The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

haggishunter
24 December 2021 02:23:49

 

Not this nonsense again.

If winter starts on 22 December does summer not start until 22 June and not end until 21 September? 🙄

It has nothing whatever to do with any government agency nor is it related to some ‘statistical convenience’. It may amaze you to know that it’s actually about how the climate works. The sun’s output is at its lowest from mid-November to mid-February but you have to allow for the thermal lag in the oceans, which skews the 3-month winter period. There might be an argument that 2 weeks isn’t sufficient to reflect the ocean lag but 5 weeks is way too long.

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

It doesn’t seem like nonsense here, the astronomical seasons seem to better fit the reality on the ground in Scotland than the Met Office definition. The average thermal mid-winter on the long term means for the North of Scotland is mid February. The average opening date of Glencoe, Scotland’s oldest ski area since 1955/56 is the 16th of January, in the vast majority of years it reaches its traditional  closing date of the May Day bank holiday Monday. 

Caz
  • Caz
  • Advanced Member
24 December 2021 06:58:04

that's the dream isn't it .To live through a winter like that or a 1947.No one disputes a winter like that will happen again, a bit like you play the lottery long enough your numbers will come up, trouble is what good is a lottery win when you are 98? I am like many others on here getting old and grey patiently waiting for that winter to come along but fearing time is running out!

Originally Posted by: CField 

Ours did come along in 2010 and since then, I’ve been careful what I wish for!  I remember 1963 but for us in the East Midlands, it wasn’t bad and by no means the worst in my lifetime.  It seems the snowiest winters have mostly been around the start of each decade - except this one so far!


Market Warsop, North Nottinghamshire.

Join the fun and banter of the monthly CET competition.

Crepuscular Ray
24 December 2021 07:29:09
We have natural seasons and they begin a good way through the month on the solstice, for example 21 December, 21 March, 21 June and 21 September. That's how it's been for a few hundred years.

In more recent times, artificial, 'meteorological' seasons have been set so that we can record and present data in a more straightforward (3 month) block

This still confuses some folk


Jerry

Edinburgh, in the frost hollow below Blackford Hill

scillydave
24 December 2021 07:29:31
If December is an Autumn month and March is a Spring month then January and February are our Winter months.

Therefore Winter hasn't even started yet and we've everything to look forward to!

Merry Christmas all.


Currently living at roughly 65m asl North of Cowbridge in the Vale of Glamorgan.

Formerly of, Birdlip, highest village in the Cotswolds and snow heaven in winter; Hawkinge in Kent - roof of the South downs and Isles of Scilly, paradise in the UK.

Tim A
24 December 2021 07:38:49

Question for Brian. Is the MOGREPS plot for Sheffield for the city centre (e.g 130masl) or a nearby peak?  Seems loads of difference between Sheffield and York - see below .

 

Of course it could be that several runs predict Sheffield to get dumped on and that is the reason for the big discrepancies(the snow depth maps are interesting).


Tim

NW Leeds

187m asl

 My PWS 

Brian Gaze
24 December 2021 07:39:02

that's the dream isn't it .To live through a winter like that or a 1947.No one disputes a winter like that will happen again, a bit like you play the lottery long enough your numbers will come up, trouble is what good is a lottery win when you are 98? I am like many others on here getting old and grey patiently waiting for that winter to come along but fearing time is running out!

Originally Posted by: CField 

My dad lived through 1947 and he always said it was bloody awful.


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

MBrothers
24 December 2021 07:44:34

 

Not this nonsense again.

If winter starts on 22 December does summer not start until 22 June and not end until 21 September? 🙄

It has nothing whatever to do with any government agency nor is it related to some ‘statistical convenience’. It may amaze you to know that it’s actually about how the climate works. The sun’s output is at its lowest from mid-November to mid-February but you have to allow for the thermal lag in the oceans, which skews the 3-month winter period. There might be an argument that 2 weeks isn’t sufficient to reflect the ocean lag but 5 weeks is way too long.

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

it needs to be said before we move on to the annual lack of flight data issue.

