The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

Gooner
27 December 2018 10:44:36

With regards any SSW I was always on the understanding there was a 4-6 week time delay with regards blocking 

Any thoughts ?


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus

Banbury

North Oxfordshire

378 feet A S L



roadrunnerajn
27 December 2018 10:50:55

With regards any SSW I was always on the understanding there was a 4-6 week time delay with regards blocking 

Any thoughts ?

Originally Posted by: Gooner 

I believe it’s more like 2-3 weeks. Bear in mind the SSW is only just coming to a slow end. Let’s give it until the end of the year before we write January off.....


Germoe, part of the breakaway Celtic Republic. 80m asl
The Beast from the East
27 December 2018 10:55:17

The model output simply demonstrates yet again that whatever happens in the strat, the UK barrier to any January weather in January is unbeatable. Even if we enter another ice age, a UK January would deliver mild, grey, dull, damp, boring gunk!

Originally Posted by: Maunder Minimum 

Yes, but at least we have lots of interesting politics to keep us amused next month, and we can use the money we save on heating to buy tins of British grown beans to stockpile for Brexit


Purley, Surrey, 70m ASL

"We have some alternative facts for you"

Kelly-Ann Conway - former special adviser to the President

moomin75
27 December 2018 11:02:09
Must admit, if taken in isolation the consistency of the GFS over the last 2 weeks would almost make it "throw in the towel" time for the whole winter. It is remarkable how consistent this model has been for what seems like an eternity. It's funny how when it's a zonal signal, GFS just runs and runs with it and is often proved to be on the ball.

However, the signals from all the other models is at least a little encouraging as is the consistent and unusually high confidence from Met Office forecasts.

I will certainly not be throwing in the towel just yet because I honestly believe we will see a big flip from GFS in the next 3-4 days.


Witney, Oxfordshire

100m ASL

Gooner
27 December 2018 11:07:56

Must admit, if taken in isolation the consistency of the GFS over the last 2 weeks would almost make it "throw in the towel" time for the whole winter. It is remarkable how consistent this model has been for what seems like an eternity. It's funny how when it's a zonal signal, GFS just runs and runs with it and is often proved to be on the ball.
However, the signals from all the other models is at least a little encouraging as is the consistent and unusually high confidence from Met Office forecasts.
I will certainly not be throwing in the towel just yet because I honestly believe we will see a big flip from GFS in the next 3-4 days.

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

Really?

Blimey you are confident mate 


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus

Banbury

North Oxfordshire

378 feet A S L



tallyho_83
27 December 2018 11:13:54

 

Really?

Blimey you are confident mate 

Originally Posted by: Gooner 

Soon we will be 6 weeks into winter come 1st week of January and there has been no frost or cold to talk about! So I am sure you can appreciate the frustration from cold weather enthusiasts - even without the SSW we don't even seem to be getting transient North westerlies or northerlies like last year or year before etc....?! Virtually nothing of interest from a cold perspective on the 06z run. 


Home Location - Vixen Tor Close, Okehampton, Devon (221m ASL)

---------------------------------------

Sean Moon

Magical Moon

www.magical-moon.com

tallyho_83
27 December 2018 11:15:40

GFS 6z continues to fly the flag for the mildies! 

My view wrt Exeter is that a significant update today is unlikely. If anything it will be tomorrow or early next week.

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

Not another Pizza that again?!!


Home Location - Vixen Tor Close, Okehampton, Devon (221m ASL)

---------------------------------------

Sean Moon

Magical Moon

www.magical-moon.com

moomin75
27 December 2018 11:16:10

 

Really?

Blimey you are confident mate 

Originally Posted by: Gooner 

Unusually so for me yes. 🤞


Witney, Oxfordshire

100m ASL

Tim A
27 December 2018 11:34:42
Met Office forecast suggests colder from Mid-month and an unsettled spell for the north first. With that in mind what we are seeing in the output is not that surprising really. Not saying the Met Office will be correct but if there are other signals showing cold later i wouldnt be changing the forecast based on mid term weather models.
Tim

NW Leeds

187m asl

 My PWS 

doctormog
27 December 2018 11:35:57
On the subject of confidence or lack thereof, the 06z GFS ensemble data t850hPa here have a spread of around two to three degrees Celsius on the 31st of December, by the next days that spread has increased to 12 or 13 degrees.
snow_dann
27 December 2018 11:42:11

 

Not another Pizza that again?!!

