The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

Whether Idle
24 April 2020 09:13:23

 

It's just about been bone dry here for six weeks. After being flooded in Jan/Feb, the garden is opening up with cracking you would see a couple of months down the line during a baron spell. The dust is pollen here!

Still no reply from Rob K and Tim S on my thoughts above why our climate has been heating faster over the last two decades (if anyone else would like to comment then in their absence, if they can!). It agrees that Greta and climate activists will change the climate with cleaner air, but not the direction she and they were thinking of!

We are currently on course to burn!

Originally Posted by: Phil G 

And burn we surely will. Thanks to greed and selfishness. 


Dover, 5m asl. Half a mile from the south coast.
Phil G
24 April 2020 13:05:30

 

And burn we surely will. Thanks to greed and selfishness. 

Originally Posted by: Whether Idle 

Yes I am not disputing that. If you read my full post I don't like fossil fuels either and prefer other energy sources.

It's been noted that the dangerous 'greenhouse gasses" stay in the atmosphere a lot lot longer than other gasses, maybe for hundreds of years would you kid. These other gasses have been creating global dimming and counter-acting somewhat the heat caused by gg's.

In the last two decades we have been cleaning our air, BUT the temps are rising at a faster rate. What's going on here? It seems that as we clean the air, the other gasses which have been neutralising somewhat the effect of the gg's, as their lifetime is very short we have created an imbalance where the heat will be more intense taking the global dimming away.

I don't have an answer but yes Greta and co will change the planet by altering the temps, but not in the direction she predicted. These other gasses have been keeping us cooler, taking them away is creating a differential between the two gasses, and we don't know where the ceiling is. The more we clean the faster the temps rise. There's a very good chance the action to try to protect our earth may end up destroying us as we burn.

TimS
  • TimS
  • Advanced Member
24 April 2020 22:03:07
The records show that sulphate and particulate emissions have cooled the earth (relative to the trend) by about 0.2C. The effect is regionally concentrated and the biggest effect in recent years has been over China and SE Asia where it’s locally probably close to 0.5C.

Here is a classic paper from the golden age of climate change discovery, the mid-1990s:

https://journals.ametsoc.org/doi/pdf/10.1175/1520-0442%281997%29010%3C0245%3AOMOGWB%3E2.0.CO%3B2 

Get rid of all of them at once and the atmosphere in those regions will warm quite quickly. Same effect happened during the late 80s and 90s in Europe and the US after action against acid rain and the collapse of the Soviet Union.

The accumulated effect of anthropogenic CO2 since the pre-industrial era is already about 0.9-1.1C, and far outweighs cooling from SO2 and particulates. We continue to pump more of the stuff into the atmosphere, along with NO2 and CH4, so the global temperature will continue to climb.


Brockley, South East London 30m asl
Phil G
25 April 2020 16:13:32

The records show that sulphate and particulate emissions have cooled the earth (relative to the trend) by about 0.2C. The effect is regionally concentrated and the biggest effect in recent years has been over China and SE Asia where it’s locally probably close to 0.5C.

Here is a classic paper from the golden age of climate change discovery, the mid-1990s:

https://journals.ametsoc.org/doi/pdf/10.1175/1520-0442%281997%29010%3C0245%3AOMOGWB%3E2.0.CO%3B2

Get rid of all of them at once and the atmosphere in those regions will warm quite quickly. Same effect happened during the late 80s and 90s in Europe and the US after action against acid rain and the collapse of the Soviet Union.

The accumulated effect of anthropogenic CO2 since the pre-industrial era is already about 0.9-1.1C, and far outweighs cooling from SO2 and particulates. We continue to pump more of the stuff into the atmosphere, along with NO2 and CH4, so the global temperature will continue to climb.

Originally Posted by: TimS 

Thank very much for this Tim.

On your last paragraph, with the scientific evidence that heat increasing greenhouse gasses (gg's) will stay in the atmosphere for years, maybe hundreds of years while other gasses (og's) are 'responsible' for global dimming, which are keeping us cooler will only stay for a few weeks at best. As we clean the air, the temperature has continued to rise in the last two decades. Does this mean as we continue to clean, the temp will continue to rise further, maybe faster. By reducing the og's, it seems to be causing an imbalance as the gg's remain in the atmosphere much longer therefore creating higher temps. If this is the case, how long will this go on for? Can we sustain such increases while we wait for gg levels to reduce, which may take hundreds of years?

Rob K
25 April 2020 17:42:44

 

It's just about been bone dry here for six weeks. After being flooded in Jan/Feb, the garden is opening up with cracking you would see a couple of months down the line during a baron spell. The dust is pollen here!

Still no reply from Rob K and Tim S on my thoughts above why our climate has been heating faster over the last two decades (if anyone else would like to comment then in their absence, if they can!). It agrees that Greta and climate activists will change the climate with cleaner air, but not the direction she and they were thinking of!

We are currently on course to burn!

Originally Posted by: Phil G 

I agree with you. From your previous post I thought you were dismissing the idea. 


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

Phil G
25 April 2020 18:49:42

 

I agree with you. From your previous post I thought you were dismissing the idea. 

Originally Posted by: Rob K 

Thanks Rob.

Sorry if I have misunderstood but my fear is BY cleaning the air are we on course to burn. The ratio of gg's to og's (the gasses that have been keeping us cooler) is widening as gg's are lasting a lot lot longer in the atmosphere.

Phil G
27 April 2020 13:23:05

So this is my summary on things, if anyone can 'put me right'.

- We all want fossil fuels replaced with cleaner energy sources and thus producing cleaner air.
-For the last two decades, we have been reducing pollution and cleaning the air, but the earth's temp is still rising, and at a faster rate breaking new records.
- Why are temps increasing?
- As we clean the air, while we reduce greenhouse gasses (gg's) such as C02 and methane which cause heating, we are also reducing other gasses (og's) such as sulphates which are responsible for global dimming, and keeping the earth cooler.
- The lifespan of gg's can be many years, hundreds of years. The lifespan of og's is at best a few weeks.
- By reducing pollution, we are causing an imbalance where because gg's stay a lot lot longer in the atmosphere than og's, the differential between the two gasses is increasing in gg's favour and heating is becoming more prevalent. If this is the case, as we continue to clean the air our temp will continue to rise.
- Quite how long this will go on for we don't know, we don't know with the ever growing gg to og differential what the ceiling is on further temperature rises.
- Greta and other climate activists are seeking to alter the earth's climate, but not in the direction they thought! The cleaner air is causing the earth's temp to rise, and we don't know the effect of this and how long this will go on for.
- I haven't got a solution, but could the actions of cleaning the air actually make our position more perilous?
- Do we need to undertake more analysis before chancing innocent practices that might actually make the world burn.
- Greta's message to the kids about being scared because of country's activity. Could it be it's her and other activists lack of understanding on 'the other side of the coin' that may take us over the precipice?

Edit: This month, another near record breaking record with less pollution, reduced jets for instance. What is going on? 

Phil G
30 April 2020 11:29:33
A short summary next to their coronavirus ticker on the BBC site:

"Lockdowns in response to the pandemic will see global emissions fall by a record 8%, the International Energy Agency say".

What do people expect. Will temps continue to rise, stabilise or fall?

Remove ads from site