The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

Sevendust
25 December 2021 21:19:32

Because of course they are always right. 

Originally Posted by: DPower 

Given the standard of LRF's overall anything beyond 10 days is increasing speculation.

The only certainty is it looks like being a long winter in Model Output

Saint Snow
25 December 2021 21:39:12

Have to admit, the Met office updates today have made me feel rather nauseous.
Not good reading for coldies at all.

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

 

Met Office were piling on a cold Xmas and into January a week ago. 

They're doing their credibility no good chopping and changing so much to p*ss with the wind. 

 

 


Martin

Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)

A TWO addict since 14/12/01

"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."

Aneurin Bevan

MBrothers
25 December 2021 21:40:30
Most lrf I saw never went for a cold December. Most turned cold after the new year.
White Meadows
25 December 2021 22:32:42
To be fair Met office contingency planners release 29.11.21 did call this winter so far pretty well. And it does not make for pretty reading later on (for cold)
fairweather
25 December 2021 23:46:26

 

 

 

They're doing their credibility no good chopping and changing so much to p*ss with the wind. 

Originally Posted by: Saint Snow 

Yes , they should have just left it as a cold spell and ignored the models flip/flopping then going mild. That would really have enhanced their credibility!


S.Essex, 42m ASL
Gandalf The White
26 December 2021 00:01:16

 

Yes , they should have just left it as a cold spell and ignored the models flip/flopping then going mild. That would really have enhanced their credibility!

Originally Posted by: fairweather 

Exactly. I have never understood this fondness in certain quarters for Met Office bashing.  Some here complain when the written forecast isn’t changed with every GFS run and others complain when they wait for a clear signal.

We should all know after the last week just how tricky forecasting is for the U.K. in particular.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



MBrothers
26 December 2021 00:29:47

 

Exactly. I have never understood this fondness in certain quarters for Met Office bashing.  Some here complain when the written forecast isn’t changed with every GFS run and others complain when they wait for a clear signal.

We should all know after the last week just how tricky forecasting is for the U.K. in particular.

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

spot on

DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
26 December 2021 07:42:31

WX summary - W Europe mild and for week 1 at least well above norm. A cold pool swashing around W Russia, with any outflow heading S-wards to the Black Sea. Rain/pptn plentiful in coastal countries of Europe, intensifying and pushing a bit further E in week 2

GFS op - shallow LP over Uk for a couple of days then LP on Atlantic and HP over France bring up mild S-lies for the rest of the week through to Wed 5th. The LP gets closer towards the end of this period and is 960mb W Scotland Fri 7th bringing in a spell of N-lies esp Sun 9th as it moves to N Sea. Final charts show the S-ly regime back in

GEFS - becoming v mild and dry (for the S - Scotland looks much wetter) around New Year but mean (and most members of ens) still significantly above norm at other times with rain appearing frequently. Perhaps a little cooler at end of run from Sun 9th. Less certainty about temps in the N with both control and op dropping well below norm from time to time in the Highlands

ECM - like GFS to Tue 4th when LP develops first W Scotland and then deepening Fair Isle with strong W-lies for all

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

CField
26 December 2021 09:27:06

ECM is pretty deeadful on the eye this morning...pushing most of the cold uppers in Europe beyond the Urals by 240hrs.


Favourite snowstorm

Famous channel low

Dec 31st 1978

Hastings East Sussex

Foot of level snow severe drifting

Next day max temp -4 degrees Celsius

The Beast from the East
26 December 2021 09:33:44

ECM is pretty deeadful on the eye this morning...pushing most of the cold uppers in Europe beyond the Urals by 240hrs.

Originally Posted by: CField 

It couldnt get any worse from a cold point of view. 1989 all over again?


Purley, Surrey, 70m ASL

"We have some alternative facts for you"

Kelly-Ann Conway - former special adviser to the President

David M Porter
26 December 2021 09:57:22

As I have said before, I have long been of the view that the models tend to struggle to one degree or another with any pattern which deviates in any way from our default atlantic-based west to east pattern. If anyone needs any proof of this, they only need to look at all that has happened in the output in the last 10 or so days alone.

