The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

Gandalf The White
06 December 2019 20:11:30

Once again its a mild looking picture with all wintry potential pegged back in the realms of 192-240 hours. This is where it stays.

Cold zonality at 240 becomes Cool zonality at 192 and normal zonality at 144.

I use 144 hours as a case in point. Just two or three days ago this was the period of huge wintry potential...and before I get told it wasn't....it was  The period 9 -15th was looking cold.

Now we have...on the day of the election day snow storm the following...

 

 

 This may not be popular with some but we need to be realistic here. The cold is being etched away as we reach the reliable. 

No doubt the latest ECM 240 hour carrot dangler will provide some comment though. Something new to follow before its demise at 144 hours.

Originally Posted by: Gusty 

Steve, that's all very well but this is the model output discussion thread and you seem to be saying that comment is invałid because the output will change.

I agree that commenting on operational charts many days ahead without caveats is unwise but it wasn't just one run or one model.  As for your comment about the Election Day snowstorm, that was indeed just one chart from one model and I'd be surprised if anyone took it seriously at that range.

This would be a very quiet and less interesting place if comments were restricted to the reliable timeframe.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



Gusty
06 December 2019 20:12:51

 Even assuming that the chart is wrong it surely shows how widely snow will have fallen at that point in northern parts (not here)?

There is no spin from me to say “the outlook is wintry” (as it is not) and I have been insistent and consistent in that message.

However there is potential for wintry precipitation in the north with elevation, whether it coincides with Election Day is still at this range uncertain. It certainly looks incredibly unlikely in the south and has never been shown for here. Depending on the timing of the storms/Lows it is possible some elevated parts of the NW will see snow, if not on the day but the day before or after. Not disruptive and possibly not even settling. My point is that it is not a generally unrelenting mild outlook, not that is is a wintry one as that would be inaccurate and misleadingly. Surely that is not hype or ramping? 

Overall it looks a bit cooler than average up north and maybe a bit above down south?

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

Thanks. 

One of these days we will all be gobsmacked when an upgrade to wintry potential occurs between 240 and 144. 


Steve - Folkestone, Kent

Current conditions from my Davis Vantage Vue

https://www.wunderground.com/dashboard/pws/IFOLKE11 

Join Kent Weather on Facebook.

https://www.facebook.com/stevewall69/ 



doctormog
06 December 2019 20:14:33

 

Thanks. 

One of these days we will all be gobsmacked when an upgrade to wintry potential occurs between 240 and 144. 

Originally Posted by: Gusty 

No, because it will be followed by a downgrade between 144hr and 00hr. 


Bertwhistle
06 December 2019 21:00:32

I've started to measure uncertainty in ensemble spreads by how far the projected modelled mean for the period deviates from the LT mean.

In the 12z GEFS suite the two are practically superimposed from the 18th. That to me says total uncertainty. From the 12th the deviation is within a couple of degrees. This suggests significant uncertainty to me at that range. If there was a greater range, say 3-4 degrees, it might look more interesting.

Within that 5 or 6 day outlook there are all the normal healthy peaks and troughs, with differences and matches in the two, as might be expected. So what I am going to keep an eye out for is an increasing deviation at the longer range. A disbalance in clustering.

No chart available for the selected hour. Many charts start at 3 hours ahead, so if you have 0 hours selected try stepping forward or selecting a later hour.


Bertie, Itchen Valley.

Retire while you can still press the 'retire now' button.

johncs2016
06 December 2019 23:13:35
Towards the end of November, I posted a comment on here which suggested that once the cold spell which we were experiencing then was over, I wouldn't then be surprised if that was it for our winter. One or two replies to that suggested that what I posted then might have set a new record for the earliest ever "winter is over" post.

Yet if you dismiss the fact that we had a very brief cold and frosty, but dry period which ran into the very first day of this month here and slightly longer than that down south, I have to say that up until now, I am largely being proved correct on that front. The last day or so in particular has been ridiculously mild here, but this is something which happens at around this time of every single year without fail.

Furthermore, we have that same old model output which we see every single year, which shows promises of colder weather in the unreliable timetable even to the point of showing phantom northerlies and/or easterlies and/or Greenland/Scandi Highs only for all of that to then disappear once we get into the more reliable time frame.

Now, there are three methods of determining what any coming winter or summer might be like. The first of these is the seasonal model output and we know how unreliable that can be at times. The second of these methods is the use of analogues which is what Gavin P. makes quite a lot of use of in his seasonal updates and forecasts in conjunction with the.seasonal model output.

