The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

llamedos
  • llamedos
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
10 April 2020 10:35:15

If there is some positive gain from the ravaging effects of the Covid-19 pandemic, global pollution levels appear to be at their lowest levels in decades.

I'm not wishing to open old wounds regarding climate change, but I'm wondering if this will have some impact on seasonal weather ie. a reset of what used to be considered "normal weather" associated with each of the what are broadly considered to be the four seasons.

Any views? 


"Life with the Lions"

TWO Moderator

Phil G
10 April 2020 14:08:34
I am sure over the last two decades our air is cleaner, but with this has brought record breaking heat?

While there is discussion that CO2 is the main driver to higher temps, could it be that other gasses have been cooling the earth to what it should have been (perhaps global dimming) and now eradicating them has increased the temps.

Yes Greta has got her wish for a change in temperature, but perhaps not in the direction she and others expected.

If this is the case, we'll burn!

johncs2016
11 April 2020 06:56:20

I am pleased to report that air pollution here in Edinburgh has gone down by quite a lot since the start of the lockdown.

As a result of that though, it just seems as though our weather (or rather, the lack of any actual "weather" in this instance) has got even more boring and uninteresting than it was before, just as we wouldn't have thought that this is possible since I already live in what is normally, the most boring and uninteresting part of the UK when it comes to our weather, with the more interesting weather always being elsewhere in the UK other than here.

I am wondering though whether or not, that relative lack of air pollution might be part of the reason why it has been so dry here recently since more pollution would probably have resulted in there being more suitable nuclei around in the atmosphere for clouds and rain to be able to form and now, the ongoing lockdown has removed quite a lot of that.

 


The north of Edinburgh, usually always missing out on snow events which occur not just within the rest of Scotland or the UK, but also within the rest of Edinburgh.

Phil G
19 April 2020 10:22:20
If the reduced activity carries on for some time yet, be interesting the effect on temps this year. If there are record temps this year after the reduction of pollution, could that bring into question climate change theories. Would activists say "you can't take one year in isolation".

There could be some big conclusions, right or wrong ones coming up this year perhaps.

Phil G
21 April 2020 10:38:04
So bright out there. Lack of aircraft pollution that normally causes a bit of global dimming perhaps?
Rob K
22 April 2020 09:50:09

If the reduced activity carries on for some time yet, be interesting the effect on temps this year. If there are record temps this year after the reduction of pollution, could that bring into question climate change theories. Would activists say "you can't take one year in isolation".
There could be some big conclusions, right or wrong ones coming up this year perhaps.

Originally Posted by: Phil G 

Not necessarily. As others have said, other pollutants have a cooling effect (global dimming) which goes some way to counteracting the warming from CO2 levels. These other pollutants will likely have a shorter residence time than CO2, so in simple terms, the smoke clears, allowing more sunlight in, but the CO2 is still there trapping the heat, so temperatures actually go up!


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

Phil G
22 April 2020 14:42:03

 

Not necessarily. As others have said, other pollutants have a cooling effect (global dimming) which goes some way to counteracting the warming from CO2 levels. These other pollutants will likely have a shorter residence time than CO2, so in simple terms, the smoke clears, allowing more sunlight in, but the CO2 is still there trapping the heat, so temperatures actually go up!

Originally Posted by: Rob K 

Yes I was expecting the usual counter claim, must be dodgy data!

This April will be the fourth or fifth warmest on record. Another record broken and while we clean up the air, these records continue to be broken.

I think Greta and the climate change people are running out of room very quickly. Pollution has been keeping the earth cooler than it should be, and taking this away is leading to increased temps. We have been transitioning to what the earth's temps should really be. We are in a earth's natural cycle warming phase, not something brought about by man.

I expect there will be a lot of debate this year as countries burn, but our air is cleaner. I wonder why? Greta had better have a damned good response!

Rob K
22 April 2020 15:44:55

 

Yes I was expecting the usual counter claim, must be dodgy data!

This April will be the fourth or fifth warmest on record. Another record broken and while we clean up the air, these records continue to be broken.

