The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

johncs2016
29 June 2019 00:03:18

You’re quite right John, there are no rules to say you can’t give a rough guide to your prediction.  It’s an agreement that those who take part in this thread have come to on GW’s suggestion, for reasons I explained in my earlier post.  That’s just how it works.

You’re also right that there are some experts who know more than you and I but we can’t just say that the experts can’t give clues and the rest of us can.  It has to be equal for everyone.  Nobody would want to copy my guesses either but I don’t give clues because I respect the way this thread works and I go with the flow.  I also think that if one person does it, others might follow and then we might as well not have that agreement at all.  

I know you like taking part in the CET competition and I enjoy your company because you make some good posts on here and you join in the fun.  All I’m asking is that you consider holding back with your clues until after the prediction close date next month, like the rest of us do.  It’s entirely up to you of course.  

Originally Posted by: Caz 

I'm not disputing anything here, but I have just thought of a question based on what you have said, and which I would like to ask.

If we take the hypothetical situation where this was the CET thread for the month of MMMM within the year YYYY, it has been established that until such time that the entries for that month's CET competition were submitted, no-one would be allowed to say in this thread that they thought that CET anomaly for that month would be roughly X.X°C above average as that would give too much away.

However, it is always possible that someone might have posted in a different thread on an earlier date (such as several months earlier) which could be the MO thread for that time for example, where they reckoned that the CET anomaly for the month of MMMM within the year of YYYY would be roughly X.X°C above average. If that was done on the basis of any sort of model output, that would be a perfectly appropriate thing to do since that doesn't go off-topic in any way for that particular thread.

At the time of that earlier MO thread post, it might not necessarily be known that there would later on, be a CET competition for that particular month. Yet, there would be nothing to stop anyone from looking back at that earlier MO thread post and using that as a possible clue for that particular month's competition. Based on that particular post on this thread creating an unfair advantage, you could therefore equally say this earlier MO thread post also created an unfair advantage for exactly the same reasons.

Should we therefore stop that from happening as well?

 


The north of Edinburgh, usually always missing out on snow events which occur not just within the rest of Scotland or the UK, but also within the rest of Edinburgh.

wallaw
29 June 2019 05:23:44

 

I'm not disputing anything here, but I have just thought of a question based on what you have said, and which I would like to ask.

If we take the hypothetical situation where this was the CET thread for the month of MMMM within the year YYYY, it has been established that until such time that the entries for that month's CET competition were submitted, no-one would be allowed to say in this thread that they thought that CET anomaly for that month would be roughly X.X°C above average as that would give too much away.

However, it is always possible that someone might have posted in a different thread on an earlier date (such as several months earlier) which could be the MO thread for that time for example, where they reckoned that the CET anomaly for the month of MMMM within the year of YYYY would be roughly X.X°C above average. If that was done on the basis of any sort of model output, that would be a perfectly appropriate thing to do since that doesn't go off-topic in any way for that particular thread.

At the time of that earlier MO thread post, it might not necessarily be known that there would later on, be a CET competition for that particular month. Yet, there would be nothing to stop anyone from looking back at that earlier MO thread post and using that as a possible clue for that particular month's competition. Based on that particular post on this thread creating an unfair advantage, you could therefore equally say this earlier MO thread post also created an unfair advantage for exactly the same reasons.

Should we therefore stop that from happening as well?

 

Originally Posted by: johncs2016 

you could, but surely you see that a guess made 2 seasons away and one made one week before would have far more pertinent information at hand, given what we know about long range forecasting. Anyway, more importantly, my wild ar$e guess is in


Ian

Stockton-on-Tees

Col
  • Col
  • Advanced Member
29 June 2019 05:25:30

 

I'm not disputing anything here, but I have just thought of a question based on what you have said, and which I would like to ask.

If we take the hypothetical situation where this was the CET thread for the month of MMMM within the year YYYY, it has been established that until such time that the entries for that month's CET competition were submitted, no-one would be allowed to say in this thread that they thought that CET anomaly for that month would be roughly X.X°C above average as that would give too much away.