However, there is a third method in play here which is known as sheer persistence. This means that if the same old conditions keep on happening every single year without fail during any given season, we can be almost certain that this will then happen again in the following upcoming season and although I might not actually have any hard evidence or data to support that, the fact the fact that these same conditions are almost certain to occur during the following upcoming season as well, then makes that almost as good in that regard, as having actual hard evidence to support that.

That third method is what I have spotted in relation to this so-called "Winter" and so, that is what I used to predict how that is likely to pan out. So far, I am seeing to nothing to suggest that I have been wrong with that in any way.


The north of Edinburgh, usually always missing out on snow events which occur not just within the rest of Scotland or the UK, but also within the rest of Edinburgh.

SJV
07 December 2019 00:04:52
Christ I typed up a response to this ridiculous post somehow self-proving a 'winter is over' post after six (yes six!) days of winter, but couldn't be arsed as it will fall upon deaf ears. Seriously John, wtf dude - your third point is complete nonsense and has no scientific basis whatsoever!

Gandalf The White
07 December 2019 00:30:53

Towards the end of November, I posted a comment on here which suggested that once the cold spell which we were experiencing then was over, I wouldn't then be surprised if that was it for our winter. One or two replies to that suggested that what I posted then might have set a new record for the earliest ever "winter is over" post.

Yet if you dismiss the fact that we had a very brief cold and frosty, but dry period which ran into the very first day of this month here and slightly longer than that down south, I have to say that up until now, I am largely being proved correct on that front. The last day or so in particular has been ridiculously mild here, but this is something which happens at around this time of every single year without fail.

Furthermore, we have that same old model output which we see every single year, which shows promises of colder weather in the unreliable timetable even to the point of showing phantom northerlies and/or easterlies and/or Greenland/Scandi Highs only for all of that to then disappear once we get into the more reliable time frame.

Now, there are three methods of determining what any coming winter or summer might be like. The first of these is the seasonal model output and we know how unreliable that can be at times. The second of these methods is the use of analogues which is what Gavin P. makes quite a lot of use of in his seasonal updates and forecasts in conjunction with the.seasonal model output.

However, there is a third method in play here which is known as sheer persistence. This means that if the same old conditions keep on happening every single year without fail during any given season, we can be almost certain that this will then happen again in the following upcoming season and although I might not actually have any hard evidence or data to support that, the fact the fact that these same conditions are almost certain to occur during the following upcoming season as well, then makes that almost as good in that regard, as having actual hard evidence to support that.

That third method is what I have spotted in relation to this so-called "Winter" and so, that is what I used to predict how that is likely to pan out. So far, I am seeing to nothing to suggest that I have been wrong with that in any way.

Originally Posted by: johncs2016 

This thread is supposed to be for model output discussion; it’s not a winter morning thread.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



David M Porter
07 December 2019 00:34:54

Christ I typed up a response to this ridiculous post somehow self-proving a 'winter is over' post after six (yes six!) days of winter, but couldn't be arsed as it will fall upon deaf ears. Seriously John, wtf dude - your third point is complete nonsense and has no scientific basis whatsoever!

Originally Posted by: SJV 

I would add, and also with the greatest of respect to John, that his post above is not based on any rational analysis of the current model output either.

As GTW has alluded to, it would IMO be an idea for people to make use of the winter moaning thread, for example, if they want to indulge in doom-mongering and trying to read the last rites on this winter (even that that is rather pointless and silly given the very early stage in the season we are in) instead of filling up this thread with such nonsense.


Lenzie, Glasgow

"A body of men holding themselves accountable to nobody ought not to be trusted by anybody." – Thomas Paine

johncs2016
07 December 2019 00:44:18

 

This thread is supposed to be for model output discussion; it’s not a winter morning thread.

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

My apologies, but I thought that this was what I was discussing here.

This wasn't actually a moan in any way, and was merely just predicting what I thought, would happen during this winter based on how the models generally normally behave at this time of the year.

Because of that, I therefore believe that my very mention of the model output here makes my very excellent post which you have just referred to here, just as relevant as other posts here which are considered to be on topic and which you yourself, would refer to as being "excellent" posts.

However, I am not here to argue with you on this point and will therefore agree to disagree with you on this occasion, and leave it at that.

 


The north of Edinburgh, usually always missing out on snow events which occur not just within the rest of Scotland or the UK, but also within the rest of Edinburgh.

Gandalf The White
07 December 2019 01:03:11

 

My apologies, but I thought that this was what I was discussing here.

This wasn't actually a moan in any way, and was merely just predicting what I thought, would happen during this winter based on how the models generally normally behave at this time of the year.

Because of that, I therefore believe that my very mention of the model output here makes my very excellent post which you have just referred to here, just as relevant as other posts here which are considered to be on topic and which you yourself, would refer to as being "excellent" posts.

