The Weather Outlook

Remove ads from site

Brian Gaze
23 December 2020 09:02:37

I don't know why people struggle to understand. The points is simple: In recent years there has been less deep cold pooling at the 850hPa level than there was several decades ago. However, that doesn't mean -10C 850hPa can't reach the UK, just that is is less likely if all other things remain equal. 


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

The Beast from the East
23 December 2020 09:05:53

Some great posts BJBlake, completely agree!

We might get lucky this season, at the least the synoptics are there which is the main piece of the puzzle.

I still have my winter tyres, never needed them so far, but you never know!

 


Purley, Surrey, 70m ASL

"We have some alternative facts for you"

Kelly-Ann Conway - former special adviser to the President

BJBlake
23 December 2020 09:06:24

I don't know why people struggle to understand. The points is simple: In recent years there has been less deep cold pooling at the 850hPa level than there was several decades ago. However, that doesn't mean -10C 850hPa can't reach the UK, just that is is less likely if all other things remain equal. 

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

Thank you Brian. You said is so much more succinctly than my ramble. 


Brecklands, South Norfolk 28m ASL
Brian Gaze
23 December 2020 09:07:20

Some great posts BJBlake, completely agree!

We might get lucky this season, at the least the synoptics are there which is the main piece of the puzzle.

I still have my winter tyres, never needed them so far, but you never know!

 

Originally Posted by: The Beast from the East 

Put petrol into our car twice since March this year. #redundant


Brian Gaze

Berkhamsted

TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 

"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Ally Pally Snowman
23 December 2020 09:08:31

Still remarkable consistency in high score model accuracy, despite the enormous drop in commercial flights remains virtually unchanged:
https://www.emc.ncep.noaa.gov/gmb/STATS/html/new_acz6.html

 

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

The much maligned GEM doing much better than most people think. Consistently better than GFS now. 


Bishop's Stortford 85m ASL.
David M Porter
23 December 2020 09:10:06

That was a rare SSW event - so strong it could displace a vast area of cold from the pole to mid-latitudes. That sort of weather event can happen any time - even after 2040, when the world will be 2-3 degrees warmer, and all Arctic year round sea ice has melted. 

We need to face the facts that the world is warming. The depth of cold and the frequency of cold events is getting less. That does not preclude cold weather events or years when the jet stream is weak, (although we have not seen as many as in decades past), when we might get a cold winter. 

In fact the possibility of cold winters could yet temporarily be increased for a decade or so by a combination of the vast ice melts, changing the salinity of the water in the arctic  ocean  slowing the Gulf Stream, as after all, we are on the same latitude as Newfoundland, and if it were not for the Gulf Stream, winters would be 6 degrees colder for the UK, than they are. 

However, it is also possible that the climate mess-up the human race is creating might cause all sorts of unknown feedbacks, and one could be the increasing frequency of SSW events. The Little Ice Age coincided with an period of sun-induced warmer global temperatures, possibly caused by a slower Gulf Stream, due to ice melt. It’s unlikely that ice melt will have the same degree of effect now, but there are cycles, oscillations we are not aware of, longer terms changes to the sun’s output/ sunspot activity. 

Since I was a child in the 1960s it has been getting warmer, and winters seeing less snow, less ice, less frosts, decade on decade. When I read my dad’s and my great aunt’s diary notes, (very disciplined weather records), there is no doubt of the magnitude of change. My dad learned to ice skate on ponds in Sussex - West Wittering, by the sea!!  Ice skate - every year saw ice so thick you could skate on it. When I was a boy - there were several years I walked on ice with my firebirds - it was inches thick. Imagine that. Not even in 2010 did that happen. 

That does not mean I am not hoping for a rip-roaring winter. they are still possible...just less deeply cold and for shorter durations that they might have been decades ago, and the pace of change does seem to be accelerating. 

Originally Posted by: BJBlake 

The Beast from the East in 2018 was indeed caused by a huge SSW, as was the cold spell of early 2013 (remember the unusually cold March that year). However, I don't recall there being any SSW in the lead-up to December 2010 or prior to the freeze that began not long before Christmas 2009 either, to give you a couple of other recent examples. So the question is, what enabled the freezes at the end of 2009 and 2010 to happen which has not allowed such weather in so many other years in recent times?

 


Lenzie, Glasgow

"A body of men holding themselves accountable to nobody ought not to be trusted by anybody." – Thomas Paine

White Meadows
23 December 2020 09:14:14

 

That'll be because there's been no such drop.

https://www.ecmwf.int/en/forecasts/charts/monitoring/dcover?facets=undefined&time=2020122300,0,2020122300&obs=aircraft&Flag=all

Data figures are, in fact, a fair bit higher than they were last year (they usually are around 200-250K data points before Christmas, falling to below 100K for 3 of the 4 time slots on Christmas Day itself).

