The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

idj20
09 August 2019 23:36:58

Or it seems that the general public now lack common sense but expect to be spoon fed the most accurate forecast for their back yard BBQ right down to the minute from a week away, and yet information overload can be just as much of a problem as a lack of it.

At the end of the day, weather forecasts - be it in the form of warnings or just standard forecasts - are only for guidance. Nothing more, nothing less. 


Home location: Folkestone Harbour.
Caz
  • Caz
  • Advanced Member
10 August 2019 05:05:22

Or it seems that the general public now lack common sense but expect to be spoon fed the most accurate forecast for their back yard BBQ right down to the minute from a week away, and yet information overload can be just as much of a problem as a lack of it.

At the end of the day, weather forecasts - be it in the form of warnings or just standard forecasts - are only for guidance. Nothing more, nothing less. 

Originally Posted by: idj20 

Exactly Ian!  People are blinkered into only seeing their own locality and selective about what they hear and read.  Forecasts are about probability, not statements of fact and should be taken as guidance.

As DEW says, forecasts and warnings generally relate to ‘some risk locally’ rather than ‘this will happen universally’.  We’ve had quite a number of warnings here this summer and few have really applied to my back yard. Neighbouring Lincolnshire and Derbyshire have had severe flooding, while we remained dry but a shift in the weather of fifty miles or so would have been a different story. 

You’d expect people with a weather interest to understand all this.  We know forecasts are projections of probability that rely on conditions falling into place.  We know that conditions vary across the country and we know weather patterns can change.  Yet we still complain if they don’t verify in our own back yards. 


Market Warsop, North Nottinghamshire.

Join the fun and banter of the monthly CET competition.

Roger Parsons
10 August 2019 05:14:35

Or it seems that the general public now lack common sense but expect to be spoon fed the most accurate forecast for their back yard BBQ right down to the minute from a week away, and yet information overload can be just as much of a problem as a lack of it.

At the end of the day, weather forecasts - be it in the form of warnings or just standard forecasts - are only for guidance. Nothing more, nothing less. 

Originally Posted by: idj20 

Correct, Ian - it seems Common Sense is a rare commodity, but a lot of this nonsense stems from our litigious compensation culture. Today everyone organising an event has a duty of care which requires us to have taken reasonable steps to consider the risks and address them, and to be able to show this has been done.

I have always considered it a good thing for children to learn to deal with risk, because if they can't do risky things safely they are less likely to live safely. It is a survival skill. A life skill. Risk-taking well handled can be fun.

As Arthur Ransome puts it: "Better drowned than duffers if not duffers wont drown."

Roger


RogerP

West Lindsey district of Lincolnshire

Everything taken together, here in Lincolnshire are more good things than man could have had the conscience to ask.

William Cobbett, in his Rural Rides - c.1830

DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
10 August 2019 06:24:24

Tomorrow's gales? We shall see.

Originally Posted by: DEW 

78 mph gust at the Needles overnight


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

warrenb
  • warrenb
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
10 August 2019 08:17:19
One of the problems is weather apps. When showing a forecast they don’t just show an area, the meto app shows your street name you are in and unfortunately in these times people think the forecast is that accurate
Col
  • Col
  • Advanced Member
10 August 2019 08:32:20

 

78 mph gust at the Needles overnight

Originally Posted by: DEW 

A ridiculously exposed station of course, but that's still a very impressive gust for August.


Col

Bolton, Lancashire

160m asl

Snow videos:

http://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3QvmL4UWBmHFMKWiwYm_gg

Caz
  • Caz
  • Advanced Member
10 August 2019 08:55:33

One of the problems is weather apps. When showing a forecast they don’t just show an area, the meto app shows your street name you are in and unfortunately in these times people think the forecast is that accurate

Originally Posted by: warrenb 

That’s a good point. Although the Met office app does give greater detail if people can be bothered to look and as I said earlier, we’re sometimes selective in what we read. 