However, I am not here to argue with you on this point and will therefore agree to disagree with you on this occasion, and leave it at that.

 

Originally Posted by: johncs2016 

hi This isn’t about agreeing or disagreeing; it’s simply that your post is not commenting on any of the current model output.

 
Merely sharing your idiosyncratic thoughts about the coming weather doesn’t meet the criteria, does it?

 


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



johncs2016
07 December 2019 01:27:32

 

hi This isn’t about agreeing or disagreeing; it’s simply that your post is not commenting on any of the current model output.

 
Merely sharing your idiosyncratic thoughts about the coming weather doesn’t meet the criteria, does it?

 

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

Again, I will agree to disagree on that one. I am proud of what I posted and am will continue to stand by it, regardless of what you tell me because at the end of the day, I couldn't care less about what your criteria is.

If a mod then comes on here and warns me about being off topic as a result, he/she will then have to ban me from this forum as this will show that the official definition of what is deemed as off-topic is in complete conflict with what I see as being off-topic and so, I would not therefore be willing to agree to the terms and conditions for this forum as a result.

 


The north of Edinburgh, usually always missing out on snow events which occur not just within the rest of Scotland or the UK, but also within the rest of Edinburgh.

tallyho_83
07 December 2019 01:54:15



Furthermore, we have that same old model output which we see every single year, which shows promises of colder weather in the unreliable timetable even to the point of showing phantom northerlies and/or easterlies and/or Greenland/Scandi Highs only for all of that to then disappear once we get into the more reliable time frame.



Originally Posted by: johncs2016 

Totally agree with that!!

Models keep chopping and changing and I do wonder when a northerly or say a cold easterly shows up at say post +240hrs will ever come about when the reliable time frame comes into action!!?

This must be a nightmare for meteorologists so I do wonder if we are relying too much on short term and longer term seasonal models to issue forecasts? 

Maybe during the Beast from the east in Feb/March 2018 we were lucky but again models were late to pick up on this and seasonal models never picked up on this short but sharp 5 to 7 day cold spell and the cold spell two weeks later between 13th and 20th March 2018!? From what I recall?? Maybe, we do need a SSW after all? But then again December 2010's freezing cold spell occurred without a SSW!? 


Home Location - Vixen Tor Close, Okehampton, Devon (221m ASL)

---------------------------------------

Sean Moon

Magical Moon

www.magical-moon.com

DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
07 December 2019 07:23:46

This must be a nightmare for meteorologists so I do wonder if we are relying too much on short term and longer term seasonal models to issue forecasts? 

Originally Posted by: tallyho_83 

UK Weather is chaotic in nature - that's what makes weather watching interesting

Nil desperandum; this is what's on offer this morning.

GFS 0z less stormy than yesterday but still wild for week 1: cold plunge on Monday long forecast and nailed on, deep LP off N Scotland Fri 13th (Wed's LP has faded since yesterday); a zonal sort of flow for week 2 some not very deep LP running N of Scotland; deep LP in central Atlantic on Thu 19th pumping up a southerly flow which [new!] becomes well established by Sun 22nd with 1025mb over the Balkans. That last bit not good news for fans of a traditional winter - but it's suspect because of its sudden appearance and could well not be there tomorrow.

Jetstream running across the UK for week 1, then increasingly looping, first dipping S in the Atlantic to give a SW flow over UK and by the end of week 2, disappearing S to the Med

ECM retains the midweek storm (955mb off Norway) and delays the Fi storm to Sat, and closer (955mb in N Sea)

Ens temps = a couple of short-lived dips 9th & 12th, then no good agreement but closer to average than a week back and a signal for well above normal from 20th. Wet 11th -19th then drier at least in SE.

Big pattern change around 19th - 20th. Will it happen?


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

roadrunnerajn
07 December 2019 07:34:58
Yes, Brian will love the Bartlet stage pressure rise over Europe. We all know what that leads too... flooding in the NW, dull and mild in the south.

As Dew says it could change as it’s two weeks out but my gut is not convinced. In the last couple of days both the ens and GFS have showed a rise of pressure in the continent.


Germoe, part of the breakaway Celtic Republic. 80m asl
Brian Gaze
07 December 2019 07:50:41

The GEFS 384 postage stamps are dreadful this morning with the key theme being high pressure building from the south. Although some could lead to calm and cold weather the most likely scenario is a mild southwesterly flow in most of the UK. 

 


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

doctormog
07 December 2019 08:10:40

With so much volatility in the weather in coming days I will leave the discussion of the charts for late December to others.

