2021 14:19:56

 

Over recent years I’ve started giving the BBC broadcast output a bit of a shrug of the shoulders to be honest.

Originally Posted by: Joe Bloggs 

I agree. I always find their forecasts extremely vague, especially their newish format. They may as well just say in every forecast "sunshine and showers" or "At leat it will be mild" and be done with it. Another one of my favourites "Somethings going on in the Stratosphere"

It's a forecast for the masses, that want a general idea, so I believe they taylor it accordingly to some degree.

Just look at the Daily Telegraph headlines spouting rubbish about PV's and apocalyptic scenarios, nobody ever really picks them up on it. So I can see why the BBC would be the same to a certain extent, just on a more benign level.

That's partly why I got into this hobby. Basically to look under the hood and see what's really going on. Five mins on here, reading posts from knowledgable people, and looking at a few charts, and coming to my own conclusion, in my view is more informative than any BBC forecast.

Snow Hoper
31 January 2021 14:20:59

 

I am incredibly impressed at your optimism for Kent today. You really are flying the coldy flag ! 

I sincerely hope you are correct with this one. We've been here too many times before and we know the outcome.

 

Originally Posted by: Gusty 

Darren's enthusiasm for the whole thing (based on the weight of evidence) is why I remain leaning towards the cold outlook. I'm not happy about the ECM op for the last few runs, with the GFS op also flopping around too, I am concerned,  but will listen to his reasoning and that of others to try and draw a balanced outcome.


Going to war over religion is like killing each other to see who has the better imaginary friend.

Home : Mid Suffolk.

48m Asl

Jiries
31 January 2021 14:24:54

 

Well, if that is the case it is appalling.  Even amateurs like me can see that that is foolhardy at best and misleading at worst.

Originally Posted by: Whether Idle 

Especially on those extremely high maxes in cold spells because 6 or 7C is average so they need to revise to -1 to -3C maxes by the weekends, I never seen them putting subzero temps since they change the awful graphic. The old graphics they used to show many times subzero temps with blue 0C anywhere in the UK.  Just 4 more days for the easterly to come here and should see temps falling to subzero by then.

fairweather
31 January 2021 14:36:52

 

A gradual blending solution starts that keeps any deep cold generally restricted to the north while the south has to contend with a brief flirtation. Southern areas will need to keep an eye on warm air from the south that has the potential to derail the easterly all together. Huge potential for significant snowfall from the Midlands northwards.

Originally Posted by: Gusty 

I feel your comments are largely based on the 06z op run which has been shown to be out of line with the rest of the ensembles in the main.


S.Essex, 42m ASL
hobensotwo
31 January 2021 14:39:49

 

Especially on those extremely high maxes in cold spells because 6 or 7C is average so they need to revise to -1 to -3C maxes by the weekends, I never seen them putting subzero temps since they change the awful graphic. The old graphics they used to show many times subzero temps with blue 0C anywhere in the UK.  Just 4 more days for the easterly to come here and should see temps falling to subzero by then.

Originally Posted by: Jiries 

Apologies I'm going way off topic now, but believe there is a bigger picture at play here involving media. In the same way that the media in the US was accused of using Facebook and the like to steer voting. The same could be at play with weather forecasting, instilling the fact that Global warming is ok, because deep down governments don't want to do anything about it.The very phrase "At least it will be mild" instills the fact that mild is good, when let's be honest, it's winter, and it's not ok. Cold in winter should be celebrated, as it seasonal, instaed the forecasts dumb it down with begin graphics. I'm sure the forecasts never use to be like that.

fairweather
31 January 2021 14:41:47

 

I am incredibly impressed at your optimism for Kent today. You really are flying the coldy flag ! 

I sincerely hope you are correct with this one. We've been here too many times before and we know the outcome.

 

Originally Posted by: Gusty 

Like me, Darren is basing it on the actual evidence as it stands today, not speculation. If it changes for the worse he will be less optimistic 


S.Essex, 42m ASL
fairweather
31 January 2021 14:45:01

It is interesting to note that we have suddenly developed a brisk Easterly this afternoon in the S.E corner. The 850hPa is about -3C according to the charts. The temperature outside at 2 pm was 3.6C. Just saying.