My Met Office app currently has a wide area yellow warning of wind covering the whole of the country South of the Humber but my local forecast shows wind strength of only 24mph.  However, if I scroll down to wind details it shows gusts of up to 45mph.  I don’t live in a particularly exposed area though and the warning does specify ‘exposed and coastal areas’ of which I’m neither, so a bit of afore mentioned common sense suggests I’m not likely to be the worst affected. 


Market Warsop, North Nottinghamshire.

Join the fun and banter of the monthly CET competition.

ozone_aurora
10 August 2019 09:11:55

People may complain about cancellation of events, but what is so fun about being at a particular event (like a tea party) in howling gales and driving torrential downpours? 

DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
10 August 2019 10:38:07

 

A ridiculously exposed station [the Needles] of course, but that's still a very impressive gust for August.

Originally Posted by: Col 

Inland at Chichester, not so far away,the gusts were forecast in the low 40s mph. That seems about right, looking at the Beaufort criteria "twigs broken off trees" - force 8, 39-46mph

Next stage up, force 9, includes "damage to canopies" so perhaps the organisers of outdoor events with marquees etc were wise to cancel for the day. That includes our local Chilli Fiesta which will resume tomorrow, Sunday.

https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beaufort_scale


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

Chichesterweatherfan2
10 August 2019 11:15:56
To my mind the weather warnings issued in recent days seem entirely appropriate....strong winds in the summer with so many events under canvas taking place can be deadly..we’ve seen tragedies in recent years with bouncy castles not being properly secured...You also have to apply some common sense with warnings relating to flooding, snowfall..etc etc..As Dew will testify, a weather warning of heavy snow in West Sussex, 9/10 times doesn’t mean Chichester will be cut off and under a foot of snow😛😛
johnr
10 August 2019 11:42:44

It's events like this one that tend to be in festival organisers' minds:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-14586001

That same story references a stage collapse in the US under strong winds the week before, which killed five people.


Mickfield, Mid Suffolk
johncs2016
10 August 2019 12:00:40

If I had my way, I would stop giving out official yellow warnings for this area on a Saturday for thunderstorms which inevitably, just never end up occurring on this particular day. This is now the second Saturday in a row where such a warning has been given for this area and once again, we just have clear blue skies with plenty of warm sunshine, only a handful of fair weather clouds in the distance and absolutely nothing showing up on either the rain radar or lightning detector map for miles on end from here.

It was the same last Saturday as well with the only difference being that last Saturday was at least much cloudier at times than today with even the odd spot of rain threatening earlier on. That was an occasion where these storms just didn't happen here and I'm struggling to see where on Earth, they are going to come from this time.

I take the point which has been mentioned here that yellow warnings are based on what might happen, and the fact that it is that word "might" which is the most important thing here. However, expectations do tend to be based on actual experience and when these warnings keep on getting put out, without any of the type of weather actually happening for which those warnings are for, people are increasingly not going to be expecting that type of weather to actually happen when these warnings are issued. The natural response then is to eventually completely ignore such warnings over time because if the type of weather which these warnings are for isn't actually happening, what is the point in even paying attention to those warnings in the first place?

Once that happens, these warnings then become a complete waste of time, and that is when such a system then becomes flawed as a result, by a warning system which just doesn't work as intended.

 


The north of Edinburgh, usually always missing out on snow events which occur not just within the rest of Scotland or the UK, but also within the rest of Edinburgh.

Gusty
10 August 2019 12:13:13

The Met Office warning system is excellent. I am sure it has saved many lives and prevented a lot of hardship and financial losses since its introduction.

As a forum of weather enthusiasts who understand the potential of nature's fury versus the balance of probability and risk we shouldn't really be having this discussion....should we ? 


Steve - Folkestone, Kent

Current conditions from my Davis Vantage Vue

https://www.wunderground.com/dashboard/pws/IFOLKE11 

Join Kent Weather on Facebook.

https://www.facebook.com/stevewall69/ 



Caz
  • Caz
  • Advanced Member
10 August 2019 12:29:51

People may complain about cancellation of events, but what is so fun about being at a particular event (like a tea party) in howling gales and driving torrential downpours? 

