The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

tierradelfuego
23 December 2021 18:43:47

 

The Question is ....and it is the $100 dollar one,

Why did the models get it so wrong within a few days before it was due to materialise!?

Why were the models so wrong with the weather for eastern Europe - Moscow was not expecting -22c daytime maxes - although not uncommon the CFS forecast December for it to be above average for much of northern and eastern Europe. Why was there such a flip? What went wrong? Is it the MJO, was it Warmer than average SST's in the Atlantic adding fuel to our jet and enhancing LP systems! 

Another thing I have notice over the past few winters is that SE Europe are experiencing more cold more often and also NW America - take Vancouver for instance - their past 2-3 winters they have see exceptionally cold weather and it's only December and one day next week the temperature isn't expected to get above -10c all day in Vancouver and in Seattle the temperature will reach a daytime high of -6c on Monday! SOrry I know this isn't the rant thread but how can it be...? anyone?

Originally Posted by: tallyho_83 

 

I think the honest answer is that we are unlikely to ever know, so probably best to let it go. There are far too many variables for even any supercomputer to ever be able to computationally be able to accurately forecast, even with the AI algorithms and processing power that they now are able to use, it isn't as easy as (with all due respect) magic.

I only moved 5 years ago, and I know we have 8 days to go until the end of the month so things will change, but currently this December is colder than two and warmer than two of those years, so it isn't exactly way out in front in terms of our local average...


Bucklebury

West Berkshire Downs AONB

135m ASL

VP2 with daytime FARS

Rainfall collector separated at ground level

Anemometer separated above roof level

WeatherLink Live (Byles Green Crew )

David M Porter
23 December 2021 18:47:38

Looked at the 12z and yes! Throwing in the towel - game over for any cold and snow for the rest of December and 1st week of January! Temperatures look like a balmy 14 or 15c daytime between the 28th and 31st December for Exeter. wow! Why hasn't the Met Office picked up on this exceptionally mild weather!? I accept milder than average but gosh 14 or 15c for a week!? This is sickening! - Just shows that the Easterly QBO doesn't guarantee a colder and blocked pattern and neither does a La Nina guarantee a colder start to the winter! I have seem let down's before but this is the worse ever - agree!? This could be warmest December ever and there was me thinking that December 2015 was mild. Although for Scotland it is a different story!

Originally Posted by: tallyho_83 

I somehow doubt that, even for southern areas.

December 2015 was very mild and wet from start to finish and there were no colder spells at all from what I can recall. The atlantic this month has been generally much quieter (apart from Storm Barra on Dec 7th) in comparison to that December.


Lenzie, Glasgow

"A body of men holding themselves accountable to nobody ought not to be trusted by anybody." – Thomas Paine

White Meadows
23 December 2021 18:52:06

 

The Question is ....and it is the $100 dollar one,

Why did the models get it so wrong within a few days before it was due to materialise!?

Why were the models so wrong with the weather for eastern Europe - Moscow was not expecting -22c daytime maxes - although not uncommon the CFS forecast December for it to be above average for much of northern and eastern Europe. Why was there such a flip? What went wrong? Is it the MJO, was it Warmer than average SST's in the Atlantic adding fuel to our jet and enhancing LP systems! 

Another thing I have notice over the past few winters is that SE Europe are experiencing more cold more often and also NW America - take Vancouver for instance - their past 2-3 winters they have see exceptionally cold weather and it's only December and one day next week the temperature isn't expected to get above -10c all day in Vancouver and in Seattle the temperature will reach a daytime high of -6c on Monday! SOrry I know this isn't the rant thread but how can it be...? anyone?

Originally Posted by: tallyho_83 

easy answer: volitility. Out spot on the planet is between an enormous warm bath and sometimes (as currently) a freezing land mass. The gradient is obviously too much and ultimately causes massive malfunctions.

Moscow? Easy.  

Chunky Pea
23 December 2021 18:58:06

 

The Question is ....and it is the $100 dollar one,

Why did the models get it so wrong within a few days before it was due to materialise!?

Why were the models so wrong with the weather for eastern Europe - Moscow was not expecting -22c daytime maxes - although not uncommon the CFS forecast December for it to be above average for much of northern and eastern Europe. Why was there such a flip? What went wrong? Is it the MJO, was it Warmer than average SST's in the Atlantic adding fuel to our jet and enhancing LP systems! 