S.Essex, 42m ASL
Shropshire
31 January 2021 14:55:50

 

I’m astonished they’ve gone for pure ECM verbatim when plenty of evidence says otherwise. I can’t believe there’s no moderation in the output forecast by Meteogroup (BBC contract) so that forecast is not good news IMO.

Originally Posted by: nsrobins 

Yes what surprised me was no mention of uncertainty later on, just progressively mild air getting all the way North.


From December 27th 2020, zonality will be banned from mixing with the UK. We appreciate that this may come as a shock to younger people and old Uncle Barty. This ban will last for a minimum of ten days.
Gooner
31 January 2021 14:55:58

 

That forecast went  for a max of 6c next Sunday in London.  Clearly the professionals are siding with the operational forecasts and they are dismissing other information the public have access to.  

We are often told that the broadcasters have access to extra information and I would expect that is where this is coming from.  

The slow motion car - crash continues.

Originally Posted by: Whether Idle 

Just watched the one on the website with SKL and she does say " it does turn colder for all of us at the end of the week and into the weekend" symbols went out to Friday

                        Thurs             Fri

Edinburgh           4c                 5c

Belfast                8c                 7c

Cardiff                 10c               8c

London                10c               9c 


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus

Banbury

North Oxfordshire

378 feet A S L



Retron
31 January 2021 14:56:18

Like me, Darren is basing it on the actual evidence as it stands today, not speculation. If it changes for the worse he will be less optimistic 

Originally Posted by: fairweather 

Yup! It's the case today, or at least right now, the models are overwhelmingly in support of a cold period in a week's time. Should that change my posts will of course change accordingly.

Yes, we all have memories of previous events that went wrong, including the 2012 letdown - but, as I mentioned in the old thread, that was expecting the Siberian High to retrogress despite the steering forces aloft being completely against that. It can happen, but it's a long shot... the models underestimated the effects of the vortex and hence the Atlantic jet and when the correction came, it was swift and final.

On the other hand, what about all the times when things did go as forecast, or even improve (from a cold POV)? 2018 was the most recent one, but 2013, 2010 (which was signalled a month out thanks to Glosea) and even as far back as January 1997 - it doesn't always go tits up, but when it does those are the ones people tend to remember.

It is interesting to note that we have suddenly developed a brisk Easterly this afternoon in the S.E corner. The 850hPa is about -3C according to the charts. The temperature outside at 2 pm was 3.6C. Just saying.

fairweather wrote:

This all reminds me of the 80s, in a way: some failed easterly wafts, perhaps even some slushy transient snow, followed by a decent easterly and proper snow. It would be nice to see that in action once again.


Leysdown, north Kent
Gooner
31 January 2021 14:57:44

 

Darren's enthusiasm for the whole thing (based on the weight of evidence) is why I remain leaning towards the cold outlook. I'm not happy about the ECM op for the last few runs, with the GFS op also flopping around too, I am concerned,  but will listen to his reasoning and that of others to try and draw a balanced outcome.

Originally Posted by: Snow Hoper 

Totally agree and that is based on Mild or Cold 


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus

Banbury

North Oxfordshire

378 feet A S L



Shropshire
31 January 2021 14:58:45

 

Especially on those extremely high maxes in cold spells because 6 or 7C is average so they need to revise to -1 to -3C maxes by the weekends, I never seen them putting subzero temps since they change the awful graphic. The old graphics they used to show many times subzero temps with blue 0C anywhere in the UK.  Just 4 more days for the easterly to come here and should see temps falling to subzero by then.

Originally Posted by: Jiries 

Jiries you've been on here long enough and seen too many failures to state this with any degree of certainty.


From December 27th 2020, zonality will be banned from mixing with the UK. We appreciate that this may come as a shock to younger people and old Uncle Barty. This ban will last for a minimum of ten days.
Ally Pally Snowman
31 January 2021 15:00:30

 

Totally agree and that is based on Mild or Cold 

Originally Posted by: Gooner 

Exactly if Retron is at least optimistic we have a chance. Hopefully the 12s wont let us down.