I think Greta and the climate change people are running out of room very quickly. Pollution has been keeping the earth cooler than it should be, and taking this away is leading to increased temps. We have been transitioning to what the earth's temps should really be. We are in a earth's natural cycle warming phase, not something brought about by man.

I expect there will be a lot of debate this year as countries burn, but our air is cleaner. I wonder why? Greta had better have a damned good response!

Originally Posted by: Phil G 

Not sure what your point is? I am not invoking "dodgy data" or anything of the sort, just simple physics. Cleaner air means that less "global dimming", which means less masking of the background warming. The global dimming pollution is a short-term effect - if factories shut down and global transport is slashed, then levels of smoke particulates, sulphates and so on will decrease rapidly as they are easily washed out of the atmosphere. Whereas CO2 levels will stop rising so fast, but they won't suddenly drop back to pre-industrial levels, they will stay at their current elevated level, more or less. It seems fairly straightforward, and nothing to do with "Greta" or anyone else.

 

Following 9/11 when air travel was shut down, studies found that daytime temperatures went up, while night-time temperatures went down, which is more or less what you would expect from clearer skies. And anecdotally, in my area at least, we have had some pretty low overnight lows, although of course how much of this is due to clearer skies from a lack of pollution and how much is just down to the HP dominance is open to question.


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

TimS
  • TimS
  • Advanced Member
22 April 2020 17:47:23

Some of the stuff in this this thread is such nonsense, it’s like the climate denial equivalent of 5G giving us Coronavirus. Even sceptics have learned to be a bit more sophisticated over time.

Misunderstanding the entire history of climate science: check
IMBY anecdotes: check
Personalising in classic American republican style (used to be Al Gore, now Greta Thunberg): check
The “house of cards is about to come crashing down” meme that pops up without fail every year: check

Would suggest looking at some of the early foundational IPCC reports from back in the 90s to see the relative contributions throigh history of atmospheric CO2, which has a residence time of decades, and cooling from tropospheric (as opposed to stratospheric) sulphates and particulates which have residence times ranging from hours to a few weeks.

Fortunately world governments, businesses and civil society have already started to make the types of changes we need to transition to a low carbon economy. And this crisis which preys on the lungs helps to convince more people that pumping crap into the atmosphere isn’t in anyone’s interests.


Brockley, South East London 30m asl
picturesareme
22 April 2020 21:20:41

Pollution has been fairly high lately and all the cars in our street are covered in dirt that i suspect has its origins some place south of the Mediterranean. Its all quite recent to as we had deluges only a few days ago. 

Phil G
22 April 2020 22:02:11

First of all, I'd like to say I am against fossil fuels. Just the same as a smoker it can't be doing anyone any good. I'd much prefer a world of solar, tidal and wind power and think using magnetism is a mostly untapped 'natural resource'.

Let's think of this another way. Say in the atmosphere there has been 50% temperature warming greenhouse gasses that stay longer, much longer than other gasses which are say 30% which are gone in a very short space of time. The other gasses are responsible for global dimming.
With the reduction of air pollution, we now have a faster reduction of other gasses and is now down to say 45% gg's v 20% og's. There is a wider differential between the two hence the increase in temperature over the last two decades.

As we move on, the og's will continue to reduce faster than gg's therefore the temp will continue to rise more sharply, sharper than the increase's we are witnessing now. In a number of years time we will be down to 35% gg's as apparently they mostly stay in the atmosphere and 0% og's.

If you took all the gasses away both gg and og, we don't know what the natural earth temp would be. All we know now is they are rising more quickly as the differential between both types of gas widens.

Yes we don't live in a perfect world by far. But, is there a possibility the world might burn if we eradicate the gasses which are actually keeping the earth cooler than it should be by global dimming.

I see it there is a kind of balance there at the moment, but as we clean the air we are forcing the temperature up and we really don't know where this ceiling is.

Yes we need to reduce gg levels, but until something can be done to compensate that we will only force the temp up higher, how high we don't know.

In our quest to fight and stop levels of gg's (which apparently will be there for a very long time), we are neutralising faster the gasses that are keeping the earth cooler.

Again and forgive me if I am wrong, Greta and climate change activists do have the planet's future in mind, but they have not got the whole picture. The evidence is already there over the last two decades is that we are creating an imbalance and an increasing rise of temperatures.
We are reducing the gasses which are keeping us cooler much faster.