IIRC, it was last Sunday (19th Dec) when one or two GFS op runs began to pick up on the rise in pressure over Iberia at the 10-day range. That model now seems to be suggesting that height might start to lower a bit in that region as we go a little further into January with the main centre of heights located over the Azores with more of a westerly flow over the UK. Far from certain that this will happen as shown of course, but maybe we shouldn't always be too quick to dismiss GFS FI.


Lenzie, Glasgow

"A body of men holding themselves accountable to nobody ought not to be trusted by anybody." – Thomas Paine

doctormog
26 December 2021 10:15:05

As I have said before, I have long been of the view that the models tend to struggle to one degree or another with any pattern which deviates in any way from our default atlantic-based west to east pattern. If anyone needs any proof of this, they only need to look at all that has happened in the output in the last 10 or so days alone.

IIRC, it was last Sunday (19th Dec) when one or two GFS op runs began to pick up on the rise in pressure over Iberia at the 10-day range. That model now seems to be suggesting that height might start to lower a bit in that region as we go a little further into January with the main centre of heights located over the Azores with more of a westerly flow over the UK. Far from certain that this will happen as shown of course, but maybe we shouldn't always be too quick to dismiss GFS FI.

Originally Posted by: David M Porter 

Indeed David. On a different note he GFS 06z op run (not FI) has a rather chilly and potentially snowy Hogmanay for many parts of Scotland. 


BJBlake
26 December 2021 10:16:08

As I have said before, I have long been of the view that the models tend to struggle to one degree or another with any pattern which deviates in any way from our default atlantic-based west to east pattern. If anyone needs any proof of this, they only need to look at all that has happened in the output in the last 10 or so days alone.

IIRC, it was last Sunday (19th Dec) when one or two GFS op runs began to pick up on the rise in pressure over Iberia at the 10-day range. That model now seems to be suggesting that height might start to lower a bit in that region as we go a little further into January with the main centre of heights located over the Azores with more of a westerly flow over the UK. Far from certain that this will happen as shown of course, but maybe we shouldn't always be too quick to dismiss GFS FI.

Originally Posted by: David M Porter 

Yes - It has been a trend finder on numerous occasions. As it turned out for the worse recently, but proved correct. It does over exaggerate at times and seem to flip flop between scenarios, but the trends - it most certainly does seem to pick up. I think all models struggle with anything abnormal - (not west to east flow), they all did this time. Perhaps the rarity means the data is less numerous,  or the equations harder, due to the counter forces at work. As the general flow from the spin of the earth, is west to east, when something goes counter, the momentum proably has to be greater than that background push (from around the globe), and the jet is hardly a stable feature - even when flowing west to east. Amplified jets and loops/ bifurcated jets especially, are even less stable - apart from 1962/3 and to a lesser extent 1947, though in both cases, there was a lot less energy in the atmosphere then. It has to be more chaotic and less stable today, and that Volatility has to have had an impact on the models ability to calculate the forces at play for any distance ahead, due the variables. The ensemble scatter has been very wide at times endorsing this theory. However, as amateurs - and in the absence of seeing any research data, this is just a theory.


Brecklands, South Norfolk 28m ASL
DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
26 December 2021 10:23:48

Yes - It has been a trend finder on numerous occasions. As it turned out for the worse recently, but proved correct. It does over exaggerate at times and seem to flip flop between scenarios, but the trends - it most certainly does seem to pick up. I think all models struggle with anything abnormal - (not west to east flow), they all did this time. Perhaps the rarity means the data is less numerous,  or the equations harder, due to the counter forces at work. As the general flow from the spin of the earth, is west to east, when something goes counter, the momentum proably has to be greater than that background push (from around the globe), and the jet is hardly a stable feature - even when flowing west to east. Amplified jets and loops/ bifurcated jets especially, are even less stable - apart from 1962/3 and to a lesser extent 1947, though in both cases, there was a lot less energy in the atmosphere then. It has to be more chaotic and less stable today, and that Volatility has to have had an impact on the models ability to calculate the forces at play for any distance ahead, due the variables. The ensemble scatter has been very wide at times endorsing this theory. However, as amateurs - and in the absence of seeing any research data, this is just a theory.