Originally Posted by: ozone_aurora 

None whatsoever, neither for visitors or those who perform, exhibit or trade.  I daresay the public would complain if an event went ahead in such adverse conditions, that’s if anyone turned out at all.  But the fact that the warnings were given well in advance means less disruption all round.    

If an event can be cancelled a few days in advance it saves a lot of hassle in setting up and a lot of money in last minute preparations, such as a food outlet ordering fresh produce to cater for a few hundred people.  Most attractions and performers have insurance against cancelled events, so the event organisers wouldn’t have to foot that bill.  Also, wherever there are extra people, there’s extra traffic!

I had to cancel a summer carnival one year even though the forecast was good for the day of the event.  But it had been extremely wet for a few days previous and the decision was made due to the fields used for car parking being waterlogged. What would I have done with hundreds of cars otherwise?

On another occasion, I had to cancel a Christmas market evening held on streets closed to traffic for the event.  Three days before the event, the diverted bus route along untreated back roads was icy, with more freezing weather forecast, so I made the decision.  That was a good call, as we had deep snow on the intended event day, so I didn’t get any stick from disappointed members of the public!  I seem to think that was December 3rd 2010. 

The point of my ramblings is that there are an awful lot of things to consider, not least disappointing the public.  Nobody wants to waste all the time and effort organising something, to then have to cancel it because of something you can’t control!


Market Warsop, North Nottinghamshire.

Join the fun and banter of the monthly CET competition.

Bertwhistle
10 August 2019 12:34:26

100% yes.

Great thread.

Hyperbole over the weather is the modern disease. TWO is bad enough but the malaise is also affecting the pros. I blame the internet!

Today was supposed to be thunderstorms and tomorrow gales.

I’m sitting in the pub garden drinking cold lager. Been mountain biking all day in temps in the mid 20s.

Forecasts are becoming utterly risk averse nonsense.

Originally Posted by: Downpour 

But that was always the forecast for the far SE, wasn't it? Weather warnings do at least focus on key areas of risk.

We had a pleasant, warm and humid day despite persistent rain forecast two days earlier; the rain  came- it's just that it cleared by morning, so the timing was out.


Bertie, Itchen Valley.

Retire while you can still press the 'retire now' button.

Caz
  • Caz
  • Advanced Member
10 August 2019 12:37:38

It's events like this one that tend to be in festival organisers' minds:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-14586001

That same story references a stage collapse in the US under strong winds the week before, which killed five people.

Originally Posted by: johnr 

Yes, Exactly!  Learning from experience can make things more difficult to do but it saves lives.

Remember the M5 firework smoke crash that killed several people?  My above mentioned annual Christmas event included a firework display and after that happened, I had to move the firing site due to new regulations. 


Market Warsop, North Nottinghamshire.

Join the fun and banter of the monthly CET competition.

picturesareme
10 August 2019 12:48:25

The Met Office warning system is excellent. I am sure it has saved many lives and prevented a lot of hardship and financial losses since its introduction.

As a forum of weather enthusiasts who understand the potential of nature's fury versus the balance of probability and risk we shouldn't really be having this discussion....should we ? 

Originally Posted by: Gusty 

Winds have overnight peaked just shy of 60mph down here, the other week they were gusting around 55mph.

Now the other week the higher gusts were more frequent and caused more damage despite being 5mph weaker. Funnily enough the met couldn't be bothered to issue a weather warning as it was largely a coastal event, unlike fhe current event that is inland 

 

Caz
  • Caz
  • Advanced Member
10 August 2019 13:01:29

Winds have overnight peaked just shy of 60mph down here, the other week they were gusting around 55mph.