Russwirral
24 December 2021 07:50:51
NYE in spain looks warm... widespread 20+*c

Some places 24 or 25.... bonkers


DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
24 December 2021 08:14:31

From 1947 to the here and now:

Wx summary keeps W Europe mild; a bit more deep cold to the NE showing but this makes a lunge towards the Balkans in week 2. Rain in week 1 from Uk down to Greece shifts in week 2 to UK up to Norway

Jet intermittent in strength and direction as loops form and pass through but never far from UK in next two weeks

GFS op - broad area of shallow LP around the UK Mon/Tue 27/28th then for rest of period the weather is controlled by LP S/SW of Iceland with strong SW-lies for the UK, extra strong when that LP generates secondaries  or simply moves closer e.g. Tue 4th & Sun 9th

GEFS - mean temps always above norm (except an early dip before temps recover in the N) and significantly so either side of Sat 1st . Good agreement to Mon 3rd after which a few colder runs creep in. Rain on and off throughout, heavier early on in the S and around around New Year in the N. Snow rows - there's a '10' in Inverness late on but otherwise forget it. EDIT - I notice a 'one-day-only' high figure for places in the N/NE for Christmas Day, almost off the edge of the chart

ECM - same pattern as GFS

 

 


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

fairweather
24 December 2021 10:12:51

"Some areas" looks suspiciously like "my area yippee"!
(No problem - I would have been posting the same map, if it were over the West Country.)

Originally Posted by: some faraway beach 


S.Essex, 42m ASL
GezM
  • GezM
  • Advanced Member
24 December 2021 10:15:59

From 1947 to the here and now:

Wx summary keeps W Europe mild; a bit more deep cold to the NE showing but this makes a lunge towards the Balkans in week 2. Rain in week 1 from Uk down to Greece shifts in week 2 to UK up to Norway

Jet intermittent in strength and direction as loops form and pass through but never far from UK in next two weeks

GFS op - broad area of shallow LP around the UK Mon/Tue 27/28th then for rest of period the weather is controlled by LP S/SW of Iceland with strong SW-lies for the UK, extra strong when that LP generates secondaries  or simply moves closer e.g. Tue 4th & Sun 9th

GEFS - mean temps always above norm (except an early dip before temps recover in the N) and significantly so either side of Sat 1st . Good agreement to Mon 3rd after which a few colder runs creep in. Rain on and off throughout, heavier early on in the S and around around New Year in the N. Snow rows - there's a '10' in Inverness late on but otherwise forget it. EDIT - I notice a 'one-day-only' high figure for places in the N/NE for Christmas Day, almost off the edge of the chart

ECM - same pattern as GFS

 

Originally Posted by: DEW 

Shame about the early rain spikes. Otherwise I'm happy with mild ....


Living in St Albans, Herts (116m asl)

Working at Luton Airport, Beds (160m asl)

fairweather
24 December 2021 10:17:31

 

Not this nonsense again.

If winter starts on 22 December does summer not start until 22 June and not end until 21 September? 🙄

It has nothing whatever to do with any government agency nor is it related to some ‘statistical convenience’. It may amaze you to know that it’s actually about how the climate works. The sun’s output is at its lowest from mid-November to mid-February but you have to allow for the thermal lag in the oceans, which skews the 3-month winter period. There might be an argument that 2 weeks isn’t sufficient to reflect the ocean lag but 5 weeks is way too long.

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

........ not to mention that long term Dec, Jan, Feb have the lowest mean temperatures and lowest average max (by about 3C) ! Bit of a clue for winter months I think.


