The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

Downpour
29 December 2020 11:00:00

These sorts of posts really are misleading, meaningless and do not contribute to the forum in any way. May I politely suggest you visit here to find some likeminded company: https://www.theweatheroutlook.com/twocommunity/default.aspx?g=posts&m=1292254&find=unread

 

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

In what way is it misleading?

 

My estimates are about right!


Chingford

London E4

147ft

BJBlake
29 December 2020 11:00:55

Unusually marginal Synoptics despite such a prolonged block forecast. You would think that Synoptics this blocked would deliver increasingly sustainable cold at this time of year. Let’s hope it does. It is unusual though: Is it perhaps a wake-up call to wider climate issues?

It is also worth looking at previous La Niña events, but if global temperatures continue at 0.2C per decade, the next coincidence of La Niña with maunder minima might see elevation being an even more important factor to precipitation forecasts. 

Nevertheless, if the blocked pattern maintains deeply into January, even at current 1.17 degrees above pre-industrial levels, there must eventually be air reaching us that is closer to the -10hpa levels over us for a brief spell at least, and it does seem that for coastal areas to receive snow, we need the air to be this cold. Mini lows may bring brief falls, but as the pressure rises, these can to turn to rain on their back edge. In land and at elevation - seems to be important already. Even in 2010, in East Anglia, it was those areas above 90m asl between Lavenham and Newmarket that saw the deepest and longest lying snow. Further east at 75m, we saw 4” less, and it disappeared 3 days earlier. Today - I live at 30m asl and there is a marked difference. This area used to be better for northerlies bringing North Sea snow showers, but these are More commonly sleet and rain these days. 

The track of the mini-low will be crucial for Wednesday. Interesting factoid today that aviation in the pandemic has fallen back to levels last seen in 1999, yet that wasn’t so long ago, and of that is a 68% fall in aviation, it is no wonder the greenhouse gasses are still rising faster than at any time before. I can buy an electric car (have done), paint my roof tiles white (not visible for planning), eat less meat, insulate, turn the heating down, plant a few trees, etc, but I cannot seed the oceans with iron, potassium and nitrogen or grow a forest in the desert. This is what is needed...by International cooperation.

I will enjoy the current Synoptics regardless, what it brings, it brings promise, and is better that mild meh from the Atlantic.


Brecklands, South Norfolk 28m ASL
Brian Gaze
29 December 2020 11:05:31

New one for the bingo - at least for me - is MMW. 


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Brian Gaze
29 December 2020 11:06:53

Unusually marginal Synoptics despite such a prolonged block forecast. You would think that Synoptics this blocked would deliver increasingly sustainable cold at this time of year. Let’s hope it does. It is unusual though: Is it perhaps a wake-up call to wider climate issues?

Originally Posted by: BJBlake 

I'll run the Northern Hemisphere 850hPa temperature grid analysis on 2020 in a few days time. It will be interesting to see how it stacks up.


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Tom Oxon
29 December 2020 11:10:16

Unusually marginal Synoptics despite such a prolonged block forecast. You would think that Synoptics this blocked would deliver increasingly sustainable cold at this time of year. Let’s hope it does. It is unusual though: Is it perhaps a wake-up call to wider climate issues?

It is also worth looking at previous La Niña events, but if global temperatures continue at 0.2C per decade, the next coincidence of La Niña with maunder minima might see elevation being an even more important factor to precipitation forecasts. 

Nevertheless, if the blocked pattern maintains deeply into January, even at current 1.17 degrees above pre-industrial levels, there must eventually be air reaching us that is closer to the -10hpa levels over us for a brief spell at least, and it does seem that for coastal areas to receive snow, we need the air to be this cold. Mini lows may bring brief falls, but as the pressure rises, these can to turn to rain on their back edge. In land and at elevation - seems to be important already. Even in 2010, in East Anglia, it was those areas above 90m asl between Lavenham and Newmarket that saw the deepest and longest lying snow. Further east at 75m, we saw 4” less, and it disappeared 3 days earlier. Today - I live at 30m asl and there is a marked difference. This area used to be better for northerlies bringing North Sea snow showers, but these are More commonly sleet and rain these days. 