Bishop's Stortford 85m ASL.
Shropshire
31 January 2021 15:27:56

And they're off for the 12zs, Icon soothes the nerves -

 

https://amz.netweather.tv/monthly_2021_01/icon-0-129.thumb.png.b6448361fac6760836a8e2454e7520a3.png

 


From December 27th 2020, zonality will be banned from mixing with the UK. We appreciate that this may come as a shock to younger people and old Uncle Barty. This ban will last for a minimum of ten days.
Joe Bloggs
31 January 2021 15:29:44

And they're off for the 12zs, Icon soothes the nerves -

 

https://amz.netweather.tv/monthly_2021_01/icon-0-129.thumb.png.b6448361fac6760836a8e2454e7520a3.png

 

Originally Posted by: Shropshire 

Its a shame ICON has backed away from Tuesday’s snow - my patch (and yours) initially looked to do quite well out of that. Looks like rain now with snow further north. 

Retron
31 January 2021 15:30:26

And they're off for the 12zs, Icon soothes the nerves -

Originally Posted by: Shropshire 

It's an interesting evolution - the trigger low crosses the UK, then gets ripped in two; the main part gets ejected eastwards, then stalls near Denmark. In theory that would produce a rash of showers on North Sea coasts exposed to the north.

Not long until the first of the big hitters comes out...


Leysdown, north Kent
squish
31 January 2021 15:30:49
Great 12z ICON for the general evolution and cold uppers streaming in from the NE
D.E.W on Dartmoor. 300m asl
Schnow in Peace
31 January 2021 15:31:36

The ensembles are offering good support for a decent outcome but there is always that nagging doubt if an operational will not play ball. 

The one recent fail I always remember is the mid Feb 2009 one - one rogue run appeared against a very tight grouping and in the space of two runs the cold spell was gone - and from an already established cold pattern. I have seen that ensemble change posted in here several times. IIRC a shard of the vortex ended up blowing up the Atlantic and that was that. 

The Kettley High looked (a bit) like this one synoptically in that a shortwave appeared at just the wrong spot (I think that was due to the orientation of the jet on that occasion, but I cant remember the details) and blocked further retrogression. although much of Scotland - and Aberdeen - got buried!

On the positive side the 144 UKMO which has foretold many such a fail looks fairly good this time - certainly better than the equivalent ECM.

On the telly here I have noticed they very closely follow the ECM operational too - and change accordingly, though I think(?) Met Eireann directly provide the forecasts and is is not outsourced like BBC. 

 

squish
31 January 2021 15:35:08
Mid Feb 2009 I remember well how the whole evolution overcooked itself. It did however result in 35cm of level snow here in very marginal conditions. Hence why I have my eye on the radar now!


D.E.W on Dartmoor. 300m asl
Surrey John
31 January 2021 15:56:27
Just about to do my February CET guess, and starting to wish I hadn’t looked here as trend is clear as mud
Bradford on Avon, Wiltshire

35m ASL

Rob K
31 January 2021 16:00:40

 

They only ever use the ECM Op though in their further ahead forecasts.

 

Originally Posted by: Ally Pally Snowman 

As I posted in the old thread, the BBC auto forecast on the website doesn’t even have an air frost from now until the end of the forecast on Feb 13th. 


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

Lionel Hutz
31 January 2021 16:02:44

 

Exactly if Retron is at least optimistic we have a chance. Hopefully the 12s wont let us down.

Originally Posted by: Ally Pally Snowman 

I always remember when Retron used to do his daily model rundown,  he was never a ramper. I never used to get too hopeful about an upcoming cold spell unless Retron was on board and he often hung back even when others were expecting snowmageddon. So the fact that Retron is on board with this cold spell gives me alot of hope. Obviously, it could still all go mammatus verticus but I think some are predicting without necessarily basing their predictions on evidence. 


Lionel Hutz

Nr.Waterford , S E Ireland

68m ASL



ballamar
31 January 2021 16:10:59
Decent op run so far, stron easterly next weekend
Hungry Tiger
31 January 2021 16:12:04

Forecasting a cold spell is notoriously hard.

 


Gavin S. FRmetS.

TWO Moderator.

Contact the TWO team - [email protected]

South Cambridgeshire. 93 metres or 302.25 feet ASL.



Remove ads from site