Another thing I have notice over the past few winters is that SE Europe are experiencing more cold more often and also NW America - take Vancouver for instance - their past 2-3 winters they have see exceptionally cold weather and it's only December and one day next week the temperature isn't expected to get above -10c all day in Vancouver and in Seattle the temperature will reach a daytime high of -6c on Monday! SOrry I know this isn't the rant thread but how can it be...? anyone?

Originally Posted by: tallyho_83 

You'll probably find this hard to stomach, but the models actually got the broader pattern pretty much spot on well over a week ago. It's just the finer details closer the time that they struggled with, as they also tend to do anyway a few days out. 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Gandalf The White
23 December 2021 18:59:18

 

 

I think the honest answer is that we are unlikely to ever know, so probably best to let it go. There are far too many variables for even any supercomputer to ever be able to computationally be able to accurately forecast, even with the AI algorithms and processing power that they now are able to use, it isn't as easy as (with all due respect) magic.

I only moved 5 years ago, and I know we have 8 days to go until the end of the month so things will change, but currently this December is colder than two and warmer than two of those years, so it isn't exactly way out in front in terms of our local average...

Originally Posted by: tierradelfuego 

IMO there are two basic weaknesses in the models which are unlikely ever to be corrected fully.  The first is that the models are just a set of mathematical equations reflecting the physics that drives the atmosphere. Even though they’re better than they used to be, they remain just an approximation of how the atmosphere will behave.

The greater problem is that the initialisation can only ever be approximated because there aren’t enough readings of all the variables at all levels across the entire globe.  Of course, the ensemble suites are supposed to test for the sensitivity of the assumptions but that’s all they can do - and we see in the way that tiny tweaks throw out hugely different evolutions amongst individual perturbations.  

We know that from time to time the op and the entire ensemble suite can change tack quite abruptly, as now, and I think this may be because the opening position was more error-prone, for whatever reason - or those errors had greater consequences much quicker.


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



Gandalf The White
23 December 2021 19:01:53

 

You'll probably find this hard to stomach, but the models actually got the broader pattern pretty much spot on well over a week ago. It's just the finer details closer the time that they struggled with, as they also tend to do anyway a few days out. 

Originally Posted by: Chunky Pea 

Except for suddenly picking up on the rapid demise of high latitude height rises. 


Location: South Cambridgeshire

130 metres ASL

52.0N 0.1E



Chunky Pea
23 December 2021 19:06:26

 

Except for suddenly picking up on the rapid demise of high latitude height rises. 

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

Heights to the north were never really progged as being that strong if I remember correctly. 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

David M Porter
23 December 2021 19:06:43

 

Was that the famous easterly which was derailed by the sudden development of a short wave feature (low pressure) over the Baltic/northern Germany, which simply cut off the easterly flow?

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

It could well have been that occasion, Peter, althought I'm not 100% sure of that.

I do recall that at one point in early December 2012, there was an occasion when the models went for an easterly later in the month which was then dropped in favour of an atlantic-dominated set-up, and it was the latter that came to pass. I do also remember though that there was something of a pattern change about a week or so into January 2013 when the atlantic spell came to quite a quick and sudden end and was replaced by a rather colder and drier spell of weather in many areas.


Lenzie, Glasgow

"A body of men holding themselves accountable to nobody ought not to be trusted by anybody." – Thomas Paine

David M Porter
23 December 2021 19:08:14

 

Heights to the north were never really progged as being that strong if I remember correctly. 

Originally Posted by: Chunky Pea 

Not on a consistent basis and within the reliable timeframe anyway, CP.


Lenzie, Glasgow

"A body of men holding themselves accountable to nobody ought not to be trusted by anybody." – Thomas Paine

dagspot
23 December 2021 19:08:58
a lot of bold mystic meg predictions… and so far out! First, long fetch hairdryers and blowtorches, now daffodils…
Neilston 600ft ASL
tallyho_83
23 December 2021 19:10:59

Thanks All, however - I still lost faith in these model output if they can't get anything right within a few days in advance such as going for an easterly wind to north easterly to easterly then south westerly and then to pure southerly/south westerly air stream! I wonder how much faith weather forecasters can put into these computer models when they are so unreliable 72 - 96 hrs out and can flip so suddenly as shown on previous page?

