The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

Tractor Boy
13 January 2021 07:57:38

I don't ALWAYS dismiss cold in the models, but it needs to be in 48-72 hour time frame. Anything past that invariably never verifies, whereas if they show long fetch southwesterlies, even 10 days hence, they invariably are on the money. 

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

Moomin, in that case then maybe avoid discussing the output beyond 72 hours and allow everyone else to discuss the model output (see title of thread) without dismissal based on your emotional reflex to avoid disappointment?

 


Dave

Farndale, North York Moors

13 January 2021 08:00:06
Definite downgrades this morning for sure, but based on one 00z set only. The ensembles look uncertain, rather than decided. Certain posters with an agenda see only one thing (that swings both ways) but I'm not certain it is wise to pin your colours to any mast this morning. Beast from the East? Not enough evidence. Zonal SW'lies? Not enough evidence.

That wise mantra of 'more runs needed' is our only sane guide at the moment, IMO.


Malcolm UserPostedImage

Wakefield & Gothenburg, SWE

ballamar
13 January 2021 08:01:18
I must be the only person still feeling a little positive, the route to cold is not smooth in the face of a big pattern change. There is more than enough in the ENS to show that. Subsequent runs can easily show this so until there are only a very small number showing a favourable outcome I am positive. But if it doesn’t it was fun
Caz
  • Caz
  • Advanced Member
13 January 2021 08:03:06

People question why I am so negative and always glass half empty. Believe it or not, I want to see a proper winter as much as the next person, but I have learned over the years to ALWAYS expect the worst for this country and you won't go far wrong. If I genuinely see promise that looks like delivering, I will shout it from the rooftops, I really will, but I never bought into this, and sadly so it seems to be.
I will always err on the side of caution when it comes to models showing something cold. If the real cold continues to be 10 days away and never coming closer, it invariably will never happen.
I am sure one day the UK will hit the jackpot again, but for me, I'm going to start looking for signs of spring, because I don't think winter 2020/21 is going to deliver.

Originally Posted by: moomin75 


It isn’t about gut feeling, usual outcomes or odds, which may well be correct.  It’s about interpreting what you see in the model output and discussing it.  The clue is in the thread title Moomin. 


Market Warsop, North Nottinghamshire.

Join the fun and banter of the monthly CET competition.

moomin75
13 January 2021 08:03:22

 

Yes, he totally and possibly intentionally missed the point entirely.

Originally Posted by: doctormog 

If you think I'm clever enough to intentionally miss a point then you are mistaken Michael. I do not have the intelligence to post loaded posts or think hard about intentionally doing anything to antagonise.

I am trying to say that models handle mild westerly and South westerly winds far, far better than anything that is out of the ordinary. That really isn't a difficult thing to grasp.

It's akin to a maths expert handling a difficult mathematical problem far better than he handles reciting the entire works of Shakespeare in Latin.

I'm sorry if my posts are antagonising, I am really not intending to, I am just trying to say that its very hard to buy into a cold scenario when the cold charts are always out of reach at 7 days-plus.

The 2010 December to remember, the cold got closer and closer, rather than staying out at 7 to 10 days permanently.

Had the models been bringing this faux cold spell forward by 24 hours each day, I would, of course, have been interested, but the real cold constantly stayed out at that range and never got closer.


Witney, Oxfordshire

100m ASL

DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member
13 January 2021 08:07:46

 

I am trying to say that models handle mild westerly and South westerly winds far, far better than anything that is out of the ordinary. That really isn't a difficult thing to grasp.

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

I'm with you on this one. The programmers of models have had much more experience of SW-lies due to the prevalence of this type of weather and thus more opportunity to refine the models.

But I remain optimistic when confronted with a cold scenario, even despite past disappointments.