Originally Posted by: BJBlake 

Er  - not so. If it were just the earth spinning, the air would spin at the same speed as the earth, i.e. stay where it was relative to the surface.

You need to look up Hadley, Ferrel and Polar cells to find out why W-lies predominate over the UK

https://www.bbc.co.uk/bitesize/guides/zpykxsg/revision/1

 


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

briggsy6
26 December 2021 11:07:16

Should I consider selling my new sledge and building an ark instead?


Location: Uxbridge
fairweather
26 December 2021 11:34:58

Should I consider selling my new sledge and building an ark instead?

Originally Posted by: briggsy6 

Yes. The two new ones I bought for my grandsons ten years ago are still unused. One of them will be 20 in May !


S.Essex, 42m ASL
Gooner
26 December 2021 11:40:57

BBC 4 at 9pm: winter 1963 special

Sorry off topic, but for those interested

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

Just watched this , love to experience something a kin to this , alas that is highly unlikely . I didn't realise there was a 3 day thaw before it returned with a vengeance 


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus

Banbury

North Oxfordshire

378 feet A S L



dagspot
26 December 2021 11:46:40

 

Just watched this , love to experience something a kin to this , alas that is highly unlikely . I didn't realise there was a 3 day thaw before it returned with a vengeance 

Originally Posted by: Gooner 

no doubt someone said ‘winter is over’ 


Neilston 600ft ASL
briggsy6
26 December 2021 11:53:08

1963. Ah for the good old days, when you had to dig yourself out of the house each morning and if your heating packed up you would most likely freeze to death! Thank god for global warming giving us our current run of balmy Winters.


Location: Uxbridge
RobN
  • RobN
  • Advanced Member
26 December 2021 12:25:55

1963. Ah for the good old days, when you had to dig yourself out of the house each morning and if your heating packed up you would most likely freeze to death! Thank god for global warming giving us our current run of balmy Winters.

Originally Posted by: briggsy6 

Enjoy them while you can before the AMOC shuts down


Rob

In the flatlands of South Cambridgeshire 15m ASL.

briggsy6
26 December 2021 12:35:02

That's the great irony of global warming of course for us: whilst the rest of the world warms we could be plunged into the freezer due to the Gulf Stream shutting down or realigning itself at a different latitude.


Location: Uxbridge
mulattokid
26 December 2021 12:35:54

 

Exactly. I have never understood this fondness in certain quarters for Met Office bashing.  Some here complain when the written forecast isn’t changed with every GFS run and others complain when they wait for a clear signal.

We should all know after the last week just how tricky forecasting is for the U.K. in particular.

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 


Located in West London

"Everything in life is our fault, but that's not our fault!"

Anonymous friend of Quentin Crisp

mulattokid
26 December 2021 12:37:05

That's the great irony of global warming of course for us: whilst the rest of the world warms we could be plunged into the freezer due to the Gulf Stream shutting down or realigning itself at a different latitude.

Originally Posted by: briggsy6 

  In theory, if it happened, that would mean colder winters, but hotter summers.


Located in West London

"Everything in life is our fault, but that's not our fault!"

Anonymous friend of Quentin Crisp

Jiries
26 December 2021 12:56:14

  In theory, if it happened, that would mean colder winters, but hotter summers.

Originally Posted by: mulattokid 

Or worse colder summers and mild winters with evidence of summers getting more colder.  Only way to provide us cold and hot days is constant easterly winds but no way from the west give us heat and cold weather.  We now very rare to see SE to NE winds any time of the year so temperatures becoming more temperate like this coming days to see 15-16C but same in poor summer days temps as well.

 

Gooner
26 December 2021 12:56:29

That's the great irony of global warming of course for us: whilst the rest of the world warms we could be plunged into the freezer due to the Gulf Stream shutting down or realigning itself at a different latitude.

Originally Posted by: briggsy6 

Can't possibly see that ever happening - there was a brief discussion on the other side talking about the UK having a canadian style climate ..................not in my time though 


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus

Banbury

North Oxfordshire

378 feet A S L



Remove ads from site