However, it is always possible that someone might have posted in a different thread on an earlier date (such as several months earlier) which could be the MO thread for that time for example, where they reckoned that the CET anomaly for the month of MMMM within the year of YYYY would be roughly X.X°C above average. If that was done on the basis of any sort of model output, that would be a perfectly appropriate thing to do since that doesn't go off-topic in any way for that particular thread.

At the time of that earlier MO thread post, it might not necessarily be known that there would later on, be a CET competition for that particular month. Yet, there would be nothing to stop anyone from looking back at that earlier MO thread post and using that as a possible clue for that particular month's competition. Based on that particular post on this thread creating an unfair advantage, you could therefore equally say this earlier MO thread post also created an unfair advantage for exactly the same reasons.

Should we therefore stop that from happening as well?

 

Originally Posted by: johncs2016 

Oh give it a rest please!

It's a relatively minor point but it has been explained by several people as to why the CET predicitons should be PM'd only. It isn't a fprum rule as such (like not going OT) but a competition rule within that forum so I don't think your account would ever be deleted for breaking it. GW runs the comp so I guess he could ban you from it if you persist in doing it, and he saw fit.


Col

Bolton, Lancashire

160m asl

Snow videos:

http://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3QvmL4UWBmHFMKWiwYm_gg

johncs2016
29 June 2019 06:27:55

 

Oh give it a rest please!

It's a relatively minor point but it has been explained by several people as to why the CET predicitons should be PM'd only. It isn't a fprum rule as such (like not going OT) but a competition rule within that forum so I don't think your account would ever be deleted for breaking it. GW runs the comp so I guess he could ban you from it if you persist in doing it, and he saw fit.

Originally Posted by: Col 

I wasn't intending to carry this on any further.

All I was looking for here was to get an answer to a question which cropped up, and I even explained that I wasn't then going to dispute that in any way.

It is after all by asking these questions and then getting the answers to them that I will then learn, or is that too much of a problem for you?

After the rather disgusting manner in which I've been treated by certain members over the last couple of days though on this thread, I don't now want anything more to do with this stupid competition ever again which is a real shame, because I was enjoying being part of it as Caz had said.

 

 


The north of Edinburgh, usually always missing out on snow events which occur not just within the rest of Scotland or the UK, but also within the rest of Edinburgh.

Col
  • Col
  • Advanced Member
29 June 2019 06:47:04

 

I wasn't intending to carry this on any further.

All I was looking for here was to get an answer to a question which cropped up, and I even explained that I wasn't then going to dispute that in any way.

It is after all by asking these questions and then getting the answers to them that I will then learn, or is that too much of a problem for you?

After the rather disgusting manner in which I've been treated by certain members over the last couple of days though on this thread, I don't now want anything more to do with this stupid competition ever again which is a real shame, because I was enjoying being part of it as Caz had said.

 

 

Originally Posted by: johncs2016 

That's called 'cutting off your nose to spite your face'. Your loss.

 


Col

Bolton, Lancashire

160m asl

Snow videos:

http://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3QvmL4UWBmHFMKWiwYm_gg

Whether Idle
29 June 2019 06:49:14

 

I wasn't intending to carry this on any further.

All I was looking for here was to get an answer to a question which cropped up, and I even explained that I wasn't then going to dispute that in any way.

It is after all by asking these questions and then getting the answers to them that I will then learn, or is that too much of a problem for you?

After the rather disgusting manner in which I've been treated by certain members over the last couple of days though on this thread, I don't now want anything more to do with this stupid competition ever again which is a real shame, because I was enjoying being part of it as Caz had said.

 

 

Originally Posted by: johncs2016 

That is completely unnecessary abusive language. Shame on you. Its a peerless competition and if people abide by the rules, even better.

 


Dover, 5m asl. Half a mile from the south coast.
Roger Parsons
29 June 2019 06:49:57

 

I wasn't intending to carry this on any further.