I can calculate the movements of stars, but not the madness of men - Isaac Newton

Chichester 12m asl

doctormog
13 January 2021 08:08:29

I must be the only person still feeling a little positive, the route to cold is not smooth in the face of a big pattern change. There is more than enough in the ENS to show that. Subsequent runs can easily show this so until there are only a very small number showing a favourable outcome I am positive. But if it doesn’t it was fun

Originally Posted by: ballamar 

As Malcolm rightly says, more runs needed. A further shift away from the scenario of the last few days over the next couple of sets of runs or days would be the final nail in the coffin. Conversely a shift back in the other direction would change the mood.

The time period to watch is, and always has been, from the 19th to the 22nd for any cold to move in. Things have wobbled around by a day or two on each set of runs but, up to the 00z suite, the trend was the steady. Has that changed? Ask me tomorrow (or after the 06z GFS )).


nsrobins
13 January 2021 08:10:14

If you think I'm clever enough to intentionally miss a point then you are mistaken Michael. I do not have the intelligence to post loaded posts or think hard about intentionally doing anything to antagonise.

I am trying to say that models handle mild westerly and South westerly winds far, far better than anything that is out of the ordinary. That really isn't a difficult thing to grasp.

It's akin to a maths expert handling a difficult mathematical problem far better than he handles reciting the entire works of Shakespeare in Latin.

I'm sorry if my posts are antagonising, I am really not intending to, I am just trying to say that its very hard to buy into a cold scenario when the cold charts are always out of reach at 7 days-plus.

Originally Posted by: moomin75 

The model ‘bias’ theory has I believe been debunked. There is no evidence that an algorithm will ‘handle’ one particular synoptic better than another and to suggest it does is a bit misguided. The correlation stats tend to be a little better in summer with long-lived high pressure because the set-up is already inherently stable. In winter the performance is more or less the same whatever the weather type.


Neil

Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)

Stormchaser, Member TORRO

TimS
  • TimS
  • Advanced Member
13 January 2021 08:13:04
The model bias theory is classic British exceptionalism. These models are global: they predict atmospheric flows worldwide of which the North East corner of the Atlantic is but one tiny piece.
Brockley, South East London 30m asl
Retron
13 January 2021 08:14:27
FWIW the 0z ECM ensembles have flipped a good couple of degrees milder too, with none of the 50 members showing -10C at 850 for London in the next 10 days.

https://www.ecmwf.int/en/forecasts/charts/web/classical_meteogram?facets=undefined&time=2021011300,0,2021011300&epsgram=classical_plume&lat=51.5084&lon=-0.125533&station_name=London,%20United%20Kingdom&altitude=21 


Leysdown, north Kent
Whether Idle
13 January 2021 08:16:37

If this January can't deliver the goods to southern counties one does have to wonder how much the odds have changed since the 1980s.

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

A great deal I would say Brian.  Coastal areas seem to be particularly maligned in that respect just at present, but the warming climate will continue, inexorably, sweeping its changes over all parts, as its a global phenomena and impossible to resist through ostriching or denial.


Dover, 5m asl. Half a mile from the south coast.
moomin75
13 January 2021 08:18:19
I am going to move on from this now, and say to everyone who I may have antagonised that really is not my intention.

Doc, I respect you hugely as a long time member of this forum. I think we've been around as long as each other.

I can tell you now, that I want to see a winter wonderland as much as the next guy, and I will be first to shout from the rooftops if we see the models showing something significant that steadily comes into range.

Onwards and upwards. I won't write off winter just yet, there is always February. It will only be in March that I officially write it off.


Witney, Oxfordshire

100m ASL

Brian Gaze
13 January 2021 08:19:52

The model bias theory is classic British exceptionalism. These models are global: they predict atmospheric flows worldwide of which the North East corner of the Atlantic is but one tiny piece.

Originally Posted by: TimS 

I recently received a formal complaint from a member of the public for using charts (or model data to be more precise) from Meteo France rather than British sources. I politely explained the reasons for doing so.