The flights are still going, of course, it's just they won't have many people on board. There's a reason BA planes have Royal Mail insignias on them!

Originally Posted by: Retron 

Statistically incorrect I’m afraid. For the week starting December 22, 2020, the number of scheduled flights worldwide was down by 40.5 percent compared to the week of December 23, 2019
This is the same throughout the entire year since February.

Whether Idle
23 December 2020 09:30:16

Statistically incorrect I’m afraid. For the week starting December 22, 2020, the number of scheduled flights worldwide was down by 40.5 percent compared to the week of December 23, 2019
This is the same throughout the entire year since February.

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

Someone is telling porkies....


Dover, 5m asl. Half a mile from the south coast.
warrenb
23 December 2020 09:32:16
Secretly the GEM is my go to model, it has the odd hiccup, but on the whole is pretty reliable
Retron
23 December 2020 09:33:03

Someone is telling porkies....

Originally Posted by: Whether Idle 

They are, aren't they? The facts speak for themselves - there's no drop in data from planes, quite the opposite in fact.

Now, it could be that there are fewer planes in the skies, but that's irrelevant: as I said in my earlier post, there is more data coming from what's left in the skies than there has been in any of the previous few years in the run up to Christmas.

 

 

 


Leysdown, north Kent
Northern Sky
23 December 2020 09:49:44

Secretly the GEM is my go to model, it has the odd hiccup, but on the whole is pretty reliable

Originally Posted by: warrenb 

Did it have an upgrade recently? Must admit I don't follow the GEM much but didn't it used to have an issue with woeful predictions for 850's?

White Meadows
23 December 2020 09:53:40

 

They are, aren't they? The facts speak for themselves - there's no drop in data from planes, quite the opposite in fact.

Now, it could be that there are fewer planes in the skies, but that's irrelevant: as I said in my earlier post, there is more data coming from what's left in the skies than there has been in any of the previous few years in the run up to Christmas.

 

 

 

Originally Posted by: Retron 

Fewer planes, same accuracy https://www.emc.ncep.noaa.gov/gmb/STATS/html/new_acz6.html

mythical almost... 

Retron
23 December 2020 09:55:15

Fewer planes, same accuracy https://www.emc.ncep.noaa.gov/gmb/STATS/html/new_acz6.html

mythical almost... 

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 

Fewer planes, more data points. You will recall from last year that we were seeing far fewer data points on the ECM charts up 'til Christmas. Again,

https://www.ecmwf.int/en/forecasts/charts/monitoring/dcover?facets=undefined&time=2020122218,0,2020122218&obs=aircraft&Flag=all

will be worth watching over the next few days. Previous years, as I said earlier, have gone below 100K for much of Christmas Day and, again, previous years have had fewer data points at this time of year than we're seeing now.

Anyway, I really can't be bothered ping-ponging back and forth with you. I'll pop you back on ignore and you can carry on spouting whatever you like! Have a wonderful Christmas WM!


Leysdown, north Kent
BJBlake
23 December 2020 10:10:51

 

Put petrol into our car twice since March this year. #redundant

Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

Just bought a full EV, but on the pcp I asked for 15,000 miles instead of the usual 35k, because it sits in the garage for so much longer these days. I think the Team’s meeting is here to stay, which is the kick start to a greener world. Hope yet for future cold winters.


Brecklands, South Norfolk 28m ASL
nsrobins
23 December 2020 10:32:23
Where GFS was so consistent last week for the medium term, volatility has returned. The general theme is the same, but confidence in ground conditions from 7 days out is typically low to zero.


Neil

Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)

Stormchaser, Member TORRO

ballamar
23 December 2020 10:32:31
Painful how close GFS is to classic cold spell
White Meadows
23 December 2020 10:32:32

 

Fewer planes, more data points. You will recall from last year that we were seeing far fewer data points on the ECM charts up 'til Christmas. Again,

https://www.ecmwf.int/en/forecasts/charts/monitoring/dcover?facets=undefined&time=2020122218,0,2020122218&obs=aircraft&Flag=all

will be worth watching over the next few days. Previous years, as I said earlier, have gone below 100K for much of Christmas Day and, again, previous years have had fewer data points at this time of year than we're seeing now.

Anyway, I really can't be bothered ping-ponging back and forth with you. I'll pop you back on ignore and you can carry on spouting whatever you like! Have a wonderful Christmas WM!