All I was looking for here was to get an answer to a question which cropped up, and I even explained that I wasn't then going to dispute that in any way.

It is after all by asking these questions and then getting the answers to them that I will then learn, or is that too much of a problem for you?

After the rather disgusting manner in which I've been treated by certain members over the last couple of days though on this thread, I don't now want anything more to do with this stupid competition ever again which is a real shame, because I was enjoying being part of it as Caz had said.

Originally Posted by: johncs2016 

A dignified deletion of your last line would be a good idea, John.

The "piranhas" of TWO thrive on spoiling the atmosphere to massage their self image and are best starved of responses. My policy is to use "hide user" and ignore them for a good while, only restoring them to view when they come to heel in a "Quote". It is only about 6 people who qualify, and on a good day some can show as bright and affable folks. Blood sugar levels perhaps? Surplus testosterone? It can't just be innate nastiness. Can it?

Roger


RogerP

West Lindsey district of Lincolnshire

Everything taken together, here in Lincolnshire are more good things than man could have had the conscience to ask.

William Cobbett, in his Rural Rides - c.1830

Caz
  • Caz
  • Advanced Member
29 June 2019 07:06:05

  Oh dear!  


Market Warsop, North Nottinghamshire.

Join the fun and banter of the monthly CET competition.

johncs2016
29 June 2019 07:06:37

 

A dignified deletion of your last line would be a good idea, John.

The "piranhas" of TWO thrive on spoiling the atmosphere to massage their self image and are best starved of responses. My policy is to use "hide user" and ignore them for a good while, only restoring them to view when they come to heel in a "Quote". It is only about 6 people who qualify, and on a good day some can show as bright and affable folks. Blood sugar levels perhaps? Surplus testosterone? It can't just be innate nastiness. Can it?

Roger

Originally Posted by: Roger Parsons 

No!!

I've said my piece and I'm sticking by it.

 


The north of Edinburgh, usually always missing out on snow events which occur not just within the rest of Scotland or the UK, but also within the rest of Edinburgh.

Gusty
29 June 2019 07:14:27

Shame on you John.

Perhaps this isn't the right thread or forum for you after all ?

We are a friendly bunch with the competitions best intentions at heart.

Simply playing by these unofficial rules would have helped your case. 

You're a rebel and proud of it as you stated.

Bye.


Steve - Folkestone, Kent

Current conditions from my Davis Vantage Vue

https://www.wunderground.com/dashboard/pws/IFOLKE11 

Join Kent Weather on Facebook.

https://www.facebook.com/stevewall69/ 



Roger Parsons
29 June 2019 07:39:43

No!!

I've said my piece and I'm sticking by it.

 

Originally Posted by: johncs2016 

Up to you, John. 

Roger


RogerP

West Lindsey district of Lincolnshire

Everything taken together, here in Lincolnshire are more good things than man could have had the conscience to ask.

William Cobbett, in his Rural Rides - c.1830

ARTzeman
30 June 2019 06:12:21
I have hidden his posts from my view so will not see the language used.




Some people walk in the rain.

Others just get wet.

I Just Blow my horn or trumpet

johncs2016
30 June 2019 07:31:28

I will now apologise for going over the top yesterday with some foul language on this thread.

What happened here was that I asked a certain question and then as it turned out, Wallaw then gave me the answer which I was actually looking for.

At that point in time, I was then fully prepared to leave it at that and say nothing more on this matter. However, I was still simmering from everything else which had happened here beforehand and when Col then opened his big mouth with the response which he gave, the very first sentence of that response was then enough to push me over the edge.

This doesn't mean that I'm blaming Col in any way here but had he not made that response in the manner in which he did in that particular sentence, I would have ended up saying nothing more on this matter and there would have been no abusive language from me as a result (I was after all, doing the very best that I can to avoid using such language and that was why I mentioned beforehand that what I had said until that point in time could easily have been a lot worse than what it was).