S.Essex, 42m ASL
fairweather
24 December 2021 10:19:55

Good points there. It was devastating for wildlife, but they did recover their numbers within 5 years. Must have been awful to witness. predators did well of course, but not the small birds and waders. Not so sure the wildlife would recover so easily today. Stoats turned white, as they often did in East Anglia (or half so) in the 60s. Most of the winters then saw snowy spells - just not lasting so long as that incredible winter. Many involved Scandi highs and lasted for 2 weeks. The volatility was less, and that perhaps is the key to tally’s question. I believe the increased heat has increased volatility, and especially the power and unpredictability of the jet stream. It is certainly true that the east used to bare the brunt of these easterly cold spells, and snow drifted regularly, to the extent, that until about 1998, Suffolk County Council paid for snow fencing along the A140, to drift the inevitable snow onto the verges to keep the roads clear. I remember that year they decided it was a waste of money, because the snow frequency had dropped remarkably. It is now very rare indeed, and only the Beast from the East repeated the historic phenomenon. Before that - there was a very brief event in 1996, a longer one in 1995 and before that 1991. Then a massive gap to 2009. 

Originally Posted by: BJBlake 

Spot on, as an even older fellow East Anglian. 


S.Essex, 42m ASL
Brian Gaze
24 December 2021 10:24:45

Question for Brian. Is the MOGREPS plot for Sheffield for the city centre (e.g 130masl) or a nearby peak?  Seems loads of difference between Sheffield and York - see below .

Originally Posted by: Tim A 

I can't remember off the top of my head what lat lon is used for that particular location. However, you can view more localised ones on the 16 day forecasts.

For example, Edale in Derbyshire is quite near I think, although I don't know the area well so you may find better locations from the place and postcode picker in the header bar on most pages.

https://www.theweatheroutlook.com/forecast/uk/Edale,Derbyshire

Dore, Sheffield is here:

https://www.theweatheroutlook.com/forecast/uk/Dore,South%20Yorkshire

 

In the next few weeks I'm intending to put an additional server in just to process the UK Met data so I'll should be able to increase the grid resolution from 0.5 deg to 0.2 deg on the MOGREPS-G charts.    

 

 


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

fairweather
24 December 2021 10:26:10

Ours did come along in 2010 and since then, I’ve been careful what I wish for!  I remember 1963 but for us in the East Midlands, it wasn’t bad and by no means the worst in my lifetime.  It seems the snowiest winters have mostly been around the start of each decade - except this one so far!

Originally Posted by: Caz 

Yes, it seems '63 and '47 were worst in the Southern half of the UK. I wonder if this is because, especially back then, there was more of a continental influence and with Siberian Highs which cause the most severe conditions and Easterlies the S.E is only tens of miles from the Continental land mass. Over the years most of my heaviest snow falls have actually  come from South-Easterlies when the Continent is cold. That is rare these days which is why the West and North have done better in this last couple of decades.


S.Essex, 42m ASL
Brian Gaze
24 December 2021 10:30:26

 

Yes, it seems '63 and '47 were worst in the Southern half of the UK. I wonder if this is because, especially back then, there was more of a continental influence and with Siberian Highs which cause the most severe conditions and Easterlies the S.E is only tens of miles from the Continental land mass. Over the years most of my heaviest snow falls have actually  come from South-Easterlies when the Continent is cold. That is rare these days which is why the West and North have done better in this last couple of decades.

Originally Posted by: fairweather 

I mentioned my dad's comments about 47. He rarely talked about 63 (living in York by then) and TBH I'd always thought it was a "bit of a bake" (a let down in his terminology) until I started looking at the stats. I've often wondered if the myth has grown over the years and the raw stats don't tell the complete story.


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Tim A
24 December 2021 10:52:14

 

I can't remember off the top of my head what lat lon is used for that particular location. However, you can view more localised ones on the 16 day forecasts.

For example, Edale in Derbyshire is quite near I think, although I don't know the area well so you may find better locations from the place and postcode picker in the header bar on most pages.

https://www.theweatheroutlook.com/forecast/uk/Edale,Derbyshire

Dore, Sheffield is here:

https://www.theweatheroutlook.com/forecast/uk/Dore,South%20Yorkshire

 

In the next few weeks I'm intending to put an additional server in just to process the UK Met data so I'll should be able to increase the grid resolution from 0.5 deg to 0.2 deg on the MOGREPS-G charts.    

