The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

ktaylor
  • ktaylor
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
31 October 2019 08:04:31

I was always told when there is alot of of berries on the Holly Bush we would be in for a bad winter. So yesterday there was one smothered in berries. Are sayings like this myths or fact? Does anyone have any good ones. 


Come on you spurs

Save ryarsh stop the quarry

https://www.ryarshprotectiongroup.com 

Roger Parsons
31 October 2019 08:14:28

I was always told when there is alot of of berries on the Holly Bush we would be in for a bad winter. So yesterday there was one smothered in berries. Are sayings like this myths or fact? Does anyone have any good ones. 

Originally Posted by: ktaylor 

Myths like this could only be true if time travel existed, KT.  Fruiting reflects past environmental conditions.  Having said that, past environmental conditions may also favour particular meterological consequences, but we are all familiar with the difficulties of long term forecasting based on limited data.  I do not accept a holly bush is cleverer than TWO readers. Well, most.... 

Roger


RogerP

West Lindsey district of Lincolnshire

Everything taken together, here in Lincolnshire are more good things than man could have had the conscience to ask.

William Cobbett, in his Rural Rides - c.1830

DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
31 October 2019 10:08:13

Last year there were more berries on the holly trees from the New Forest up to Surrey than I ever remember seeing. And if we had a winter, then I missed it!


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

Roger Parsons
31 October 2019 19:20:45

Last year there were more berries on the holly trees from the New Forest up to Surrey than I ever remember seeing. And if we had a winter, then I missed it!

Originally Posted by: DEW 

An excellent example of my argument, DEW.  Good conditions for insects = good conditions for pollination. Good conditions for photosynthesis = good conditions for fruit development and ripening.  Here's the scientific question: How often, if ever, does a "good berry year" predict a really cold winter? Or perhaps a "bad berry year" signal a mild winter ahead?  Occam's Razor says any apparent link is down to chance alone.

Roger


RogerP

West Lindsey district of Lincolnshire

Everything taken together, here in Lincolnshire are more good things than man could have had the conscience to ask.

William Cobbett, in his Rural Rides - c.1830

westv
31 October 2019 19:30:32
Bill Foggitt wòuld have known!
roadrunnerajn
31 October 2019 19:42:08
One of my favourites....

“It’s too cold to snow.”

My take is this-

In winter we get very cold conditions under high pressure which usually produce clear, cold and dry conditions. Hence it’s too cold to snow.

When the Atlantic systems eventually move in from the west we get snow as the temperatures rise.


Germoe, part of the breakaway Celtic Republic. 80m asl
Saint Snow
31 October 2019 19:43:53

 

An excellent example of my argument, DEW.  Good conditions for insects = good conditions for pollination. Good conditions for photosynthesis = good conditions for fruit development and ripening.  Here's the scientific question: How often, if ever, does a "good berry year" predict a really cold winter? Or perhaps a "bad berry year" signal a mild winter ahead?  Occam's Razor says any apparent link is down to chance alone.

Roger

Originally Posted by: Roger Parsons 

 

One would think these sayings have *some* basis in fact or they'd not become widely known.

Perhaps it derives from repeating weather patterns creating two scenarios across 2/3 seasons.


Martin

Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)

A TWO addict since 14/12/01

"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."

Aneurin Bevan

scillydave
31 October 2019 19:59:23
There are sayings though that do work in terms of weather lore. The best known would be 'Red sky at night, Shepherd's delight, red sky in the morning, Shepherd's warning'. This is because a red sky generally indicates a high pressure system which traps dust and small particles high in the atmosphere, these scatter the blue light making the sky look red. Because our weather systems generally move west to east a red sky to the west night generally indicates fine weather via the high pressure system to come.

Another less well known one is 'Swallows flying low, rain and a blow. Swallows flying high, fine and dry.' Again there is a good bit of truth in this one as well - when humidity and/or the wind gets up then insects which the Swallows feed on stay low to the ground. Increasing humidity and/or wind often are precursors to rain and poor weather. Conversely when the weather is settled and calm insects reach much greater heights as do the Swallows that seek them as their prey.

Another good one is 'Mare's tails and Mackerel's scales make Tall ships carry low sails.' The Mare's tails are cirrus clouds which shaped by high winds and can signal an approaching front. The Mackerel scales are cirrocumulus being shaped by different winds and are a classic sign of an approaching front.

There are many more both true and false but I think that they're all fascinating nonetheless especially as we've started to lose quite a few as a country as people rely on the forecasts.


Currently living at roughly 65m asl North of Cowbridge in the Vale of Glamorgan.

