The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

Saint Snow
08 January 2021 10:53:40

Probably better with quiet roads for deliveries regardless of weather type. It’s usually Numpties skidding off in their rear wheel drive BMW’s and audis making life hell for everyone else including heavy goods vehicles 

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

 

NB - Audis are front-wheel drive (but do seem to have a high proportion of pillocks for drivers) 


Martin

Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)

A TWO addict since 14/12/01

"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."

Aneurin Bevan

soperman
08 January 2021 10:55:13

Right ! Still not seeing any signs of a tropospheric response given we have now had the SSW and reversal of zonal winds do you think there is still time or is it going to do a February 2019?

Originally Posted by: tallyho_83 

 

Hi Tally

Lost track of this.  When did the SSW occur and was it as significant as predicted?

Thanks

Mark


Happily living by the sea in Brixham......but sad to leave the snowy Chiltern Hills after 35 years!
tallyho_83
08 January 2021 11:06:28

 

 

Hi Tally

Lost track of this.  When did the SSW occur and was it as significant as predicted?

Thanks

Mark

Originally Posted by: soperman 

Between 3rd and 6th January and the reversal of zonal winds was on 6th January:

But shouldn't we be seeing a trop response by now - at least in the models?

https://www.bbc.co.uk/weather/features/55551461

 


Home Location - Vixen Tor Close, Okehampton, Devon (221m ASL)

---------------------------------------

Sean Moon

Magical Moon

www.magical-moon.com

Iceman
08 January 2021 11:08:48

Full details and results from the NH 850 analysis are here

https://www.theweatheroutlook.com/weather-news/5594/air-mass-temperatures-since-1961

 

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

Great piece of research Brian!

I have compared the two 30 year periods for each temperature category with t-tests:

               -10 C or lower.     -9 to -5 C.    -4 to 0 C

1961-90.    667444.               287660.        309076

1991-2020. 625163.               288932.         316544

-10 or lower was a highly significant decline at the 0.1% level

-9 to -5 was a non significant increase.

-4 to 0C was a highly significant increase at the 0.1% level

It is surprising that the middle category was non-significant.

My guess at an explanation would be it is something to do with the reduction in arctic sea ice extent. Now at the beginning and end of the Arctic sea ice season, there are big areas which are ice-free compared to 1961-90 which would reduce cooling of t850s. Redoing the analyses on a monthly basis might show this but that would be a big undertaking.

As to the impact on UK cold spells in winter, yes, this reduction in the -10 C t850 cold pool will lessen to some extent the chances of cold spells. BUT it is clear from historical data that cold UK winters come in groups (1980s, 2008/9 to 2010/11) and this is related to the strength of the westerlies and the increased likelihood of retrogressive synoptics bringing easterlies when westerlies are weaker and the jet stream slows and buckles. This is what brings very cold air to the UK in winter. And happily, we seem to be having an example of this phenomenon currently. 


East Kilbride 480 ft
Brian Gaze
08 January 2021 11:20:03

Wrt the SSW it's worth noting the Copernicus paper the Met Office is quoting seems to suggest there is actually a weak bias for MILDER conditions when a European trough is present at the outset.  

"or Greenland blocking at the SSW onset, a weak preference for cyclonic flow regimes around 20–30 d after the SSW is apparent, with an opposite surface response in the aftermath of the SSW as compared to SSW onsets dominated by EuBL. These events almost exclusively correspond to SSWs that have in the literature been classified as having no tropospheric response."

https://wcd.copernicus.org/articles/1/373/2020/

 


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Hippydave
08 January 2021 11:32:05

Wrt the SSW it's worth noting the Copernicus paper the Met Office is quoting seems to suggest there is actually a weak bias for MILDER conditions when a European trough is present at the outset.  

