The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

tallyho_83
29 January 2020 20:00:53

I don't know if this does deserve a new thread but do feel free to delete if necessary.

I have a question... - past several winters the PV has been exceptionally strong as we all know and this winter is no exception as it has coincided with exceptionally cold stratospheric temperatures like past few winters despite occasional SSW's. Temperatures in the stratosphere over the pole have been well below normal for many winters in general. Why is this?

I am really keen to know what is the cause of such cold stratospheric temperatures - which we have seen over recent years!? Is this down to the QBO? Or does solar minimum have anything to do with this?

If not then surely whether we are in ENSO Neutral or weak El Nino, moderate beit a strong one or weak, moderate or strong La Nina, westerly or easterly QBO, solar minimum or solar max - then it wouldn't make any difference?

What causes a SSW? We all know it's a rise of 50c or so in the stratosphere within a few days but what causes this and when are we more likely to get them? During an easterly or westerly QBO?

Thanks.


Home Location - Vixen Tor Close, Okehampton, Devon (221m ASL)

---------------------------------------

Sean Moon

Magical Moon

www.magical-moon.com

ozone_aurora
29 January 2020 20:46:03

Bookmarked this, as I like to know, too.

tallyho_83
29 January 2020 21:29:47

Bookmarked this, as I like to know, too.

Originally Posted by: ozone_aurora 

Ok so this was what i thought!

So no matter what stage the topical SST's are in, no matter what QBO we are in or whether or not we are at solar min or solar max, negative AO or NAO etc - if THE temperatures in the stratosphere are exceptionally colder than average causing a strong PV then this will over ride everything!?

As for what causes a cold stratosphere and what causes a SSW is unknown then? -

There is nothing that can contribute to a SSW or cold stratosphere or SSC - Sudden stratospheric cooling!? - (Just made that up!).

 


Home Location - Vixen Tor Close, Okehampton, Devon (221m ASL)

---------------------------------------

Sean Moon

Magical Moon

www.magical-moon.com

lanky
29 January 2020 22:08:26

For SSW's I came across this reference which I found informative and worth a quick look

https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/earth-and-planetary-sciences/sudden-stratospheric-warming


Martin

Richmond, Surrey

lanky
29 January 2020 22:31:20

On the subject on a colder stratosphere (not just in polar regions) I think I'm right in thinking that as the troposphere warms up thanks to increased CO2 that there is a compensating cooling at higher altitudes as more of the energy radiated back to space is absorbed at lower levels and that the whole system needs to stay "in balance" from an energy in/out point of view

I have no idea of the magnitude of this effect or whether there are other (perhaps more significant) factors at work too

 


Martin

Richmond, Surrey

tallyho_83
29 January 2020 23:45:35

For SSW's I came across this reference which I found informative and worth a quick look

https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/earth-and-planetary-sciences/sudden-stratospheric-warming

Originally Posted by: lanky 

Thanks

I found this article informative as well:

https://www.forbes.com/sites/startswithabang/2019/01/30/this-is-why-global-warming-is-responsible-for-freezing-temperatures-across-the-usa/#3f6b8001d8cf

and this from Met Office:

https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/weather/learn-about/weather/types-of-weather/wind/sudden-stratospheric-warming

Again still no link between frequent or infrequent occurrence of a SSW during solar minimum or westerly or easterly QBO. etc. 

 


Home Location - Vixen Tor Close, Okehampton, Devon (221m ASL)

---------------------------------------

Sean Moon

Magical Moon

www.magical-moon.com

John S2
30 January 2020 00:51:58
I don't have the links readily to hand, but my recollection is that there has been research showing:

1) Winter PV tends to be stronger during westerly QBO compared with easterly QBO

2) Winter PV tends to be weaker during El Nino events [I believe this is more marked in the second half of winter, but don't have a link]

3) SSW frequency is greater during El Nino events compared to La Nina state

4) SSW frequency is greater during easterly QBO compared with westerly QBO

Several commentators are blaming the very strong +IOD event for 'ruining' winter 2019/20, and I believe there has been research showing a correlation between +IOD events and +NAO

tallyho_83
30 January 2020 02:08:53

I don't have the links readily to hand, but my recollection is that there has been research showing:
1) Winter PV tends to be stronger during westerly QBO compared with easterly QBO
2) Winter PV tends to be weaker during El Nino events [I believe this is more marked in the second half of winter, but don't have a link]
3) SSW frequency is greater during El Nino events compared to La Nina state
4) SSW frequency is greater during easterly QBO compared with westerly QBO
Several commentators are blaming the very strong +IOD event for 'ruining' winter 2019/20, and I believe there has been research showing a correlation between +IOD events and +NAO

Originally Posted by: John S2 

Thanks John - very interesting ,

Your first and second points I agree with and i am sure you're correct. But 3rd and 4th I am unsure!?

Winter 2018/19 we were in a strengthening westerly QBO and had a SSW end December 2019 and in winter of 2017/18 we had a SSW around 2nd week of Feb and we were in a LA Nina albeit weak one BUT it was a designated a La Nina - which as we all know lead to the 'beast from the east' two - three weeks after. Also in during the super El Nino in 2015/16 we never saw a SSW. So - I do wonder if it's luck as well?

Re solar min - it seems like there is no connection or link between what stage of the solar cycle we are in and frequencies of SSW from developing what I understand then!?