Originally Posted by: tallyho_83 

 

More like a Greggs pizza slice that one!

tallyho_83
27 December 2018 11:44:35

Unusually so for me yes. 🤞

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

either the GFS will flip cold or met Office update will go mild in line with models. Hope it's not the latter?


Home Location - Vixen Tor Close, Okehampton, Devon (221m ASL)

---------------------------------------

Sean Moon

Magical Moon

www.magical-moon.com

doctormog
27 December 2018 11:48:02

 

either the GFS will flip cold or met Office update will go mild?

Originally Posted by: tallyho_83 

The Met Office forecast which suggests a change to cold weather from mid-January or the GFS which goes out to the 12th of January? 


ballamar
27 December 2018 11:56:37

 

either the GFS will flip cold or met Office update will go mild in line with models. Hope it's not the latter?

Originally Posted by: tallyho_83 

 

if you are that worked, take a break and look next week you might be surprised failing that upset !!  Zonal will not prevail for eternity and a change will happen it just might not make us go into the freezer

Northern Sky
27 December 2018 11:58:47

 

The Met Office forecast which suggests a change to cold weather from mid-January or the GFS which goes out to the 12th of January? 

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

And we all know how accurate GFS T384 charts are 

The long range models/teleconnections seem to have indicated a change to cold from around the 10th to 15th of Jan. At the moment that's still 14 days away at the earliest. If in a weeks time there are no building blocks to cold showing in the output then it's time to get worried. I know there will still be plenty of Winter left but one thing I really don't want is a repeat of last Spring.

Please can we have some cold in actual Winter? 

Steve Murr
27 December 2018 12:05:11

With regards any SSW I was always on the understanding there was a 4-6 week time delay with regards blocking 

Any thoughts ?

Originally Posted by: Gooner 

The standard propergation time for a SSW is 10-14 days, thats from the top down to the troposphere.

Post the final date where the winds have reversed you would expect to see heigher heights extending into the pole & more high lattitude blocking, the blocking pattern 'locale' is directly related to where the lobes of the vortex are when theres a 'split'

This is where models like the GFS fail moreover than the Euro/ Euros- the vertical resolution of the ECM is far superior to the GFS- Which is why the GFs couldnt see a split @10HPA when the ECM has it nailed days out, the GFS just sees a blob of displaced energy.

With that in mind we move onto a 'QTR' - quick tropospheric resonse, which as the name would suggest- The troposphere responds to the reversal far quicker than the standard 10-14 day window.

A QTR will create high entropy ( what we have now ) & for a non 'high top' model like the GFS it will not resolve the jet deceleration until much closer to T0. ( Vis a vee GFS will 'project' everything further East as opposed to the Euros that will resolve the deceleration quicker- ( within that initial signal of high entropy )

What this means essentially is if your an avid GFS fan your 'zonal' flow will ever so slowly be replaced by an amplified pattern, not across one run but ever so slowly the over projection east will correct West & North.

As we stand today, this mood of this forum is highly gravitated towards the GFS ( still not sure why when its poor ) so to that end its no suprise theres minimal excitement here-

However all the other models have caught up- The ECM operational yesterday, most of the EPS today- with the ICON being the slowest & most farthest west-

So, the winds of change or shall I say deceleration are blowing over the models at the moment, it hasnt quite reached the GFs which is about 6/700 miles to far east @144 this morning....

S

JOHN NI
27 December 2018 12:13:05
There are a several points worth noting / reiterating at the moment in my opinion......

(a) Not all SSW's produce cold spells in the UK - they increase the chances of blocking and colder weather.

(b) Not all SSW's are the same. This one appears to have been a 'displacement' type event followed by a split.

(c) Historically, repercussions of stratospheric events do indeed take 2 to 3 weeks to completely impact the troposphere - if indeed they do...not all do.

(d) All other 'ducks' need to line up......soooooo

(e) The current MJO is in phase 5 and expected to propagate into a strong phase 6/7 which would tend to encourage a negative NAO by late January.

(f). We're in a moderate El Nino - which tends to produce milder first halves to winter in northwest Europe and 'colder' second halves. (This can be masked though by the general ongoing seasonal cooling which makes January/February colder than December anyway).