"or Greenland blocking at the SSW onset, a weak preference for cyclonic flow regimes around 20–30 d after the SSW is apparent, with an opposite surface response in the aftermath of the SSW as compared to SSW onsets dominated by EuBL. These events almost exclusively correspond to SSWs that have in the literature been classified as having no tropospheric response."

https://wcd.copernicus.org/articles/1/373/2020/

 

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

But what's a European trough? East Europe? UK? France? The pattern in place was blocking with an Easterly impacting UK and Northern France etc, said block being based over Northern Europe.

So why does that correlate to a bias towards milder conditions? I queried this yesterday - pointing to one part of continental Europe and saying it had LP therefore the warming will favour milder conditions makes no sense when you can equally point to the fact there was blocking present and say it favours colder conditions.

The bold bit is also presumably more than a little relevant too - it says if you've got an unsettled pattern and a SSW occurs which doesn't impact the troposphere you're more likely to have an unsettled pattern after it. That's a bit like saying in a flat zonal set up most places will see rainfall during the next week, i.e a bit obvious.

This SSW is I believe expected to impact the troposphere, removing it from the subset that showed a mild bias anyway surely?

 

Edit: Sorry if this came across as bit aggressive! Just find this all a bit odd - I'd agree caution is needed regarding SSW = Cold as that's clearly not always true but concluding from that paper the current warming is more likely to lead to mild seems wrong too. Even over Europe the pattern wasn't zonal albeit there was LP over southern Europe.  


Home: Tunbridge Wells

Work: Tonbridge

tallyho_83
08 January 2021 11:32:29

Wrt the SSW it's worth noting the Copernicus paper the Met Office is quoting seems to suggest there is actually a weak bias for MILDER conditions when a European trough is present at the outset.  

"or Greenland blocking at the SSW onset, a weak preference for cyclonic flow regimes around 20–30 d after the SSW is apparent, with an opposite surface response in the aftermath of the SSW as compared to SSW onsets dominated by EuBL. These events almost exclusively correspond to SSWs that have in the literature been classified as having no tropospheric response."

https://wcd.copernicus.org/articles/1/373/2020/

 

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

Lot's of info so i won't understand this well but have already booked marked it? - Weak trough? hmm... ok. So are you suggesting that there will not be a chance of colder weather end of January and February following the SSW? Because looking at the temperature at 10hpa again it appears we could have another SSW.


Home Location - Vixen Tor Close, Okehampton, Devon (221m ASL)

---------------------------------------

Sean Moon

Magical Moon

www.magical-moon.com

tallyho_83
08 January 2021 11:36:26

Another SSW could be on the cards - this of course FI range but has been well modeled for several days now:

Would this be the right sort to give us cold and snow finally? - Let's hope it is and will deliver this time!

 


Home Location - Vixen Tor Close, Okehampton, Devon (221m ASL)

---------------------------------------

Sean Moon

Magical Moon

www.magical-moon.com

ballamar
08 January 2021 11:36:58

Control run shaping up nicely, but p8 is lovely

tallyho_83
08 January 2021 11:37:32
Let's hope the 06Z GFS Operational is a mild outlier - it's dire for mid winter esp following a SSW zonal flow reversal and a negative AO and NAO.
Home Location - Vixen Tor Close, Okehampton, Devon (221m ASL)

---------------------------------------

Sean Moon

Magical Moon

www.magical-moon.com

hobensotwo
08 January 2021 11:41:28

Another SSW could be on the cards - this of course FI range but has been well modeled for several days now:

Would this be the right sort to give us cold and snow finally? - Let's hope it is and will deliver this time!

 

Originally Posted by: tallyho_83 

Interesting, looks like a bigger warming as well. Also look at the date, end of Jan, so with a 4 week response to the trop, puts us at the end of Feb early March. Isn't this when we've seen the biggest winter impacts over recent years.