However, I also recognise that this still doesn't take anything away from the fact that I shouldn't have used such abusive language and that is why I have come on here to formally apologise for doing so. Having said though, my previous views which I had stated here remain unchanged. and because of that, I will continue to take no further part in the CET competition from now on.

Having said that though, there is a reason why the CET competition exists and regardless of what my own views on that competition and its rules actually are, it is still a good idea to have that competition and although I don't want to have anything to do with it myself from now on, I would not discourage anyone else in any way from playing their part in it.

For that reason, I would like to take this opportunity to wish everyone else all of the best of luck in the CET competition and so, let's hope that there are no hard feelings over this because as Caz said earlier on, we are all friends at the end of the day.

EDIT:

I have also just deleted the offending sentence where that abusive language was used to save Brian or any mod from having to do that instead.

Oh and while I'm at it, I'have also edited the initial comment which led to all of this happening by removing the initial temperature anomaly prediction which I gave there. I am of course, aware that there was at least one direct reply to that where this initial post is actually quoted so if whoever made such replies can then go back and remove my prediction from that quote, that should then at least minimize any unfair advantage which might have resulted from that.

 


The north of Edinburgh, usually always missing out on snow events which occur not just within the rest of Scotland or the UK, but also within the rest of Edinburgh.

Col
  • Col
  • Advanced Member
30 June 2019 08:29:06

I will now apologise for going over the top yesterday with some foul language on this thread.

What happened here was that I asked a certain question and then as it turned out, Wallaw then gave me the answer which I was actually looking for.

At that point in time, I was then fully prepared to leave it at that and say nothing more on this matter. However, I was still simmering from everything else which had happened here beforehand and when Col then opened his big mouth with the response which he gave, the very first sentence of that response was then enough to push me over the edge.

This doesn't mean that I'm blaming Col in any way here but had he not made that response in the manner in which he did in that particular sentence, I would have ended up saying nothing more on this matter and there would have been no abusive language from me as a result (I was after all, doing the very best that I can to avoid using such language and that was why I mentioned beforehand that what I had said until that point in time could easily have been a lot worse than what it was).

However, I also recognise that this still doesn't take anything away from the fact that I shouldn't have used such abusive language and that is why I have come on here to formally apologise for doing so. Having said though, my previous views which I had stated here remain unchanged. and because of that, I will continue to take no further part in the CET competition from now on.

Having said that though, there is a reason why the CET competition exists and regardless of what my own views on that competition and its rules actually are, it is still a good idea to have that competition and although I don't want to have anything to do with it myself from now on, I would not discourage anyone else in any way from playing their part in it.

For that reason, I would like to take this opportunity to wish everyone else all of the best of luck in the CET competition and so, let's hope that there are no hard feelings over this because as Caz said earlier on, we are all friends at the end of the day.

EDIT:

I have also just deleted the offending sentence where that abusive language was used to save Brian or any mod from having to do that instead.

Oh and while I'm at it, I'have also edited the initial comment which led to all of this happening by removing the initial temperature anomaly prediction which I gave there. I am of course, aware that there was at least one direct reply to that where this initial post is actually quoted so if whoever made such replies can then go back and remove my prediction from that quote, that should then at least minimize any unfair advantage which might have resulted from that.

 

Originally Posted by: johncs2016 

OK, thanks John. No need for anyone to fall out over this.

It's a shame you still feel the need to leave the CET competition however if you disagree with how it is run, that is probably the best course of action to take.


Col

Bolton, Lancashire

160m asl

Snow videos:

http://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3QvmL4UWBmHFMKWiwYm_gg

Hungry Tiger
30 June 2019 10:47:31

I will now apologise for going over the top yesterday with some foul language on this thread.

What happened here was that I asked a certain question and then as it turned out, Wallaw then gave me the answer which I was actually looking for.