Originally Posted by: Retron 

fewer data points earlier in the year too, yet same (or even better) model accuracy. Its something you don’t have to discuss further if you do not wish to. 

fairweather
23 December 2020 10:35:45

 

Sorry but that’s simply not true.  An outlier is something with no support in the ensembles: the 18z op has support from several other perturbations and is often within the main pack.

The ECM 12z ensemble suite for London T2m remains consistent, with the mean continuing to show maxima around 3-4c and the op  tracking the mean aside from the minimum on 30th.

The expected scatter past Day 10 but still good clusters around cold outcomes:

 

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 

Sorry, I was referring to the 18z GFS (London) 850 hPa's. You are probably right in that it is not statistically an outlier, especially in the second half, where the standard deviation is high and therefore as I said - the mean is of little significance. I should have been less casual with my use of "outlier" You are incorrect to define an outlier as a value with no support though. Mathematically the definition of outliers is complex and different depending on the source and type of data. A common definition is 1,5 x outside the lower quartile which, given the variability, it is unlikely that any are true outliers. There is no question whatsoever though that the op run was clearly at the cold side of the run at the beginning and end.


S.Essex, 42m ASL
fairweather
23 December 2020 10:38:33

Beast does have a point. Brian has cleared up this debate. The decadal shrinking of the area covered by deep cold (Hpa of -10 or less) has been measured and demonstrated by Brian’s stat’s. This is a climate thing. 2010 was a weather event, and every 11 years there will be a cluster of cold winters, coinciding with the Maunder minima - notwithstanding longer term oscillations - and fortunately - we might just be at the start of a cluster. 

If the climate were getting colder instead of warmer, there is no doubt that the current Synoptics would produce more cold weather and there would be more deep cold about. Even in my lifetime the warming is noticeable (astonishing in climate evolutionary terms). That does not preclude the right Synoptics delivering snowmaggedon - but has to be a better and better shot, and there will be less peripheral (lucky events) snow events. Suffolk County Council used to pay for snow fencing for the A140 every year to prevent snow drifting. They stopped paying for that after about 1997, because it was a waste of money...we just did not get the annual drifting snow events any more. But nor too did we get the short northerly and snow showers. 
So in summary, both are correct. Weather events can happen, and persistent Synoptics will shunt deep cold our way, but the chance of deep cold reaching us is less - but especially the shorter term good Synoptics. 

The rareness of cold weather is part of the fascination of course.

Originally Posted by: BJBlake 

Accurate analysis of the situation. 


S.Essex, 42m ASL
White Meadows
23 December 2020 10:42:59
Fascinating 06z. Ensembles trending colder again in the longer term

pdiddy
23 December 2020 10:44:05

06z GFS Op is much more like the parallel this morning... not sure, but it looks like a better evolution for cold

nsrobins
23 December 2020 10:47:16

06z GFS Op is much more like the parallel this morning... not sure, but it looks like a better evolution for cold

Originally Posted by: pdiddy 

It’s (OP) one option longer term of many - but not the one most of us want to see (for this run).

 


Neil

Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)

Stormchaser, Member TORRO

ballamar
23 December 2020 10:48:09

06z GFS Op is much more like the parallel this morning... not sure, but it looks like a better evolution for cold

Originally Posted by: pdiddy 

so close to being ideal charts not quite getting there. Think it will in the end but frustrating 

CField
23 December 2020 11:06:27

 

so close to being ideal charts not quite getting there. Think it will in the end but frustrating 

Originally Posted by: ballamar 

was reading up on the bone biter 1895...that was alternating easterlies northerlies which started in Jan but the real cold came in February...sure there was more cold air around to start off with but be interesting if the cold and proximity of cold develops over the next few weeks if patterns continue.....be more amazing if patterns continue  and no visitations of real cold occur......cant see that happening 


Favourite snowstorm

Famous channel low

Dec 31st 1978

Hastings East Sussex

Foot of level snow severe drifting

Next day max temp -4 degrees Celsius

GezM
  • GezM
  • Advanced Member
23 December 2020 11:06:48
Unless my brain has pickled pre-Christmas, I'm seeing Easterlies all the way from Scandinavia to northern Quebec on the GFS 06Z. The previous run had them from Western Russia to about the same area!

https://www.wetterzentrale.de/topkarten.php?map=1&model=gfs&var=1&run=6&time=252&lid=OP&h=0&mv=0&tr=3#mapref 


Living in St Albans, Herts (116m asl)

Working at Luton Airport, Beds (160m asl)

Remove ads from site