Gusty
08 January 2021 11:43:53

The GFS 06z sat towards the top of the suite in the mid term.

https://www.wetterzentrale.de/en/show_diagrams.php?model=gfs&lid=ENS&var=2&bw=1&geoid=49909

 


Steve - Folkestone, Kent

Current conditions from my Davis Vantage Vue

https://www.wunderground.com/dashboard/pws/IFOLKE11 

Join Kent Weather on Facebook.

https://www.facebook.com/stevewall69/ 



ballamar
08 January 2021 11:47:13

The GFS 06z sat towards the top of the suite in the mid term.

https://www.wetterzentrale.de/en/show_diagrams.php?model=gfs&lid=ENS&var=2&bw=1&geoid=49909

 

Originally Posted by: Gusty 

P8 is a thing of beauty

White Meadows
08 January 2021 11:49:10

 

Interesting, looks like a bigger warming as well. Also look at the date, end of Jan, so with a 4 week response to the trop, puts us at the end of Feb early March. Isn't this when we've seen the biggest winter impacts over recent years.

Originally Posted by: hobensotwo 

It’s not a second warming- what we’re looking at there is the delayed response to the mean wind reversal:

 

https://apps.ecmwf.int/webapps/opencharts/products/extended-zonal-mean-zonal-wind?area=nh&base_time=202101070000

 

White Meadows
08 January 2021 11:50:10

Nice 06z suite in comparison to what’s been on offer the past week or so.

tallyho_83
08 January 2021 11:55:15

 

Interesting, looks like a bigger warming as well. Also look at the date, end of Jan, so with a 4 week response to the trop, puts us at the end of Feb early March. Isn't this when we've seen the biggest winter impacts over recent years.

Originally Posted by: hobensotwo 

Yes - but the past SSW's we have been having appear to be the wrong type - this one is more associated with milder weather like the one in early January 2019 - which gave us a blowtorch warm February 2019. Let's hope THIS next SSW will deliver proper cold and snowy weather - and a reversal once again as well modelled here:

If it is the case that we won't see a tropospheric response - Another question is why are recent SSW the 'wrong type' - what was it following the SSW of February 2018 and the one of January 2013 which brought us prolonged freezing bitterly cold and snowy weather? anyone?

No description available.


Home Location - Vixen Tor Close, Okehampton, Devon (221m ASL)

---------------------------------------

Sean Moon

Magical Moon

www.magical-moon.com

tallyho_83
08 January 2021 11:57:16

 

It’s not a second warming- what we’re looking at there is the delayed response to the mean wind reversal:

 

https://apps.ecmwf.int/webapps/opencharts/products/extended-zonal-mean-zonal-wind?area=nh&base_time=202101070000

 

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

So do we need to look beyond 14th for a trop response in models?


Home Location - Vixen Tor Close, Okehampton, Devon (221m ASL)

---------------------------------------

Sean Moon

Magical Moon

www.magical-moon.com

Retron
08 January 2021 12:20:06

More importantly your ensemble watch hasn't run at all this winter IIRC? TBH I still think that approach is the best one for looking between 7 and 16 days ahead.  

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

It hasn't, you're right - this current cold spell was noteworthy for having virtually zero -10 850s appearing for London, hence there was no point (as an empty chart isn't very thrilling!)

As for a potential event to come... well, I'll see what the 6z offers on Meteociel* when it's fully out. If there are a few -10s, as there have been for the past day or two, I might ressurrect it.

(* used for consistency reasons, as whatever their "London" gridpoint is will be the same now as it has been over the past several years.)


Leysdown, north Kent
Retron
08 January 2021 12:37:43

Here we go. The template XLS file I had was from 2011 and was labelled part 5, so I'd been doing these for longer than I remembered.

No gaurantees as ever, purely provided for a bit of entertainment. As ever, it plots the number of -10C 850 runs for London from the Meteociel ensembles. -15, should it show up, is shown in a special blue outline.


Leysdown, north Kent
fairweather
08 January 2021 12:50:13

 

 

NB - Audis are front-wheel drive (but do seem to have a high proportion of pillocks for drivers) 

Originally Posted by: Saint Snow 

Oi, I had an Audi A3 hatch previous car. I didn't know at the time about the carism against it. Bought it because it was basically a VW Golf only cheaper and more luxurious. You'll like me more I've got a nice EU Renault now !