At that point in time, I was then fully prepared to leave it at that and say nothing more on this matter. However, I was still simmering from everything else which had happened here beforehand and when Col then opened his big mouth with the response which he gave, the very first sentence of that response was then enough to push me over the edge.

This doesn't mean that I'm blaming Col in any way here but had he not made that response in the manner in which he did in that particular sentence, I would have ended up saying nothing more on this matter and there would have been no abusive language from me as a result (I was after all, doing the very best that I can to avoid using such language and that was why I mentioned beforehand that what I had said until that point in time could easily have been a lot worse than what it was).

However, I also recognise that this still doesn't take anything away from the fact that I shouldn't have used such abusive language and that is why I have come on here to formally apologise for doing so. Having said though, my previous views which I had stated here remain unchanged. and because of that, I will continue to take no further part in the CET competition from now on.

Having said that though, there is a reason why the CET competition exists and regardless of what my own views on that competition and its rules actually are, it is still a good idea to have that competition and although I don't want to have anything to do with it myself from now on, I would not discourage anyone else in any way from playing their part in it.

For that reason, I would like to take this opportunity to wish everyone else all of the best of luck in the CET competition and so, let's hope that there are no hard feelings over this because as Caz said earlier on, we are all friends at the end of the day.

EDIT:

I have also just deleted the offending sentence where that abusive language was used to save Brian or any mod from having to do that instead.

Oh and while I'm at it, I'have also edited the initial comment which led to all of this happening by removing the initial temperature anomaly prediction which I gave there. I am of course, aware that there was at least one direct reply to that where this initial post is actually quoted so if whoever made such replies can then go back and remove my prediction from that quote, that should then at least minimize any unfair advantage which might have resulted from that.

 

Originally Posted by: johncs2016 

John - If you're unhappy with the forum - feel free to leave. I've removed two of your quite offending posts. I'm issuing a ban warning to you.

Any more of those types of posts and you account will be locked for a number of days.


Gavin S. FRmetS.

TWO Moderator.

Contact the TWO team - [email protected]

South Cambridgeshire. 93 metres or 302.25 feet ASL.



johncs2016
30 June 2019 11:56:49

 

John - If you're unhappy with the forum - feel free to leave. I've removed two of your quite offending posts. I'm issuing a ban warning to you.

Any more of those types of posts and you account will be locked for a number of days.

Originally Posted by: Hungry Tiger 

It wasn't so much the forum as a whole that I was unhappy with and indeed, I very much enjoy producing the content which I provide elsewhere on this forum such as on the daily CC threads and monthly PW threads. I know that other members also enjoy reading that content as they have said so themselves in the past.

What I was unhappy with here was the unofficial rules of the CET competition. I know that this is a separate matter from the forum itself but since the CET competition was created within this forum, it is therefore a part of this forum. This in turn means that my views on the CET competition then have an impact on my views of the entire forum as a result.

By removing myself from that competition, I have therefore broken that link by no longer being part of this competition and this means that this will now no longer have any impact on what I do within this forum as a whole. That way, I can then enjoy the rest of this forum as I have been doing without anything else getting in the way of that.

I will of course heed your warning and will do everything that I can to remain within the forum rules from now on although this does mean that I will be a lot more careful about what I post here from now on. In the meantime, I will apologise once again for any offence which I may have caused.

 


The north of Edinburgh, usually always missing out on snow events which occur not just within the rest of Scotland or the UK, but also within the rest of Edinburgh.

Hungry Tiger
30 June 2019 12:45:23

 

It wasn't so much the forum as a whole that I was unhappy with and indeed, I very much enjoy producing the content which I provide elsewhere on this forum such as on the daily CC threads and monthly PW threads. I know that other members also enjoy reading that content as they have said so themselves in the past.

What I was unhappy with here was the unofficial rules of the CET competition. I know that this is a separate matter from the forum itself but since the CET competition was created within this forum, it is therefore a part of this forum. This in turn means that my views on the CET competition then have an impact on my views of the entire forum as a result.

