The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

KevBrads1
26 December 2020 08:06:19

The ECM 2m temperatures for Manchester look distinctly chilly, could be a really chilly first third to January, maybe the coldest for a decade. 


MANCHESTER SUMMER INDEX for 2021: 238

Timelapses, old weather forecasts and natural phenomena videos can be seen on this site

http://www.youtube.com/channel/UCgrSD1BwFz2feWDTydhpEhQ/playlists

Tim A
26 December 2020 08:58:31

Euro 4 shows some snowfall for NW parts of UK up to Monday morning.  Most snowfall for NW England and Scotland is from showers Sunday afternoon and overnight with the system on Monday likely to bring some snow further south. This system could be tricky to pin down on the day and Euro4 has it more widespread than some models.  For here , I would think the showers on Sunday evening are more likely to produce. Some elevation probably required.

 


Tim

NW Leeds

187m asl

 My PWS 

dagspot
26 December 2020 09:14:32
actually often this is what West of Scotland does best out of for snow
Neilston 600ft ASL
BJBlake
26 December 2020 09:25:01

GFS OP looks to be the outlier of all other runs, bringing less cold and an eventual mild outcome. All other runs, including the control and para keep the outcome cold. Some education is needed for anyone like me who does not quite know which run is selected as Op and why, and also how they tweak for the Control and Para? Brian, I am sure you have educated many on here before, and therefore this request may be a tad tiresome - but having been so helpful clearing up the impact of climate change on the cold pool extent and relative chances of cold winters, A suitably succinct definition on the relative merits of the different model outputs would be most welcomed. - at least by me.

The oddity of the Op compared to all other runs is marked - but should we read anything into this? The Op run in the last few runs, for some 4-5 days, has often been the milder outlier compared to the others, in terms of the latter time periods, which are always “just for fun” anyway. 

Many thanks in anticipation....

Happy Boxing Day to all on Two too.


Brecklands, South Norfolk 28m ASL
Surrey John
26 December 2020 09:47:38
Quite a lot of inconsistency in the models for lying snow by Monday morning, can click on various models on this link (the boxes across top of map, for those that are unfamiliar)

https://meteologix.com/uk/model-charts/gbr-hd/united-kingdom/snow-depth/20201228-0600z.html 

Appears Western and central Scotland are favoured, as is most of Wales and moors of SW England, then rather more inconsistent for western Pennines, Cotswolds etc

Looks like a fine line between sleet / wet (melting) snow / proper laying on ground snow, so altitude will be relevant, as will local topography (is air rising or falling as it goes over a hill).

Trying to phrase this in non technical and non abbreviation form as their are loads of guests reading this forum currently who might be looking for snow.


Bradford on Avon, Wiltshire

35m ASL

White Meadows
26 December 2020 09:47:49
Reading between the lines in the met office updates, cold or rather cold through the entire period up until late January is now favoured, although not exceptionally so (currently).. although the fact it’s been mentioned means it could become less of a remote possibility. Perhaps a strat warming event can come into play, I’m sure they’re monitoring with level headed expectations. As Retron pointed out yesterday there is a clear signal for something occurring 1st week Jan:

https://apps.ecmwf.int/webapps/opencharts/streaming/20201225-2010/13/pdf2svg-worker-commands-7745797d4-lnckp-6fe5cac1a363ec1525f54343b6cc9fd8-8Rhx7k.svg 

On a side note, what is the difference between cold and rather cold?

Gandalf The White
26 December 2020 09:48:24

GFS OP looks to be the outlier of all other runs, bringing less cold and an eventual mild outcome. All other runs, including the control and para keep the outcome cold. Some education is needed for anyone like me who does not quite know which run is selected as Op and why, and also how they tweak for the Control and Para? Brian, I am sure you have educated many on here before, and therefore this request may be a tad tiresome - but having been so helpful clearing up the impact of climate change on the cold pool extent and relative chances of cold winters, A suitably succinct definition on the relative merits of the different model outputs would be most welcomed. - at least by me.