(g) We're at the bottom of the 11 year solar cycle where colder, more blocked winter tend to cluster.

(h) Unfortunately the QBO is the one big player which has now gone westerly (having previously been easterly) - milder winters are therefore favoured - but not guaranteed.

Only on the very latest Contingency Planners Forecast have the Met Office suggested below average temperatures are more likely than above. All of those issued to the end of November had favoured above average temperatures.

The strongest signal for easterlies from both GLOSEA and ECM has always been February.

So far the seasonal expectations have gone well - a mild first half. We're now entering the business end of winter. I'd expect, not least that we're entering (climatologically) the coldest eight weeks of the year that winter weather will put in an appearance. What form this takes, its severity or longevity is still open to debate - but personally I feel there is enough evidence to suggest colder easterly types could become more apparent as time progresses.

Hold the faith....


John.

The orange County of Armagh.

Shropshire
27 December 2018 12:14:36

 

either the GFS will flip cold or met Office update will go mild in line with models. Hope it's not the latter?

Originally Posted by: tallyho_83 

I feel that the GFS is leading the way at the moment, first to identify the sinking of the High for early Jan.

It should be noted that the METO cold period though is mid-Jan and not even at the beginning of the period starting Jan 11th on their update so even the GFS at T384 only takes us up to Jan 12th.

 


From December 27th 2020, zonality will be banned from mixing with the UK. We appreciate that this may come as a shock to younger people and old Uncle Barty. This ban will last for a minimum of ten days.
David M Porter
27 December 2018 12:18:08

Must admit, if taken in isolation the consistency of the GFS over the last 2 weeks would almost make it "throw in the towel" time for the whole winter. It is remarkable how consistent this model has been for what seems like an eternity. It's funny how when it's a zonal signal, GFS just runs and runs with it and is often proved to be on the ball.
However, the signals from all the other models is at least a little encouraging as is the consistent and unusually high confidence from Met Office forecasts.
I will certainly not be throwing in the towel just yet because I honestly believe we will see a big flip from GFS in the next 3-4 days.

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

What everyone should bear in mind IMO is that though what GFS shows is an important part of the overall picture, is it not the be all and end all. I think that GFS sometimes gets more attention that the others because it issues four updates a day whereas ECM and UKMO only issue two per day, but the solutions they come up with are no less important even though they don't go as far ahead and they only issue two updates per day as opposed to four.


Lenzie, Glasgow

"A body of men holding themselves accountable to nobody ought not to be trusted by anybody." – Thomas Paine

David M Porter
27 December 2018 12:27:36

What I have noticed about the FI section of a number of recent GFS op runs is that while it shows things turning generally unsettled, it does at the same time show the jet stream taking a more southerly track with what looks to be some fairly cold air moving into nothern areas. This was a pattern what we had on a few occasions last winter IIRC and one which delivered a few transient snow events to parts of Scotland and possibly northern England; we had snow on about five or six consecutive days back in mid-January where I live.


Lenzie, Glasgow

"A body of men holding themselves accountable to nobody ought not to be trusted by anybody." – Thomas Paine

Brian Gaze
27 December 2018 12:32:25

 

I feel that the GFS is leading the way at the moment, first to identify the sinking of the High for early Jan.

It should be noted that the METO cold period though is mid-Jan and not even at the beginning of the period starting Jan 11th on their update so even the GFS at T384 only takes us up to Jan 12th.

 

Originally Posted by: Shropshire 

That is true, however the 384 stamps virtually all look a good way off a significant cold snap.  

https://www.theweatheroutlook.com/twodata/gefs.aspx?run=na&charthour=384&chartname=ps_500hpa&chartregion=na-region&p=1&charttag=PS%20500hPa%20(GPDM)

PS: I see some people are now falling back on to El Nino back loading the winter.

 


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

nsrobins
27 December 2018 12:43:07

There are a several points worth noting / reiterating at the moment in my opinion......