The track of the mini-low will be crucial for Wednesday. Interesting factoid today that aviation in the pandemic has fallen back to levels last seen in 1999, yet that wasn’t so long ago, and of that is a 68% fall in aviation, it is no wonder the greenhouse gasses are still rising faster than at any time before. I can buy an electric car (have done), paint my roof tiles white (not visible for planning), eat less meat, insulate, turn the heating down, plant a few trees, etc, but I cannot seed the oceans with iron, potassium and nitrogen or grow a forest in the desert. This is what is needed...by International cooperation.

I will enjoy the current Synoptics regardless, what it brings, it brings promise, and is better that mild meh from the Atlantic.

Originally Posted by: BJBlake 

I think the lack of cold pooling is more 'weather' than 'climate' in this scenario.  We've just not had a trough in the east for Arctic air advection into the continent. 

https://www.wetterzentrale.de/en/topkarten.php?map=2&model=gfs&var=1&run=6&time=0&lid=OP&h=0&mv=0&tr=3#mapref

 

There're troughs into Canada and Siberia, that's where the cold air is.  Our deep cold has been somewhat scuppered by a stubborn Ural high cutting off the flow with ridges towards Scandi.


S Warwickshire countryside, c.375ft asl.
Rob K
29 December 2020 11:10:30
The parallel GFS run started off less interesting than the op run but it still gets there with a Greenland High and a cold unstable northerly. By the time the op run has started to break down with the high heading into Canada and letting mild SWerlyies in, the parallel is just getting going.

It's encouraging that almost every permutation seems to result in the same scenario at some point.


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

Rob K
29 December 2020 11:12:51

If it can go wrong it will go wrong.

 

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

 

Interesting to see the 1080mb isobar there! On Meteociel there is just a large 1070mb ring so I assume they don't draw anything above that. Does the raw data indicate what the highest SLP value is over Greenland, Brian?


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

fairweather
29 December 2020 11:13:38

 

Correct. Which is perfectly compatible with my 70% estimate!

London, SE and EA alone accounts for 25 million people, and many many more areas are snowless! 

Originally Posted by: Downpour 

Apart from that i think it is because the North (by definition) will almost always see some snow. In fact the last few years even the SW has seen some where there has not even (and still this year) been as much as a flake in the air for three years in the winter months here  and even then the 2018 Beast was really in March. The area of the extreme S.E, including Kent and east Anglia were amongst the snowiest areas thrpoghout the 60's to 60's so perhaps it is missed the most here?


S.Essex, 42m ASL
Joe Bloggs
29 December 2020 11:14:26

 

I'll run the Northern Hemisphere 850hPa temperature grid analysis on 2020 in a few days time. It will be interesting to see how it stacks up.

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

Hugely unscientific and a massively flawed approach but here is a snapshot comparison of 850s between now and 30 years ago. 6am 29th December 2020 vs the same time and date in 1990. 







My verdict - if we have the right synoptics we can still get deep cold, but it’s probably more difficult to achieve (even if just ever so slightly). 

Rob K
29 December 2020 11:17:30

 

Hugely unscientific and a massively flawed approach but here is a snapshot comparison of 850s between now and 30 years ago. 6am 29th December 2020 vs the same time and date in 1990. 







My verdict - if we have the right synoptics we can still get deep cold, but it’s probably more difficult to achieve (even if just ever so slightly). 

Originally Posted by: Joe Bloggs 

There is still plenty of cold air, but this year it does mostly seem to be over the far side of Asia. Sod's law that this is the year we get a nice easterly arriving, but then maybe the factors that led to the distribution of cold are the same ones leading to the easterly...