By removing myself from that competition, I have therefore broken that link by no longer being part of this competition and this means that this will now no longer have any impact on what I do within this forum as a whole. That way, I can then enjoy the rest of this forum as I have been doing without anything else getting in the way of that.

I will of course heed your warning and will do everything that I can to remain within the forum rules from now on although this does mean that I will be a lot more careful about what I post here from now on. In the meantime, I will apologise once again for any offence which I may have caused.

 

Originally Posted by: johncs2016 

Thnaks for your apology John.


Gavin S. FRmetS.

TWO Moderator.

Contact the TWO team - [email protected]

South Cambridgeshire. 93 metres or 302.25 feet ASL.



johncs2016
30 June 2019 12:50:13

 

Thnaks for your apology John.

Originally Posted by: Hungry Tiger 

Thanks and course, I'm sure you probably know that I wouldn't actually leave this forum anyway because if it really was the case that I didn't like this forum and was unhappy with it, I would have left it a long time ago and then never looked back on that afterwards.

 


The north of Edinburgh, usually always missing out on snow events which occur not just within the rest of Scotland or the UK, but also within the rest of Edinburgh.

Saint Snow
01 July 2019 09:11:02

In case anyone's interested, I've gone for something which is roughly around 1°C above the 1981-2010 average.

 

 


Martin

Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)

A TWO addict since 14/12/01

"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."

Aneurin Bevan

Rob K
01 July 2019 11:30:14
Did I miss a change in closing date? I thought the last monthly comps closed on the 1st or 2nd of the month in question, but it seems I have missed the boat on this one!
Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

ARTzeman
01 July 2019 11:35:13

The deadline was published in post number 1 . For this month.




Some people walk in the rain.

Others just get wet.

I Just Blow my horn or trumpet

Saint Snow
01 July 2019 12:11:59

Did I miss a change in closing date? I thought the last monthly comps closed on the 1st or 2nd of the month in question, but it seems I have missed the boat on this one!

Originally Posted by: Rob K 

 

You should still send your entry; there's only very modest penalties for slightly late predictions/guesses.


Martin

Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)

A TWO addict since 14/12/01

"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."

Aneurin Bevan

Bertwhistle
01 July 2019 15:44:19

 

A dignified deletion of your last line would be a good idea, John.

The "piranhas" of TWO thrive on spoiling the atmosphere to massage their self image and are best starved of responses. My policy is to use "hide user" and ignore them for a good while, only restoring them to view when they come to heel in a "Quote". It is only about 6 people who qualify, and on a good day some can show as bright and affable folks. Blood sugar levels perhaps? Surplus testosterone? It can't just be innate nastiness. Can it?

Roger

Originally Posted by: Roger Parsons 

That's what I've done Roger, as I was getting a virtual earache!  But as you say, it still comes back and haunts me in quotes. Can you get a hide quote of hidden poster feature?

 To the competition then! Can't wait to see if the new approach has an impact on guesses; but GW is away for a while, so we will have to enjoy the anticipation. 


Bertie, Itchen Valley.

Retire while you can still press the 'retire now' button.

Caz
  • Caz
  • Advanced Member
01 July 2019 15:55:24

That's what I've done Roger, as I was getting a virtual earache!  But as you say, it still comes back and haunts me in quotes. Can you get a hide quote of hidden poster feature?

 To the competition then! Can't wait to see if the new approach has an impact on guesses; but GW is away for a while, so we will have to enjoy the anticipation. 

Originally Posted by: Bertwhistle 

 Same here!

Erm, hang on, the new scoring isn’t being implemented until next year!  


Market Warsop, North Nottinghamshire.

Join the fun and banter of the monthly CET competition.

Bertwhistle
01 July 2019 15:58:26

 Same here!

Erm, hang on, the new scoring isn’t being implemented until next year!  

Originally Posted by: Caz 

And that's after I did read all the previous conversation. 

(Almost)


Bertie, Itchen Valley.

Retire while you can still press the 'retire now' button.

Remove ads from site