The upcoming week has an almost “traditional winter storminess” about it and the first storm moves in tomorrow. Strong winds will affect many areas with showers or longer spells of rain impacting the west especially. As the system clears on Monday it will briefly drag down some colder air, enough to turn showers in northernmost parts wintry.

Beyond that it remains a very unsettled picture, with winds prevailing from a westerly quarter and quite deep low pressure to the NNW it will be very blustery at times with no shortage of rain and temperatures fluctuating a bit although maybe nothing notable. Changes to the details are inevitable  on a daily basis in such a setup.


Rob K
07 December 2019 08:11:49

 

😂😂

had to laugh at the Iceland comment. Shows us all the fickle nature of model watching. Still, at least it shows The Express for the gutter rag that it is with its predictions of snowmageddon. 

Originally Posted by: JACKO4EVER 

I’m sure they’ll find some pictures of snow on a mountain pass in Scotland and claim they were right. 

Also I have noticed a strange trend in here for people to equate commenting on wintry looking long-range charts with somehow believing they will come to fruition. This is the model output discussion thread. Why shouldn’t we discuss them? We all know that anything out of the ordinary, be it very cold or very hot, appearing beyond 120hrs (or less!) is unlikely actually to happen. Doesn’t mean we shouldn’t talk about the charts, surely?


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

marting
07 December 2019 08:14:48

There continue to be signs of a rise in pressure to the north circa FI in about 9/10 days as per ECM today. Plus the odd Scandinavia high out further. Just some straws to clutch onto. 
martin


Martin

Greasby, Wirral.

Gandalf The White
07 December 2019 08:16:01

Yes, Brian will love the Bartlet stage pressure rise over Europe. We all know what that leads too... flooding in the NW, dull and mild in the south.
As Dew says it could change as it’s two weeks out but my gut is not convinced. In the last couple of days both the ens and GFS have showed a rise of pressure in the continent.

Originally Posted by: roadrunnerajn 

That is not a Bartlett pattern.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



Shropshire
07 December 2019 08:24:17

There continue to be signs of a rise in pressure to the north circa FI in about 9/10 days as per ECM today. Plus the odd Scandinavia high out further. Just some straws to clutch onto. 
martin

Originally Posted by: marting 

It's a very poor picture this morning, and as Brian has shown the longer range GFS is all about HP to the South.

 


From December 27th 2020, zonality will be banned from mixing with the UK. We appreciate that this may come as a shock to younger people and old Uncle Barty. This ban will last for a minimum of ten days.
White Meadows
07 December 2019 08:29:58

 

It's a very poor picture this morning, and as Brian has shown the longer range GFS is all about HP to the South.

 

Originally Posted by: Shropshire 

Watch it change all over again on the 06z ...do you ever learn?

doctormog
07 December 2019 08:31:12

Yes, Brian will love the Bartlet stage pressure rise over Europe. We all know what that leads too... flooding in the NW, dull and mild in the south.
As Dew says it could change as it’s two weeks out but my gut is not convinced. In the last couple of days both the ens and GFS have showed a rise of pressure in the continent.

Originally Posted by: roadrunnerajn 

As GtW says it isn’t a “Bartlett High” scenario. That aside, the weather in the next few days looks much more interesting (I won’t use the word pleasant” in your area especially.


marting
07 December 2019 08:31:27

The ECM ensembles are a lot more confident (tightly packed) than the GFS today. It will be interesting to review these in a few days to see how they progress. The GFS throwing up a real mix at 384 hours and not just mild.

martin


Martin

Greasby, Wirral.

Shropshire
07 December 2019 08:34:26

Watch it change all over again on the 06z ...do you ever learn?

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

The theme hasn't changed for days since the idea of a plungng jet was dropped by the models - as I predicted it would be. We are looking at zonality in the short and mid term with the potential for something very mild later on.


From December 27th 2020, zonality will be banned from mixing with the UK. We appreciate that this may come as a shock to younger people and old Uncle Barty. This ban will last for a minimum of ten days.
Gusty
07 December 2019 08:47:29

 The theme hasn't changed for days since the idea of a plungng jet was dropped by the models - as I predicted it would be. We are looking at zonality in the short and mid term with the potential for something very mild later on.

Originally Posted by: Shropshire 

A good call and in line with what the professionals are forecasting. The signal for a wet and mild month was strong. I suspect the CET will finish above average if this new signal to build high pressure from the south emerges and we tap into long fetch SW'lies.

I wonder if we will experience a blow torch Christmas. THey have been fairly common in the tens. 

 


Steve - Folkestone, Kent

Current conditions from my Davis Vantage Vue

https://www.wunderground.com/dashboard/pws/IFOLKE11 

Join Kent Weather on Facebook.

https://www.facebook.com/stevewall69/ 



Remove ads from site