Must be a nightmare for forecasters!?

Furthermore, I have notice in recent years that the models are becoming more unreliable and I wonder if climate change is to do with this as well?

Anyway, enough for now from me!

Merry Christmas All and let's hope January delivers if not all eyes on a SSW to deliver something - but even then that isn't a guarantee either!? - Last winter the SSW delivered severe extreme cold to Texas and the mid west end of January and SE Europe. UK missed out except the SE and east but even then it wasn't proper locked in cold which delivered any substantial snow!


Home Location - Vixen Tor Close, Okehampton, Devon (221m ASL)

---------------------------------------

Sean Moon

Magical Moon

www.magical-moon.com

picturesareme
23 December 2021 19:16:29

a lot of bold mystic meg predictions… and so far out! First, long fetch hairdryers and blowtorches, now daffodils…

Originally Posted by: dagspot 

Daffodils are already beginning to shoot down here 😅

Chunky Pea
23 December 2021 19:19:51

Thanks All, however - I still lost faith in these model output if they can't get anything right within a few days in advance such as going for an easterly wind to north easterly to easterly then south westerly and then to pure southerly/south westerly air stream! I wonder how much faith weather forecasters can put into these computer models when they are so unreliable 72 - 96 hrs out and can flip so suddenly as shown on previous page?

Originally Posted by: tallyho_83 

Almost forgot that I saved these two images from the 16th. The GEFS and ECMWF mean 10 day charts, which at that point brought us up 00z on Christmas Morning:

ECM:

and the GEFS:

 

It's debatable as to which model came the closest, but although many differences between the two, both picked up on the broader synoptic scale pattern pretty well. 

 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

Lionel Hutz
23 December 2021 19:20:55

Thanks All, however - I still lost faith in these model output if they can't get anything right within a few days in advance such as going for an easterly wind to north easterly to easterly then south westerly and then to pure southerly/south westerly air stream! I wonder how much faith weather forecasters can put into these computer models when they are so unreliable 72 - 96 hrs out and can flip so suddenly as shown on previous page?

Originally Posted by: tallyho_83 

But I'm not sure that the models got it all that far wrong. Scotland will do fairly well out of this, albeit for a shorter period than we might have hoped a few days ago. What's happened here is that the cold just didn't get far enough South. But that's only a matter of a few hundred miles. We have to allow for some margin of error in the models.


Lionel Hutz

Nr.Waterford , S E Ireland

68m ASL



Chunky Pea
23 December 2021 19:26:58

 

Daffodils are already beginning to shoot down here 😅

Originally Posted by: picturesareme 

I still have summer plants blooming out the front and back. Surreal. Usually either the frost or the wind will have had them killed off well by now, but we've had none of either. 


Patrick,

East Galway, Ireland.

MBrothers
23 December 2021 20:16:10
Here in Newquay it’s just one long autumn. One air frost so far. Does make u think .
White Meadows
23 December 2021 20:31:24
BBC 4 at 9pm: winter 1963 special

Sorry off topic, but for those interested

tierradelfuego
23 December 2021 20:37:16

Merry Christmas All and let's hope January delivers if not all eyes on a SSW to deliver something - but even then that isn't a guarantee either!? - Last winter the SSW delivered severe extreme cold to Texas and the mid west end of January and SE Europe. UK missed out except the SE and east but even then it wasn't proper locked in cold which delivered any substantial snow!

Originally Posted by: tallyho_83 

 

Correct, so no point pining any hope of an SSW bringing something different and bringing what many of us wish for... I'm sure you wont of course.


Bucklebury

West Berkshire Downs AONB

135m ASL

VP2 with daytime FARS

Rainfall collector separated at ground level

Anemometer separated above roof level

WeatherLink Live (Byles Green Crew )

ballamar
23 December 2021 20:39:08
For all those who are despondent, just remember Xmas day is a Saturday we will get absolute dream charts for a couple of days to get excited about. Just the usual dross to get out the way first.
Gooner
23 December 2021 20:47:55

Massively deflated , EQBO , MJO into 7 EC46 showing 2-3 weeks of blocking , models not worth the paper they are printed on . Just goes to show in complex situations they are naff it's like p&%^* in the wind.