The oddity of the Op compared to all other runs is marked - but should we read anything into this? The Op run in the last few runs, for some 4-5 days, has often been the milder outlier compared to the others, in terms of the latter time periods, which are always “just for fun” anyway. 

Many thanks in anticipation....

Happy Boxing Day to all on Two too.

Originally Posted by: BJBlake 

The easy part: the parallel run is a new computer programme - intended to be an improbable the current Op.

The Op starts with what is thought to be the best approximation of the state of the atmosphere at T0.  But there are always some estimates in that starting point.  The various ensemble runs just tweak those estimates to test how it affects the evolution.

IIRC the Control is run at a lower resolution.

 

The professionals don’t just focus on the Op from one source; they use the ensembles and other sources.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



Gooner
26 December 2020 09:55:29

Reading between the lines in the met office updates, cold or rather cold through the entire period up until late January is now favoured, although not exceptionally so (currently).. although the fact it’s been mentioned means it could become less of a remote possibility. Perhaps a strat warming event can come into play, I’m sure they’re monitoring with level headed expectations. As Retron pointed out yesterday there is a clear signal for something occurring 1st week Jan:
https://apps.ecmwf.int/webapps/opencharts/streaming/20201225-2010/13/pdf2svg-worker-commands-7745797d4-lnckp-6fe5cac1a363ec1525f54343b6cc9fd8-8Rhx7k.svg

On a side note, what is the difference between cold and rather cold?

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

Yes , I'd agree , just read the Met update and January could be a cold month with ( hopefully) some surprises 


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus

Banbury

North Oxfordshire

378 feet A S L



Ally Pally Snowman
26 December 2020 10:01:18

ECM ensembles are very chilly this morning for an extended period. 


Bishop's Stortford 85m ASL.
doctormog
26 December 2020 10:02:38

Reading between the lines in the met office updates, cold or rather cold through the entire period up until late January is now favoured, although not exceptionally so (currently).. although the fact it’s been mentioned means it could become less of a remote possibility. Perhaps a strat warming event can come into play, I’m sure they’re monitoring with level headed expectations. As Retron pointed out yesterday there is a clear signal for something occurring 1st week Jan:
https://apps.ecmwf.int/webapps/opencharts/streaming/20201225-2010/13/pdf2svg-worker-commands-7745797d4-lnckp-6fe5cac1a363ec1525f54343b6cc9fd8-8Rhx7k.svg

On a side note, what is the difference between cold and rather cold?

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

”Cold” is colder than “rather cold”. The latter is essentially the winter equivalent if the summer term “cool” and it means a little below average. Cold would be cold.

Essentially it is the difference between what you would typically get with polar marítime compared with Arctic maritime air masses for example.


Rob K
26 December 2020 10:12:21

GFS OP looks to be the outlier of all other runs, bringing less cold and an eventual mild outcome. All other runs, including the control and para keep the outcome cold. Some education is needed for anyone like me who does not quite know which run is selected as Op and why, and also how they tweak for the Control and Para? Brian, I am sure you have educated many on here before, and therefore this request may be a tad tiresome - but having been so helpful clearing up the impact of climate change on the cold pool extent and relative chances of cold winters, A suitably succinct definition on the relative merits of the different model outputs would be most welcomed. - at least by me.

The oddity of the Op compared to all other runs is marked - but should we read anything into this? The Op run in the last few runs, for some 4-5 days, has often been the milder outlier compared to the others, in terms of the latter time periods, which are always “just for fun” anyway. 

Many thanks in anticipation....

Happy Boxing Day to all on Two too.

Originally Posted by: BJBlake 

As I understand it the op run is the one that uses the input data “as is”, and the other perturbations are fed slightly modified input data to see how the unavoidable errors in the data affect the outcome (eg if the pressure at point X is 1mb higher how will that change the outcomes).

The control run used to be run using the unmodified data but at a lower resolution I believe, but that may not be the case now. I’m sure someone here will know.