Formerly of, Birdlip, highest village in the Cotswolds and snow heaven in winter; Hawkinge in Kent - roof of the South downs and Isles of Scilly, paradise in the UK.

Roger Parsons
31 October 2019 21:20:34

One would think these sayings have *some* basis in fact or they'd not become widely known.

Perhaps it derives from repeating weather patterns creating two scenarios across 2/3 seasons.

Originally Posted by: Saint Snow 

Post hoc, propter hoc is not Science!  Observation serves to generate questions and hypotheses.  Science starts when you predict and then obtain data to show how close you were to the actual outcome.  So here's a prediction.  Based on the bountiful production of berries this year - an observation which we can probably agree upon - we predict there will be an exceptionally  [=above average] cold winter ahead.  If there is, we can suggest there is a link between heavy berry years and cold subsequent winters, and say that berry yields can be good predictors of the weather ahead.

Roger


RogerP

West Lindsey district of Lincolnshire

Everything taken together, here in Lincolnshire are more good things than man could have had the conscience to ask.

William Cobbett, in his Rural Rides - c.1830

Bertwhistle
31 October 2019 22:14:02

Red sky

 

Shepherd's pie.


Bertie, Itchen Valley.

Retire while you can still press the 'retire now' button.

DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
01 November 2019 07:38:39

 

One would think these sayings have *some* basis in fact or they'd not become widely known.

Perhaps it derives from repeating weather patterns creating two scenarios across 2/3 seasons.

Originally Posted by: Saint Snow 

It's part of human psychology to search for patterns, not infrequently being too good at it and seeing a pattern which isn't there -plus the religious beliefs which predict that a Creator provides a bountiful harvest for his creation in advance of a hard winter.

But, as Roger says, it's more reliable to set up your predictions and then test them, not to try and work with hindsight.

Some which verify:
Red sky etc (as discussed)
Mackerel sky and mares' tails /make loftyships to carry low sails (approach of depression)
Rain before 7, fine before 11 (works for typical passage of weather front)
Clouds moving against the wind betokens rain (typical of wind shear in thundery weather)
When the wind is in the east / tis neither good for man nor beast (except cold rampers)


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

AJ*
  • AJ*
  • Advanced Member
01 November 2019 08:01:54

scillydave's post reminds me of a weather saying that I think is accurate, but I'm not sure of the reasoning which might support it.

'Mackerel sky, mackerel sky, not long wet and not long dry' - a prediction of showery weather.


Angus; one of the Kent crew on TWO.

Tonbridge, 40m (131ft) asl

Roger Parsons
01 November 2019 08:22:18

scillydave's post reminds me of a weather saying that I think is accurate, but I'm not sure of the reasoning which might support it.

'Mackerel sky, mackerel sky, not long wet and not long dry' - a prediction of showery weather.

Originally Posted by: AJ* 

Well AJ, one might expect meteorologists and those whose work depends on weather conditions to be able to associate specific weather evidence with actual weather outcome - it would be bizarre if they could not.  However, all will know it can be an inexact exercise.  Human memory is a fickle research tool - most folks don't write down such weather observations, even when they corroborate the folk lore, still less if they don't.

Here's a null hypothesis: No folk lore weather prediction is more accurate than a random prediction would be.

Roger

 

p.s. Googling for research evidence on this discussion I found this pleasant and useful website. Enjoy.

https://www.naturalnavigator.com/the-library/weather-lore/

R


RogerP

West Lindsey district of Lincolnshire

Everything taken together, here in Lincolnshire are more good things than man could have had the conscience to ask.

William Cobbett, in his Rural Rides - c.1830

Sharp Green Fox
01 November 2019 17:22:03

One of my favourites....
“It’s too cold to snow.”

My take is this-
In winter we get very cold conditions under high pressure which usually produce clear, cold and dry conditions. Hence it’s too cold to snow.
When the Atlantic systems eventually move in from the west we get snow as the temperatures rise.

Originally Posted by: roadrunnerajn 

Yes. Explaining this to friends, colleagues and relatives over the years has driven me mad when they don't understand the reasons.  If it was too cold to snow why has the Arctic got snow is my last resort.

richardabdn
02 November 2019 10:08:49

The biggest myth has to be that the UK has a changeable climate. What a joke. Nowadays it's just the same misery day in day out.

Weather was far more changeable in Cyprus than it ever is here now and there was more interesting weather in a fotnight than in over a year here 


Aberdeen: The only place that misses out on everything

2023 - The Year that's Constantly Worse than a Bad November

2024 - 2023 without the Good Bits

2025 - The Weekend Curse hell intensifies

Remove ads from site