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

idj20
13 January 2021 08:23:11

 

I think its game over already. The writing was on the wall yesterday. The next two days will now show a steady correction back to the westerlies. It's disappointing but not as painful as previous crashes of the past, probably due to the fact we are fairly used to it now. 

I'm just so glad weather is no longer my only hobby. 

 

Originally Posted by: Gusty 

Me too with the hobby thing.

Also I don't know why everyone are picking on Moomin as I'm finding myself agreeing with him for the most part, simply because I do think we (or rather, I) we no longer do proper actual winters but more as an extension to Autumn. For the most part it really has been feeling like chasing rainbows with tasty looking outputs constantly out of reach, now it becomes a case of hoping we get to avoid the worst of the wind and rain. 


Home location: Folkestone Harbour.
Rob K
13 January 2021 08:23:48

 

I'm with you on this one. The programmers of models have had much more experience of SW-lies due to the prevalence of this type of weather and thus more opportunity to refine the models.

But I remain optimistic when confronted with a cold scenario, even despite past disappointments.

Originally Posted by: DEW 

I don’t see how that can be the case at all. Remember that the GFS for instance is an American model and that the G stands for “global”. Why on Earth should it perform better for a global circulation pattern that just happens to have south westerlies over our tiny patch of planet? Zoom out and it’s just a meander in the jet stream. 


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl

"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome

Whether Idle
13 January 2021 08:24:58

 

I recently received a formal complaint from a member of the public for using charts (or model data to be more precise) from Meteo France rather than British sources. I politely explained the reasons for doing so.

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

O M G.  Brexit demented cretins know no limits.  FFS.


Dover, 5m asl. Half a mile from the south coast.
Hippydave
13 January 2021 08:25:01

Fairly noticeable move away from sustained cold in the South from the GFS this morning I see, although both Op and Control show how easy it is to pull cold air over most of the UK for a day or two in the projected set up, even after the initial pattern collapses. Scotland fares better but even here there's some mild scatter appearing suggesting how far North the encroaching LPs get is still uncertain (as you'd expect, it's FI after all). 

Probably worth noting the GFS Op still brings an initial push from the North for 3 days or so even down here - it's not removed the cold signal, just decided the Atlantic will have more influence. 

ECM is pretty consistent in it's run versus the last day or so - LP over us with cool but not cold uppers, snow for some, rain for others, possibly mostly dry and chilly for quite a few too. Hints in the T240 chart that colder air may make it over us although the big Atlantic LP may also move towards or over us too. Fairly steady set of deviation ens suggesting a cool down to chilly at least is still favoured. (Just seen Darren's ens link - colder air still looks favoured longer term on that to me, although not as he notes any deep cold).

GEM brings in coldish air also having LP over the UK and eventually collapses the HP over us to give a couple more cold days post the end of it's run. Bit uncertain what would happen after that with a weird/messy picture in the Atlantic albeit the LPs don't seem to be steaming through us, more spinning around.

It'll be interesting to see what the GFS does in the next few runs as to whether it sustains the 'not really got a clue' scatter of the 00z ens (albeit there's still enough cold clustering in the mid term to suggest that remains a plausible option) or whether it starts to remove the cold signal entirely. I know there's been a lot of comment about the GFS being too far west but at least as important to me is that today's effort doesn't have anywhere near as strong a HP build over Greenland and that helps to allow much more Atlantic influence than yesterday's runs which had a much stronger and cleaner HP in place. The less enthusiastic HP build was a feature of the uncertainty before yesterday's stellar 6z run so not massively surprising to see it back today. 

The good news IMO is even with this mornings models we're due to get some colder air over us, it's just the possibility of deep and sustained cold is much more remote on the runs as they stand. The latter part being more true the further south in the UK you are. It's not the classic we were being teased with (although still time to move back towards that) but it remains a cold and unsettled outlook and there'll always be interest in that

 

 

 

 

 


Home: Tunbridge Wells

Work: Tonbridge

Surrey John
13 January 2021 08:27:08
I am not sure how last nights model produced a much less cold outcome that was inconsistent with previous few runs.