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

ballamar
29 December 2020 11:19:10

 

Hugely unscientific and a massively flawed approach but here is a snapshot comparison of 850s between now and 30 years ago. 6am 29th December 2020 vs the same time and date in 1990. 







My verdict - if we have the right synoptics we can still get deep cold, but it’s probably more difficult to achieve (even if just ever so slightly). 

Originally Posted by: Joe Bloggs 

going to write that winter off as it looks too zonal, nothing of note could happen 6 weeks down the line

Joe Bloggs
29 December 2020 11:22:56

 

There is still plenty of cold air, but this year it does mostly seem to be over the far side of Asia. Sod's law that this is the year we get a nice easterly arriving, but then maybe the factors that led to the distribution of cold are the same ones leading to the easterly...

Originally Posted by: Rob K 

Very true.

To be honest looking at those two images again, I’m encouraged by how similar they actually look (in terms of the depth and scale of cold)  and how much deep cold air there is right now in the northern hemisphere, even if it is in the wrong place! 

Not for a second suggesting you can make firm conclusions with a snapshot like that, but with the right synoptics we could absolutely still strike it lucky. 

 

Anyway I’m drifting off topic now and Brian will tell me off. 

fairweather
29 December 2020 11:23:23

The GFS 06z 850 hPa ensemble mean is probably the best so far. I say this because as I still think New Years Eve has possibilities and the 4th of Jan still looking good with the mean now down to -6.8C at that point - the lowest so far and ties in well with the op at that point. These two points in time still have the highest snow rows as well.


S.Essex, 42m ASL
Rob K
29 December 2020 11:23:47

ICON shows that rare beast, the "south of the M4" snow event 


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

Downpour
29 December 2020 11:24:02

 

Apart from that i think it is because the North (by definition) will almost always see some snow. In fact the last few years even the SW has seen some where there has not even (and still this year) been as much as a flake in the air for three years in the winter months here  and even then the 2018 Beast was really in March. The area of the extreme S.E, including Kent and east Anglia were amongst the snowiest areas thrpoghout the 60's to 60's so perhaps it is missed the most here?

Originally Posted by: fairweather 

 

Indeed, I’m rather sick of being lectured, when my estimate is correct. This spell hasn’t delivered for the majority of the population: snow on hills and in favoured northern spots is not unusual. 

The simple truth is that the modelled 850s are not sufficiently cold to deliver widespread snowfall for the majority. So we are left with scraps. 


Chingford

London E4

147ft

Joe Bloggs
29 December 2020 11:26:31

 

 

Indeed, I’m rather sick of being lectured, when my estimate is correct. This spell hasn’t delivered for the majority of the population: snow on hills and in favoured northern spots is not unusual. 

The simple truth is that the modelled 850s are not sufficiently cold to deliver widespread snowfall for the majority. So we are left with scraps. 

Originally Posted by: Downpour 

South Manchester and St Helens are not favoured spots at all, they are in fact some of the more snowless parts of the UK, and yet we have had lying snow as a result of this cold spell. 

nsrobins
29 December 2020 11:28:32

The parallel GFS run started off less interesting than the op run but it still gets there with a Greenland High and a cold unstable northerly. By the time the op run has started to break down with the high heading into Canada and letting mild SWerlyies in, the parallel is just getting going.
It's encouraging that almost every permutation seems to result in the same scenario at some point.

Originally Posted by: Rob K 

I’m quite heartened by the GEFS actually.

Pert #2 has the right idea anyway 😎


Neil

Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)

Stormchaser, Member TORRO

Downpour
29 December 2020 11:34:33

 

South Manchester and St Helens are not favoured spots at all, they are in fact some of the more snowless parts of the UK, and yet we have had lying snow as a result of this cold spell. 

Originally Posted by: Joe Bloggs 

 

Sure, yet my estimate is that 70% of the UK is snowless, which is accurate.