Now the other week the higher gusts were more frequent and caused more damage despite being 5mph weaker. Funnily enough the met couldn't be bothered to issue a weather warning as it was largely a coastal event, unlike fhe current event that is inland 

Originally Posted by: picturesareme 

That may be because the Met Office warnings tend to be regional, rather than local.  But I disagree about the current warning being for inland as I said in a previous post.  On my information it says to ‘expect coastal routes, sea fronts and coastal communities to be affected’.


Market Warsop, North Nottinghamshire.

Join the fun and banter of the monthly CET competition.

doctormog
10 August 2019 13:14:48

That may be because the Met Office warnings tend to be regional, rather than local.  But I disagree about the current warning being for inland as I said in a previous post.  On my information it says to ‘expect coastal routes, sea fronts and coastal communities to be affected’.

Originally Posted by: Caz 

The problem is Caz some people do not, cannot or choose not to read full statements or posts in a form of confirmation bias. 


picturesareme
10 August 2019 13:30:39

That may be because the Met Office warnings tend to be regional, rather than local.  But I disagree about the current warning being for inland as I said in a previous post.  On my information it says to ‘expect coastal routes, sea fronts and coastal communities to be affected’.

Originally Posted by: Caz 

Dorset to East Sussex and IOW all had gales and even mentioned in forecasts but there were no warnings. Had these winds today only been for the coast i doubt a weather warning would have been issued, but since its effecting inland to they wrote a warning and mentioned the coast.

 

picturesareme
10 August 2019 13:42:28
This was about as much mention of the gales that hit us the other week, and caused a fair bit of damage.

https://mobile.twitter.com/metoffice/status/1156158013943746560 

no weather warning were issued as like i say it was a coastal thing and i guess it's assumed being coastal these winds speeds are nothing untoward. The top gust was 55mph... this system brought a gust 58mph to Devon.

Caz
  • Caz
  • Advanced Member
10 August 2019 14:55:04

Dorset to East Sussex and IOW all had gales and even mentioned in forecasts but there were no warnings. Had these winds today only been for the coast i doubt a weather warning would have been issued, but since its effecting inland to they wrote a warning and mentioned the coast.

Originally Posted by: picturesareme 

And that’s another reason why the warnings for this weekend are justified!  People complain when there aren’t any!


Market Warsop, North Nottinghamshire.

Join the fun and banter of the monthly CET competition.

Jim-55
10 August 2019 16:06:12

For my part of the SW well we have just lived through a breezy day and a bit of showery rain with one heavy burst yesterday other than that totally normal for any time of the year. Was the yellow warning justified? maybe but the media from all areas have grabbed hold yet again and blew it into something far worse than it was ever going to be, and some tv forecasters were winding it up a bit as well so there should be a lot of eggy faces around or if not there should be. Right now the weather outside is breezy, warm and sunny so in fact a nice day which is opposite to what was forecast for here today.


Previously JimC. joined back then in 2009. Frome, N/E Somerset, 125mtrs asl.
doctormog
10 August 2019 16:23:47
I would say the warnings were justified lthough I’m sure in some parts of the warning areas people had warm sunshine for at least some of the time. Others did not.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-kent-49304501 

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-49305216 

It has been a pleasant, dry, albeit mostly cloudy day here but I suspect a few places in the warning area got a deulge and there is still time.

I can imagine the outcry in the media if the Met Office had not issued warnings and something serious had happened.


DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
10 August 2019 16:28:37

If I had my way, I would stop giving out official yellow warnings for this area on a Saturday for thunderstorms which inevitably, just never end up occurring on this particular day. This is now the second Saturday in a row where such a warning has been given for this area and once again, we just have clear blue skies with plenty of warm sunshine, only a handful of fair weather clouds in the distance and absolutely nothing showing up on either the rain radar or lightning detector map for miles on end from here.


Originally Posted by: johncs2016 

Curious, then, that I've just seen footage on BBC news of the closure of the main west coast line near Lockerbie closed because of the amount of flood water running down it. The MetO weather radar makes it look as if that storm is about to visit Edinburgh, too - poetic justice!


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

Remove ads from site