S.Essex, 42m ASL
fairweather
08 January 2021 12:57:00

Wrt the SSW it's worth noting the Copernicus paper the Met Office is quoting seems to suggest there is actually a weak bias for MILDER conditions when a European trough is present at the outset.  

"or Greenland blocking at the SSW onset, a weak preference for cyclonic flow regimes around 20–30 d after the SSW is apparent, with an opposite surface response in the aftermath of the SSW as compared to SSW onsets dominated by EuBL. These events almost exclusively correspond to SSWs that have in the literature been classified as having no tropospheric response."

https://wcd.copernicus.org/articles/1/373/2020/

 

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

I found a definition of SSW:-

"A meteorological phenomenon that crops up during mild spells when avid cold lover fans are desperately searching for signs of a forthcoming cold spell"


S.Essex, 42m ASL
Brian Gaze
08 January 2021 12:57:17

Here we go. The template XLS file I had was from 2011 and was labelled part 5, so I'd been doing these for longer than I remembered.

No gaurantees as ever, purely provided for a bit of entertainment. As ever, it plots the number of -10C 850 runs for London from the Meteociel ensembles. -15, should it show up, is shown in a special blue outline.

Originally Posted by: Retron 

 Don't forget the GEFS now has 30 ps rather than 20.


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Hippydave
08 January 2021 13:06:46

Not the most exciting set of 6z ens for down here, but not the worst I guess. 

Deep FI favours plonking HP to our South, which would more than likely mean mild down here although the 850s aren't generally that high despite this, probably because of weak HP to our North allowing colder air to get drawn in to the flow.

More runs needed and all that but I'm not feeling wildly optimistic about the prospects for cold at the moment - maybe the best we can hope for is the SSW leads to at least a temporary death of the Atlantic and we get another spell of cold but sort of settled weather like we've just had (appreciating for some spots inc MBY there's been a reasonable amount of rain about!).

(Might just be the fact it's clouded over today and it's consequently cold and grey, which doesn't fill me with enthusiasm)


Home: Tunbridge Wells

Work: Tonbridge

Brian Gaze
08 January 2021 13:14:47

 

Great piece of research Brian!

I have compared the two 30 year periods for each temperature category with t-tests:

               -10 C or lower.     -9 to -5 C.    -4 to 0 C

1961-90.    667444.               287660.        309076

1991-2020. 625163.               288932.         316544

-10 or lower was a highly significant decline at the 0.1% level

-9 to -5 was a non significant increase.

-4 to 0C was a highly significant increase at the 0.1% level

It is surprising that the middle category was non-significant.

My guess at an explanation would be it is something to do with the reduction in arctic sea ice extent. Now at the beginning and end of the Arctic sea ice season, there are big areas which are ice-free compared to 1961-90 which would reduce cooling of t850s. Redoing the analyses on a monthly basis might show this but that would be a big undertaking.

As to the impact on UK cold spells in winter, yes, this reduction in the -10 C t850 cold pool will lessen to some extent the chances of cold spells. BUT it is clear from historical data that cold UK winters come in groups (1980s, 2008/9 to 2010/11) and this is related to the strength of the westerlies and the increased likelihood of retrogressive synoptics bringing easterlies when westerlies are weaker and the jet stream slows and buckles. This is what brings very cold air to the UK in winter. And happily, we seem to be having an example of this phenomenon currently. 

Originally Posted by: Iceman 

 I thought about that when halfway through. It would actually be easy to log it and then filter in Excel so I'll re run if I get the opportunity. It takes about 24 hours to run in full.


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Iceman
08 January 2021 13:24:42

 

 I thought about that when halfway through. It would actually be easy to log it and then filter in Excel so I'll re run if I get the opportunity. It takes about 24 hours to run in full.

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

That would be great. What I think the monthly data would show is greater reductions in -10 t850s in spring and autumn, not winter.


East Kilbride 480 ft

Remove ads from site