 

Looking at the 06Z GFS, some places may be getting snow to welcome in 2021. It’s making a bit more of the low pressure coming southwards  

 

 


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

nsrobins
26 December 2020 10:15:38
Parameters as expected marginal for lowland snow early Monday. These set-ups however are fluid and subject to short-term tweaks so anyone missing out Monday will have other opportunities. Indeed as uppers continue to slowly fall under slack low pressure (-4/-5 Mon to -6/-7 Thurs) mid to late week looks more likely to deliver.

Longer term and maybe GFS is picking-up on the early Jan ‘milder’ interlude before the long-predicted and much discussed SSW (however it manifests itself).

It’s a much used phrase in here but we might have to be patient.


Neil

Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)

Stormchaser, Member TORRO

tallyho_83
26 December 2020 10:17:22

 

”Cold” is colder than “rather cold”. The latter is essentially the winter equivalent if the summer term “cool” and it means a little below average. Cold would be cold.

Essentially it is the difference between what you would typically get with polar marítime compared with Arctic maritime air masses for example.

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

Yes that was what I asked in the media Thread when the Met office said " Feeling Cold or rather cold" what is the difference between? Or do they mean feeling rather cold? Or even better they could have said it will feel cold'. Full Stop. Then they also went on to say nothing 'exceptionally cold.' What is exceptionally cold anyway?


Home Location - Vixen Tor Close, Okehampton, Devon (221m ASL)

---------------------------------------

Sean Moon

Magical Moon

www.magical-moon.com

doctormog
26 December 2020 10:23:45

 

Yes that was what I asked in the media Thread when the Met office said " Feeling Cold or rather cold" what is the difference between? Or do they mean feeling rather cold? Or even better they could have said it will feel cold'. Full Stop. Then they also went on to say nothing 'exceptionally cold.' What is exceptionally cold anyway?

Originally Posted by: tallyho_83 

Well, I answered the first parts. Re. the last question, I would have thought that it was obvious that exceptionally cold means much colder than normal i.e. exceptional, and yes that does not look likely currently.


fairweather
26 December 2020 10:27:41

Reading between the lines in the met office updates, cold or rather cold through the entire period up until late January is now favoured, although not exceptionally so (currently).. although the fact it’s been mentioned means it could become less of a remote possibility. Perhaps a strat warming event can come into play, I’m sure they’re monitoring with level headed expectations. As Retron pointed out yesterday there is a clear signal for something occurring 1st week Jan:
https://apps.ecmwf.int/webapps/opencharts/streaming/20201225-2010/13/pdf2svg-worker-commands-7745797d4-lnckp-6fe5cac1a363ec1525f54343b6cc9fd8-8Rhx7k.svg

On a side note, what is the difference between cold and rather cold?

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

"Cold" is rather colder than "rather cold" 


S.Essex, 42m ASL
White Meadows
26 December 2020 10:33:37

 

Well, I answered the first parts. Re. the last question, I would have thought that it was obvious that exceptionally cold means much colder than normal i.e. exceptional, and yes that does not look likely currently.

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

Bang on Doc, and thank you.

They are clearly aware and assessing with great interest the phenomenal dip in mean zonal winds in about a weeks time. Otherwise Why mention the word exceptional, then rule it out based on current data/ likelihood? 
it’s going to be fascinating to see subsequent updates and how & if this affects the model output. 
Of course SSW‘s do not always have direct impact on our winters... I wonder what the % ratio of resulting cold outbreaks is. Anyone?

Gandalf The White
26 December 2020 10:34:24

 

As I understand it the op run is the one that uses the input data “as is”, and the other perturbations are fed slightly modified input data to see how the unavoidable errors in the data affect the outcome (eg if the pressure at point X is 1mb higher how will that change the outcomes).

The control run used to be run using the unmodified data but at a lower resolution I believe, but that may not be the case now. I’m sure someone here will know.

 

Looking at the 06Z GFS, some places may be getting snow to welcome in 2021. It’s making a bit more of the low pressure coming southwards  

 

 

Originally Posted by: Rob K 

Yes, but....  even the opening position includes some estimates simply because there are more grid points in the model than their are pieces of data. When you think about just how many horizontal and vertical grid points there are then it's inevitable that there simply won't be any actual data for some and limited data for others.