Chingford

London E4

147ft

Brian Gaze
29 December 2020 11:35:56

 

 

Sure, yet my estimate is that 70% of the UK is snowless, which is accurate.

Originally Posted by: Downpour 

Complete guess but I would have thought 80% to 90% would be closer to the mark. I think the interest is focused on a) the length of the cold period b) the disruption to the Atlantic flow


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Sasa
  • Sasa
  • Advanced Member
29 December 2020 11:37:14

 

I think the lack of cold pooling is more 'weather' than 'climate' in this scenario.  We've just not had a trough in the east for Arctic air advection into the continent. 

https://www.wetterzentrale.de/en/topkarten.php?map=2&model=gfs&var=1&run=6&time=0&lid=OP&h=0&mv=0&tr=3#mapref

 

There're troughs into Canada and Siberia, that's where the cold air is.  Our deep cold has been somewhat scuppered by a stubborn Ural high cutting off the flow with ridges towards Scandi.

Originally Posted by: Tom Oxon 

 

Tom,

 

Agree. yesterday in Ojmjakon Siberia -62c which is I think only 5c off the record. Stubborn high behind Urals giving plenty of cold to Siberia, parts of Asia.


Kingston Upon Thames
Ally Pally Snowman
29 December 2020 11:40:56

 

I’m quite heartened by the GEFS actually.

Pert #2 has the right idea anyway 😎

Originally Posted by: nsrobins 

 

Seems to be the way at the moment that the 6z and 18z are coldies and the 0z and 12z are back down to earthers.


Bishop's Stortford 85m ASL.
Rob K
29 December 2020 11:43:12

The GFS 06z 850 hPa ensemble mean is probably the best so far. I say this because as I still think New Years Eve has possibilities and the 4th of Jan still looking good with the mean now down to -6.8C at that point - the lowest so far and ties in well with the op at that point. These two points in time still have the highest snow rows as well.

Originally Posted by: fairweather 

Later in the run the mean is a degree or so higher (-3.5C in London by 276hrs as compared to -5C on the 00Z GEFS) but it's all noise at that stage.

 

GEFS mean pressure pattern at 240 hours has 1040mb Greenland high, 995mb Azores low and a low over northern Italy. If the upper air was colder it would be dreamland.


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

Downpour
29 December 2020 11:43:21

 

Complete guess but I would have thought 80% to 90% would be closer to the mark. I think the interest is focused on a) the length of the cold period b) the disruption to the Atlantic flow

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

 

Well my original estimate was 80-90% but I have modified it to 70% following today’s showers. Maybe I should have stuck to my guns.

In any case, it’s a very poor return so far!


Chingford

London E4

147ft

Ally Pally Snowman
29 December 2020 12:00:25

 

 

Well my original estimate was 80-90% but I have modified it to 70% following today’s showers. Maybe I should have stuck to my guns.

In any case, it’s a very poor return so far!

Originally Posted by: Downpour 

 

Looks to me we have a good week to 10 days of marginal snow chances before it probably gets too mild again. All models are rubbish at forecasting snow so hopefully something will pop up at relatively short notice. For my area nothing obvious yet. Will be very annoying if further south gets snow tomorrow. 


Bishop's Stortford 85m ASL.
Joe Bloggs
29 December 2020 12:05:39

 

 

Well my original estimate was 80-90% but I have modified it to 70% following today’s showers. Maybe I should have stuck to my guns.

In any case, it’s a very poor return so far!

Originally Posted by: Downpour 

One thing I would say is be careful with your perceptions - some of the places which have received snow as a result of this spell so far are areas which don’t very often get it (promising for other low lying urban areas, there is hope). 

Secondly the short range models have been RUBBISH. The UKV in particular (and the MetO app as a result) has been woeful . In many ways it’s better to get a broad idea of what’s likely to come, ignore the track and timing, and then just check the radar instead. 

Remove ads from site