 

 

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 


Tim

NW Leeds

187m asl

 My PWS 

ballamar
24 December 2021 10:52:51
www.wetterzentrale.de/maps/GFSOPEU06_300_1.png

Potential for another chase

Tim A
24 December 2021 10:53:47
https://modeles16.meteociel.fr/modeles/gfs/runs/2021122406/gfs-1-180.png?6 

Point of interest NYE there on the GFS, battleground, potential to be further north or south.


Tim

NW Leeds

187m asl

 My PWS 

DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
24 December 2021 10:55:23

 

 

I mentioned my dad's comments about 47. He rarely mentioned 63 (living in York by then) and TBH I'd always thought it was a "bit of a bake" (a let down in his terminology) until I started looking at the stats. I've often wondered if the myth has grown over the years and the raw stats don't tell the complete story.

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

In 1963 I was in Cambridge and I remember 1963 for its frosts - the Cam froze solidly enough for someone to drive a car on it. Although there was snow lying in Cambridge, my family on the S Coast (Hants/Dorset) remember it more for snow - there was a bus on the Isle of Wight ran into  a snowdrift up to its top deck


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
24 December 2021 10:59:01

 

My dad lived through 1947 and he always said it was bloody awful.

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

Exactly. One warm room in the house and coal bunker down to scrapings. I remember going with my father to collect two sacks (the maximum allowed) from the railway yard just in time. But he did build me an igloo in the garden (Kent/SE London)


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

fairweather
24 December 2021 11:03:15

 

I mentioned my dad's comments about 47. He rarely mentioned 63 (living in York by then) and TBH I'd always thought it was a "bit of a bake" (a let down in his terminology) until I started looking at the stats. I've often wondered if the myth has grown over the years and the raw stats don't tell the complete story.

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

No myth for the S.E and South and SW. Nothing comes close in our lifetime other than '47 which was close to it but a massive gap to the next ones, including 2010 down here. Although that said, I think '47 brought greater hardship. It was just after the war and many bombed out areas weren't cleared and the housing was poor with little or no heating and large fuel shortages as there was in '63 but heating was starting to be more sophisticated. In'47 my dad had to cut tree branches to get firewood, I remember him telling us that.


S.Essex, 42m ASL
fairweather
24 December 2021 11:10:52

it needs to be said before we move on to the annual lack of flight data issue.

Originally Posted by: MBrothers 


S.Essex, 42m ASL
fairweather
24 December 2021 11:16:55

 

........ not to mention that long term Dec, Jan, Feb have the lowest mean temperatures and lowest average max (by about 3C) ! Bit of a clue for winter months I think.

Originally Posted by: fairweather 

Just to be sure of the facts I've done a quick snapshot of my data for the last three (albeit mild) winters. If we change the winter months to Dec 21st to March 21st from the accepted three months the mean and average max are both higher in each year for the mid-winter to equinox values. By about 0.5C on average. So even the fact that we are an Island and influenced by sea temperatures that don't reach minimum till late March the existing definition of meteorological winter makes more sense.


S.Essex, 42m ASL
Gavin P
24 December 2021 11:30:23

 

I mentioned my dad's comments about 47. He rarely mentioned 63 (living in York by then) and TBH I'd always thought it was a "bit of a bake" (a let down in his terminology) until I started looking at the stats. I've often wondered if the myth has grown over the years and the raw stats don't tell the complete story.

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

The thing with 1963 is that (as is often the case with very easterly/Scandinavian High based winters) much of the time it would have been very cold, dry and frosty.

Of course there was a lot of snow in some places, some of the time and because it's so cold any snow that falls sticks for weeks one end, but when you go through the reanalysis there are many, many days where there's not much happening and the uppers don't even look that cold.

If that winter happened now I've no doubt you'd get people in social media moaning about "faux cold" and how boring it was haha 

1947 is truly unique for not only being very cold but also very snowy as one after another after another low pressure somehow gets diverted southwards. If that winter happened now everyone would be living on their wits waiting for one of those lows to end the freeze lol!


Rural West Northants 120m asl

Short, medium and long range weather forecast videos @ https://www.youtube.com/user/GavsWeatherVids

Remove ads from site