(a) Not all SSW's produce cold spells in the UK - they increase the chances of blocking and colder weather.
(b) Not all SSW's are the same. This one appears to have been a 'displacement' type event followed by a split.
(c) Historically, repercussions of stratospheric events do indeed take 2 to 3 weeks to completely impact the troposphere - if indeed they do...not all do.
(d) All other 'ducks' need to line up......soooooo

(e) The current MJO is in phase 5 and expected to propagate into a strong phase 6/7 which would tend to encourage a negative NAO by late January.
(f). We're in a moderate El Nino - which tends to produce milder first halves to winter in northwest Europe and 'colder' second halves. (This can be masked though by the general ongoing seasonal cooling which makes January/February colder than December anyway).
(g) We're at the bottom of the 11 year solar cycle where colder, more blocked winter tend to cluster.
(h) Unfortunately the QBO is the one big player which has now gone westerly (having previously been easterly) - milder winters are therefore favoured - but not guaranteed.

Only on the very latest Contingency Planners Forecast have the Met Office suggested below average temperatures are more likely than above. All of those issued to the end of November had favoured above average temperatures.

The strongest signal for easterlies from both GLOSEA and ECM has always been February.

So far the seasonal expectations have gone well - a mild first half. We're now entering the business end of winter. I'd expect, not least that we're entering (climatologically) the coldest eight weeks of the year that winter weather will put in an appearance. What form this takes, its severity or longevity is still open to debate - but personally I feel there is enough evidence to suggest colder easterly types could become more apparent as time progresses.

Hold the faith....

Originally Posted by: JOHN NI 

Great summary John. 


Neil

Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)

Stormchaser, Member TORRO

picturesareme
27 December 2018 12:55:47

 

As we stand today, this mood of this forum is highly gravitated towards the GFS ( still not sure why when its poor ) so to that end its no suprise theres minimal excitement here

S

Originally Posted by: Steve Murr 

I mentioned this a couple months back.. this forum should be renamed 'Model output (mainly gfs) discussion *date*'..

It's the only one people only take notice of in here.

 

6 January and gfs has low pressure slap bang over UK and awful weather..

same time ecm has high pressure over lower Scandinavia with a low over Italy and easterly winds just clipping South East England but with the real cold heading into France and towards Spain.... wouldn't take much direction north or west to bring some deep cold to England. 

doctormog
27 December 2018 13:03:59

 

There are a several points worth noting / reiterating at the moment in my opinion......

(a) Not all SSW's produce cold spells in the UK - they increase the chances of blocking and colder weather.
(b) Not all SSW's are the same. This one appears to have been a 'displacement' type event followed by a split.
(c) Historically, repercussions of stratospheric events do indeed take 2 to 3 weeks to completely impact the troposphere - if indeed they do...not all do.
(d) All other 'ducks' need to line up......soooooo

(e) The current MJO is in phase 5 and expected to propagate into a strong phase 6/7 which would tend to encourage a negative NAO by late January.
(f). We're in a moderate El Nino - which tends to produce milder first halves to winter in northwest Europe and 'colder' second halves. (This can be masked though by the general ongoing seasonal cooling which makes January/February colder than December anyway).
(g) We're at the bottom of the 11 year solar cycle where colder, more blocked winter tend to cluster.
(h) Unfortunately the QBO is the one big player which has now gone westerly (having previously been easterly) - milder winters are therefore favoured - but not guaranteed.

Only on the very latest Contingency Planners Forecast have the Met Office suggested below average temperatures are more likely than above. All of those issued to the end of November had favoured above average temperatures.

The strongest signal for easterlies from both GLOSEA and ECM has always been February.

So far the seasonal expectations have gone well - a mild first half. We're now entering the business end of winter. I'd expect, not least that we're entering (climatologically) the coldest eight weeks of the year that winter weather will put in an appearance. What form this takes, its severity or longevity is still open to debate - but personally I feel there is enough evidence to suggest colder easterly types could become more apparent as time progresses.

Hold the faith....

Originally Posted by: JOHN NI 

Good stuff John (and a belated Merry Christmas!)


Gooner
27 December 2018 13:04:21

 

I mentioned this a couple months back.. this forum should be renamed 'Model output (mainly gfs) discussion *date*'..

It's the only one people only take notice of in here.

Originally Posted by: picturesareme 

I'd disagree , there are far too many knowledgeable people in here.

More charts get posted and more comments made but only because it goes out to 384 and appears 4x a day  


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus

Banbury

North Oxfordshire

378 feet A S L



Remove ads from site