 

Just shows EVERYTHING has to be bang on to get a classic in the UK

 

Just wondering what the Met are seeing ?

Nearly a 1/3 of the way through the Winter and with TWO , NET W and Gav going for a colder than average Winter going to see what Jan and Feb and March actually throw at us.

 

As I said a few weeks ago Ice in November to bear a duck ........blah blah blah , I wonder 


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus

Banbury

North Oxfordshire

378 feet A S L



CField
23 December 2021 21:10:42

BBC 4 at 9pm: winter 1963 special

Sorry off topic, but for those interested

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

that's the dream isn't it .To live through a winter like that or a 1947.No one disputes a winter like that will happen again, a bit like you play the lottery long enough your numbers will come up, trouble is what good is a lottery win when you are 98? I am like many others on here getting old and grey patiently waiting for that winter to come along but fearing time is running out!


Favourite snowstorm

Famous channel low

Dec 31st 1978

Hastings East Sussex

Foot of level snow severe drifting

Next day max temp -4 degrees Celsius

fairweather
23 December 2021 21:22:18

that's the dream isn't it .To live through a winter like that or a 1947.No one disputes a winter like that will happen again, a bit like you play the lottery long enough your numbers will come up, trouble is what good is a lottery win when you are 98? I am like many others on here getting old and grey patiently waiting for that winter to come along but fearing time is running out!

Originally Posted by: CField 

Watch it everyone! Then ask me what it was like as a 12 year old up to your neck in drifts. I've been searching for it and expecting it again for 60 years now with no joy. Been a few good ones but nothing comes close.


S.Essex, 42m ASL
White Meadows
23 December 2021 21:26:09

that's the dream isn't it .To live through a winter like that or a 1947.No one disputes a winter like that will happen again, a bit like you play the lottery long enough your numbers will come up, trouble is what good is a lottery win when you are 98? I am like many others on here getting old and grey patiently waiting for that winter to come along but fearing time is running out!

Originally Posted by: CField 

I would thoroughly enjoy the experience.

Call me a weirdo, I’m ok with that. 

Gooner
23 December 2021 21:38:39

 

I would thoroughly enjoy the experience.

Call me a weirdo, I’m ok with that. 

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

I'd love it 

 

The harshest the better , be bloody great 


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus

Banbury

North Oxfordshire

378 feet A S L



western100
23 December 2021 21:40:44

Massively deflated , EQBO , MJO into 7 EC46 showing 2-3 weeks of blocking , models not worth the paper they are printed on . Just goes to show in complex situations they are naff it's like p&%^* in the wind.

 

Just shows EVERYTHING has to be bang on to get a classic in the UK

 

Just wondering what the Met are seeing ?

Nearly a 1/3 of the way through the Winter and with TWO , NET W and Gav going for a colder than average Winter going to see what Jan and Feb and March actually throw at us.

 

As I said a few weeks ago Ice in November to bear a duck ........blah blah blah , I wonder 

Originally Posted by: Gooner 

 

Its remarkable, my thoughts are mixed and trying to stay realistic to reality and reflect. 

Typically cold winters are rare in the UK. I’ve only experienced 5 colder than average winters in the UK. Even if your born in 1980 you won’t have experienced many more colder than average winters. 

Typically what we see now is probably very normal but my thoughts are alarmed by how many background signals are supportive of a colder than average winter. 

This makes the start of winter very perplexing and the next 2 weeks (currently) don’t show much more than what we are seeing now. That will take us to mid winter (almost) 

The background signals may well give some cold weather, I have no doubt there’s a high chance of that. It may come later and we’ve had as many cold March as we have other winter months. 

With no colder than average December since 2010 I do believe firmly our current climate has made December an autumnal month by temperatures and (early) March a 3rd winter month (2.5 winter months, as late March is often much warmer than early March)

Ive said to many times as well, I truly think GH HPs often very little to the UK. I’ve not experienced many cold periods with a GH HP. Currently…for me….our cold is delivered by mid Atlantic ridges. Seldom to Scandi HPs also provide cold on their own (more chance than GH, IMO of course)

 


Worcestershire / Warwickshire Border

100m ASL

X…..@Weather4u2

Remove ads from site