Have you ever looked at the individual ensemble members at T+6 and seen just how many tiny changes there are even in the first six hours? Obviously they're inconsequential at that point but they are the building blocks for the next iteration for 6 hours later and so on.

Butterflies flapping their wings and all that.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



doctormog
26 December 2020 10:35:20

The GFS op runs, after a period of notable inter-run consistency seems to have lost that consistency and is flipping from one scenario to the other in the medium to long term (circa day 10). I’m not sure if it is uncertainty, data or a pattern change but it’s difficult to see any clear sign at day ten on that model or indeed perhaps more widely.


fairweather
26 December 2020 10:35:36

06z still rock solid for a cold spell till at least the start of January. 850's generally -4C and down to -5C by 1st.  Storm Bella may well play a key part. I seem to recall that severe January storms can upset the applecart in more ways than one though no doubt they are tracked better these days. The Low Pressure of Jan 1953 led to snow on its back edge and a cold spell after? I can remember one or two others heralding a cold spell in January.


S.Essex, 42m ASL
hobensotwo
26 December 2020 10:40:26
The GFS OP at t+188 showing a more traditional snow risk for my area (al la March 2013). Although exact positioning and 850's crucial..

Subject to change at that range anyway.

Gooner
26 December 2020 10:42:47

Parameters as expected marginal for lowland snow early Monday. These set-ups however are fluid and subject to short-term tweaks so anyone missing out Monday will have other opportunities. Indeed as uppers continue to slowly fall under slack low pressure (-4/-5 Mon to -6/-7 Thurs) mid to late week looks more likely to deliver.
Longer term and maybe GFS is picking-up on the early Jan ‘milder’ interlude before the long-predicted and much discussed SSW (however it manifests itself).
It’s a much used phrase in here but we might have to be patient.

Originally Posted by: nsrobins 

The Beeb had an area of snow IMBY for Monday , so will be interesting to see 


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus

Banbury

North Oxfordshire

378 feet A S L



nsrobins
26 December 2020 10:45:13

 

Yes, but....  even the opening position includes some estimates simply because there are more grid points in the model than their are pieces of data. When you think about just how many horizontal and vertical grid points there are then it's inevitable that there simply won't be any actual data for some and limited data for others.

Have you ever looked at the individual ensemble members at T+6 and seen just how many tiny changes there are even in the first six hours? Obviously they're inconsequential at that point but they are the building blocks for the next iteration for 6 hours later and so on.

Butterflies flapping their wings and all that.

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

Atmospheric models like many use a spatially uneven matrix of input data and resolve it into an even three dimensional grid at the start of the computational space. This process naturally involves interpolation. The higher the number of input data the better the interpolation and hence more accurate the projection. If you only have two measurements of temperature 30km apart the starting grid of 5km voxels will contain some rather diffuse interpolations. Measure every 5km however and it’s much more accurate. In essence more data - better result.

 


Neil

Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)

Stormchaser, Member TORRO

Rob K
26 December 2020 10:56:55
GFS has reverted to traditional UK winter in the latter stages with the Azores high back in its usual place.
Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

doctormog
26 December 2020 11:00:39

GFS has reverted to traditional UK winter in the latter stages with the Azores high back in its usual place.

Originally Posted by: Rob K 

And totally different to the equivalent 6 hours earlier. Whether colder extremes or milder ones the 06z GFS op run quite often bucks the trend. It may be on to something, but in isolation I will take it with a pinch of salt.


Joe Bloggs
26 December 2020 11:06:04

I had been very very impressed with how rock solidly consistent the GFS op had been for building heights in the North Atlantic & Greenland region. Reminded me a bit of the run up to the December 2009 cold spell. 

The past few runs seem to have toned down the Greenland heights and everything in the long range has become a bit “flabby” to our NW and there are some hints now of the high slipping over the UK with lower heights returning to Greenland. 

Will be interesting to see if this is maintained or we see the return to some very cold synoptics maybe after a more settled/less cold blip?

Either way in the reliable range it is a cold outlook with a snow risk for some. 

Remove ads from site