At this rate of air pollution reduction the world will burn. Bit of a different message that has gone out to scare the kids, but are we looking at the whole picture here? Like our bodies the earth is complex place. We still know little about our bodies and likewise the earth. What seems like the likely fix of reducing pollution might make the whole situation a lot lot worse.







Phil G
22 April 2020 22:07:48

Pollution has been fairly high lately and all the cars in our street are covered in dirt that i suspect has its origins some place south of the Mediterranean. Its all quite recent to as we had deluges only a few days ago. 

Originally Posted by: picturesareme 

On the contrary our air source has been mainly from the east and the air gin clear for some time now. I did notice the cars and windows got dirty one afternoon here from an easterly based wind a few weeks back. I thought it strange at the time but as at this time there has been no reason why this happened.

 

picturesareme
22 April 2020 23:02:39

 

On the contrary our air source has been mainly from the east and the air gin clear for some time now. I did notice the cars and windows got dirty one afternoon here from an easterly based wind a few weeks back. I thought it strange at the time but as at this time there has been no reason why this happened.

 

Originally Posted by: Phil G 

It's definitely not  been clean which would also explain the metoffice pollution levels being between medium & high lately. All the cars are covered and like i say its recent as we had an 1.5 inches of rain a few day back. 

With low pressure over the south of France and Sardinia bringing up winds from north Africa right in the path of the winds from the high.

 

Edit: there is an article in the Express about it but i refuse to use them, however asthma website also mentions it..

 

https://www.asthma.org.uk/about/media/news/asthma-uk-responds-to-saharan-dust-cloud/

 

picturesareme
22 April 2020 23:17:13
Two different cars one on each finger...

A little bit of Africa 😁

UserPostedImage 

UserPostedImage 

UserPostedImage 

AJ*
  • AJ*
  • Advanced Member
23 April 2020 08:25:00

I've noticed a lot of dust being deposited on my car windscreen, even though I've been cleaning it off occasionally.  The very dry, dusty air has been making me cough, which in the current hyper-vigilant times for Covid-19 infection, has not been a welcome symptom for me or anyone else.


Angus; one of the Kent crew on TWO.

Tonbridge, 40m (131ft) asl

Rob K
23 April 2020 08:41:59
Strange that the skies have seemed very clear when there has been this Saharan dust coming. Usually you can see a hazy dirty look to the sky when we get the dust falls.
Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

Phil G
23 April 2020 09:43:55

I've noticed a lot of dust being deposited on my car windscreen, even though I've been cleaning it off occasionally.  The very dry, dusty air has been making me cough, which in the current hyper-vigilant times for Covid-19 infection, has not been a welcome symptom for me or anyone else.

Originally Posted by: AJ* 

Is this tree pollen? Loads of it about at the moment with a lot of sneezing going on as well. Nothing to wash it away for a while now.

picturesareme
23 April 2020 11:44:16

 

Is this tree pollen? Loads of it about at the moment with a lot of sneezing going on as well. Nothing to wash it away for a while now.

Originally Posted by: Phil G 

Nope not tree pollen its dust, and there was plenty to wash it away a few days ago. See link above.

picturesareme
23 April 2020 11:49:16

Strange that the skies have seemed very clear when there has been this Saharan dust coming. Usually you can see a hazy dirty look to the sky when we get the dust falls.

Originally Posted by: Rob K 

Looking back at pictures i took yesterday i noticed that the sky wasn't actually crystal clear.. i slightly hazed look.

 

UserPostedImage 

Chunky Pea
23 April 2020 14:12:16

 

Looking back at pictures i took yesterday i noticed that the sky wasn't actually crystal clear.. i slightly hazed look.

 

UserPostedImage 

Originally Posted by: picturesareme 

Didn't realize how hazy the sky was here until I put on my sunglasses. Oddly though, visibility at the surface is pretty good. Not much haze at this level at all. 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Phil G
23 April 2020 15:27:09

First of all, I'd like to say I am against fossil fuels. Just the same as a smoker it can't be doing anyone any good. I'd much prefer a world of solar, tidal and wind power and think using magnetism is a mostly untapped 'natural resource'.