My only guess is something was unusual (possibly the current boundary, the trough with cold to East) as a start point, and this created a battleground from which the seriously different evolution span out.

If that is the case (and it is guesswork) then next few runs might be all over place as well, until the dominant trend makes its way in. Something isn’t normal, as shouldn’t be this level of inconsistency between runs, but I have no idea what


Bradford on Avon, Wiltshire

35m ASL

backtobasics
13 January 2021 08:27:11

I can't quite understand the mood in here this morning, the more extreme charts of days ago were always likely to be watered down to some extent many posters even said as much. Still a signal for cooler / colder shots which could give some of us some snow, just less chance of an extended deep freeze which tbf are like hens teeth these days, dare I say in this era 😋

Chin up folks, two ways you can look at it, still some weeks of winter left, or as I prefer we are getting closer to spring 😁

Just to add there is also time for things to swing back the other way a little ?

Jiries
13 January 2021 08:56:43

 

I recently received a formal complaint from a member of the public for using charts (or model data to be more precise) from Meteo France rather than British sources. I politely explained the reasons for doing so.

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

Nothing wrong with using Meteo charts as the German charts as in the 90s days I used to rely on Astra channels of German and Holland to look for hot or cold weather as when you look at their 6 days forecast you can see the dropping of the temps like Amsterdam went to do day time max in November 1993 -4C and you can work out that my area will get 0 to -1C which came off.  Also Euronews used to have good 6 days teletext forecasts which is very accurate and good to know what ahead of you.

Hippydave
13 January 2021 08:57:39

Personally I think the issue with some comments in here lately is that the title of the thread is Model Output Discussion, not dismissing anything in the models that doesn't show a mild South Westerly. 

The entire point of the thread is to discuss what the models show, not to dismiss what they show. Highlighting the uncertainty and explaining why you think the milder options that have mostly been present (more so for the South) in the GFS ens are a more plausible outcome is fine. Just saying because milder always wins doesn't add anything though. 

Its fair enough* if your personal view is to ignore anything post T96 unless it shows milder and unsettled but maybe don't clog a discussion thread up with that as it's not IMO what the thread is for and will just cause unnecessary irritation. 

We all know colder solutions are rarer and harder to get to T0, if nothing else because it means an interruption to the prevailing flow but the fun of this thread is seeing colder solutions in FI and watching them develop because this one may verify as shown (although experience says it'll probably be a watered down version if it happens). 

Whilst I'm having a whingy post the whole 'cold has remained at 7 - 10 days thing is irritating - we actually got colder air brought it at much shorter notice than that with the next few days. Also, the projected Greenie HP build now starts to happen at circa T120, that's got steadily closer over the last few days as you'd want to see. What has changed this morning is the strength of that build and, over the last few days, the placement of the trough - much more over us than just to the East as had been projected previously. 

On the models handling a SW flow better thing IMO SW flows are usually a stable pattern where slight changes to the input don't usually change things too much on the ground in the UK. Anything that interrupts the usual SW flow is unusual and generally relies on all sorts of factors where slight changes do have a big impact. The maths for each stay the same but changes in the input used will impact the pattern much more noticeably. If my initial data position for example has 95% of the jet energy in the southern arm in a zonal set up, but that changes to 91% I'll probably still have a zonal flow but maybe with a little less oomph than FI showed. If FI was showing a pressure build to Greenie though and I stick another 4% energy in to the Northern arm of the jet, that can be the difference between a toppling ridge and a clean HP build (Gandalf made this point this a while ago when I queried why GFS's Greenie HP builds in the last cold spell didn't verify ). 

*Given we're at the edge of a warmish ocean and climatically speaking our weather is relatively mild and wet you could ignore most of the output most of the time and correctly call the general pattern the majority of the time without ever looking at the models, certainly in late autumn/winter. 