What is really evident is that the whole of not just Europe but N. America has had a mild winter? now this is very rare and all cold air has been bottled up in Alaska and Canadian Arctic, Iceland and Greenland ETC!! Also, Russia - esp western Russia as you may know has been exceptionally mild this winter and is set to stay that way. 

It's just so rare to see it so milder than average in both continents (both sides of Atlantic and for not weeks but months on end!?

I dare to think what summer will hold - both summer 2018 & 2019 was exceptionally hot over many parts of Europe , esp the nights too. I hate sticky hot humid uncomfortably warm nights.

Anyway! - I digress. Thanks for your input.

 


Home Location - Vixen Tor Close, Okehampton, Devon (221m ASL)

---------------------------------------

Sean Moon

Magical Moon

www.magical-moon.com

jhall
30 January 2020 10:48:26

I don't have the links readily to hand, but my recollection is that there has been research showing:
1) Winter PV tends to be stronger during westerly QBO compared with easterly QBO
2) Winter PV tends to be weaker during El Nino events [I believe this is more marked in the second half of winter, but don't have a link]
3) SSW frequency is greater during El Nino events compared to La Nina state
4) SSW frequency is greater during easterly QBO compared with westerly QBO
Several commentators are blaming the very strong +IOD event for 'ruining' winter 2019/20, and I believe there has been research showing a correlation between +IOD events and +NAO

Originally Posted by: John S2 

I'm familiar with PV and QBO, but what's IOD?


Cranleigh, Surrey
Stormchaser
30 January 2020 11:42:41

On the subject on a colder stratosphere (not just in polar regions) I think I'm right in thinking that as the troposphere warms up thanks to increased CO2 that there is a compensating cooling at higher altitudes as more of the energy radiated back to space is absorbed at lower levels and that the whole system needs to stay "in balance" from an energy in/out point of view

I have no idea of the magnitude of this effect or whether there are other (perhaps more significant) factors at work too

 

Originally Posted by: lanky 

This is the accepted reason for the cooler stratosphere tendency.

It's a really interesting situation actually, because there is also increasing energy in the troposphere with which to assault the stratospheric vortex, whenever the tropospheric wave patterns align correctly.


This leads me to anticipate an increase in dramatic strength changes in the polar vortex, regardless of any technical SSW occurrence, during winters with conducive tropical forcing for wave-driven stratospheric warming.

A more volatile, harder to predict state of affairs .


If you have any problems or queries relating to TWO you can Email [email protected]

https://twitter.com/peacockreports 

2025's Homeland Extremes:

T-Max: 32.0°C 12th Aug | T-Min: -5.4°C 4th Jan | Wettest Day: 31.8 mm 18th Dec | Ice Days: None

Keep Calm and Forecast On

Rob K
30 January 2020 11:46:37
There have been plenty of extreme cold outbreaks in North America, and east Asia, in recent winters, and the US media have been talking about how the jet stream is becoming more meandering, which allows both record mild incursions to the north and corresponding cold incursions to the south. My question would be why none of these meanders ever seem to allow cold to flood south over the UK? Will it be our turn one year or is there some other forcing (eg stronger Azores high) that is stopping it?
Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

John S2
30 January 2020 14:12:59

 

I'm familiar with PV and QBO, but what's IOD?

Originally Posted by: jhall 

A couple of articles that may be of interest re the IOD:

1) http://www.bom.gov.au/climate/enso/history/ln-2010-12/IOD-what.shtml

2) https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-50602971

Scandy 1050 MB
30 January 2020 16:30:02

There have been plenty of extreme cold outbreaks in North America, and east Asia, in recent winters, and the US media have been talking about how the jet stream is becoming more meandering, which allows both record mild incursions to the north and corresponding cold incursions to the south. My question would be why none of these meanders ever seem to allow cold to flood south over the UK? Will it be our turn one year or is there some other forcing (eg stronger Azores high) that is stopping it?

Originally Posted by: Rob K 

Good point, I think what is different this year is that Eastern America has been warm and it's Western America that has been cold at times - is this due to the decreasing SST's off the coast of Alaska?  Is this area of warmer water which in recent years seems to reinforce a persistent area of high pressure also responsible in some way for the colder stratosphere temperatures?  It seems to be weakening now so should be interesting next Winter and also the state of the polar vortex, certainly overdue a period of a weaker PV. 

jhall
30 January 2020 16:40:11

 

A couple of articles that may be of interest re the IOD:

1) http://www.bom.gov.au/climate/enso/history/ln-2010-12/IOD-what.shtml

2) https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-50602971

Originally Posted by: John S2 

Thanks. So it seems to be similar in nature to ENSO, but centred on the Indian Ocean rather than the Pacific.


Cranleigh, Surrey
Whether Idle
31 January 2020 19:09:44

There have been plenty of extreme cold outbreaks in North America, and east Asia, in recent winters, and the US media have been talking about how the jet stream is becoming more meandering, which allows both record mild incursions to the north and corresponding cold incursions to the south. My question would be why none of these meanders ever seem to allow cold to flood south over the UK? Will it be our turn one year or is there some other forcing (eg stronger Azores high) that is stopping it?

Originally Posted by: Rob K 

That sums things up well.  And yes, the AH is strong these days


Dover, 5m asl. Half a mile from the south coast.

Remove ads from site