Let's think of this another way. Say in the atmosphere there has been 50% temperature warming greenhouse gasses that stay longer, much longer than other gasses which are say 30% which are gone in a very short space of time. The other gasses are responsible for global dimming.
With the reduction of air pollution, we now have a faster reduction of other gasses and is now down to say 45% gg's v 20% og's. There is a wider differential between the two hence the increase in temperature over the last two decades.

As we move on, the og's will continue to reduce faster than gg's therefore the temp will continue to rise more sharply, sharper than the increase's we are witnessing now. In a number of years time we will be down to 35% gg's as apparently they mostly stay in the atmosphere and 0% og's.

If you took all the gasses away both gg and og, we don't know what the natural earth temp would be. All we know now is they are rising more quickly as the differential between both types of gas widens.

Yes we don't live in a perfect world by far. But, is there a possibility the world might burn if we eradicate the gasses which are actually keeping the earth cooler than it should be by global dimming.

I see it there is a kind of balance there at the moment, but as we clean the air we are forcing the temperature up and we really don't know where this ceiling is.

Yes we need to reduce gg levels, but until something can be done to compensate that we will only force the temp up higher, how high we don't know.

In our quest to fight and stop levels of gg's (which apparently will be there for a very long time), we are neutralising faster the gasses that are keeping the earth cooler.

Again and forgive me if I am wrong, Greta and climate change activists do have the planet's future in mind, but they have not got the whole picture. The evidence is already there over the last two decades is that we are creating an imbalance and an increasing rise of temperatures.
We are reducing the gasses which are keeping us cooler much faster.

At this rate of air pollution reduction the world will burn. Bit of a different message that has gone out to scare the kids, but are we looking at the whole picture here? Like our bodies the earth is complex place. We still know little about our bodies and likewise the earth. What seems like the likely fix of reducing pollution might make the whole situation a lot lot worse.







Originally Posted by: Phil G 

Rob K and Tim S. Thank you for your comments and you can see I responded above. Just thought I would bump it as it has trundled up the thread, but obviously your call if wish to get back on the above post. 

picturesareme
23 April 2020 15:33:10

 

Didn't realize how hazy the sky was here until I put on my sunglasses. Oddly though, visibility at the surface is pretty good. Not much haze at this level at all. 

Originally Posted by: Chunky Pea 

Checking out car windows just now.. its pretty bad the level of dust that had accumulated over last couple days.

UserPostedImage 

 

Chunky Pea
23 April 2020 16:39:42

 

Checking out car windows just now.. its pretty bad the level of dust that had accumulated over last couple days.

UserPostedImage 

 

Originally Posted by: picturesareme 

Amazing. 

With all of that dust in the atmosphere and patchy high cloud about, perhaps a spectacular sunset to be had later on. 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

AJ*
  • AJ*
  • Advanced Member
24 April 2020 08:02:22

 

Is this tree pollen? Loads of it about at the moment with a lot of sneezing going on as well. Nothing to wash it away for a while now.

Originally Posted by: Phil G 

I think that tree pollen could be at least a constituent of it, as well as dust.  I seem to recall that when we had the heavy rain recently, here and west of here in the south of England, where you are in Essex missed most of it, which is why it hasn't been washed away there.


Angus; one of the Kent crew on TWO.

Tonbridge, 40m (131ft) asl

Phil G
24 April 2020 09:00:57

 

I think that tree pollen could be at least a constituent of it, as well as dust.  I seem to recall that when we had the heavy rain recently, here and west of here in the south of England, where you are in Essex missed most of it, which is why it hasn't been washed away there.

Originally Posted by: AJ* 

It's just about been bone dry here for six weeks. After being flooded in Jan/Feb, the garden is opening up with cracking you would see a couple of months down the line during a baron spell. The dust is pollen here!

Still no reply from Rob K and Tim S on my thoughts above why our climate has been heating faster over the last two decades (if anyone else would like to comment then in their absence, if they can!). It agrees that Greta and climate activists will change the climate with cleaner air, but not the direction she and they were thinking of!

We are currently on course to burn!

Remove ads from site