 


Home: Tunbridge Wells

Work: Tonbridge

Brian Gaze
13 January 2021 09:02:24

 

*Given we're at the edge of a warmish ocean and climatically speaking our weather is relatively mild and wet you could ignore most of the output most of the time and correctly call the general pattern the majority of the time without ever looking at the models, certainly in late autumn/winter. 

 

Originally Posted by: Hippydave 

If the year was 1978 I don't think that approach would yield such good results over the following 13 years.


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Arbroath 1320
13 January 2021 09:07:42

Wow, incredible reaction on here to one set of runs.

Whilst it could be the first signs of a pattern change, let's see what the 12zs bring.


Kenmore, Highland Perthshire, GGTTH
Brian Gaze
13 January 2021 09:09:22

On the model accuracy issue a thought occurred to me. It would be interesting to take several grid points across the UK and run a script to verify forecast accuracy from the different models. Exactly the same as NCEP do on the global level. I'm not sure if anyone is doing this. Technically it is quite easy but I don't really have the time at the moment. Alternatively it's possible NCEP can subset their data down to a very granular level, but I've not seen it published anywhere.


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Lionel Hutz
13 January 2021 09:13:58

Fairly noticeable move away from sustained cold in the South from the GFS this morning I see, although both Op and Control show how easy it is to pull cold air over most of the UK for a day or two in the projected set up, even after the initial pattern collapses. Scotland fares better but even here there's some mild scatter appearing suggesting how far North the encroaching LPs get is still uncertain (as you'd expect, it's FI after all). 

Probably worth noting the GFS Op still brings an initial push from the North for 3 days or so even down here - it's not removed the cold signal, just decided the Atlantic will have more influence. 

ECM is pretty consistent in it's run versus the last day or so - LP over us with cool but not cold uppers, snow for some, rain for others, possibly mostly dry and chilly for quite a few too. Hints in the T240 chart that colder air may make it over us although the big Atlantic LP may also move towards or over us too. Fairly steady set of deviation ens suggesting a cool down to chilly at least is still favoured. (Just seen Darren's ens link - colder air still looks favoured longer term on that to me, although not as he notes any deep cold).

GEM brings in coldish air also having LP over the UK and eventually collapses the HP over us to give a couple more cold days post the end of it's run. Bit uncertain what would happen after that with a weird/messy picture in the Atlantic albeit the LPs don't seem to be steaming through us, more spinning around.

It'll be interesting to see what the GFS does in the next few runs as to whether it sustains the 'not really got a clue' scatter of the 00z ens (albeit there's still enough cold clustering in the mid term to suggest that remains a plausible option) or whether it starts to remove the cold signal entirely. I know there's been a lot of comment about the GFS being too far west but at least as important to me is that today's effort doesn't have anywhere near as strong a HP build over Greenland and that helps to allow much more Atlantic influence than yesterday's runs which had a much stronger and cleaner HP in place. The less enthusiastic HP build was a feature of the uncertainty before yesterday's stellar 6z run so not massively surprising to see it back today. 

The good news IMO is even with this mornings models we're due to get some colder air over us, it's just the possibility of deep and sustained cold is much more remote on the runs as they stand. The latter part being more true the further south in the UK you are. It's not the classic we were being teased with (although still time to move back towards that) but it remains a cold and unsettled outlook and there'll always be interest in that

 

 

 

 

 

Originally Posted by: Hippydave 

That's good, level headed analysis.

https://www.theweatheroutlook.com/twodata/gefs.aspx?modelrun=na&lg=850&lglocation=London

Looking at the "spaghettis", the control and Op. clearly flip the wrong way for coldies around the 23rd(indeed, the control never appears terribly interested in cold in the first place). However, there is still a cluster of colder options remaining after the 23rd, so the possibility of the Op. swinging back towards cold is still live, particularly given that the 23rd is still at +240. 


Lionel Hutz

Nr.Waterford , S E Ireland

68m ASL



Remove ads from site